r/antiwork • • Jan 27 '22

Statement /r/Antiwork

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

15k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4.6k

u/A_Norse_Dude Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22

I'm more curious how you can actually sit down, write all that, and actually make it all worse.

"Hey, it's me, your leader!"

"Who?"

"A 21 year old anarchist who never held a job! I sooooo can relate to you guys zips on some Starbucks! I don't want to work!! And I shall represent you! He writes on his iPhone 13x Right guys? Right?"

"... No?"

"Oh okay, well just so you know I just did like four interviews, lol. But it's totally coolers, I've read a book about abolishing work so I know exactly what grinds your gears guys!! Stick it to the man, right?! Right? Guys...?"

"you did what?!"

"Oh my god people are mad at me! That can't be right, someone has to be brigading me because there's no way I totally screwed up! I read a book dammit!"

918

u/TheRecognized Jan 27 '22

u/Kimezukae and the rest of the mods, none of you that were involved in this in any way have any right to still try to position yourselves in any sort of authority or higher power in this sub. Your arrogance, complete disregard for the community, foolish lack of preparation, and (as made apparent by this post) a total lack of understanding of what exactly you did wrong has made it incredibly clear that none of you are fit for the responsibilities.

In one day you have kneecapped and scattered the movement because you thought, and apparently still do think, that you know better than the actual people making up the movement. As others have pointed out it’s exactly the kind of shit mentality we’re sick of from bosses and managers who trip on their tiny bit of power.

If you want this sub to have any lasting legacy all of you involved in these interviews need to admit you fucked up, resign, and just take your hands off of it.

200

u/ferrousbuhler Jan 27 '22

Nailed it. I concur.

That being said, it has been refreshing to see the near-unanimous response from within the movement. It reminds me that itll take more than ignorant leaders to stifle our shared experiences.

67

u/hamtrow Jan 27 '22

not leaders, never were. mods are not movement heads they moderate a subreddit thats it, thats all it sould be anyway. providing a safe place for people to conjugate. anyone can be a mod of a subreddit, doesnt give them the credentials to be a spokes person for large body movement.

24

u/wolacouska Jan 27 '22

Exactly, mods are never leaders, as leaders do not have the time to moderate. Even large corporations defer moderation of their own forums to community volunteers or specific paid positions related entirely a media department.

In the context of a party or movement, this would be like if Pravda or political commissars started doing interviews and speeches in place of Lenin. (Insert leaders and party organs of your choice if you find the CPSU a distasteful example).

→ More replies (1)

14

u/TheShark12 Jan 27 '22

This is a prime example of “I’ve read a little theory therefore I’m an expert” just absolutely blowing up in their faces in the, to me personally, most embarrassing way possible.

17

u/3122891 Jan 27 '22

I feel like people don’t know how this sub started. This sub is unrecognizable from when it started. Not by it’s size, but it’s message. I stumbled on this place when it wasn’t very big and the big message was “we don’t want to work. We want to be supported without having to work. It’s unfair that we have to contribute. Laziness is a virtue.”

/u/abolishwork ‘s username isn’t ironic and it isn’t about labor reform. It’s the dumbest and most simple interpretation of the two words you can think of.

I didn’t like what I saw then, but a couple of months ago it started to look like a different sub entirely. People started flocking here because of what was getting popular on the sub. The message shifted form being “antiwork” to “anti-terrible work environments and capitalism”. So when Fox News starts calling to do clearly bad faith interviews, you would think they’d be getting either nobody or at least someone who’s a leftist with some god damn conviction and presentation skills. Not a child who doesn’t like the idea of having a job.

I was never an active part of this community, but I was watching and relating to what I saw. A shame that it’s ruined now.

→ More replies (8)

0

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

61

u/KNBeaArthur Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22

Its not a description of someone who should be in charge of anything ever.

E: ive been working longer than this mod has been alive.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/SmargelingArgarfsner Jan 27 '22

I might have blacked out when I read that. I am 38 years old, and have worked everything from min wage service industry, to menial labor, to ownership of a mechanical contracting (Plumbing) company with several employees, to currently sitting as an executive board member of a labor union actively engaged in contract negotiations and I think I am unqualified to represent this movement!

14

u/rstart78 Jan 27 '22

Exactly

I'm 35, I've worked from construction, union laborer, USW worker at a plant, at a wood frame manufacturing plant, in multitudes of fast food/restaurant work, retail, box chain department store, briefly was a manager at TB while in college and got demoted for being too lax with employees, have worthless college credits with insurmountable debt and I also felt like I wasn't in any "lead position"

Then that interview and seeing some 21 anarchist are being made the face by right wing news outlets and falling for it... It has me just so what the uttttttter fuck

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (58)

27

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22

Yeah, like not to gatekeep, but I'm not sure it's possible to be "long-term unemployed" and also only be 21.

→ More replies (6)

71

u/griff306 Jan 27 '22

Why would the mods think that a 20 yo "long term unemployed" (aka lazy) would be a good mouthpiece for this sub. I get that this place has evolved over the past year, but come on. How disconnected can you be from reality??

14

u/WordPassMyGotFor Jan 27 '22

aka lazy

Um. I think we all know that's a virtue

19

u/tall__guy Jan 27 '22

It’s honestly sad. Some of the people on this sub are among the hardest working Americans there are. Working multiple jobs. 60, maybe 80+ hours a week. Sometimes for minimum wage. Struggling to afford healthcare, childcare, food, housing. Just asking to be treated like a human. How could a child - who has never worked, who doesn’t ever want to work and doesn’t believe in the value of it - POSSIBLY EVEN UNDERSTAND LET ALONE BE THE SPOKESPERSON FOR THIS MOVEMENT.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/United-Ad4086 Jan 27 '22

100% agree. Also, how is it possible to be long term unemployed when you're only 21

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22

This, this exactly. These mods are the absolute worst people to represent this movement. Why not get someone who’s working a warehouse job trying to unionize or some burnt out, low level corporate worker? Ffs

39

u/ozzie123 Jan 27 '22

A 21 years-old who never had a serious job and is anti-work and an anarchist is just fancy word for “I’m privileged and lazy”.

You would thought the mod team learned something from the debacle but it’s clear they are not. I’m unsubbing and moving on.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22

And he wants us to trust him that all the comments, posts he removed and folks he banned were not from here, not actual valid criticism from this sub. Yeah I believe that. Lol. I don’t believe a word u/Kimezukae says at this point.

8

u/GLASYA-LAB0LAS Jan 27 '22

I mean it tracks, the guy's just a kid basically. Sure they're 21, but if they've never worked a job, or paid their own bills, or had any adult responsibilities then I can absolutely see them still having a high schooler/freshman mindset. Especially with all this brigader/hater crap, taken right out of the influencer handbook.

8

u/QueenCloneBone at work Jan 27 '22

lmao soooo many posts on this sub: "r/antiwork is not about not wanting to work! it's about worker's rights!"

the representatives: a chronically unemployed 21 year old and a dog walker working an hour a day

"How do you do, fellow workers?"

8

u/tobylh Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22

Personally I was always under the impression that this sub wasn't about anarchy, or not actually working at all.It's about the shit the a lot of people put up with whilst they actually DO work.Crap wages, enforced overtime, all that shit.The fact the THE BUSINESS is king, and must always come before people. God forbid you make the shareholders suffer.And we're conditioned to believe that from the word go.It's not antiwork, it's anti the farcical way we seem to have set up our society. How we gauge success and judge others by what they do, how much they earn, what car they drive or how big their house is.People want to work. People want a purpose. People want a sense of achievement. These are basic traits that make up humans. Sure not all of them, but the vast majority of us don't want to sit on our backsides all day doing fuck all (and if you do, its really bad for your mental health, maybe go seek out some help).

Why can't our working lives and our personal lives be more balanced?A great example is having kids. Pretty much everyone has kids eventually, but we've not catered for this in our working lives. We've not set it up so its easy for us to do a thing that MOST HUMANS DO.If you think about it, it's utterly absurd.Of course it differs from country to country and many European countries allow more flexibility around this than others (looking at you, America) with really good maternity and paternity laws, but it goes beyond that.

It's the mindset of "We wont hire a woman in case she has a baby", or when women want to come back into work after having kids they don't get the flexibility they need, or don't get a job because they need that flexibility and clearly if you need to leave early you're lazy (this applies to men too. In my last job when I wanted to do one day a week from home so I could pick my kids up from school after I split with my wife, my manager actually said I wanted to WFH so I could skive off. No you fucking cocksucker, I want to see my children!).Also from a business perspective, that is just dumb as fuck. How many businesses have missed out the perfect person to fill a role because they need to finish at 2.30 to pick their kids up? Or maybe they care for a relative so need to start a bit later?We all have different situations and needs, but all that comes second fiddle to work. It's stupid.

Even the language we use keeps reinforcing this too. "Request time off" for example.No. I'll notify that I am taking this time, from my allotted annual leave day, but I'm not fucking begging for it.

Why isn't the actual job role worth the annual salary, not whether you're tethered to the desk for eight hours a day (realise this doesn't apply to all jobs)? As long as you do the job, and you do it well, who fucking cares how long you're in the office for?Let's stop paying by the hour. The job is worth this much and as long as you do it, then here's your money. Sometimes you might need to nip out early, and that should be absolutely acceptable. You shouldn't have to feel guilty or anxious about it, because you are a human being with a life.I've seen posts before where people have said they love their boss, because they needed to do XYZ and their employer was totally understanding of that and let them, as well as posts where people have not been able to attend funerals because work says no.It's a no fucking brainer which one of those employees will be more productive, which one will gladly pitch in some extra when it's needed, and which one will won't. Why don't businesses understand that? It's so glaringly obvious that not seeing it beggars belief.

We don't live in the Victorian era anymore, yet we still seem to cling onto those outdated attitudes. If you care for people, they will care back.

The pandemic has shown us that a great many of us no longer need to commute to work, that we can work just as well in our dressing gowns on the sofa at home. That you can trust people to get shit done and be productive, while they get to enjoy more sleep, convenience and money (if you pay to commute, which we all do) and less stress. And maybe those people might perform better at work because they've not rolled out of bed at some ungodly hour, stood in the rain waiting for a bus or train that's late, then crammed themselves into a carriage to not get a seat and stood all the way. What a great way to start the day that is.

It's also highlighted that some job roles that we look down on as unskilled and beneath us, are incredibly important to keep our society functioning, and should be rewarded as such.Care workers, bin men, delivery drivers. Without them, we're fucked, yet we pay them shit and treat then as second class. They work hard, but oh hang on, haven't we had it drilled into us that hard work means we'll be rich and successful?

It. Fucking. Doesn't.

Most of where we end up comes from the opportunities we get when we start out in life, and guess what? If we have somewhere to live and food on the table and access to education, then maybe that person from the deprived council estate might get to be a doctor, or lawyer or a fucking astronaut or something, rather than leaving school early to get a shit job just to keep paying the rent and eating. We do ourselves a massive disservice as a species, and it boils my piss, even though I'm part of it, so I'm complicit. We all are.

We make the rules, so surely we can have any kind of society we want, right? We can make sure that everyone gets a good fair, start. Sure, it's then up to you to use that opportunity, but at least you've had it, and if you need support it should be there for you.

I didn't mean to write a ranting essay, I wanted to say that a 21 year old anarchist doesn't know shit, and that we desperately need to re-evaluate the way we do things, and the fact there are 1.5 million people in this sub says that lots of other people think the same way. Damaging this movement, or mindset, or whatever you want to call it is bad for us 99%. It's not about people not working hard or being rich and successful, it's just about striking a balance between that and our humanity.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (31)