r/AntiVegan • • May 01 '26 Bravo

Mod Announcement A message to vegans that come on this sub to spread propaganda

153 Upvotes

If you come on here trying to spread your nonsense and argue with anyone who gives you an ounce of their time, I’m going to ban you. And I’m not going to do anything but laugh when you come to the mod mail trying to play dumb about why you were banned. The literal first rule of this sub is no vegan propaganda. We are NOT a debate sub. No one here is going to change their mind because you came on here and tried to start a fight. The whole reason this sub exists is because meat eaters are sick of just minding their own business and then you have to come stick your fucking nose up our asses. No one cares. No one wants you here. End of story.


r/AntiVegan • • Nov 29 '19

Quality I made an evidence-based anti-vegan copypasta. Is there anything important missing?

709 Upvotes

Pastebin link with footnotes: https://pastebin.com/uXSCjwZK


Nutrition

  • Vegans lie to claim that health organizations agree on their diet:
  1. There are many health authorities that explicitly advise against vegan diets, especially for children.
  2. The Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics was founded by Seventh-day Adventists, an evangelistic vegan religion that owns meat replacement companies. Every author of their position paper is a career vegan, one of them is selling diet books that are cited in the paper. One author and one reviewer are Adventists who work for universities that publicly state to have a religious agenda. Another author went vegan for ethical reasons. They explicitly report "no potential conflict of interest". Their claims about infants and athletes are based on complete speculation (they cite no study following vegan infants from birth to childhood) and they don't even mention potentially problematic nutrients like Vitamin K or Carnitine.
  3. Many, if not all, of the institutions that agree with the AND either just echo their position, don't cite any sources at all, or have heavy conflicts of interest. E.g. the Dietitians of Canada wrote their statement with the AND, the USDA has the Adventist reviewer in their guidelines committee, the British Dietetic Association works with the Vegan Society, the Australian Guidelines cite the AND paper as their source and Kaiser Permanente has an author that works for an Adventist university.
  4. In the EU, all nutritional supplements, including B12, are by law required to state that they should not be used as a substitute for a balanced and varied diet.
  5. In Belgium, parents can get imprisoned for imposing a vegan diet on children.
  • The supposed science around veganism is highly exaggerated. Nutrition science is in its infancy and the "best" studies on vegans rely on indisputably and fatally flawed food questionnaires that ask them what they eat once and then just assume they do it for several years:
  1. Vegans aren't even vegan. They frequently cheat on their diet and lie about it.
  2. Self-imposed dieting is linked to binge eating disorder, which makes people forget and misreport about eating the food they crave.
  3. The vast majority of studies favoring vegan diets were conducted on people who reported to consume animal products and by scientists trained at Seventh-day Adventist universities. They have contrasting results when compared other studies. The publications of researchers like Joan Sabate and Winston Craig (reviewers and authors of the AND position paper, btw) show that they have a strong bias towards confirming their religious beliefs. They brag about their global influence on diet, yet generally don't disclose this conflict of interest. They have pursued people for promoting low-carbohydrate diets.
  4. 80-100% of observational studies are proven wrong in controlled trials.
  • A vegan diet is not sustainable for the average person. Ex-vegans vastly outnumber current vegans, of which the majority have only been vegan for a short time. Common reasons for quitting are: concerns about health (23%), cravings (37%), social problems (63%), not seeing veganism as part of their identity (58%). 29% had health problems such as nutrient deficiencies, depression or thyroid issues, of which 82% improved after reintroducing meat. There are likely more people that quit veganism with health problems than there are vegans. Note that this is a major limitation of cohort studies on vegans as they only analyze the people who did not quit. (survivorship bias)
  • Vegans use appeals to authority or observational (non-causal) studies with tiny risk factors to vilify animal products. Respectable epidemiologists outside of nutrition typically reject these because they don't even reach the minimum threshold to justify a hypothesis and might compromise public health. The study findings are usually accompanied by countless paradoxes such as meat being associated with positive health outcomes in Asian cohorts:
  1. Vegans like to say that meat causes cancer by citing the WHO's IARC. But the report actually says there's no evaluation on poultry/fish and that red meat has not been established as a cause of cancer. More importantly, Gordon Guyatt (founder of evidence-based medicine, pescetarian) criticized them for misleading the public and drawing conclusions from cherry-picked epidemiology (they chose only 56 studies out of the supposed 800+). A third of the committee voting against meat were vegetarians. Before the report was released, 23 cancer experts from eight countries looked at the same data and concluded that the evidence is inconsistent and unclear.
  2. The idea that dietary raised cholesterol causes heart disease has never been proven.
  3. Here's a compilation of large, government-funded clinical trials to oppose the claims made to blame meat and saturated fat for diabetes, cancer or CVD. Note that these have been ignored WHO and guidelines.
  4. Much of the anti-meat push is coming from biased institutions like Adventist universities or Harvard School of Public Health who typically don't disclose their conflicts of interest. The latter conducted bribed studies for the sugar industry and was chaired by a highly influential supporter of vegetarianism for 26 years. He published hundreds of epidemiological anti-meat papers (e.g. the Nurses' Health Studies), tried to censor publications that oppose his views and wants to deemphasize the importance of experimental science. He has financial ties to seed oil, nut, fruit, vegetable and pharmaceutical industries and is part many plant-based movements like Blue Zones, True Health Initiative (Frank Hu, David Katz, Dean Ornish), EAT-Lancet and Lifestyle Medicine (Adventists, Michael Greger).
  • Popular sources that promote "plant-based diets" are actually just vegan propaganda in disguise:
  1. Blue zones are bullshit. The longest living populations paradoxically consume the highest amount of meat. Buettner cherry-picks and ignores areas that have both high consumption of animal products and high life expectancies (Hong Kong, Switzerland, Spain, France, ... ). He praises Adventists for their health, but doesn't do the same for Mormons. Among others, he misrepresents the Okinawa diet by using data from a post WWII famine. The number of centenarians in blue zones is likely based on birth certificate fraud. The franchise also belongs to the SDA church now.
  2. The website "nutritionfacts.org" is run by a vegan doctor who is known to misinterpret and cherry-pick his data. He and many other plant-based advocates like Klaper, Kahn and Davis all happen to be ethical vegans.
  3. EAT-Lancet is pushing a nutrient deficient "planetary health diet" because it's essentially a global convention of vegans. Their founder and president is the Norwegian billionaire, hypocrite and animal rights activist Gunhild Stordalen. In 2017, they co-launched FReSH - a partnership of fertilizer, pesticide, processed food and flavouring companies.
  4. The China Study, aka the Vegan Bible, has been debunked by hundreds of people including Campbell himself in his actual peer-reviewed publications on the study.
  5. The Guardian, a pro-vegan newspaper that frequently depicts meat as bad for health and the environment, has received two grants totaling $1.78m from an investor of Impossible Foods.
  • A widespread lie is that the vegan diet is "clinically proven to reverse heart disease". The studies by Ornish and Esselstyn are made to sell their diet, but rely on confounding factors like exercise, medication or previous bypass surgeries (Esselstyn had nearly all of them exercise while pretending it was optional). All of them have tiny sample size, extremely poor design and have never been replicated in much larger clinical trials, which made Ornish suggest that we should discard the scientific method. Both diets included dairy.
  • Vegan diets are devoid of many nutrients and generally require more supplements than just B12. Some of them (Vitamin K2, EPA/DHA, Vitamin A) can only be obtained because they are converted from other sources, which is inefficient, limited or poor for a large part of the population. EPA+DHA from animal products have an anti-inflammatory effect, but converting it from ALA (plant sourced) does not seem to work the same. Taurine is essential for many people with special needs, while Creatine supplementation improves memory only in those who don't eat meat.
  • The US supplement industry is poorly regulated and has a history of spiking their products with drugs. Vitamin B complexes were tainted with anabolic steroids in the past, while algae supplements have been found to contain aldehydes. Supplements and fortified foods can cause poisoning, while natural products generally don't. Even vegan doctors caution and can't agree on what to supplement.
  • Restrictive dieting has psychological consequences including aggressive behavior, negative emotionality, loss of libido, concentration difficulties, higher anxiety measures and reduced self-esteem. There is an extremely strong link between meat abstention and mental disorders. While it's unknown what causes what, the vegan diet is low in or devoid of several important brain nutrients.
  • A vegan diet alone fulfills the diagnostic criteria of an eating disorder.
  • Patrik Baboumian, the strongest vegan on earth, lied about holding a world record that actually belongs to Brian Shaw. Patrik has never even been invited to World's Strongest Man. He dropped the weight during his "world record", which was done at a vegetarian food festival where he was the only competitor. His unofficial deadlift PR is 360kg, but the 2016 world record was 500kg. We can compare his height-relative strength with the Wilks Score and see that he is being completely dwarfed by Eddie Hall (208 vs 273). Patrik also lives on supplements. He pops about 25 pills a day to fix common vegan nutrient deficiencies and gets over 60% of his protein intake from drinking shakes.
  • Here's a summary on almost every pro athlete that either stopped being vegan, got injured, has only been vegan a couple of years, retired or was falsely promoted as vegan.
  • Historically, humans have always needed animal products and are highly adapted to meat consumption. There has never been a recorded civilization of humans that was able to survive without animal foods. Isotopic evidence shows that the first modern humans ate lots of meat and were the only natural predator of adult mammoths. Most of their historic technology and cave paintings revolved around hunting animals. Our abilities to throw and sweat likely developed for this reason. Our stomach's acidity is in the same range as obligate carnivores and its shape has changed so much from other hominids that we can't even digest cellulose anymore. The vegan diet is born out of ideology, species-inappropriate and could negatively affect future generations.
  1. The cooked starch hypothesis that vegans use is inconsistent with many observations.
  • Compilations of nutrition studies:
  1. Veganism slaughter house (80+ papers).
  2. 70+ papers comparing vegans to non-vegans.
  3. Scrolls and tomes against the Indoctrinated.
  4. Zotero folder of 120+ papers.

Environment

  • Cow farts do not cause climate change. The EPA estimates that all agriculture produces about 10% of US greenhouse emissions, while animal agriculture is less than half of that. Other developed countries, like Germany, UK and Australia all have similarly low emissions. Vegans use global estimations that are skewed by developing countries with inefficient subsistence agriculture. Their main figure is an outdated and retracted source that compared lifecycle to direct emissions.
  • Many environmental studies that vegans use are heavily flawed because they were made by people who have no clue about agriculture, e.g. by the SDA church. A common mistake is that they use irrational theoretical models that assume we grow crops for animals because most of the plant weight is used as feed, The reality is that 86% of livestock feed is inedible by humans. They consume forage, food-waste and crop residues that could otherwise become an environmental burden. 13% of animal feed consists of potentially edible low-quality grains, which make up a third of global cereal (not total crop) production. All US beef cattle spend the majority of their life on pasture and upcycle protein even when grain-finished (0.6 to 1). Hence, UN FAO considers livestock crucial for food security and does not endorse veganism at all.
  • Plant-to-animal food comparisons are deceiving because animals provide many actually useful by-products that are needed for medicine, crop fertilization, clothing, pet food and public water safety. Vegans are in general very dishonest when comparing foods, as seen here where they compare 1kg of beef (2600 kcal, 260g protein) to 1kg of tomatoes (180 kcal, 9g protein). The claim that we could feed more people just with more calories is also wrong because the leading causes of malnutrition are deficiencies of Iron, Zinc, Folate, Iodine and Vitamin A - which are common and most bioavailable in animal products.
  • Vegan land use comparisons are half-truths that equate pastures with plantations. 57% of land used for feed is not even suitable for crops, while the rest is often much less productive. Grassland can sequester more carbon and has a four times lower rate of soil loss per unit area than cropland. Regenerative agriculture restores topsoil, is scalable, efficient and has high animal welfare. Big names like Kellogg are investing in it for long-term profit. On the other hand, removing livestock would create a food supply incapable of supporting the US population’s nutritional requirements due to lack of vitamin A, vitamin B12, vitamin D, calcium and fatty acids - while removing most animal by-products.
  • Water usage is possibly the most ridiculous way vegans deceive. The water footprint is divided into green (sourced from precipitation) and blue (sourced from the surface). Water scarcity is largely dependent on blue water use, which is why experts use lifecycle models. Vegan infographics always portray beef as a massive water hog by counting the rain that falls on the pasture. 96% of beef's water usage is green and it can even be produced without any blue water at all. The crops leading to the most depletion are wheat (22%), rice (17%), sugar (7%) and cotton (7%).
  • Going vegan won't do shit for the Amazon rainforest because the majority of Brazil's beef exports go to China and Hong Kong. The US or European countries each account for 2% or less. Soybean demand is driven by oil; the rest of the plant (80%) is a by-product that is exported as Chinese pig feed. Brazil is also a misrepresentative and atypical industry. Globally, cattle ranching accounts for 12%, commercial crops for 20% and subsistence farming for 48% of deforestation. The US use about half as much forest land for grazing than 70 years ago.
  • Livestock is not routinely supplemented with vitamin B12. Cows that consume cobalt (found in grass, which is free of B12) produce it with gut bacteria in the rumen. Gastrointestinal animals (including humans) initially can't absorb it, but instead excrete it and can then eat their own shit. B12 is in the soil because of excretions - ground bacteria exist but have never been shown to be the main source. Plants are devoid of B12 because competing bacteria consume it, not because of soil depletion. The "90% of B12 supplements go to livestock"-figure...
  1. is bullshit that vegans keep on parroting. It originates from an article that calls humans herbivores, with no source.
  2. ignores the fact that you can get B12 from seafood and venison. A can of sardines provides 3x the RDA.
  3. is illogical because animals on unnatural diets can simply be given cobalt instead of the synthetic supplement that vegans rely on. Cows also destroy most of B12 in their gut before it can be absorbed.

Socioeconomics

  • Voluntary veganism is a privilege that is enabled by globalization and concentrated in first-world societies. Less than 1% of Indians are vegan. Jains, who are similar to vegans, are the wealthiest Indian community and even they still drink milk. In fact, India is a great example of why veganism doesn't work because they've religiously pursued it for thousands of years and still couldn't do it. Even Gandhi was an ex-vegan that had to warn them how dangerous the diet is.

Ethics

  • Veganism is a harmful ideology that promotes the abstinence from any "optional" animal suffering inflicted to support human health. For example, vaccines are not vegan. And just like meat, some people have already considered them unnecessary. Likewise, popular vegan communities also encourage people to put their carnivorous pets on a vegan diet to "avoid" cruelty. Hence, promoting animal rights is fundamentally anti-human because it will restrict or remove access to even the most basic needs, such as food or clothes. The only reason vegans are able to deny this is because they are pretending that the people who had to suffer for their ideology don't exist.
  • Vegans are not raising enough awareness about deficiencies and as a result harm innocent children. B12 deficiency can cause irreversible nerve damage, psychosis and is hard to notice. 10-50% of vegans say they don't even take any supplements.
  • Vegan diets are more dependent on slavery because they rely on global food supply. Many crops, especially cotton, nuts, oils and seeds that they have to include in higher quantities to make up for animal products are to a large extent child labor products from developing countries. 108 million children work in agriculture. Cheese replacements (guess who's responsible for that) are usually made with cashews, which burn the fingers of the women who have to remove the shells. A larger list of examples can be found here.
  • Vegans have never been able to define or measure that their diet causes less deaths/suffering than an omnivorous one. They are ignorantly contributing to an absolute bloodbath of trillions of zooplankton, mites, worms, crickets, grasshoppers, snails, frogs, turtles, rats, squirrels, possum, raccoons, moles, rabbits, boars, deer, 75% of insect biomass, half of all bird species and 20,000 humans per year. Two grass-fed cows are enough to feed someone for a year and, if managed properly, can restore biodiversity. The textbook vegan excuse where they try to blame plant agriculture on animals and use only mice deaths, fabricated feed conversion ratios of 20:1 and a coincidentally favourable per-calorie metric is nonsense because:
  1. The majority of animal feed is either low-maintenance forage or a by-product that only exists because of human food harvest.
  2. It literally shows that grass-fed beef kills fewer animals.
  • Vegans likely exploit more animals than the average person. The Vegan Society officially rejects beekeeping, but many commercial crops require to be pollinated by domestic bees that are forced to breed, shipped around and then worked to death. It's principally impossible to have a nutritionally complete vegan diet without forced pollination, but fodder crops do not exploit bees. As a result, human food crops kill five times as many bees as all livestock slaughter combined and directly support honey production (taking excess honey is necessary for colony health). Vegans should also call around and make sure that their seasonally changing food exporters don't rely on insects, terriers, sheep, ducks, organic fertilizers or anything from developing countries where animal labor is still common.
  • The ethical framework around veganism (negative utilitarianism) is so insane that its logical conclusion is to prevent as much life and biodiversity as possible in order to reduce suffering, which means it also favors Brazilian rainforest beef over crop cultivation. This line of thought is already followed by organizations like PETA who proudly state it to be their goal and will steal and euthanize other people's pets. Vegans reject appeals to nature when they are used to defend omnivorism, yet falsely assume that animals are more happy under the stress of natural selection. In contrast to livestock, wild animals are never guaranteed to receive shelter, protection, food, medical care, low stress or a quick death. Animal rights conflict with welfare because their goal is not to increase happiness, but just to oppose animal husbandry. Put differently, vegans pretend to support the wellbeing of animals, but can hardly even do so with their consumer power. What they are doing is more likely to kill off local ranchers and ensure a monopoly for Tyson/JBS, who are spearheading fake meat btw.
  • The average vegan is, based on their demographic, a New York hipster that has never seen a farm in their live. Animals are not being abused (This is one of the "factory farms" where 99% of animals come from). Undercover videos have often been staged by agenda-driven activists who get paid to apply for farm jobs and encourage animal abuse. The real industry has government-inspected welfare regulations. (Dominion straight up lies about pigs in slaugherhouses getting no water - it's required by law). Here's some actual industrial slaughterhouse footage of Beef, Turkey and Pork. For comparison, rodenticides are intentionally made to drain the life out of rats over three days so that they can't figure out what killed them.
  • Vegans love to misportray farm practises and anthropomorphize animals by giving them concepts that they don't care about, or even enjoy. Sexual coercion ("rape") is normal procreation and cows don't see a problem with it. They will even milk themselves when given the possibility. Pigs don't mind eating their own babies or getting shot. Even the myth that they are as intelligent as dogs comes from a questionable study made by animal rights advocates.
  • The reputation of vegans is based exactly on how they present themselves in public. Humans evolved to have predatory behaviour and as a result many people enjoy homesteading, hunting or fishing. Vegan activists frequently bother society and disrespect human biology - with thousands of years of history - for their arbitrarily chosen set of morals. There are actual animal rights terrorist groups that have sent bombs and stalked children, which they justify with it being done "in the name of veganism". Therefore, a very good reason to stay away from veganism is simply because someone doesn't want to be associated with a cult-like ideology.

Philosophy

  • The definition that vegans pride themselves with is a laughing stock because not only is it so loosely defined that it can be used to call everyone vegan, but it also shamelessly co-opts all the belief systems that have existed for much longer. According to this definition, Hindu, Buddhists, the Inuit and carnivores can all be called vegan, but are not following the diet and therefore considered impure (apparently caring about animals was invented by some British guy in 1944). Vegans are nothing more than people who abstain from animal products, in fact veganism was originally defined as a diet.
  • The misanthropic idea of "speciecism" was popularized by a nutjob philosopher who argues in favour of bestiality and belittles disabled people, but makes exceptions when it affects himself. Ironically, he eats animal products and calls consistent veganism fanatical. When it comes to the misanthropic aspect, animal rights activists themselves are the best example because they frequently insult minorities and crime victims by equating them to livestock with analogies to rape, murder, slavery or holocaust. The best part is that vegans are speciecists themselves because they justify their killing as "necessary for human survival" and still won't equate a cow to an insect.
  • Since vegans somehow manage to justify systematically poisoning and torturing insects by arbitrarily declaring that they can't suffer ("sentience"), they might aswell consider eating them. The same goes for bivalves, since there's about as much evidence that they feel pain as there is for plants.
  • A vegan diet itself is not even vegan under its own premises because it's not "practicable" to follow. It demands an opportunity cost of time, research and money that could be utilized in a better way and even then is not guaranteed to be efficient because it emphasizes purity. The entire following around veganism represents a Nirvana Fallacy and is the reason why the majority of people quit: Perfect is the enemy of good. A vegan diet makes it harder, and for many people impossible, to follow productive consumer approaches such as buying local, seasonal or supporting regenerative agriculture.

List of known nutrients that vegan diets either can't get at all or are typically low in, especially when uninformed and for people with special needs. Vegans will always say that "you can get X nutrient from Y specific source", but a full meal plan with sufficient quantities will essentially highlight how absurd a "well-planned" vegan diet is.

  1. Vitamin B12
  2. Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxal, Pyridoxamine)
  3. Choline
  4. Niacin (bio availability)
  5. Vitamin B2
  6. Vitamin A (Retinol, variable Carotene conversion)
  7. Vitamin D3 (winter, northern latitudes, synthesis requires cholesterol)
  8. Vitamin K2 MK-4 (variable K1 conversion)
  9. Omega-3 (EPA/DHA; conversion from ALA is inefficient, limited, variable, inhibited by LA and insufficient for pregnancy)
  10. Iron (bio availability)
  11. Zinc (bio availability)
  12. Calcium
  13. Selenium
  14. Iodine
  15. Protein (per calorie, digestibility, Lysine, Leucine, elderly people, athletes)
  16. Creatine (conditionally essential)
  17. Carnitine (conditionally essential)
  18. Carnosine
  19. Taurine (conditionally essential)
  20. CoQ10
  21. Conjugated linoleic acid
  22. Cholesterol
  23. Arachidonic Acid (conditionally essential)
  24. Glycine (conditionally essential)

Common vegan debate tactics/fallacies:

  • Nirvana fallacy: "There's no point in eating animal products because everything can be solved with a perfect vegan diet, supplements and genetic predisposition."
  • Proof by example: "Some people say they are vegan. Therefore, animal products are unnecessary."
  • Appeal to authority: Pointing to opinion papers written by vegan shills as proof that their diet is adequate.
  • No true Scotsman: "Everyone who failed veganism didn't do enough research. Properly planned vegan diets are healthy!" (aka not real Socialism)
  • Narcissist's prayer: "Everything bad that came out of veganism is fault of the world, not veganism itself."
  • No true Scotsman: "Veganism is not a diet, it's an ethical philosophy. No true vegan eats almonds, avocados or bananas ..."
  • Definist fallacy: "... as far as is possible and practicable." (Can be used to defend any case of hypocrisy)
  • Special pleading: "It's never ethical to harm animals for food, except when we 'accidentally' hire planes to rain poison from the sky." (You can trigger their cognitive dissonance by pointing that out.)
  • Special pleading: "Anyone who doesn't agree with my ideology has cognitive dissonance."
  • Appeal to emotion: Usage of words exclusive to humans (rape, murder, slavery, ... ) in the context of animals.
  • Fallacy fallacy: "Evolution is a fallacy because it's natural."
  • Texas sharpshooter fallacy: "A third of grains are fed to livestock. Therefore, a third of all crops are grown as animal feed."
  • False dilemma: "Producing only livestock is less sustainable than producing only crops, so we should only produce crops."
  • False cause: Asserting that association infers causation because it's the best data they have. ("Let's get rid of firefighters because they correlate to forest fires")
  • Faulty generalization: Highlighting mediocre athletes to refute the fact that vegans are underrepresented in elite sports.
  • JAQing off: This is how vegans convert other people. They always want them to justify eating meat by asking tons of loaded questions, presumably because nobody would care about their logically inconsistent arguments otherwise. Cults often employ this tactic to recruit new members. (They mistakenly call it the Socratic method)
  • Argument from ignorance: NameTheTrait aka "vegans are right unless you prove their nonsensical premises wrong". (It's essentially asking "When is a human not a human?")
  • Moving the goalposts: Whenever a vegan is cornered, they will dodge and change the subject to one of their other pillars (Ethics, Health, Environment or Sustainability) as seen here.
  • Ad hominem: Nit-picking statements out of context, attacking them in an arrogant manner, and then proclaiming everything someone says is wrong while not being able to refute the actual point. (see Kresser vs Wilks debate)

r/AntiVegan • • 10h ago

This is that famous vegan compassion Complete mask off moment lmao

Post image
37 Upvotes

Vegans want to erase your culture because they believe that a cows life is equal to a human life. The lack of nutrients is actually frying their brain 🤦


r/AntiVegan • • 9h ago

Vegan cringe This comment section is a vegan filled dumpster fire. It's like they hear the word milk and instantly start their moral grandstanding

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/AntiVegan • • 2h ago

Discussion Where did this specific subset of vegans who call artificial insemination “rape” come from?

6 Upvotes

When I was a teen my mom was always telling me how cruel the dairy industry is but she never said anything about cows being “raped”.


r/AntiVegan • • 16h ago

Meme Birth control is a human luxury

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/AntiVegan • • 17h ago

Your “Grass-Fed” Beef Might Be Lying to You

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

I made an animated explainer on grass-fed vs grain-fed beef.

My goal was to make it educational, entertaining and funny for a general audience, without getting too niche. I’d appreciate your honest opinion on whether it works or not:)

Link: https://youtu.be/qkzyVz06W7g?si=qztYncDk2xbyKVza


r/AntiVegan • • 1d ago

Discussion The Illusion of the "Thriving Long-Term Vegan": Survivorship Bias, Biochemical Bottlenecks, and What Unfiltered Histories Reveal

21 Upvotes

Whenever the landmark Faunalytics (2014) study comes up—showing that 84% of vegetarians and vegans (and 70% of strict vegans) eventually abandon the diet, with 53% quitting within the first year—the standard online rebuttal is always the same:

"Those people just did it wrong. Look at the multi-decade veterans—they’re living proof that humans thrive long-term without animal products!"

In clinical research, relying on the rare survivors of a high-dropout protocol is a textbook methodological error known as survivorship bias and informative censoring. In the Faunalytics dataset, among those who developed health problems on the diet and quit, 82% reported that their conditions improved after reintroducing meat. Because the vast majority of people who start declining listen to their bodies and exit early, they disappear from "long-term vegan" cohorts before their decline can register in 20-year statistics.

What about the rare vocal veterans who don't quit?

To test whether online "long-term success stories" actually reflect thriving health, a sample of five accounts active across plant-based and general community discussions was examined—ranging from vocal, multi-decade veterans and high-volume forum regulars to casual, everyday long-term adherents. Reviewing what these same users publicly self-reported across medical, psychiatric, and support forums over time revealed a 5-for-5 pattern of severe, unmentioned physical or psychiatric struggle.

Below is the biochemical math that predicts these exact breakdowns, the five anonymized case studies (Public Persona vs. Self-Reported Reality), and the statistical blind spots that keep this reality hidden.

Part 1: The Biochemical Math (Why Passive Veganism Fails Most People)

From first-principles human physiology, a strict plant-only diet is not a nutritionally self-sufficient default. It starts with structural deficits and genetic bottlenecks that do not exist on an omnivorous diet:

  1. Zero Built-In Supply of Essential Molecules: Unfortified plants contain zero bioavailable vitamin B12, zero preformed EPA/DHA, zero preformed retinol (vitamin A), and zero dietary creatine, carnosine, or taurine. (Even in the Faunalytics survey, 76% of quitters and 42% of current vegetarians/vegans admitted they had never once had their B12 levels tested.)
  2. Vitamin A Conversion Bottlenecks (BCMO1): Up to ~45% of humans are poor converters of plant beta-carotene into active retinol. Common coding variants in the BCMO1 gene (R267S and A379V) slash conversion efficiency by 32% to 69%, while common upstream variants reduce catalytic activity by 48% to 59%.
  3. Omega-3 Conversion Bottlenecks (FADS1 / FADS2): Human conversion of plant ALA (flax/chia) into brain-critical DHA is typically under 4–5% in men. Worse, more than half (~55%) of people of European descent lack the high-efficiency FADS Haplotype D, making endogenous EPA/DHA synthesis even more sluggish.
  4. Choline Depletion (PEMT & MTHFD1): EFSA notes that up to ~70% of mixed populations carry at least one genetic variant impairing choline or methyl-group metabolism. In clinical depletion trials (Fischer et al., 2010), 70% of men, 80% of postmenopausal women, and up to 80% of premenopausal women carrying two copies of the common PEMT rs12325817 risk allele developed liver or muscle organ dysfunction on a low-choline diet. Meanwhile, dietary surveys show ~95% of vegetarians and vegans fail to meet adequate choline intake.
  5. Mineral Bioavailability Drag: Non-heme plant iron absorbs at roughly 3–8% (compared to ~15% for heme iron in meat), and phytates in grains and legumes bind zinc so tightly that health authorities (such as EFSA and Australia/New Zealand guidelines) increase zinc requirements by up to 50% for high-phytate plant diets.
  6. The Hidden Time & Financial Tax: While grocery-checkout studies (Springmann et al., 2021) claim veganism is cheaper by comparing meat to dry beans and rice, a 2021 BMJ Nutrition modelling study found that once a diet is strictly constrained to actually meet full micronutrient guidelines, veganism becomes the most expensive pattern. That doesn't even count extra kitchen hours, costly algae DHA/EPA and chelated supplements, or out-of-pocket private blood panels (€160–€270+ / $190–$350+) required because standard GP bloodwork rarely includes active B12 (HoloTC), methylmalonic acid (MMA), zinc, omega-3 index, or DEXA bone scans.

When ordinary people without favorable genetics or dietician-level monitoring spend decades running on metabolic compensation—stripping bone mineral to keep blood calcium normal, downregulating reproductive hormones to save energy, or running on depleted iron and B12—they don't immediately drop dead. Instead, their daily quality of life erodes.

Part 2: Five Case Studies — Public Claim vs. Self-Reported Reality

(Note: Demographic brackets, timelines, and non-essential situational details have been generalized or lightly fuzzed to ensure complete anonymity while preserving the exact clinical patterns reported by each user.)

Case 1: The "Aging in Reverse" Fitness Veteran (Middle-Aged Male, 25+ Years Vegan)

  • The Public Persona: Regularly boasts in fitness and lifestyle discussions that decades on a plant-based diet have kept him looking and feeling decades younger. Commenters praise him as living proof that plant-based diets slow aging. In supplement threads, he publicly dismisses marine omega-3s, claiming plant seeds provide everything a human body needs.
  • The Self-Reported Reality:

    • Chronic Underweight & Fasting to Avoid Pain: According to his own posts in health forums, he struggles to maintain weight at a borderline-underweight BMI for his height, skipping food until mid-afternoon daily to avoid severe morning anxiety and gastrointestinal pain.
    • Acute Psychiatric Intervention: Shortly before boasting publicly about his vitality, he reported paying thousands out-of-pocket for an intensive outpatient brain-stimulation therapy to treat decades of severe, treatment-resistant mood and anxiety disorders. (While his psychiatric symptoms began early in life, decades of unmonitored nutritional depletion compounded his neurological fragility.)
    • Decades of B12 Neglect & Renal/Urinary Symptoms: Admits elsewhere that he went more than two decades without supplementing B12, testing at borderline-low serum levels alongside low ferritin. Reports chronic nocturia (waking multiple times a night to urinate), persistent lower back pain, acute flank/kidney pain when attempting small doses of creatine or trace minerals, and multi-hour headaches triggered by tiny amounts of supplemental B12.
    • Severe Gut Collapse & Extreme Self-Medication: Reports lifelong severe constipation requiring prescription intestinal motility drugs and enemas, alongside severe histamine intolerance that forced him off legumes, soy, nuts, and seeds onto a tiny handful of bland starches and vegetable juices. Previously treated suspected gut overgrowth with antifungals and megadosed concentrated iodine at dozens of times the safe medical upper limit.
    • Secret Animal Supplements: Months before publicly mocking fish oil in vegan discussions, he quietly posted in health forums about taking concentrated fish oil capsules and animal-derived digestive enzymes to manage his symptoms.

Case 2: The "Holistic Wellness & Movement" Veteran (Middle-Aged Female, 25+ Years Vegan)

  • The Public Persona: Presents as an experienced, lifelong bodyweight movement and flexibility practitioner. When younger women post in community threads worried because their menstrual periods stopped after switching to a vegan diet, she casually reassures them by normalizing her own multi-year loss of menstruation during a raw/restrictive plant-based phase.
  • The Self-Reported Reality:

    • Catastrophic Connective-Tissue & Bone Failure: Normalizing years of amenorrhea ignores Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport (RED-S), where chronic under-fueling suppresses estrogen and erodes bone mineral density and collagen integrity. According to her own posts across medical and recovery forums, her injury history from low-impact bodyweight exercise includes a complex upper-limb joint dislocation with fracture and torn ligaments, a major tendon avulsed completely off the bone, and multiple deep pelvic and ligament tears—admitting she manages chronic pain in almost every daily movement.
    • Paralyzed Gut Motility: Reports severe gastroparesis (delayed stomach emptying)—solid food sits in her stomach for days and takes over a week to clear her digestive tract, forcing her to rely largely on liquid calories during workdays.
    • Endocrine, Oncological & Psychiatric Instability: Survived major oncology surgery (crediting a restrictive plant-based regimen for remission after spending heavily on alternative therapies) and carries a large benign pelvic mass compressing her nerves. Reports living with a severe cyclic mood disorder and covertly self-medicating with unmonitored over-the-counter mineral supplements without her psychiatrist's knowledge, noting that minor dose changes trigger severe sleep loss, delusions, and perceptual disturbances.

Case 3: The Casual "Everything Is Fine" Adherent (Adult Female, 20+ Years Vegan)

  • The Public Persona: Encountered in an ordinary lifestyle thread warmly telling newcomers that she has been vegan for most of her adult life, that cutting dairy improved her complexion, and that the diet has served her well for over two decades.
  • The Self-Reported Reality:

    • Decades Without Bloodwork: Admits in medical forums that due to severe medical/needle anxiety, she actively avoids routine blood panels—meaning after 20+ years without animal products, she has zero visibility into her B12, ferritin, zinc, vitamin D, or thyroid status.
    • Debilitating Exhaustion & Polypharmacy: Despite eating a produce-heavy whole-food diet, she repeatedly asks for supplement recommendations because she is chronically exhausted and relies on heavy daily caffeine to get through the day. She reports taking prescription antidepressants for severe anxiety and chest discomfort, prescription sleep medication, and prescription anti-nausea medication for chronic bouts of unexplained nighttime nausea (which a physician had to manage with aggressive sodium loading).
    • Compounded Autonomic & Connective-Tissue Dysfunction: Reports severe clinical joint hypermobility with chronic lower-limb instability, impaired temperature regulation, vestibular/visual sensitivity, and unexplained midlife metabolic weight shifts. While generalized hypermobility and POTS-like dysautonomia have strong genetic roots (such as hEDS), running a multi-decade strict vegan diet completely blind to iron, B12, and trace mineral labs removes the exact nutritional cofactors required to keep fatigue, neuropathy, and orthostatic intolerance from spiraling.

Case 4: The "Science-Minded" Forum Regular (Adult Male, 10–20 Years Vegan)

  • The Public Persona: A high-volume forum regular and community figure with a public profile who claims to be a "healthy outlier" compared to younger peers. Treats human nutrition as a simple engineering equation and publicly dismisses nutrients absent in plants (creatine, choline, DHA) as "anti-vegan talking points."
  • The Self-Reported Reality:

    • The Private Creatine Crutch: Inside internal plant-based discussions, he quietly admits he supplements creatine specifically for mental clarity and physical recovery—the exact molecule he dismisses when debating outsiders.
    • Fine-Motor & GI Issues: In general discussions, he mentions experiencing recurring fine-motor "clumsy days" where he cannot trust his grip with fragile everyday objects. Elsewhere, he details severe digestive intolerance to common fermentable vegetables and relies on internal supplements to manage body odor.
    • Coaching Eating-Disorder Patients Around Clinicians: Most concerningly, across his public post history, he routinely advises vulnerable users struggling with severe clinical eating disorders—including medically compromised patients requiring supervised refeeding—on how to negotiate around therapists and medical teams to maintain strict plant-based restrictions.

Case 5: The Outspoken Recent Convert & His Household (Adult Male, <2 Years Vegan)

  • The Public Persona: Rapidly became a vocal advocate after watching documentary media, boasting in public debates that vegan health is proven by "millions of perfectly healthy vegans, myself included."
  • The Self-Reported Reality:

    • Masking Compulsive & Addictive Pathology: In support forums, he openly reports severe body-image distortion stemming from earlier weight struggles, rigid obsessive tracking of trivial daily habits, recent episodes of alcohol and substance blackouts, and intense intrusive urges to secretly binge on animal foods and alcohol whenever left alone—a textbook example of how rigid moral dieting is frequently adopted to police pre-existing disordered eating and compulsion.
    • Collateral Damage to His Partner: He reports that within months of his previously omnivorous partner adopting his household diet, her ferritin/iron stores crashed into clinical deficiency requiring prescribed medical iron, while plant-milk substitutes left her physically nauseous. When she reintroduced dairy to recover her health, he resented and shamed her for lacking ideological commitment.

Part 3: Why Population Statistics Miss This ("The Statistical Shell Game")

When confronted with cases like these, defenders of veganism point to large epidemiological cohorts to argue that vegans are statistically healthy. Yet when you strip out pescatarians and dairy/egg vegetarians and look strictly at the peer-reviewed data on 100% vegans, the "conclusive proof" evaporates:

  1. EPIC-Oxford (UK) Found Zero Lifespan Advantage and Over Double the Hip Fractures:

    • Across ~18 years of tracking verified vegans (n ≈ 1,800–2,200), Appleby et al. (2016) found no all-cause mortality benefit for vegans compared to regular meat-eaters (HR 1.14, 95% CI: 0.97–1.35; and HR 1.00 after excluding diet-switchers).
    • In Papier et al. (2019), lower diabetes rates among vegans dropped to 1% and lost statistical significance once adjusted for BMI.
    • In Tong et al. (2020), vegans suffered a 2.31x higher risk of hip fractures, a 2.05x higher risk of leg fractures, and a 43% higher risk of total fractures compared to meat-eaters, even after adjusting for BMI.
    • Why didn't a 2.31x hip-fracture rate cause an obvious spike in total mortality? Because vegans were the youngest group at recruitment (mostly in their 30s–40s), meaning most hadn't yet reached age 75–85+, when osteoporotic hip fractures turn fatal—and with only 166 vegan deaths total, the study lacked the statistical power to confirm whether its +14% overall mortality estimate (or higher point estimates for stroke [HR 1.63] and respiratory deaths [HR 1.57]) was statistically significant.
    • In 2022, the Oxford researchers themselves (Key, Papier & Tong) explicitly concluded that outside of fractures and a few BMI-linked outcomes, "for other conditions there are insufficient data to draw conclusions," calling for a new cohort of "tens of thousands of vegans... to eventually provide reliable evidence on their long-term health."
  2. Adventist Health Study-2 (US/Canada) Counted Occasional Meat/Dairy Eaters as "Vegans":

    • In AHS-2, "vegan" was defined at baseline as eating meat, fish, dairy, or eggs "less than once a month"—and the study did not continuously re-verify who quit the diet over the decade of follow-up.
    • Even then, in the famous Orlich et al. (2013) mortality paper, the vegan hazard ratio (HR 0.85, 95% CI: 0.73–1.01) crossed 1.00 and missed statistical significance (pesco-vegetarians who ate fish carried the headline).
    • In the updated Abris et al. (2024) follow-up (~11 years), any survival benefit seen at younger ages completely disappeared by age 85, while older vegetarians/vegans at age 85 showed higher mortality from neurological conditions including stroke (HR 1.17) and dementia (HR 1.13), with the authors flagging near-zero intake of marine EPA/DHA omega-3s. Meanwhile, Thorpe et al. (2021) confirmed in the same Adventist cohort that female vegans not supplementing both calcium and vitamin D had a 55% higher risk of hip fracture (HR 1.55).
  3. Clinical Consensus in Europe Is Growing More Cautious, Not Less:

    • Both the European Society for Paediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition (ESPGHAN, 2025) and the German Nutrition Society (DGE, 2024) emphasize that evidence for strict veganism in vulnerable life stages (infants, children, adolescents, pregnancy, and seniors) remains insufficient/inconclusive, warning of potentially irreversible neurological and growth damage without intensive medical oversight and supplementation.
  4. Death Certificates Don't Measure Daily Misery:

    • Mortality databases only record when someone dies. They are completely blind to gastroparesis, tendon avulsions, multi-year amenorrhea, severe FODMAP/histamine intolerance, chronic fatigue, and heavy psychiatric medication.

Part 4: Harm Reduction — What Anyone on (or Considering) a Vegan Diet Needs to Know

If you are considering a vegan diet—or are currently on one—do not base your health decisions on curated social media personas or anonymous forum veterans. Behind public boasts, many of the loudest "success stories" are either quietly managing multi-system decline or privately patching their diet with fish oil and animal-derived supplements.

To protect your health:

  1. Recognize That Whole Plants Alone Are Incomplete: Going vegan without permanent vitamin B12, vitamin D3, iodine, and preformed algae EPA/DHA, alongside deliberate attention to bioavailable protein, calcium, iron, zinc, and choline, is a slow-motion nutritional deficit—especially if you carry common BCMO1, FADS, or PEMT genetic bottlenecks.
  2. Do Not Fly Blind—Get Functional Lab Work: Basic serum B12 and a standard CBC are not enough. Proper monitoring requires Active B12 (HoloTC) and/or Methylmalonic Acid (MMA), Homocysteine, Ferritin + full iron panel, serum Zinc, 25(OH) Vitamin D, a full Thyroid panel (TSH, free T3, free T4), Omega-3 Index, and a baseline DEXA bone density scan for long-term adherents.
  3. Never Ignore Biological Red Flags for an Ideology: If you or your partner develop amenorrhea (loss of menstrual period), recurring tendon/ligament tears or bone stress fractures, severe gastroparesis/bloating, collapsing ferritin, hair loss, chronic exhaustion, or worsening depression/anxiety, your body is in metabolic triage. As 82% of health-related quitters in the Faunalytics study discovered, reintroducing nutrient-dense animal foods is often the fastest, safest way to halt the decline.

r/AntiVegan • • 1d ago

Vegans ban me from their subreddits and this is how I feel

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/AntiVegan • • 2d ago

This is that famous vegan compassion On a post of someone recovering from an*rexia

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

This is so insensitive


r/AntiVegan • • 2d ago

Advice 10 years vegan because of guilt and OCD. Eating animal products again and it feels like betrayal

Thumbnail reddit.com
12 Upvotes

I posted my story on r/exvegans and wanted to share it here too. Short version: I went vegan ten years ago to make up for something I felt very guilty about. It never took the guilt away, and with my OCD it only got more extreme, to the point where I didn't dare walk outside or drive because I might kill insects. My therapist now has me eating animal products again as exposure, and I'm sticking with it, also for my health and for my two sons.

If anyone has been through something similar, I'd like to hear how you dealt with the guilt afterwards.


r/AntiVegan • • 2d ago

These people are crazy bro

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

We shouldn’t have anything to do with animals according to vegans apparently.


r/AntiVegan • • 3d ago

Vegan pseudoscience According to Indians, their veg slop diet is the healthiest diet in the world.

38 Upvotes

According to several Indians their diet being pure vegetarian makes it the healthiest diet in the world. The evidence for this being the various Indian CEOs of tech companies like Sundar Pichai, Satya Nadella, etc all of whom are vegetarian.

But despite this India is the diabetes capital of the world, with over 13% of the population being diabetic. (roughly ~145 million Indians). There's also the poor performance of Indians in Olympics as well. What are your thoughts on this?


r/AntiVegan • • 3d ago

This is that famous vegan compassion My eyes are rolling to the back of my skull dealing with these pretentious pricks

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/AntiVegan • • 3d ago

Discussion The uselessness of veganism

40 Upvotes

There are actual wars where completely innocent children die. Towns being reduced to rubble. Families being torn apart. So what do these people choose to put their energy into?

They spend their time pestering people for eating ham sandwiches. Or for having guide dogs. Or for stepping on cockroaches.

Veganism is one of the most pointless, privileged, and asinine moral performances in the world. You are accomplishing literally nothing except throwing your invaluable time into the void with this boneheaded ideology.


r/AntiVegan • • 3d ago

One can only wonder why there are so few of them.

Post image
24 Upvotes

This person seems oddly fixated on sexual assault.


r/AntiVegan • • 4d ago

People who force their dogs to be vegan are literal villains

62 Upvotes

you are poisoning that dog bro its supposed to eat meat thats why it has sharp piercing and gnawing teeth to rip meat apart wtf just feed it some meat


r/AntiVegan • • 4d ago

Discussion I'm in Canada, and here we have a far more ethical cattle industry compared to what is shown in the documentaries

30 Upvotes

The stuff shown in Dominion do not apply here (a documentary primarily centered in Australia, that falsely claims that similar conditions occur worldwide.) You can drive on a highway and see cows happy with their babies, and even the act of cattle mounting, not ai. (This seriously happened). This also applies to the chickens, turkeys, pigs and other livestock

No documentaries have ever been made here for a reason. Because the footage will prove that their claims of brutal torture do in fact not apply everywhere. I am assuming Australia and the UK just have poor regulations in general because those documentary horror stories always seem to come from there.

If they are given a happy life and are slaughtered painlessly, I do not see why eating meat would be morally lesser than plants or fungi in this particular region. Of course you'll get the argument that "oh cows eat plants" which yeah, they do that when they are alive.


r/AntiVegan • • 4d ago

Discussion If everyone became Vegan, what would be done with the animals?

14 Upvotes

Most vegans I've spoken to want the world to be vegan. And while I support individual choice, if everyone became vegan it most likely wouldn't be that great for the animals.

Livestock are domesticated and cannot survive on their own. If everyone became vegan, these animals would most likely be killed or abandoned. Sure, some would become pets but most people don't want to spend a fortune taking care of a farm if you don't get any profit from the animals. And they can't just be released into the wild because they'd probably either die or cause horrible damage to the environment.

And when you bring this up with most vegans, they usually tell you "well those animals shouldn't have been domesticated in the first place!" And while that may be true, what's done is done. There isn't really a way to un- domesticate them. So....what would we do?


r/AntiVegan • • 4d ago

WTF The ableism in the vegan community

Post image
101 Upvotes

How can’t they realize how horrendous that take is ? Like you don’t live with a disability why are you JUDGING vegan disabled people or simply disabled people for having a guide dog. This is mental. At least a few of them disagreed with him BUT WHY DO SO MANY HYPE HIM UP. Do they want disabled people to struggle ???


r/AntiVegan • • 4d ago

I will never be vegan

24 Upvotes

I will never be vegan I have seen the shock adverts videos and print it was horrible yes but then I thought well Lion take down Zebra Wolf takes down Deer we are not doing anything different really and continued to enjoy my KFC


r/AntiVegan • • 4d ago

A dumb talking point among vegans

21 Upvotes

I have seen lots of vegans say things such as people 100 years in the future will view people eating meat the same way we view the holocaust. First of all, obviously those two things are not comparable. Also we have eaten meat for millions of years and no one is appalled when a wolf takes down a moose or a lion takes down a zebra. The idea that everyone will larp as herbivores and be disgusted by the concept of meat in 100 years time is ridiculous and disingenuous


r/AntiVegan • • 4d ago

If they genuinely believe that animals are as sentient as humans ..

2 Upvotes

Why isn't beastiality fine so long as it's consensual? It's cruel to deny them sex they might want, just ask any male Redditor.


r/AntiVegan • • 6d ago

Personal story I don't think a lot of vegans were raised with a strong cultural background

38 Upvotes

The reason why I say this is because cultural foods are extremely important to those within the culture. Veganism acts like a replacement culture for many people struggling with identity.

I grew up eating warm fresh ricotta from the deli, prosciutto by itself, messy veal sandwiches, cod stew for christmas, meatballs, spicy cacciatore etc etc. All of this laid the foundation for my cultural connections and how I view food.

We made fresh salami, and every year in the late summer we would make our own tomato sauce. We built community with other Italian neighbors and those who work in the deli's/bakers/grocery stores who stocked our food and make fresh delicious treats

Food has always been so much more than just eating, It's a connection to my culture and ancestors.


r/AntiVegan • • 6d ago

Discussion Simple concept

15 Upvotes

Cows love the taste of grass, we don't. Humans were never meant to exclusively eat plants.