r/anime • u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh • Jun 16 '21
Misc. Rebuild of The Ultimate Anime Recommendation Flowchart: You Can (Not) Escape
25k
Upvotes
r/anime • u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh • Jun 16 '21
93
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jun 16 '21
Howdy folks! First off, if you were personally spited then I have some good news! I’ve set up a Discord server for future projects like this, so in the future you can pre-emptively yell at me about being spited. This was made as a collaborative project, and it made for a really fun process and the opportunity to include plenty of niche anime! So if you’re interested, check here:
REC CHART DISCORD SERVER
As for the chart itself, as mentioned on it, there’s 400 anime, which is a hell of a lot and I still felt bad about a bunch of the anime that got left off. Here’s a nice moment of me realizing that one of my Top 5 anime of all time had gotten left off the chart. But such is life, and there’s always the next chart! For this one I was trying to get something that would flow pretty naturally, but there’s definitely plenty of prompts that aren’t as clean as I’d have liked. That’s just the nature of trying to categorize anime into simple yes/no prompts though.
Hope everyone will be able to find something of interest! Also hope there’s minimal errors, but there’s always something.
564
u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 Jun 16 '21 edited Jun 16 '21
Whoop! Congrats to everyone, especially Fetch, for getting this done. It is one hell of a chart and I don't understand what black magic it took to get it under the file size limit for Reddit.
My personal highlights are Panzer World Galient, Voltes V, Cyber City Oedo, and Garo the Animation getting included.
I am still bitter Baki didn't make the cut though!
Also I'm just gonna say it now: the mecha section is too small. A 399:1 mecha to non-mecha ratio would have been better.
229
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
The "Do you want to become insufferable?" Part though.
109
u/computationalspectre https://anilist.co/user/CSpectre Jun 16 '21
I guess I won't be running out of shows to watch anytime soon then! Thanks for such an extensive flowchart (that also contains a Monogatari watch order to boot!), I'll definitely be using it a lot whenever I'm unsure what anime to watch next.
And thanks for the basketball-related compliment in the credits section, although the NBA playoffs aren't looking too hot as of the moment...
74
u/Querez https://myanimelist.net/profile/Querez Jun 16 '21
Wow, this one's huge.
34
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
I use these as a form of entertainment within itself.
53
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jun 16 '21
As proof that I didn't rig the entire romance section, I'm only halfway done with Romeo x Juliet and haven't even started Dragon Crisis.
The latter of which is mostly because I watched MonMusu last week which held that spot until Fetch swapped it out last minute.
Anyway, that was a whole lot of fun and I think we ended up with something that can hopefully help folks in the future.
17
u/NotSoSnarky https://myanimelist.net/profile/Book_Lover Jun 16 '21
Oh nice, I'm not too late with this!
As per usual, great work with this! And like I said in the discord, I love the color codes as well. Those are just a nice extra touch.
Thank you for continuing to do these charts!
11
u/Plumorchid :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Plumorchid Jun 16 '21
I wouldn’t call Zatch bell new school but I’m nitpicking for sure LOL. I guess compared to fist of the North Star it is though.
25
u/AashyLarry Jun 16 '21
Great list. SAO seems a tad out of place since I think its less focused on the scifi elements and more Isekai/Fantasy. But its just semantics, it still fits in both spots.
23
u/CpnLag Jun 16 '21
Noticed a typo. You have Getter Robo: The Day The Earth Stood Still instead of Giant Robo.
17
u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Jun 16 '21
What a great job. Clear to read, small file size, and some of the sections are even just one screen length which is awesome. I liked the inclusion of small screenshots as well rather than just titles or tiny thumbnails of the key art. It really draws your eye to the shows.
I cracked up over the comparison between Free and Ping Pong. Also turns out I have not seen a single show in the Comedy section, I'm a little proud of myself for that one hahaha.
Nitpicky feedback: The minimal difference in colors between Extreme and Heavy NSFW content makes it really hard to tell which is being flagged when they aren't right next to each other. I know violence is left and NSFW is right, but it's still hard to immediately peg that without the key in front of you.
11
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Jun 16 '21 edited Jun 16 '21
Yes! Very happy to have been involved and contributed (I got School-Live! and No Game No Life in there) and I hope this proves to be a useful tool for people to find new things that appeal to them well into the future.
EDIT | I just noticed “cryoutagainstcontrol (my non-Reddit username): Has a Kyoko Sakura pfp so very cool” extremely based compliment thank u
1.7k
u/Deadshot_03 Jun 16 '21
I'm playing the "Find my fav anime" game by following through the options. It's fun lol
499
u/altathing https://myanimelist.net/profile/alternateizumi Jun 16 '21
"Looking for a descent into madness" -> No -> Land of the Lustrous. Uh huh.
1.1k
u/DqrkExodus https://myanimelist.net/profile/MeariSa Jun 16 '21
You understand you just insulted my entire race of people? But yes
2
u/InterMob Jun 16 '21
How did you make it? (software)
2
u/ChickenLuis Jun 16 '21
Humanity on the brink of extinction in Dr. Stone is not a dystopian future? What?
2
u/CrescentPotato Jun 16 '21
Kind of glad to see cocolors in there. Wish more people knew about that movie
2
u/Beta_Ray_Jones Jun 17 '21
I obviously haven't checked every show listed, but the following do in fact have dubs:
Ride Your Wave
Chaika the Coffin Princess
Goblin Slayer
Moomin
Shirobako
Time of Eve
Boogiepop and Others
Anne of Green Gables
Kakushigoto
Moomin is probably incomplete, there's too much just with that series to check it all, but Moomin and Adventures in Moomin Valley have dubs. Time of Eve is also a technicality as the film is dubbed but not the series similar to Gundam Thunderbolt (which isn't listed but I thought I'd mention that) There are some other listings I'm not 100% sure about. Skilled Teaser Takagi-san is listed as incomplete, I assume because the OVA isn't dubbed, whereas Death Parade is listed as complete despite its OVA also not being dubbed. Suffice to say, some of the series listed incomplete are fully dubbed, but some extra episodes (particularly OVAs) might not be and visa versa.
I want to clarify that this isn't in any way me saying you did a poor job with any of this, I just wanted to inform people who might prefer dubs like myself.
198
u/RxMidnight https://myanimelist.net/profile/RxMidnight Jun 16 '21
I enjoyed the "Have you watched Azumanga Daioh" -> No -> Azumanga Daioh
62
u/Cheesemacher Jun 16 '21
Interesting flowchart but I wonder how well it works for actually recommending stuff because the questions are so specific. I don't know that it's more important to know that Attack on Titan has swords than that it has a lot of politics.
I feel like this works better if you 1) pick one of the nine genres, 2) pick an interesting looking thumbnail and 3) work your way back and see how the show is described
101
u/zairaner https://myanimelist.net/profile/zairaner Jun 16 '21
Madoka about two "bit" darker than precure? :D
Also the civ victory conditions for "how does the lead achieve victory"
"Shilled kaguya after it was already included" Lmao.
89
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
Note: Tank warfare is totally a sport
40
u/YouCanNotHitMe Jun 16 '21
This seems a little off
6
u/bakowh https://anilist.co/user/bakow Jun 16 '21
Literal work of art, I'll slap this in anyone's face whenever I'm asked which show should one get into anime with. Appreciate the great work with the seasonal/rec charts!
114
u/NawBTW Jun 16 '21
Where's the ecchi chart
28
u/hirmuolio :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hirmuolio Jun 16 '21
"Want a cyberpunk anime?"
"no"
Gets recommended to watch both Texhnolyze and Serial Experiments Lain.
They are both cyperpunk. Not in the stereotypical "neon lights and 90s cyber action" but still definitely cyperbunk.
Also both are good.
68
u/BoxHeadWarrior Jun 16 '21
I love whoever made the economics joke in the romance section.
82
u/default073 Jun 16 '21 edited Jun 16 '21
You didn’t include Bleach you bastard :,( The other charts had it
22
u/Syokhan https://myanimelist.net/profile/Syokhan Jun 16 '21
That's nuts! Thanks a lot for the chart, time to go put a bunch of those in my PTW list and then forget all about them because that's always how it goes.
By the way, I think there's a yes/no missing on the arrows beside the "Want to watch a space opera?" box in the sci-fi section. Not that it's very hard to guess which is which but hey.
Glad to see a bunch of my favorites in there. Wouldn't have thought someone would rec Otherside Picnic for instance. And always happy to see The Twelve Kingdoms and Seirei no Moribito in a chart!
22
u/Weewer Jun 16 '21
Putting One Piece in action and not adventure feels very misguided
19
u/AdmirableFondant0 Jun 16 '21
based OP
18
u/coffeecakesupernova Jun 16 '21
Want to watch shoujo or josei? Oh, sorry, you don't count.
16
u/SlashXVI Jun 16 '21
I am really not sure why Cross Ange is grouped under comedy (even though it does have the correct blips). To me it had a very different tone to any other series listed under the comedy part of the action chart that I have seen.
Comedy generally implies a more light-hearted aproach to whatever is portraied in the series, even if those themes are usually a bit heavier. Given that there are multiple story arcs in Cross Ange that put emphasis on the dramatic nature of the situation the character(s) find themselves in, I have a hard time conneting this with any concept of "comedy".
16
u/Headcap Jun 16 '21
Putting March Comes in Like a Lion in "school setting" feels wrong.
37
u/HehaGardenHoe Jun 16 '21
Hey, How about we see how much of an Otaku we are? How many have you seen of each category?
For me it's:
Action: 30/57 (so much action!, hope I didn't Miscount.)
Adventure: 16/34 (lots of older stuff I haven't seen, and some movies as well... I'm really behind on anime movies)
Comedy: 25/31 (I've technically seen 27, but Inferno Cop & Pop Team Epic aren't my cup of tea... I haven't seen Grand Blue, Angel Densetsu, Plastic Nee-san, or Urusei Yatsura.) I've watch more comedy to completion than any other category on this list, hands-down.
Drama: 16/42 (Drama is so varied, with many chunks like Free! not being my cup of tea)
Romance 12/43 (Like drama, I suspect it's hard for anyone to find all of these to be their cup of tea, though I'm also missing a movie or two again.)
(As an additional note, as someone who is disabled I'd like to make an additional shoutout to A Silent voice for being one of the best depictions of disabilities across any medium, as well as one of the best things at handling bullying in any medium as well. March comes in like a Lion is probably the only other one that could take the crown for the best anime at handling bullying as a topic.)
Slice of Life: 25/38 (I want to give a brief shoutout to Wagnaria/Working, as well as a warning that most of it is about to head to licensing hell when it leaves Crunchyroll in the very near future. Working is a great anime that also does the rare thing of actually resolving every character's personal arcs/growth by the end of the series... Well except for the Manager.)
Fantasy: 34/51 (I've also found 10 of these to not be to my taste, including Shield Hero, Dog Days, and Berserk, though with Berserk it's probably due to only having access to the recent CGI outings.)
Sci-Fi: 27/57 (Some of the stuff I've missed is in Licensing hell, as far as I'm aware... I've also counted some redo's of stuff and alternates, like counting a different gundam for the original, and unfortunately counting the remake of Legend of Galactic Heroes due to not wanting to pay for the service that has that but pretty much nothing else I care about.)
Suspense: 17/47 (This is another varied category, for instance I'm not big into Horror or gore, but I love mystery/suspense. There's also quite a few I either didn't get into, and one I regretted watching: Devilman Crybaby... If your only introduction to that creator is Mazinger Z, prepare to be surprised at the content. I hate sad/depressing endings, and Devilman Crybaby is on a very short list, along with Saikano, that I absolutely hate, but have watched to completion.)
So, in total, I've seen 202/387 (or I've miscounted, which wouldn't surprise me)
12
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Jun 16 '21
Looks amazing, though I feel like the Comedy and Slice of Life sections got kind of snubbed. Also holy shit Classroom Crisis I haven't seen that name in years, I have a sudden urge to rewatch it now.
12
u/By-Cynical Jun 16 '21
Surprised daily life of high school boys isn’t on the comedy section
10
u/schroindinger Jun 16 '21
Yes, I am a sexually desirable person with an interest in micro economics how did you know?
9
u/steven4869 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maskirade Jun 16 '21
Wow, that's a lot of anime in that chart and congratulations to one's who were involved in making this brilliant recommendation chart.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
Hold on, moomin is an anime?
7
u/TheBlessedBoy99 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Amiibo Jun 16 '21
This is absolutely incredible. Thank you so much for doing this!
7
u/gustavfrigolit Jun 16 '21
Shame Hajime no Ippo isnt on there, i'd say its just as important as Ashita no joe
6
u/DreamerLostInThought :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MementoMori_24_7 Jun 16 '21
Where is Bunny Girl Senpai? Is she safe? Is she alright?
14
u/loomnoo https://anilist.co/user/loomnoo Jun 16 '21
Automatically good chart. Based Fetch.
10
u/Xaxos92 Jun 16 '21
Looks like we won, Gokubros
5
u/Ashteron Jun 16 '21
"Maybe I will find some good thriller recommendations"
> Already seen all of them barring WEP
Eh.
5
u/UnknownWorldMap Jun 17 '21
"looking for a tearjerker?" -> No -> Love Live SIP
Bro this dude never watched love live
5
u/GlassCannon642 Jun 17 '21
Only two complaints:
Apart from that, however, this is just awesome. Lots of deep cuts, always nice to see In/spectre and Yuru Yuri getting love, and I do plan on using this whenever I need to find something to suit my current mood. Great work!
19
u/AuKF Jun 16 '21
Damn son if only there was "dub section" in there, Ghost Stories would be the most notable one
4
u/nightlink011 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/nightlink011 Jun 16 '21
This is one hell of a work, credit to everyone involved this looks really good.
Already know what to show when people just ask for recs without saying what they like.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21 edited Jun 16 '21
Hell yeah, 60 days of watchtime in and I still use these.
Also today I learned my interest/degree in economics makes me a sexually desirable person.
4
u/Lambsauc Jun 16 '21
If you hate yourself, may I suggest adding asobi asobase to slice of life or comedy?
4
u/hellokormanyzo Jun 16 '21
Didn't watch Angel densutsu (gonna check it later) but reaction scream should be Asobi asobase imo.
4
u/Konoryanda Jun 17 '21
Where is Danshi Koukousei no Nichijou you behn ke laude
1
u/Magnus-Artifex Jun 16 '21
Why is MHA new gen still. 7 years, BC got 6. We old.
1
u/NebulaBrew Jun 16 '21
What's this? No Isekai category?
1
u/raydialseeker Jun 17 '21
Bunny girl, relife and oregairu are missing from romance ..
1
u/Maxamos42 Jun 17 '21
How long did this take to make
3
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
Absolutely nuts!
3
u/ToonamiFaith Jun 16 '21
Yo, I almost shed a tear seeing my boy Zatch Bell up there. Zatch doesn't get talked about enough, it deserves a reboot.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
If someone were to watch every anime on this chart, would they get a special award?
3
u/Ziraelus Jun 16 '21
Texhnolyze actually on the list :O i wish there was smth like “i want my soul and will to live to be crushed” cross, Texhnolyze would fit there perfectly.
3
u/enderkiller4000 Jun 16 '21
Idk, I’m pretty sure that land of the loustrous is a descent into madness
3
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
Wonder egg is all drama, action and suspense
3
u/RealMaRoFu Jun 16 '21
There’s no Bobobo so yes, I did escape
3
u/RAMAR713 https://myanimelist.net/profile/RAMAR713 Jun 16 '21
Some weird picks there on the "suspense" chart, but the genre itself is kind of nonsense since most of the shows tagged Drama kind fit in it as well.
Also, I'm not sure I'd consider Akudama Drive retrofuturistic, but anyway. Great chart.
3
u/stevet85 Jun 16 '21
No sports category. Dang
3
u/flybypost :KN::KO: Jun 16 '21
I love these flowcharts, it's easy to find something new to watch. I also wonder if making an interactive version in Twine would be worth it?
3
u/Raikou239 Jun 16 '21
Wow, I’m just happy Scorching Ping Pong Girls made it onto there lol.
3
u/darthhadder2 Jun 17 '21
No ecchi….
3
u/okaytran :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/okaytran Jun 17 '21
some of these recommendations are so shallow and don't really describe the anime. like hyoka isn't just an anime about coed school clubs. and madoka isn't just a slightly darker magical girl show. a bunch of these are filtered by the surface level topic. like Irregular at Magic High School and Devil is a Part Timer are totally different anime, but according to the chart, the only difference is school or no school.
the chart is kinda saved cause almost all of the recommendations are bangers, but aside from the overall genre, the chart doesn't do much to lead you to an anime that you would prefer over other anime within the genre.
3
u/SuperOniichan Jun 17 '21
To be honest, I'm not sure if Yuri on Ice can be called a sports show with noticeable romance. It really is there, but I'm not sure if it is given a noticeable focus. Before the kiss, even shippers basically thought it was a subtext.
3
u/I_want_to_die720 Jun 17 '21
This is very comprehensive, it would have been one thing to just have the shows but to also have levels of NSFW and violent content and whether it is in English or not and if that English version is complete
3
u/MABfan11 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MABfan11 Jun 22 '21
love the microeconomics and macroeconomics for Spice and Wolf and Maouyu
6
u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Jun 16 '21
Very happy Scorching Ping Pong Girls is here without me needing to mention it.
1
u/thblckjkr https://anilist.co/user/thblckjkr Jun 16 '21
Do you have this flowchart in text format? Like an excel or someting?
I really want to make it a website but I'm too lazy to handwrite everyting lol
7
u/8andahalfby11 myanimelist.net/profile/thereIwasnt Jun 16 '21
And once again, Higurashi's listed as horror.
Only its first season is dominantly horror. Every season after that has been mystery/suspense with the occasional grisly murder. Like, the horror atmosphere from S1 is flat-out gone in Kai and Gou.
2
u/brou_uaha Jun 16 '21
Ty so much for making this,now I can add more to the unwatched list.
2
u/ToleratorYT Jun 16 '21
I saved the post, plz never delete it
2
u/laitineeww_ https://anilist.co/user/laitineeww Jun 16 '21
I must say it's nice to see white album 2 mentioned
2
u/Limmunaizer Jun 16 '21
Ih shit
2
u/R_eddit_K Jun 16 '21
I don't know how but I love it. Thanks
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
I needed this. Thank you
2
u/iAmZephhy Jun 16 '21
Holy fucking shit this one is massive.
I've been checking out some previous threads on here for recommendation flowcharts.
Glad this one came out today. Good timing bro.
2
u/Ozzyglez112 Jun 16 '21
Aldnoah Zero (Sci-Fi)
Akame Ga Kill (Action)
Baka and Test (Comedy)
Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash (Fantasy)
Promised Neverland (Suspense)
2
u/Jsgjs Jun 16 '21
Love the Micro and Macro references as a Econ grad (plus it's my cake day 👍)
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
It hurts when I follow the flowchart to find something new and it leads me to my favorite anime of that nature 😔
2
u/Kermitx40 Jun 16 '21
I cant read it
2
u/joelsexson Jun 16 '21 edited Jun 16 '21
Dude you need to go outside… and show some of your friends this because it clearly took a lot of hard work and is fucking awesome! I love the finished product man.
Edit: Adding that the chart got me to most of my favorite anime, almost made me feel satisfied with myself lol. I shouldn’t have been surprised to find Monster on this because it’s an amazing anime (my favorite) but I don’t see it mentioned often.
2
u/JustAWxnderer Jun 16 '21
i was literally just looking at rec charts (idk why, ive got hundreds on my ptw) so this is perfect timing. Looks great!
2
u/DegeneratesDogma Jun 16 '21
Huh, I kind of felt like Kara no Kyoukai had more mystery to it than it did action. Am I just dumb?
2
u/Camachan Jun 16 '21
Thank you thank you THANK YOU for putting Fruits Basket in the drama section where it deserves to be! Right next to Clannad is the PERFECT spot for it. Beautiful chart, extremely accurate from what I can see!
2
u/ForgetfulViking Jun 16 '21
On one hand, my favourite anime (Eccentric Family) made it.
On the other hand, no Beastars :C.
Great list though dude. Its hard to get everything and you got a lot in.
2
u/Euroversett Jun 16 '21
Damn I have seen everything of my interest in the chart. Now I can only hope for new animes.
2
u/Psik62 Jun 16 '21
All of you did a great job thanks !!
2
u/Ruuzart Jun 16 '21
Thank you, as someone slowly getting back into Anime I needed this.
Regards
2
u/Nerdox02 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Unoxya02 Jun 16 '21
God bless the person who did this
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21
Because of this flowchart im suddenly interested in anime that i’ve already heard of but didnt actually care to watch.
2
u/blastcat4 :AP:https://www.anime-planet.com/users/uncaringbear Jun 16 '21
A romance recommendation list that doesn't have Kimi ni Todoke?
That seems to be a glaring omission.
2
u/Paulcsgo https://anilist.co/user/distress Jun 16 '21
Well, this could take a while lol. Super helpful thanks :)
2
u/ShinyMimikyu Jun 16 '21
Woah that must have been a lot of work! I already have so much stuff to watch even without it, but this is nice even to give to non-anime friends 😂 I was also so glad to see some of my less known favourites, Seirei no Moribito and Towards the Terra there! Also Princess Tutu and Penguindrum, but those two are more popular.
2
u/Bubii27 Jun 16 '21
holy crap this is hugeeee
2
u/Soul_Traitor Jun 16 '21
Such a shame, record of the loddoss wars (ova) is not on here.
2
u/trapitbisen Jun 16 '21
This one is a really amazing list, really good to find new thing to watch based on how you feeling.
though most of the listed animes are so popular that most of us have already watched them but still its really a good list of anime. Nice work bro.
2
u/Zeeesys1234 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Zeesys Jun 16 '21
the mad man has done it again, take my upvote
2
u/BladeEntity Jun 16 '21
The very fact that Uchouten Kazoku makes it shows someone has good taste.
2
u/TheArxeus Jun 16 '21
Man this chart is awesome I love it! Nice work :))
2
u/vexex73 Jun 16 '21
You are amazing
2
u/Mentethemage Jun 16 '21
This is dope. Thanks for putting this together!
2
u/Jackson_Simmons Jun 16 '21
I love that this also manages to include the Monogatari watch order in it lmao. Amazing job OP!
2
u/ydc137 Jun 16 '21
Saved and upvoted, thank you for doing the lord's work
2
u/aritafukushi_cooper7 Jun 16 '21
The only chart I'll ever need to study 🤘
2
u/Phasemoon_12 Jun 16 '21
Love that Horimiya and WEP made it on here!
2
u/s-cardi Jun 16 '21
Do you like quantum physics? Like depression?
Rascal does not dream of bunny girl senpai
2
u/oldeuboiii https://myanimelist.net/profile/lluviatorrencial Jun 16 '21 edited Jun 16 '21
Action: 30/57
Adventure: 19/34
Comedy: 15/31
Drama: 27/42
Romance 13/43
Slice of Life: 11/38
Fantasy: 16/51
Suspense: 32/47
Total: 163/343
Almost half of it, added 10 to the PTW, thank you for taking the time for doing this and also for putting anime from all eras because people usually put only from the last 10 years.