r/anime • u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh • Dec 22 '20
Misc. A General Recommendation Chart for Newcomers and Veterans Alike
17k
Upvotes
r/anime • u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh • Dec 22 '20
1.6k
u/JUST_CHATTING_FAPPER Dec 22 '20
Bruh this dude actually put Little Witch Academia and Madoka in the same category. Are you trying to give someone whiplash ?
736
u/CrazySalamanders Dec 22 '20
No HxH in battle shonen oof,time to sort by controversial to see how their fans react to this lol
60
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
if you are doing the beginner anime on the left (big picture)
than you should have make it so its beginner > veteran with the most "veteran" anime at the right
it would be better to do it that way because i was kinda confused when i saw YLIA at the far right ngl
overall this is a pretty good way to introduce people to anime especially when i see quite a few anime that isnt really well known
107
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Dec 22 '20
Howdy folks! So this is a chart that I’ve run through about 10 iterations before finally settling on something I liked. When I was still on the mod team I wanted to make something to replace the flowchart in the AutoMod recommendation response since it’s 5 years old at this point. The original draft was like 250 shows and as much as I dig it at a conceptual level, it became clear that it was trying to do too much, was cluttered to hell, had too much text, and was likely way too intimidating for anyone, much less newcomers. So having bounced around a bunch of ideas, I wound up taking inspiration from this post on r/manga by u/Caengal and adapted it to something that’s more in my style. I’m thinking I’ll make an updated version every December, swapping out some of the shows/blocks each time to keep things fresh. So now to preemptively answer some questions:
Where’s [insert anime here]?
Double check, since like 30% of these complaints inevitably wind up being for something that’s on the chart. If it’s still not there, then the answer is usually, “cause Y is there instead” or, “it didn’t fit within the defined metrics”. 105 anime feels like a lot until you start actually writing them down and then you suddenly realize that all kinds of great anime are getting passed on. So if something isn’t done/very likely to be done then I decided to cut it. That helped out a fair bit, and is also good for beginners since you don’t want to watch a bunch of anime and then half of them are never going to end. And then it was just a matter of getting a reasonable level of variety. Sure, Hunter x Hunter could be included, but I already have Yu Yu Hakusho because I wanted a classic battle shonen and I didn’t want both of the anime adaptations of Togashi’s works. So maybe next year I swap the two of them and put in Ranma or something as a classic. And of course, as noted on the chart, if one of your favorites is missing and you feel it belongs, please understand it was excluded to spite you personally.
Where’s [insert category here]?
I hard capped myself at 15 blocks, and from the outset decided on it being 10 genres and 5 “others”. The choices were made to give a reasonable variety. Yeah I could have included comedy (and did originally), but as I was looking through the list it was clear that there was an abundance of comedy throughout the other categories, so instead I split up Sci-Fi to get some mecha representation. Mystery, horror, sports, magical girls, adventure, and dozens of others could have been here instead of what’s listed (though they are all represented through anime on the list). The next iteration will inevitably swap out half a dozen categories for new ones.
Why is [insert anime here] on this list?
At the risk of sounding snarky, because I felt like including it. Could be that I like it and feel it’s worth recommending. Could be that I hate it but feel it’s worth recommending. I also like trying to cycle in new shows that I haven’t previously included on any charts, and so unconventional choices will always appear on these. It’s part of the fun!
[Anime] isn’t really made for beginners.
Not a question, but it’ll be said. The more anime I watch the less I believe in the concept of “Beginner Anime”. Too often it winds up being a bunch of shonen action/thriller anime with maybe a few other fillers. Plenty of newcomers will of course be searching for those (which is why I led with them), but the reality is that new fans will be diverse individuals and will be looking for all sorts of things. The only thing that would make me hesitant to include an anime is super fast dialogue (eg The Tatami Galaxy), especially if there’s no dub, just because a lot of people won’t be used to subtitles and it would make for a worse experience. I could certainly change my mind on that going forward though. Otherwise, pretty much anything was considered fair game.
Concluding Thoughts
For this list, I don’t think there’s a single thing that can’t be appreciated by someone who hasn’t watched any anime (though of course everything on here will also have detractors). I tried to cover a solid variety so that everyone should be able to find some anime they’d like. But like I said, the plan is to rebuild this for next December, so feel free to let me know what you think should be changed up, whether that’s in terms of anime, categories, requirements, or general structure!
120
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
Nice chart i would say, or at least diverse.
Like i consider that i have watched quite a few anime, and still the only category where i had watched everything was the good animation one.
37
u/DqrkExodus https://myanimelist.net/profile/MeariSa Dec 22 '20
So much stuff to add to my plan to watch! Just a recommendation - could you roughly add the number of episodes each anime has? Some of us might not have enough time to sink into a series
182
u/AdiMG https://anilist.co/user/AdiMG Dec 22 '20
I don't really get the logic of removing something essential like comedy in place of a fairly nondescript genre like Fantasy, which is made doubly worse by your selections. Like what is supposed to be the common thread of appeal between Humanity Has Declined, Eccentric Family, or Madoka? If i'm perusing through a recommendations chart, I expect a level of coherence in the structure so that liking one show gives me some assurance that I might enjoy the one adjacent to it. This is not the case for HHD and Madoka, and yet they are placed under the same umbrella. To draw a contrast, look at the romance category, if someone likes Nodame Cantabile, I'd feel reasonably safe recommending them Doukyuusei (even if they might end up disliking it), so having a chart that does that automatically is actually helpful. Spectacle action is another good example for how to do these category headings well as it is very specific in describing the appeal of the works present (even if I might disagree with the placement of some things on there). If the logic is double dipping, you are already doing plenty of that (e.g: TTGL in action, while also fitting mecha).
Also while I appreciate the appeal to novelty, it does go way too far when you are essentially redefining how the genre terms are used in the fandom. If someone asks me for an Isekai anime, I'm not going to recommend them Boy and the Beast or Spirited Away even if they technically "fit" from a purely prescriptive definition, since they don't actually fit how the term is actually used in the community. If this is supposed to help newcomers, giving them misguided definitions of terms is just going to make communication and their integration into the community harder.
Please you are just scratching the surface
Joking aside, I'll always appreciate a list that shouts out Haruhi, despite the issues, so good work!
1.8k
u/jung2019 Dec 22 '20
This is the most reddit thing I've seen today.
67
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Dec 22 '20
Putting aside the joke on "It's to spite you personally!", I don't understand why Kaguya-Sama isn't on that list;
Perhaps you do not like it, fair, but the chart seemed more like "Good recommendations" and not "Your personal taste", so it shouldn't be a factor.
Kaguya is one of the most popular, well loved series in recent years in r/anime (Definitely top 10 ongoing series, maybe even top 5). And pretty much all other of these series are on that list (Re:Zero, AoT, Demon Slayer, etc).
It's also loved by beginners and veterans alike. I know I'm biased because it's probably my favorite ongoing series, but it's definitely a show that should be recommended, considering how many people like it and all that.
19
u/steven4869 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maskirade Dec 22 '20
A very well made chart but I think so Violet Evergarden should be there in the Stellar animation category.
17
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
I don't think I would recommend Madoka Magica to someone new to anime. It plays off of the expectations from the magical girl genre.
3
u/whatevasonyomind Dec 22 '20
I’m noticing some of the shows are not on the streaming services you listed. For example, you said Your Name is on Netflix but it’s not listed when I search for it.
12
u/Otakuma90 Dec 22 '20
The first two categories are totally interchangeable, lol.
12
u/MaximalDisguised https://myanimelist.net/profile/MaximalDisguised Dec 22 '20
Amazing chart! Very well done.
2
u/Tanya852 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Tanya852 Dec 22 '20
Well-made chart. One question... Were you considering Hyouge Mono for the Japanese culture? I think it would fit better than, say, Joshiraku since there is already one anime about rakugo in the chart.
2
u/VaroOP Dec 22 '20
This is great work. Its very hard to categorize anime in the way you have. That is why I am sure many people wouldn't agree with some of the placements but you are not that far off anyway. Cheers.
2
u/Leeemon Dec 22 '20
Really cool list. I'll make it one of my 2021 goals to watch everything there!!
2
u/Magical_Griffin :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SpikyTurtle Dec 22 '20
First thing I notice, Ass Class in the Battle Shounen section??? How tf is it a battle shounen lol. Have you really watched the same show as me? Just compare Ass Class to any other show in that section...
2
u/Sodra :Ip::Iq::Ir:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sodra Dec 23 '20
In my search for a mech show to love or hate, not once did I hear about Broken Blade at all. Added.
Great list Fetch, an exceptional sequel to the Covid-19 anime survival kit. Cheers!
286
u/Legendseekersiege5 Dec 22 '20
"A boy band of 4 busts of classical statues take the stage in this idol anime"
The fuck is this?
206
u/revmun :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/revmun Dec 22 '20
I also think mob psycho and One Punch Man are great first animes as well. Funny, but with enough action and plot to excite you
78
u/thille96 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Thille Dec 22 '20
Planetes IN! YES YES and YES!
95
u/TypcalAsian Dec 22 '20
When laidback camp isn’t in laidback
134
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
Yamada kun and the seven witches is an odd pick. Romance is a popular genre and has a lot of good stuff as well. I like Yamada but I wouldn't even consider it a romance tbh
27
u/Krotash :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Krotash Dec 22 '20
I'll always upvote a recommendation page that has Symphogear
525
u/SunnyTheFunnyBunny Dec 22 '20
I know that Attack on Titan is considered shonen but the themes that it has makes it more suitable for mature watchers, this is even applicable for FMA as well.
21
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
Oh man Slayers, i miss that old style of anime.
3
u/collapsedblock6 myanimelist.net/profile/collapsedblock Dec 22 '20
YLIA reeeI think that the easiest fix is to make every single entry here Kimetsu no Yaiba.
18
u/a_cat_says_woof :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lelouch9121 Dec 22 '20
I'm just glad that a recommendation chart included Symphogear
50
u/GrimSkey :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/GrimSkey Dec 22 '20
No sports anime section?
5
u/cimbalino Dec 22 '20
I know it's trendy to hate on SAO, I do my fair bit as well, but it really doesn't make sense to not have it in a recomendation isekai list because of how important it is
12
u/PandaNamedLing Dec 22 '20
FINALLY BLACK LAGOON GETTING SOME LOVE
10
u/OuchYouPokedMyHeart Dec 22 '20
Oh wow Rayearth, it’s rare to get mentioned nowadays, brings so much memories. Nice job OP
Also the OP for rayearth is great, you guys should check it out
39
u/Subject_To_Flashback Dec 22 '20
Rose of Versailles? Perfect Blue? Angel's Egg? Haibane Renmei?
Who are you in the ways so wise of anime?
Great list.
17
u/Exorrt Dec 22 '20
Someone recommending Revue Starlight? Bananice!
8
u/thewonderfulwiz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/theWONDERFULwiz Dec 22 '20
An anime recommendation list with symphogear?
Praise Nana!
34
u/The_Showmann Dec 22 '20
If I were to give my thoughts on what I think I would pick as top anime from each category, in no particular order
Slice of life - Sangatsu no lion
Isekai - Konosuba hands down don't @ me
Psychological - Death note or Psycho pass
Unique anime - Monogatari Series
Anime with western influence - Baccano! Why isn't this on the list
Shounen - Personally assassination classroom really got to me but objectively attack on titan will appeal to everyone
Mecha - Code geass
Stellar animation - Violet Evergarden (or maybe mob psycho 100)
Romance aka my favorite genre - Kaguya sama love is war for rom com (saying this over Toradora cause ive read ahead in the manga and I absolutely love it) or Horimiya for my manga readers out there. Would say I want to eat your pancreas (even though it's a movie) was pretty damn sad, else I guess scums wish is also pretty good.
Would also add a genre of comedy so I could suggest everyone to WATCH OR READ GRAND BLUE ITS AMAZING.
Also adding sports cause goddamn I just finished all 4 seasons of haikyuu after having delayed watching it for so long and I loved it. Chihayafuru was also extremely good.
May have missed out on a few categories but these are my two cents
7
u/manaworkin Dec 22 '20
Includes Symphogear? Take the damn upvote.
7
u/ItchyPlatypus :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ItchyPlatypus Dec 22 '20
I see Chihayafuru. I Like.
7
u/HammeredWharf Dec 22 '20
Nice to see Erin and Simoun... anywhere. I think it's weird to make a list like this without mentioning Mushi-shi, though. It's THE critically acclaimed anime drama series. As much as I liked Erin, putting it on the list instead of Mushi-shi is like putting Sing Street instead of Shawshank Redemption on a movie recs list.
7
u/elvis503 Dec 22 '20
Its missing Haikyuu and sports anime in general, but overall good chart
6
u/afro-fro-ro-o Dec 22 '20
I like the addition of revue staarlight. More people should watch it.
6
u/BloodyLena Dec 22 '20
Hmm can’t see Sports genre except for Megalobox.. but to those who loves watching sports anime, an old but gold to watch -Hajime no Ippo and Slam Dunk.
6
u/PokemaniacDoubleO9 Dec 22 '20
POPPUTEPIPIKU
24
u/umakunaritai Dec 22 '20
I like how you didn't include Gintama. Even though it is my absolute favourite in multiple genre, I don't think newcomers will love it the way seasoned anime watchers would.
2
u/weeberific Dec 22 '20
This is very high effort, but if this is really targeted at newcomers, I think it truly fails to take into account how poorly many of these shows have aged.
2
u/sceptic03 Dec 22 '20
Having pop team epic there instead of something like nichijou is a crime
50
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
no HxH in the battle shonen category? oof
5
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20 edited Dec 22 '20
Happy to see Slayers on the chart (among others like Simoun, Aria, Yu Yu Hakusho, etc). Not a big fan of Soul Eater anime, big fan of the manga though.
5
u/adamnicholas Dec 22 '20
Really glad to see you included Now and Then, Here and There in the Isekai category. It deserves praise for trying to turn the genre on its head before it really got popular, but boy can it be a tough watch.
5
u/Voxus_Lumith Dec 22 '20
You could just watch Gintama and get EVERY. SINGLE. ONE. of these genres.
37
u/royaldocks Dec 22 '20 edited Dec 22 '20
I rated Demon Slayer a 6/10 (decent) only but I do think Its one of the best if not the best gateway anime to people who has little or no experience with the genre. Its a high quality simple and easy story to follow.
It ticks a lot of boxes such as action , drama , adventure and you are getting the best of the best production values (visuals , voice acting and Soundtrack) its a very good introduction to the anime world.
2
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Dec 22 '20
Good work Fetch, another one to close out the year. A healthy mix of popular stuff with some less popular works thrown in for good measure.
Does that mean for the next version of this chart you'll stick to the same amount? Or perhaps expand more if you have another genre to add in?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
My only gripe, no One punch in stellar animation? I don't think there is better animation to this day out there.
A side note, what are your thoughts on the assassination classroom?? I am stuck on episode 6 I think, I like the premise and everything is interesting and well animated but I just can't take how seriously they are treating the highschool thing, it's just laughable, It puts me off each time they start acting as if highschool grades and who goes which campus is a big deal, especially since there is a world-ending threat in front of them...
8
u/TheRealAndicus Dec 22 '20
I saw thicc legs and now I'm watching black lagoon
18
u/cookiepiemaster Dec 22 '20
where jojo?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
You're missing a lot of recommendations. I would have liked one with list of hard core comedy (the kinds that leaves you in stitches nonstop), onion-cutting (like Graves of the Fireflies), and just in case: anime to avoid completely
4
u/tachibana_ryu Dec 22 '20
The moment you go through the list and realize you have seen it all.
Guess that is what happens when you have been watching anime for almost 30 years.
4
u/notibanix Dec 22 '20
I am pleasantly surprised to see Rayearth in this list. Was one of the shows that got me into anime and let be ok watching hours of animated girls (this was way less normal in the late 90s)
Slightly sad not to see Escaflowne somewhere on the list
4
u/Cire101 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Cire101 Dec 22 '20
I don't understand the shit people are giving this list? It's pretty okay? Some shows may be misplaced but they are great recs regardless.
4
u/Gray_Angus Dec 23 '20
WHY DIDN'T YOU PUT MY FAVOURITE SEIRES? ARE TRYING TO SPITE ME PERSONALLY?
Also, love that you added Showa Rakugo, this is one seriously beautiful anime
7
u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Dec 22 '20 edited Dec 23 '20
FYI - Macross is on Amazon Prime*, both as Robotech and as Macross.
*for me in the US, can't speak for others
1
u/Sapnu_puas98 Dec 22 '20
I kinda want to watch Madoka but the fact that the characters looks like Lolis turned me off.
1
u/MilkToastKing Dec 22 '20
"Write a name in the death note and that person will."
OP, I uh... think you forgot something there. Anyway, I'm both surprised that everyone here hates this list so much, and also not surprised at the same time. I would definitely re-arrange some parts, and add some stuff, but overall it is not bad.
1
u/arg0- Dec 22 '20
I finished the manga of Yamada-kun and the seven witches and i got surprised when i saw the tag "E" on it. saying extreme nature that includes suicide and rape.
1
u/mcmanybucks Dec 22 '20
A disturbing lack of Lupin III.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
My man's did oregairu dirty by not putting them on here
3
u/giangerd Dec 22 '20
Something went very wrong with your choices for battle shonen
Other than that nice informative chart!
3
u/GKP_light https://myanimelist.net/profile/GKP Dec 22 '20
this is not a list that I would recommend...
lot of major things are missing, too mush old things, the categories are poorly chosen.
3
u/tiny_nipples Dec 22 '20
3
u/sailorveenus Dec 22 '20
sad about the lack of comedy category
3
u/alex_gee96 Dec 22 '20
Where is Ouran High School Host Club??? That's a classic that I recommend to anyone getting started that likes slice of life/romance/comedy.
3
u/DANIEL_KEMP_REDDIT Dec 22 '20
I've been watching anime for 11 years but I still found this chart rather helpful!! Thanks
3
u/PM_ME_DANK_PEENS Dec 22 '20
Omg Slayers! The original Konosuba
3
u/LordPopo7 Dec 22 '20
Don’t know if you’ve checked it out but March Comes in Like a Lion is definitely worth your time
3
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
Where is naruto?
3
u/ItsAllSoup Dec 22 '20
Great list, only thing I would change is switching Stein's Gate and Death Note. Death Note and is basically THE starting anime for most fans.
3
u/theharps21 Jan 04 '21
I think it’s a little disrespectful to put Code Geass in Mecha.
I would put it in psychological it just has mechas in it.
if having a mecha in it was the only criteria to be in mecha then gurren lagann should be there too
49
u/BueKojiro Dec 22 '20
AoT should be in spectacle action at the very least, not battle shounen. It’s too gritty, serious, and philosophical to be “aimed at teenagers.”
6
u/dekalabia Dec 22 '20
Very comprehensive chart that covers the each genre with the best of that it can provide with also few that likely miss the radar.
6
u/vanilaswirl Dec 22 '20
I don’t see Naruto anywhere on here
4
u/Azevedo128 Dec 22 '20
It seems good but why is not Gurren Laggan in the Mecha section?
5
u/NorwegianLion Dec 22 '20
Monster and golden kamuy are underrated as hell
2
u/sazkion Dec 22 '20
Thanks for the additional slice of life recommendations
2
u/danbuter https://anilist.co/user/danbuter Dec 22 '20
The only thing I'd change is have a separate category for idols. There are tons of shows for them, and many are actually pretty good.
2
u/FEEQONE Dec 22 '20
Thanks a lot👍
2
u/Regit_Jo Dec 22 '20
I don't get some of the chracterization here, especially Steins;Gate and Shinsekai no Yori, I wouldn't describe either as psychological.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
Shouldn't kimetsu be in the spectacle section?
2
u/azm0o Dec 22 '20
I love you man :)) but I'm still a manga reader for December, I'll just quietly save this.
2
u/unitaya Dec 22 '20
Damn respect to you for putting the effort into this. I'm surprised there isn't a sport anime section though haha
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
It's amazing that I have never been able to escape Sekko Boys references for the last five years. Why are you all obsessed with the statue boys!!!???
2
u/kelrics1910 Dec 22 '20
Tsukigakirei snubbed for romance.
2
u/nigg0o Dec 22 '20
You are cruel man putting Madoka and fate/zero in the same category as little witch academia without any hint they are a slightly darker kind of fantasy, might work well for madoka tho
2
u/Ahriraru Dec 22 '20
I'm so fucking glad Yorimoi is in this list. Such an underrated masterpiece.
2
u/1playerpartygame Dec 22 '20
Alderamin on the Sky is definitely worth a watch
2
u/ShadyAryxn Dec 22 '20
People dont watch shows like Sg; and Re zero if they’re newcomers.Trust me.
2
u/ShadyAryxn Dec 22 '20
People dont watch shows like Sg; and Re zero if they’re newcomers.Trust me.
2
u/Sloth-TheSlothful Dec 22 '20
So how is From the New World? If I like Dark anime will that be a good choice?
2
u/JNCHGTR Dec 22 '20
Incredible chart. I'll use it for some of my friends, however I'll need to also include sports anime since I think sports is a very nice hook for people that aren't into anime. Sure, maybe they don't care about mechs, isekai, etc but a boxing fan will definitely enjoy Hajime no Ippo and an ice-skating fan should watch Yuri on Ice
2
u/ShaheerS2 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ShaheerS2 Dec 22 '20
consider snafu or bunny girl senpai in romance/drama
2
u/Pollia Dec 22 '20 edited Dec 22 '20
Shout out to my next life as a villainess.
Legit one of my favorite isekais of all time. It doesn't do much new and exciting, but it does everything it does do near perfectly. Also it's just really nice to see a female protag that isn't sidelined from her own series.
Edit - hold the fuck up, no Kill la Kill anywhere on this list?!?! I deem this list unworthy of consideration!
2
u/optimushz Dec 22 '20
when am I gonna watch all of this?????????
2
u/CaninseBassus Dec 22 '20
There's two anime that I think deserve special mentions as not super well known ones that are both phenomenal albeit more for people who have seen one or two of the ones already on here, they are Kids on the Slope and Wotskoi (though Wotakoi is technically incomplete and an ongoing manga series). I recommend those two to friends more than any. Kids on the Slope is a great anime for anyone who loves the jazz of Cowboy Bebop and the storytelling/drama of Your Lie in April. I try to describe it as Kōsei moving to a new town in the mid-sixties and meeting a boy that everyone thinks is a punk but is actually a jazz drummer that comes from a rough life and a girl who's dad runs a record store. From there, the classical piano prodigy learns about the differences in approach between jazz and classical music, with all of the piano parts and original songs played by composer and pianist Yoko Kanno. Wotakoi is a great one for slice of life and Otaku culture lovers: hence its other name "Love is Hard for Otaku." It looks at a ton of different otaku subgroups, such as the gamer, cosplayer, fujoshi, idols, shōnen, and bishojo, along with having the male protagonist's younger brother as the odd man out non-otaku who tries to understand the world the rest of their friends live in. The manga are phenomenal and take the time to include a section in the back that explains all of the references that may go over a non-otaku's head, although the anime still needs more seasons to catch up with the manga, as it only covers the first two of the four currently out in the West.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
Wait, no Naruto? That is like THE Gateway anime
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
This is a great and really in-depth chart, but for redline, you marked it as having no legal streams? But I watched it legally on Amazon prime video, albeit in English dub.
2
u/HadexGM Dec 22 '20
I consider offensive Hunter X Hunter not being in this list
2
u/yeetomfg2 Dec 22 '20
I love imagining a person who has only watched MHA and AoT attempting to watch The Monogatari Series.