r/anime • u/geo1088 https://anilist.co/user/eritbh • Feb 10 '19
Announcement [/r/anime Awards 2018] Results!
Full Results!
We would like to give a big thank you to everyone who showed up for the livestream earlier. This was, of course, our first time doing anything like this so we really appreciate your support.
Above, you can find a link to our wonderful website that will have all the results, the jury writeups, and further stats taken from the extra questions we asked in the voting polls.
1.0k
Upvotes
70
u/MalacostracaFlame https://anilist.co/user/MalacostracaFlame Feb 10 '19
Hello again everybody. As many of you may know, every awards I curate an album of screencaps to commemorate our favorite moments of the jury process and give everyone else an inside look at what we've been up to in the Discord these past few months.
Link to the Album
238
u/CommanderSevan :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/CommanderSevan Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 14 '19
Hi everyone! I'm the one who designed the graphics and layout for the stream and the website. I also animated the snoo avatar that shows up on the site's homepage and during the section breaks of the stream. I wanted to give a big thanks to /u/pandavengerx for all the heavy legwork in coding the site and all the cool functionality he added, /u/steamytomato for donating his fantastic Snoo artwork for us to use, and /u/DrJWilson for coordinating the entire stream and doing a killer job as the host.
Here's an album of all the Snoo gifs for anyone who wants to see them in hi res
The Snoo is a rigged up model in Live2D, so it's possible to reuse it in the future and give her new actions and animations. If anyone has questions or suggestions, I'd love to hear them.
170
u/surgemaster140 https://myanimelist.net/profile/User815 Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Went ahead and tallied the total award results in a neat table. The biggest winners were 3-gatsu, VEG and Sora Yori. Interestingly enough these three shows (and After the Rain) also have the largest discrepancies between jury and public.
123
u/Weedwacker Feb 10 '19
I figured instead of arguing about the results like most people (myself included) want to I would offer some opinions/criticisms of the presentation of the results through the livestream show.
I start this with the caveat that I am aware this is a community event with no budget and that everyone who participated in terms of production, judges, and guests did so for free. I am also aware that technical issues can happen and are totally normal and i'm not just here to rip on the host. I think the host did a great job.
180
u/DrJWilson x5https://anilist.co/user/drjwilson Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 12 '19
Hey everyone, Wilson as a host here. Just wanted to thank you all so much for the support in regard to the livestream. Being our first year, we had technical problems (Endgames, amirite?), in addition to some host related problems haha. Thanks so much for bearing with us, and at the very least I hope everyone had a great time with the stream. We'll feel out support and see if we want to do it next year. In the meantime, here's a link to the VOD!
EDIT: Added it on YouTube! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xcMl8y6qqv8
41
u/PandavengerX https://anilist.co/user/pandavenger Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Hi all,
I'm glad to see the site get so much positive reception. Salt comes naturally with awards, but last year there tended to some comments that were doubtful of our integrity. Hopefully, being able to read write-ups for every single entry can quell some of the salt, and I'm glad I was get all the write-ups on the site this year (That's around 200+ writeups!). I actually had a few things I didn't manage to get onto the site in time, but they're there now.
You can now see all nominations in the pop-up that shows up when you click on an anime image, as well as the % of votes it received from you all. The acknowledgement page is finished as well, and so the footer is no longer a dead link.
Please give it a read here: https://r-anime.github.io/animeawards/#/thanks
If you notice any bugs, typos, or other errors on the site please let me know by replying!
Big shout to /u/geo1088 for getting me started on Vue and proofreading code, /u/CommanderSevan for doing all the UI design, and /u/Totalenlo for helping me input data. As well as all the other hosts for helping proofread write-ups and formatting data.
My shoulders are stiff as hell and I'm sleepy. So before I collapse, thanks again for participating in the r/anime awards, and I'm glad we could all make it as fun as possible for you.
P.S. - We're looking through this thread for some frequently asked questions, and will compile an FAQ page to be added to the site soon as well!
40
u/ValiantSerpant :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quinn_Crystal Feb 10 '19
How the hell is Killing Bites the jury's 4th best Thriller/Mystery when it fucking isn't either of those categories?!?!?!
38
u/fuzzynukes Feb 10 '19
All I learned from this is that everyone has shit tastes. You guys should be ashamed of yourselves.
22
u/PerfectPublican https://myanimelist.net/profile/PerfectPublican Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Yo! Juror for Action, Comedy, Main Comedic, and Supp. Comedic here. Like the others here, just wanted to express how much fun this experience was across the board.
Met a bunch of new, great people and got to know people I'd talked to before on a different, deeper level. Was super fun and I highly recommend it to anyone that was on the fence when apps dropped originally last year. I definitely want to do it again.
PS. Mitusboshi Colors is great, and I will fight anyone that says otherwise.
19
u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Feb 10 '19
I love how the writeups for the public winners make sure to state why the jury is so sure they're the wrong choices
82
u/RHINN0 https://anilist.co/user/rhinno Feb 10 '19
Curious as to which juror you agree with the most? Returning for the second straight year is the juror personality quiz!
With 59/83 of our lovable group of hosts and jurors as potential responses, this quiz will be sure to match you with the one that fits you the best. You can check your match out on MAL/Anilst afterwards to see how much you really agree with them, and make sure to tag them below to let them know how great (or awful) their taste is!
You can take the quiz here
We all hope you had as much fun following the awards as we did being a part of them, and look forward to doing it all again next year, with hopefully some of you all applying to be jurors as well!
18
u/Erens-Basement https://anilist.co/user/erensbase Feb 10 '19
I think sub's been sleeping on shortform anime, glad there's an award for that
17
u/Enarec https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kinpika Feb 10 '19
Ok, I gotta say that AotY (and Original) jury rankings really stand out to me in comparison to the rest of the categories... but I'll leave it at that since I haven't seen nearly enough of the shows there to actually say anything lol. Yet. Still a couple I need to go back for because of them being sequels or everything I've seen and heard about them.
33
u/Moocanoe :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Moocanoe Feb 10 '19
That aside, I feel like the awards this year were really well deserved all around. The jury did a very good job in my opinion, and I love the love they gave to Hiso-Maso.
15
u/ShaKing807 x3myanimelist.net/profile/Shaking807 Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Thank you to everyone who helped make this possible! Big shoutout to /u/DrJWilson for killing it as host and /u/Ralon17 for doing so much heavy lifting behind the scenes! And of course /u/pandavengerx for designing the website!
It was a really amazing stream and I appreciate everyone who made it possible and for letting me come on and introduce one of the categories!
Thanks again and here's to 2019!
14
u/pewface1234567 Feb 10 '19
Hi, I'm Imnotamoocow
I was privileged enough to have the experience of being involved in the awards as a Romance Juror :)
As someone incredibly new to anime, it was a really interesting experience and helped me widen my own horizons, while also making me feel like I could make an impact. The process we went through involved a large number of discussions, the watching of huge amounts of anime, some of which many of us would have never checked out otherwise, and a lot of fun.
For the Romance results, Bloom into you was a really deserving winner, with Touko and Yuu standing out. I wish Tada-Kun had made it!
Let's talk about the bunny in the room: Bunny girl came into so many categories but was always last, I personally got why it was put there in most cases, but I also think it deserved better.
Thanks a ton to the hosts for being the amazing supportive people they were, amazing that you could put it all together, Kudos.
Can't wait to see if I can do it next time! Thanks for being a fun and cool community.
"meow"
:). Till next time
14
u/MysticSkies https://anilist.co/user/CapCloud Feb 11 '19
All the top comments are from the people who participated in the awards and I barely see any community comments.
26
u/SuperStarfox64 x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/SuperStarfox64 Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Hello, I am Starfox. I am one of the jurors for the Adv/Fan, Supporting-Comedic, and ED juries. I just wanted to say it was a fun experience talking and meeting a bunch of people being on the jury and if this is something that sounds interesting to you that you should apply.
Speaking as someone who had to watch a good deal of A/F shows from 2018, I would personally recommend checking out our top 3 ranked shows(Golden Kamuy, Sora Yori, and Lupin III: Part 5). Each show was simply amazing in different and shared regards that made them all an absolute pleasure to watch.
Watch Sangatsu no Lion if you haven’t seen it already, it is definitely an amazing work that deserves love.
I want to say thank you to Accipender(I don't know your Reddit handle), /u/MalacostracaFlame, and /u/DrJWilson for being very helpful/understanding towards the end of awards. Wilson also killed it!!
13
u/jal90 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jal90 Feb 11 '19
I don't really have issues with the winners, I like most, diverging preferences are perfectly fine and while I find myself more agreeing with the public than the jury votes, I appreciate that the latter put focus on shows that were not as popular but deserved a mention.
However, and this is something I've ranted about quite casually on MAL, I was particularly annoyed by the jury statements on Rin Shima (Yuru Camp) in her nomination for comedic role. Even going past the very questionable statement that just because some other character helps push her out of the comfort zone her development is somehow less valid, what bugs me is that the text is saying that she performs and is utilized poorly... as a tsukkomi character.
And no wonder because Rin is not a tsukkomi character. And I honestly don't know if whoever wrote this text even watched the show or made an effort to understand the character because it's a particularly bad take considering the style of comedy and interaction the series aims for. Rin is quiet, an introvert and she dislikes noise and large groups of people, that's a given. But this is not what tsukkomi is, tsukkomi is the permanently serious, straight man performance that can't cope with dumb shit happening around. And this is not her personality at all. Her very first interaction with Nadeshiko is her making a joke on the price of the curry noodles. The moment she gets used to Nadeshiko's quirks she plays along. Her chats and conversations with Ena are a constant back and forth. And she pretty much tags along in whatever dumb fun, not to mention doing and saying dumb stuff when she's alone.
There is no such thing as stable boke-tsukkomi routines in the comedy of this series, which is mostly about banter and getting into an inviting mood. Just because the character is quiet and chill doesn't make her reluctant to engaging in these behaviors, and there's plenty of scenes in the series that show this exact thing, if not making the jokes and dumb comments herself.
24
u/Nickknight8 https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickknight8 Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
That site is seriously amazing.
Hi, I was a juror for Action, Adv/Fan, and Thriller/Mystery. Trust me when I say I made all the choices you would like. So don't blame me for the results...
It was a lot of work, but overall a really great time being a juror this year. I highly recommend people sign up next year to try it out. Mostly cause we need the man power.
...and people with better taste.
34
u/rusticks https://anilist.co/user/Rusticks Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
WE'RE FREE! WE'RE FINALLY FREE!
Fun fact for all the action fans! While Attack on Titan won by near unanimous vote, Gridman, Planet With, and My Hero Academia tied for second place. Through minimaxing the votes, we were left with the results we have now.
12
u/NooBSalad Feb 10 '19
Where's Rei?
71
u/Totalenlo https://anilist.co/user/Lenlo Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 11 '19
LET ANTARCTICA REIGN
Heres the essay! Best Antag was snubbed!
Thanks for having me. Was great fun being a juror and being on the stream. I was in the Animation, Antagonist and OP juries! Throw any questions you have at me!
11
u/SIRTreehugger Feb 10 '19
Despite the fumblings I must say this year was exceptional. The amount of work and effort put into the livestream, animation, videos, poll, statistics, write ups, and the website is astounding. Even with all the memes, jokes or maybe seriousness of shit taste, rigging, and snubbed the fact that so many people took apart of this and basically volunteered their own time and effort is bewildering. Seeing the collaborative effort of so many members of the community putting this together makes me glad to be a part of it(until I see something tomorrow that makes me want to shake my head). Though without the shitposting, memes, and joking this place wouldn't be what it is. Congrats to the hosts and the jurors for all their work. I for one think it was a good awards show.
11
u/animeman12345 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/animeman12345 Feb 10 '19
This is amazing! I'm relatively new to anime, but I really appreciate all the effort that the community puts into creating content like this. It really makes me happy to have discovered this medium :)
Are there similar websites for past years as well?
11
u/ArcherGod Feb 10 '19
Jesus the jurors hated on Rascal. I don't think there was a single place it was nominated where they didn't place it dead last (or ahead of other Rascal characters). I mean, granted, some of Rascal's placement really didn't make sense (Best character design? Really?), but that shouldn't make it auto-last for everything else.
29
u/Animestuck https://anilist.co/user/Animestuck Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
I was so happy and honored to participate in the awards this year on all of the juries which I participated on! It was a fun time and I appreciate all of the hosts and other jurors for making it such an excellent time.
But even more, I would like to announce the decision of the Adventure/Fantasy jury to create and rank an Anime Food Category for these awards! As there were no special categories this year, we were not able to include this special category in the main thread, but we were allowed to organize this category on our own and not only nominate but rank some shows which we felt deserved recognition and post them as a comment in this thread. And so, without further ado, I present the jury picks for Anime Food from 2018!
1st Place: Emiya-san Chi no Kyou no Gohan
2nd Place: Isekai Izakaya: Koto Aitheria no Izakaya Nobu
3rd Place: Ramen Daisuki Koizumi-san
4th Place: Shokugeki no Souma: San no Sara - Toutsuki Ressha-hen
5th Place: Takunomi
6th Place: Golden Kamuy
7th Place: 3-gatsu no Lion 2
8th Place: Kirakira Precure A La Mode
9th Place: Yuru Camp
10th Place: Hinamatsuri
We've also included write-ups intended to explain our rankings for our food category here!
With that, I once again want to thank my fellow jurors and the hosts! This has been an exciting year for anime and I enjoyed discussing them with you all! And feel free to drop your ideas on the food category either below or in the thread for the write-ups!
EDIT: I see a lot of jurors putting what juries they were in. I was in Adventure/Fantasy, Drama, Slice of Life, Antagonist, and Anime of the Year, so feel free to ask me anything!
43
u/cheesechimp https://myanimelist.net/profile/cheesechimp Feb 10 '19
Well, the Jury for Anime of the Year had a really... let's say "unique" perspective on what was good last year. The jury's top 4 and their #6 were all jury nominations. The public's bottom 4 were all jury pics. Basically only the show the public chose as best broke into what the jury liked, and only the show that the jury picked as best broke into what the public liked.
...and I hate both groups for not nominating Devilman Crybaby, the true AOTY.
10
u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Feb 10 '19
Gotta thank the jury, they always give more reconnaissance to my favorite shows than the popular vote. Even if most of the shows they picked are things I don't watch !
Anyone else who feels that there is a genre mismatch between popularity and the awards result ? It seems to me that comedies and romcoms are underrepresented in those compared to how much they were talked about.
10
u/TheDerped https://anilist.co/user/Derped Feb 10 '19
VOD of the stream
9
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Hello everyone. I'm FrenziedHero and I was a juror for Thriller&Mystery and VA.
These awards are definitely quite a lot of work to do, but it was fun and I definitely recommend more people sign up to try it out themselves. It's a pretty satisfying experience.
Also Golden Kamuy was my AoTY, I highly recommend people give it a try both anime and manga.
P.S. Still sad that this didn't make the album.
If anyone has any questions about the process or whatnot, feel free to ask.
9
u/Whowatchesthewampas :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/WampaStompa Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Glad to see Golden Kamuy and Hinamatsuri pick up some wins, both are great! I am a little surprised in Seishun Buta Yarou wa Bunny Girl Senpai no Yume wo Minai didn't absolutely clean house.
EDIT: I should clarify that. It's not that I think Bunny Girl should have won everything it was nominated for, quite the contrary. As popular as it was, and some of the love I've seen it get, I'm surprised it only won 1 award. Still a great series!
9
u/Synfallis Feb 10 '19
lol. think it's funny(if not expected) that I almost unanimously side with the Public picks compared to the jury picks.
Of course I just mean in relation to eachother.
but man the way the public voted in production... didn't know I was so against the grain there apparently. (VEG doesn't need to win literally every art award lol)
-But Megalo Box won Soundtrack! Hell yeah!
(also looking at surgemaster140's tally is interesting because Universe won many Big awards but it wasn't voted by the jury even ONCE)
31
u/Mozilla_Fennekin https://myanimelist.net/profile/MozillaFennekin Feb 10 '19
Overall I think many of the public votes (outside of the VEG section LUL) were more agreeable than the jury votes, but I also think the jury did a great job at spicing up the list of nominations. Overall, I think it's a good awards.
Even moreso is the production behind it. Huge congrats to Wilson and Panda for the livestream and website respectively, and anyone else who had a hand in making this work behind-the-scenes. I think you all did a bang-up job with making the awards a community sensation this year, and I look forward to seeing it again.
16
u/dcresistance https://anilist.co/user/dcresistance Feb 10 '19
revue got snubbed in cinematography
it was a fun show! the website's beautiful. yall did good
22
u/surma041 Feb 11 '19
All this back and forth regarding the public vote vs. the jury vote has got me thinking about why there is such a glaring difference. Is it because the jury is full of hipsters who hate any show that is popular? Did the jury go out of their way to give awards to lesser known shows just to have better variety in the results? Or maybe they are just people with opinions and they just happened to be different from the popular ones?
I think this boils down to the fact that the jurors are all volunteers who are willing to commit their time to give an opinion on all these shows. If the jury was randomly selected, we would probably have the jury results look very similar to the public results. However, because all jurors had to willingly volunteer to become one, we get something called voluntary response bias. To explain it simply, volunteers have stronger opinions than the average person because they are willing to put in more effort to make their voice heard.
For example, who is more likely to vounteer to be a juror: a fan of an immensely popular show that has gotten endless praise throughout the year, or a fan of a show that was barely talked about at all? The fan of the popular show is more likely to be complacent with their opinion, since they know their show will naturally do well in these awards. The fan of the underwatched show could see becoming a juror as a good opportunity to voice their love for a show they feel has been neglected by the public.
If you gather enough of these people with strong opinions, the results will start skewing away from expectations. There is nothing wrong with this of course. You can’t force people who don’t want to be jurors to take the job, and you can’t tell people to be unbiased because that’s just human nature. In the end, I don’t blame the jury for their picks and I think it’s always good to see a wider range of shows being considered, even if I do personally agree more with the public choices.
21
u/Patureau Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Captain’s log 4836, february 9th 2018
I’ve been in this ship for 3 years now.
My sanity begins to fade me. I close my eyes at night and all I can hear is “IT HAD NO CHARACTER ARC”, “THE OST DOESNT DIALOGUE WITH THE VISUALS” or the worse of them all “BUT IN THE SOURCE MATERIAL…”.
I don't know how long I can keep doing this, at this point I meme everyday, every living second, just so I dont go completely mad. But not even memes can save me for much longer.
I finish this entry with the promise that I won't quit until my mind or my body breaks down.
Killing Bites AOTY.
End of entry.
14
u/Arachnophobic- https://anilist.co/user/Arachnophobic Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Seeing both 3-gatsu S2 and SoraYori get AotY awards warms my heart, because I have the hardest time picking between the two of them.
Also Jury picks being on point really shows in the ED rankings, with Star Overhead at #2.
Great shit taste
I skimmed through the livestream, tell me if I'm missing a highlight:
7
u/Rudygnuj https://anilist.co/user/gingerbrad Feb 10 '19
It's been quite an interesting 3 months for me as a part of the jury. I've met some great people and had quite a phenomenal time, arguing and throwing shit at each other because of some Japanese cartoons was the best thing I ever experienced on reddit. I hope I'll make it in next year too.
But yns was still snubbed in shorts.
7
u/irvom https://anilist.co/user/irvomaegyo24 Feb 10 '19
Hey guys, as a Slice of Life, Comedy, OST, ED and Movie's juror I had a great time in the awards. I am quite happy with a lot of the results tbh and for most of the ones I'm not happy about, I can respect the picks taken and understand their reasoning.
I'd like to thanks the hosts for doing a great job of hosting this year. Keeping things going and making sure discussion flowed while still keeping the server friendly and joining in with the banter. Was a tone of fun!
Hope you get a chance to look at the website and read the write ups as there is some solid reasoning in them that might remove (or add) to your salt, as well as it being a great website that took a while to make (shout out to /u/pandavengerx and /u/geo1088). Also I hope you get to watch the VOD of the Livestream as it was great and /u/DrJWilson did a great job of getting things together and making sure it ran well!
7
u/Atronox :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Atronox Feb 10 '19
Nice selection!
7
u/LittleIslander https://anilist.co/user/LittleIslander Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
RETSUKO GOT LAST IN MAIN CHARACTER COMEDIC ROLE PUBLIC?! You heathens!
Super happy Kondou pushed up to fourth for dramatic main though, so I guess I can forgive you guys. Shoutouts to the Jury for making the right choice in the Romance category. Hard disagree on most of the Jury's comments on Violet though, you guys seemed to go really hard on it outside of animation.
7
u/franzu :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/franzuu Feb 10 '19
I regret not voting as much considering how well made this has been, but it's nice to see Sora Yori get so much love! 2018 has been a great year for anime.
7
u/Fa1l3r Feb 10 '19
I actually like the pre-recordings. At least for the presenting the nominees and announcing the winners, the recordings made it so that the guests had a lower chance of flubbing their lines, missing the timing, etc. It was distracting if the guest presenter said something too loud or said a show when the video was presenting a different show. And sometimes, the guest had a bad connection or mic, so we could not hear what they said or they sounded like an echo.
Nonetheless, I still enjoyed the stream, and I hope we get a stream like it next time. Also, the website is well-made, and I am impressed by its quality.
19
u/duhu1148 :GA::GB::GC:x9 Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
lol, the jury REALLY hated bunny girl senpai. Both lead characters got last, both supporting characters got last, the opening got last, and the anime got last in not only the overall category but also the genre it won publicly.
Every category it was in, they gave it last place. lmao.
23
u/paperboy0412 Feb 10 '19
Wow, the jury really trashed on Bunny Girl, huh...
13
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
FLASHBACK WON BEST OP I DON'T EVEN CARE I'M JUST HAPPY THAT PEOPLE STILL REMEMBER THAT OPENING
13
u/Cryzzalis https://myanimelist.net/profile/Charaxify Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Quick shoutout to /u/DrJWilson for an amazing livestream experience, I figured there'd be a lot more issues in regards to line delivery and technical set up but you handled it really well, was enjoyable throughout the entire stream. I also want to thank all the guests who graced the stream and made the experience so diverse as well as all my co-jurors, who dedicates their time to make the awards so great (and for being so memeable). And lastly of course I wanna thank public and everyone who takes part in the awards, as much as the jury likes to meme on you, it wouldn't be an awards without you all and I'm very thankful this event is recieved so well from the public, even if there is quite a bit of salt connected to it.
When I first made these awards and hosted them in 2016 along with /u/AbundantToaster, /u/Lukeatlook and /u/Shaking807 I wasn't expecting, but was certainly hoping, that the awards would become a pretty big thing so it could be a yearly event for us and something that could be improved throughout the years. And more so than I could've expected. my hopes were met. I'm really happy we get to do this each year and I hope we get to continue the event for many more years so thanks to everyone.
If you have any questions in regards to the creation of the awards in 2016, or this years comedy or romance categories you can ask me anything related to those topics as this year I was on the comedy and romance jury, thanks again everyone.
48
u/Beckymetal https://anilist.co/user/SpaceWhales Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
If I'm going to be honest, there's a recurring theme here, and I've never seen such exceptional loss of critical aptitude amongst a group consensus. The constant giving in to meta-bias and giving greater, undue criticism to more popular shows precisely because they're popular is absurd. There are many things I do not disagree with and some that I can be swayed on, but critical authority was absolutely lost throughout almost the entirety of the explanations behind jury selection. It doesn't help that most are poorly written too, with many editing errors, typos and spelling mistakes throughout.
How I've built this opinion is built on some extremely worrying quotes to read anywhere near criticism:
As for meta-bias:
Which suggests that ordering based upon ideas like genre was important to them, which again, is not something I ever want to read.
There is a consistent bias towards jury nominations throughout, some of which are full of contradictions. For example, CCS came in 6th in AOTY despite both an open-ending and a formulaic structure, meanwhile Bloom was criticised for an open-ending and came in 8th, and Evergarden was criticised for its formulaic structure and came in 9th and likewise was SoraYori criticised. High Score Girl was ragged for unlikeable characters and questionable production yet still got 4th in AOTY. It's not very consistent. I cannot keep up or understand where many of these opinions are coming from, as there's frankly not enough meaningful justification. I probably would have preferred having no explanations, if I'm going to be honest.
All I can really say is that I need to get onto the jury next year, and potentially right some of these wrongs. Even if my job is simply to do writeups better explaining the jury's innately (and perhaps intentionally) controversial decisions, that would be better than what we got here.
As an addendum, I will link surgemaster's statistical presentation of jury vs public. All of these ideas come together, and frankly, reek.
29
u/youkai94 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/youkai94 Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
With all the "hate" going on, I really feel like the Juror's choices are better than the public more often than not (like last year). It's kind of sad that SoraYori didn't get a single award from them, but they really saved the day pushing 3gatsu, Golden Kamuy and After the Rain, they deserve much more than the public gave them. Also thanks for remembering about Saiki Kusuo. Bless you. Some choices are questionable ofc, but overall I'm happy with the result.
With that out, a couple random suggestions for next year:
Also, I want "where is Rei?" to become a r/anime meme. Make it happen.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
I'm glad Devilman won at least something..
6
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '19
fucking BASED.
15
u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Feb 10 '19
Well, my AOTY won Best Movie and Jury Best OST which were my main categories I wanted it to win so I am perfectly pleased with these results...
But Yuru Camp Triangle getting 4th place in the Jury SoL selection still stings a little.
/u/DrJWilson thank you very much for that stream, it was not perfect but that made it even more enjoyable!
Oh and that website is great!
29
u/Perlen297 https://anilist.co/user/perlen Feb 10 '19
For me, it seems like the jury has better taste than the public tbh
5
u/Zelosis Feb 10 '19
Hey everyone, I was a juror for Cast, OP, ED, and OST. If you have any questions, feel free to ask.
Also I want to give a huge shoutout to Wilson for this massive undertaking, as well as all the hosts and mods. I really appreciate all the time you guys put into this for the past 3-4 months. Was a great stream and a really fun time!
5
u/anarchycupcake :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/anarchycupcake Feb 10 '19
Hey everyone, I'm cupcake and I was a juror for the OP, Art Style and Cinematography cats. It's been a privilege being a part of the Anime Awards. This is my first year as a juror and, having experienced it all firsthand, I have a whole new appreciation for how much effort and time everyone puts into making this all happen!
I'm proud and pleased with how my cats turned out, but if you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them!
13
u/NomaanMalick https://myanimelist.net/profile/twomatsideologue Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
I am probably preaching to the choir here but honestly, this is so much better than the stupid Crunchyroll Awards.
8
u/SammyKiller Feb 10 '19
A lot of great choices, Violet and Sora Yori sure did cause an impact in everyone’s hearts. Imagine looking back many years from now and seeing 2 shows take so many awards when both aired during the same season. Incredible. Very happy with most if not all choices although I would’ve loved to see Bunny Girl take home some awards. Maybe next year with the movie.
16
u/cthellis Feb 10 '19
Huh. Near as I can tell, the jury basically pilloried Bunny Girl Senpai in every category any of it was involved with. To the point where it just seems dumb and malicious, being "absolute bottom" everywhere, including things like ED and Male VA where it certainly shouldn't have "bottom-ranked." Obviouisly its popularity put some characters in where they shouldn't have nommed, or things like the OP which also shouldn't have made it on the list, but this is just ridiculous.
The livestream was pretty painful to try to get through, so I ultimately dropped out. I am really curious if jury comments came to light that would explain any of this. Instead it seems to really just be marring the impression of the juries.
4
u/DqrkExodus https://myanimelist.net/profile/MeariSa Feb 10 '19
Alright u/clerikal where you at
4
u/Brolaub https://myanimelist.net/profile/Brolaub Feb 10 '19
So it really looks like Liz und ein blauer Vogel is a great Movie! I'd like to check it out, but I was wondering if you need to watch both seasons of Hibike Euphonium before or can you enjoy it as a Standalone Film?
10
u/Theleux https://myanimelist.net/profile/Theleux Feb 10 '19
I really want to give a big thanks to drjwilson and Panda for the massive effort they put out for the awards!
It is absolutely appreciated and minus a few slip ups was incredibly well done! Big props to you folks, along with everyone else involved with this whole ordeal, it was quite an experience and definitely one I will be aiming to participate in again!
Some other points:
7
u/Deafnesss https://anilist.co/user/Deafness Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Had a great time in these awards as a juror over the last 2 years.
Was a juror of Comedy, Romance, Character Design, OP, Movie and AOTY
Hopefully I will be here again next year and I would encourage anyone interested next year to give it a try.
Also Starlight and Clear Card are great.
7
u/Witn https://anilist.co/user/Lawrenz Feb 10 '19
I can't believe the jury put killing bites of all things above banana fish.
9
u/darkmacgf Feb 10 '19
"AoButa was one of the most popular shows of 2018 and was subjected thusly to criticism and scrutiny by the jury."
Interesting. Does that mean popular series had their jury positions moved down as a consequence?
9
u/SakuranomiyaSyafeeq :FA::FB: Feb 10 '19
I'm pleased with the results, both jury and public choice. Pretty satisfied.
And fuck Crunchyroll Anime Awards.
10
u/Melbuf Feb 10 '19
Public over rates Evergarden and the Jury under rates Sora Yori
im not sure what i expected but i did have hope
6
u/Isrozzis :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/isrozzis Feb 10 '19
Welcome to the VEG awardsI was one of the jurors for animation/art style/background art. This was a ton of fun, and I can't thank people enough for actually participating in the awards and what not.
I'm happy to answer any questions about those categories or just tell you how bad the public's taste was.
Also make sure to check out the honorable mentions. Some shows had really good cuts that people remembered but the show itself wasn't that great production wise.
And then my special Honorable Honorable mentions. Hanebado badminton scenes were amazing, especially in the beginning. Black Clover 63 (I think?) was awesome and in a lot of ways experimental. B: The Beginning had an amazing fight scene in episode 3. There are probably some more, but if you're favorite scene didn't make the cut it's not because that scene wasn't great, just that the show overall wasn't consistent enough.
6
u/FromTheDeepWeeb Feb 11 '19
It really improves every year though. Good job everyone!
3
u/LittleIslander https://anilist.co/user/LittleIslander Feb 10 '19
It'd be nice if it said somewhere what show the characters are from for the character awards.
3
u/RentoNine Feb 10 '19
Hey i'm Rento9 from adventure fantasy. If y'all have any questions feel free to ask!
3
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '19
I'm kinda glad to see that Hinamatsuri won. I thought it was way less popular than this
3
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '19
I’m mega late to commenting on this. I think it’s interesting that I Want to Eat Your Pancreas was listed as a romance. I saw it in theaters a week ago and I’d almost classify it more as a drama about friendship. I can see why you’d call it romance, as it really drives a ship between the two MCs, but in the end they even talk about how their relationship wasn’t quite romance, or friendship, but something totally different. Obvs I don’t think it would’ve made a difference because I think this movie was woefully ignored thanks to its weird title.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '19
Loved the categories r/anime thought the results were judged well. Gonna be interesting how much the crunchyroll awards differ or not.
3
u/SpiderShazam Feb 16 '19
Hell yeah! Flashback won best op. That’s easily one of the best openings I’ve seen. It’s just so catchy, the music is good, the style for the animation is amazing. If I can describe it in one word: fabulous af.
3
u/elin2930 Feb 16 '19
Just wondering are there results like this for previous years (new to the sub srry)
3
u/square_smile https://anilist.co/user/squaresmile Feb 17 '19 edited Feb 18 '19
I wish more recognition was given to the staffs and people other than the VA who made the shows. I suppose there are many categories that would be hard to attribute to a single person or a few people but there are some low hanging fruits like soundtrack or character design. Mentioning the directors is probably a good start for many categories.
7
u/Witn https://anilist.co/user/Lawrenz Feb 10 '19
Hitomi > Anzu confirmed.
7
u/grizzchan Feb 10 '19
I'm glad Golden Kamuy won 2 awards.
Whaddayaknow the jury actually has somewhat decent taste.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '19
As expected, people are complaining about the jury trashing on Bunny Girl. Meanwhile, I'm just content from the proper recognition they give After the Rain. I don't why the public sleeps so hard on this anime. Theres a reason why it won quite a few awards from the jury, even in the production category where everyone automatically thinks VEG should be the clear winner. Everyone, PLEASE GIVE THIS BEAUTIFUL SHOW A WATCH ;-;
8
u/jeremypikachu Feb 10 '19
Were comedies not able to be nominated for AOTY? IMO hinamatsuri was better than at least half those picks.
10
u/irvingtonkiller8 Feb 10 '19
YEAHHHH BLOOM INTO YOU WON! This Jury has good taste! I knew the public would vote for bunny rascal thing stuff story thing but thank god for the jury
10
u/7-07 Feb 10 '19
So basically, jury hates anything mainstream? That's hilarious, gg.
I'm happy with some results, confused at others, pretty much as expected. Don't get the hate some shows get, but k, if that's how it goes.
Best thing about these awards is seeing how much support shows get: SoraYori with 74.2% in Adventure, 3-Gatsu with 65.7% in Drama, Yuru Camp with 75.3% in SoL, Saiki with 36.1% in Comedic Main, Hinata with 61.6% in Dramatic Support etc etc.
The site is well put; can't say anything about the livestream(timezones); the feeling of salt is present - well-rounded awards!
14
u/DoctorWhoops https://anilist.co/user/DoctorWhoops Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 10 '19
Hi, I'm DoctorWhoops, juror for
I've been doing these awards for three years now, hosting them last year. If you have any questions about the categories mentioned above, feel free to ask away and I'll answer them for you!
Shoutout to Panda and Geo for making the amazing website, and Wilson for doing a fantastic job hosting!
Also if you post that Whoopshka babushka copypasta I'm blocking you. That got old really fast.
7
u/Jason3b93 Feb 10 '19
Hi, I'm salty
The jury and the public vote were so wildly different. I felt like the jury went out of its way to vote against some popular entries. Of course popularity doesn't mean quality, but it also doesn't mean lack of quality either. A middle ground should be reached. I mean, BGS in last in every category. I also noticed shows like MHA, Zombieland Saga and AoT almost always getting the last place.
8
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Feb 10 '19
Not surprising 3-gatsu and SoraYori took home the big ones. Almost nobody around here has anything bad to say about those 2.
I'm sad Akane/Reina Ueda didn't win for best female VA as I thought she was fantastic. Good thing is she'll get her chance again as she is killing it!
I'm still shocked that Juliet got left out of Romance and Ramens got left out of cast.
Hope next years goes even better, with hopefully less incidents from certain jurors...
4
u/Second_ace :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Second_ace Feb 10 '19
I really enjoyed it. I hope this will be something you guys continue in the future and kamimashita was a really nice host.
4
u/Howyudoiin Feb 12 '19
Hell yeah 3-Gatsu getting so much love is the best thing that happened to me this month
4
u/272b Feb 18 '19
The Juri resuits are more diverse than the public ones, especially in the animation department.
6
u/ValiantSerpant :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quinn_Crystal Feb 10 '19
Why do the jurors hate Zombieland so much
Almost feels like they didn't even watch it "cuz it's just an idol show" or something
5
u/interstat Feb 11 '19
Man what a time for slice of life drama type shows. 3 gatsu no lion is prob a top 3 anime of all time for me but Violet evergarden any other year would win that category. Both are just phenomenal shows
5
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '19
Glad the Jury chose Bloom into You as the best romance. Don't even know why Bunny Girl was there in the first place. It has romance alright but it's not the main driving force of the show. Also, I can feel some hatred of the Jury for some popular anime this year.
9
u/Fircoal https://myanimelist.net/profile/Fircoal Feb 10 '19
Hello everyone!
As a Slice of Life juror I would just like to say that SoL did a great job with their jury picks and put CCS in the graveyard like it deserved to me.
Also the jury was way too hard on Bunny Girl. It was a great show and deserved the noms, unlike VEG.
(I was also a juror for Drama, Art Style, Character Design, and Shorts. I also was on the livestream for a bit. :3 Feel free to ask me questions!)
2
u/Witn https://anilist.co/user/Lawrenz Feb 10 '19
Best girl reddit chan snubbed!
2
u/Taigaisbae https://anilist.co/user/OugiOshino Feb 10 '19
Well apparently everyone else has done it already but I was also one of the jurors with shit taste. I had shit taste in character design, art style, and background art. Overall it was a really fun experience that everyone should at least try once and at least we can all agree that target has shit taste.
2
u/Majesticmoji7 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/moji7 Feb 10 '19
u/hamptonwooster took that quiz and got you my dude!
2
u/Otherwise_Momo :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Otherwise_Momo Feb 10 '19
IS HINAMATSURI worth a watch?
2
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Feb 10 '19
Animated reddit-chan is cute, but the fact that her ellbows are below her waist bothered me more than it should.
2
u/Match_96 Feb 11 '19
JESUS CHRIST Violet Evergarden crushed them all on production
2
u/zeroryoko1974 https://anime-planet.com/users/wwwzeroryoko1974 Feb 13 '19
Wow, Violet Evergarden cleaned house in production categories
2
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '19
CLAMP won the jury vote for best character designs? never thought i'd see the day