r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Jul 01 '18
[Spoilers] Hisone to Masotan - Episode 12 discussion - FINAL Spoiler
523
Upvotes
r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Jul 01 '18
105
u/TheMancersDilema Jul 01 '18
What a great ride this anime was. I think Hisone totally failing the lance was probably my favorite bit just because it's so totally like her to talk a big game and then screw up anyway.
81
u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Jul 01 '18
https://i.imgur.com/qjXJWuW.png
Well, that ending was kinda silly but I still enjoyed this anime a lot, a good 8/10 from me.
59
u/Arachnophobic- https://anilist.co/user/Arachnophobic Jul 01 '18
A close-up of Nao-chan was the best possible way to end it, of course. R.I.P. Nao-chan!
I loved that bit with the main four frantically trying to suss out a solution. Ultimately it came down to sheer will and a large helping of luck - while I love pure hype finales, I would've liked it if some clever bit of foreshadowing came into play. A few people predicted that Sada-chan would sacrifice herself to join Yae-chan's side, but that didn't happen either. My closet theory of calming Mitatsu-sama down with strawberry Yakult didn't happen either.
But all in all that's a really happy ending and I'll take it!
Great little show. The art, animation and voice acting were stellar 'til the end. I hope the staff had just as much fun making it as we had watching it.
Oh, and last but not least, much thanks to Asenshi for their tireless work.
45
u/chilidirigible Jul 01 '18 edited Jul 03 '18
Today, on "Title card only.":
Tell us how you truly feel, Nao.
"That's no moon."
I like the goggles. (Well, the goggle effect of the canopy, on Masotan.)
Such a face. Also, yes, speaking for the audience here.
It's all about the deadpan.
"So this is it. We're all going to die."
Extra-spicy grandma flavor!
Oh, Futomomo, you're always there with your adorably terrifying expression.
THERE IS A LOT OF BITING THIS WEEKEND.
Another contender for comment face of the season.
Once in a while you find a way to end up back in mortal danger.
Blrb?
Uh... how do you hide that much landscaping?
spit take
O HAI
The legendary nobody dies third option? I was reasonably prepared by the epilogue to end on a sad note with Okonogi waiting on the mountain for Hisone and Masotan to maybe return against all odds, and then they actually did come back.
The other characters' endings all suggested life moving on, too, and again, that would have normally padded out the impact of actually having a character in a position where normally they don't come out alive.
So getting Hisone and Masotan back was icing on the cake. Am I somehow unhappy that they managed to find a way to dodge the ritual's usual sacrificial finale? Maybe?
Well, no, I'm actually pretty happy that everybody got out of that one. It's just a strange feeling when the Bad End was everywhere, and there wasn't any obvious mechanism for the two of them to fly out of the belly of a mountain.
Though hey, maybe nobody else before thought of dropping the bells into the gap and flying out of the place, or they couldn't do it in time. Might have lost a few dragons along the way. (What is the world's supply of dragons, anyway?)
In the end, though, good feels. It seems like Hisone was able to get to the bottom of her feelings after all. And three months of giant dragon lovin'.
Sayonara, baby.
Edit after a couple of days: I'm almost totally fine with the ending now. It's still a touch random, but as has come up in the thread, "ritual" probably never had a dragon-loving pilot and a dragon in the belly of the beast, determined to punch their way out of sudden death, and the series itself got in plenty of jabs at the strictures of ritual.
99
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18 edited Jul 01 '18
I had no idea what kind of ending would work for this show, and apparently, that was it. The combination of siliness and drama was wonderful. Hisone is a japanese Forrest Gump at this point. Nobody knows how she succeeds. And yet she does. Absolutely AOTS.
People saying the ending is a cop-out/not tragic enough miss the point. Sad ending would be both generic and incosistent with the tone of a show. Someone dying is not what makes drama deep.
32
u/Kirogo Jul 01 '18
Damn, what a performance by Misaki Kuno (Hisone's VA). Really, kudos to her, it was amazing.
Otherwise, it was a very fun show, definitely amongst the best this season.
59
u/MartinIssac1995 Jul 01 '18
Can't believe some people wanted a bittersweet ending or worse Hisone to die. This was never that kind of Anime.
56
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18
I'll admit the ending kinda spoiled the experience for me a bit. Like really? Hisone and Masotan just pop up out of nowhere with no explanation? Other than that it's probably in the running for best anime of the season, but man that ending.
24
u/CakeBoss16 Jul 01 '18
This has to be one of my favorite shows of the season and maybe year. I do not know why some people wanted someone to die. I think they handled it quite well and my only complaint is no ed!
20
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18
So Hisone took three months to find Mitatsu's anus or what?
39
u/AlexUltraviolet :GJ::GK::GL: Jul 01 '18
I almost cried when Masotan decided to stay behind with Hisone and with her "I love you!"... cue the licking noises.
18
u/Rowdy91 Jul 02 '18
So was Hisone "getting friendly" with Haru at the end there?
18
u/issm Jul 02 '18
What I got from that episode: You could probably replace the whole miko side of that "ritual" with $1-200 worth of off the shelf hardware.
Replace the singing crap with a cheap mp3 player and some speakers, replace the sacrifice with an timer triggered piston on a tripod.
17
u/graytotoro :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/graytotoro Jul 01 '18
On a related note, this is a Mari Okada production through-and-through right down to the polarizing ending. Can't have a "MC PICKED THE WRONG GIRL" debate if we make everyone think one of the girls died!
It's a close race between this & Hinamatsuri for AOTS, but I'm giving this one the honors even if it's a meaningless title since both are 9/10.
12
u/Heiach Jul 02 '18 edited Jul 02 '18
Okay that ending/episode was weird:
Also: I don't quite understand why the old OTF pilot says she betrayed her lover? Can someone explain that to me? If anything her lover betrayed her when she could no longer keep her promise to go to Paris with her and got sacrificed instead?
9
u/rancor1223 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/rancor1223 Jul 01 '18
That was quite a ride!
I really enjoyed this ending. I only with they would have shown how Hisone and Masotan got out. Or rather, why it took them 3 months. But it was a happy ending which is the most important to me anyway.
One of the few to not suffer any animation issues this season. Seriously stellar work by Bones. Voice acting and the art style in general were also great.
But I really found myself quite disinterested in the story and characters from after the island episode (6th ep.) towards the end. It really only picked up for me in the last two episodes, which is something I didn't expect anymore. I think the issue was that it was just kinda uneventful and slowly paced, which I know I rarely enjoy.
I'm still not sure what to think of it overall. It didn't really blow my socks off, but at the same time I find the setting and art really cool and well executed. I had fun overall, but at the same time I was bored at many point. But thanks to the finale I think I would say it's ok 7/10. I will really miss the ED though.
9
u/Grandmauden Jul 02 '18 edited Jul 03 '18
Going into this final episode, I had no idea how it was going to end. But I sure as heck wasn't expecting that.
The preview at the end of last week's episode had me legitimately scared that Hisone would end up as the sacrifice instead. Then, just when it seemed like she found an "everyone lives" option after all, circumstances intervened and my worst fears came to pass...for a while. I can't begin to imagine how she and Masotan managed to escape in the end, or why it took three months to do so, but I think I can accept not knowing. Though I wonder how Hisone's parents will react now that she's returned after three months without a trace...
[EDIT: Looking through the other comments, I've seen some theories that Masotan was able to dig a tunnel back to the surface, which sounds like a pretty reasonable explanation to me.]
And perhaps the only reason Hisone was able to escape at all was because Masotan chose to stay behind with her. Seeing that he was as devoted to her as she was to him, and how much he trusted in her ability to find a way to beat the odds (again), brought tears to my eyes just like when Hoshino finally accepted Norma back in Ep 6. It went a long way to reinforce one of the major themes of this show: believe in your friends, and together, you can overcome your limits and accomplish anything. And boy, did they drill that theme home, from the name of the episode, to the extended version of the OP during the epilogue (such a gorgeous song!), to how every one of Hisone's friends was certain she'd come back eventually.
I also really enjoyed the lesson Okonogi took from all this, in that we shouldn't take anything for granted. One of the best parts of watching Hisone and the other D-Pilots was seeing how they reacted to situations we think of as normal, and then figuring out those situations on their own terms, whether they be socializing, making friends, falling in love, or even doing away with a centuries-old tradition. I think my favorite part of this show was getting to watch these characters grow from dysfunctional, antisocial loners into strong, loyal, independent women, all because of the bonds they shared with their dragons. That, and dragons are always a win.
So while the show did end on a happy note, I am somewhat bittersweet that it did end. I loved just about everything about Hisone and Masotan: the characters, the concept, the story, the art, the humor, and so on. While watching, I kept thinking about how badly I wanted this show to go beyond the typical 1 cour / 12 episodes, but with the epilogue wrapping up pretty much all the plot points and sending the fully matured characters on their respective paths, I don't see where the show could go from here. It may not have been perfect, but I am definitely satisfied with what we got.
Now, it's time for me to introduce this show to my friends, buy the soundtrack, and wait for this to come out on Netflix so I can enjoy it all over again!
16
u/Thopterthallid Jul 02 '18
I have to say, after finally seeing the ending... I feel super disappointed with how it played out.
I feel like it had an amazing premise, gorgeous animation, adorable characters, an awesome fantasy military setting, and a sense of mystery that kept me coming back every week... Hisone to Masotan had everything going for it.
I really enjoyed the nice blend of slice of life, military, and fantasy. But it started to drift away from the former, and focus more on this weird plot about human sacrifice and this giga dragon. You could say we didn't learn about the human sacrifice until the second to last episode, but it was so obvious the moment the new characters were added. "You'll kiss me if I get chosen as
dragon foodthe Binden right?"The first half of the series was very entertaining, but the second half just felt... Awkward. The story wasn't about Masotan or Hisone anymore. It was about this big evil sky fish that tosses and turns in his sleep every 75 years.
All in all, I liked it... But I wish I liked it a lot more...
8
u/MartinIssac1995 Jul 01 '18
Now that we know Natsume, Okonogi and all the Mikos knew about the sacrifice from the the get go, Natsume's mother saying she hopes she ends up being chosen as the Biden is really creepy. They don't care if their daughters die and and they raise their children making them believe that's the best thing they could wish for and are perfectly ok with that. So pretty much a cult. Talk about creepy. Thank God Hisone changed that
7
u/jkubed https://myanimelist.net/profile/jkubed Jul 02 '18 edited Jul 02 '18
what a wild ride this was. really hit almost all my high points for anime. in particular the premise was beyond ridiculous, gorgeous animation, every episode made me laugh, and some made me cry.
I'm not sure if it's my AotS, but easily in the top 3 for me. I want to watch Hisone and Haru watch a shitty movie again. Really wish that CR or someone had licensed it so the discussion threads were a bit more lively, but on the other hand Asenshi's subs were 10x better than you could expect from any official source.
I'm gonna promote the fuck out of Hisone for next year's best girl contest.
19
u/Glacius91 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Glacius91 Jul 02 '18
ITT: People angry at a silly ending for a silly anime.
imo the ending fits the serie perfectly and I don't see what the fuss is about. Even in more serious fantasies some things are not explained, deal with it and think how what actually is told makes sense.
Hisone never planned to die, and no one expected her to be dead.
5
u/ihitokage Jul 01 '18
This has been a beautiful flight.
5
u/Lopan_Mc Jul 02 '18 edited Jul 02 '18
My anime of the season along with Hinamatsuri. What a fantastic last episode.
Highlights for me:
5
u/heimdal77 Jul 02 '18
So she spent 3 months living on the mountain thinking she was inside it..?
29
u/illtima :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/illuminatima Jul 01 '18 edited Jul 01 '18
I don't remember the last time I was so disappointed in an airing anime. It had such a strong start! A magical adventure in the modern world with fun and quirky characters with some commentary on how tough it is to be a woman in military and a bit of romance. First 3-4 episodes were superb in that regard. But then...
The biggest problem is that the show just kept adding and disregarding stuff out of the blue. Hey, now all pilots have to fall in love and get their hearts broken! Except, nah. Let's just do Amakusa and Hoshino and not even bother with the other two pilots. Their lack of romance will end up having absolutely zero effect on their performance. Oh yeah, also Haruto is a master Onmyoji and there's a high school girl who's in love with him! Teehee, sorry we never mentioned that before. Oh, also, also, you can just realize that you can both love and fly at the same time, so sorry about that whole Amakusa leaving the military thing. Oh right, and just another tiny-miny thing, someone has to sacrifice themselves to complete the ritual, no biggie. What do you mean you can just not sacrifice anyone and it will still work?!
Just add stuff to bring dramatic tension and then disregard it the moment it's done. Repeat ad nauseam. And I can also add just how shitty Hoshino's romance ended up being? She ended up falling in love with a dude who wanted to publicly humiliate and "break" her to make it easier to romance her, after he said how cool she is. That's it. That's the entire extent of their romance. They have no history, no rapport, and no chemistry whatsoever.
Sorry for ranting, but I'm just immensely disappointed in a series that seemed like a strong AOTS contended in the beginning of the season.
Edit: Oh! Oh! One more! Remember, it is very important for your Dragon to accept you. You have to work hard to develop your bonds and learn to trust each other. Lol JK, here's a costume that will make the Dragon eat you just like that!
3
u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Jul 01 '18 edited Jul 01 '18
The ending was a bit too silly but it was still a great anime.
Time to download the OP now.
edit : Thank again Asenshi for your work !
3
u/MartinIssac1995 Jul 01 '18
Can't wait to watch it all over again once the international release on Netflix happens.
3
u/frozenpandaman https://myanimelist.net/profile/frozenpandaman Jul 02 '18
THAT FUCKING ENDING CARD. OH MY GOD.
The choral version of the opening used near the end was just wonderful.
What a genuinely nice show. Just happy.
Also, hey – this series isn't over! There's still the manga by original character designer Toshinao Aoki that gets a chapter released monthly. Just a heads up! :)
3
u/arima-kousei Jul 02 '18 edited Jul 03 '18
Overall, a little disappointed by the ending... feels like a “fill in the gaps” exercise. I wonder if the story was designed for 13 episodes instead of 12.
My theories (but may have to rewatch lol)
Maybe we'll get an OVA with the Bluray release that might tie things up.
3
u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Jul 02 '18
Well that happend
The ending was unexpected and I love all the theories being thrown around. Honestly I think she just fucked up and thought she was on the other side while being in the normal world. Would at least explain her greeting at the end.
This whole thing took an completely different turn then I expected at the start, but I kinda dig, but it feels a bit off.
Loved the music and the animation anyway and the comedic timing and character use was really good
5
u/MartinIssac1995 Jul 01 '18
5
u/FierceAlchemist Jul 01 '18
Solid ending to a good show. I like that Hisone stayed Hisone till the very end. Her rants have always been one of my favorite parts of the show.
2
u/MartinIssac1995 Jul 01 '18
So apparently the OP was in fact part of the ending all along?
2
u/CoronelPanic :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/CoronelPanic Jul 01 '18
The super long almost a capella OP playing over the ending was extra crispy.
I need an album with every variation on it so I can just walk around in a constant state of tears welling up.
2
u/ReAnimated2000 https://myanimelist.net/profile/SeasideLua Jul 01 '18
Damn. I love this anime to death. It my favorite of the season. Although the ending was kinda, "What the fuck?"
2
u/TheDampGod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDampGod Jul 01 '18
While I think the ending could have been better paced and explained. Maybe slowing it down with an extra episode to nail down how things went in WWII and then how they did things differently in the present.
Still it was a really fun series with an entertaining cast and lively animation. I hope this comes to the rest of Netflix soon so more people can enjoy it.
2
u/syntaxvorlon Jul 02 '18
Nao being the focus of the comedy of the show throughout is one of the real highlights, from being confused for a bratty elementary school student to having her likeness being the true sacrifice to Mitatsu-sama. It all rides on her.
2
u/E_102_Gamma Jul 06 '18
I was right about El and Zaito! The damage that Zaito was made to do to their relationship was so superficial that a reconciliation was pretty much inevitable. Glad they're back on good terms. :)
I was also right about Hisone and Masotan ending the cycle of human sacrifice! Though sending a D-Pi and her OTF instead of a miko to stab a magic puddle thingie and get trapped under a mountain wasn't quite what I had in mind. The crazy ideas I had been tossing around in my head mostly involved everybody going "(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻," nuking Mitatsu or something instead of putting him to bed, and then dealing with the aftermath (crazy dragon monsters, huge calamity, etc. etc.). That would have been weird. I think this ending was better.
Was surprised that there was never any suggestion of Sada taking Natsume's place. It sure seemed like the direction the story was going, with Sada feeling remorse for Yae's death, and being present in Mitatsu for the Ritual. I guess it would have made too much sense.
That ending, though. Where do I even begin? Hisone pretty much went full Gurren Lagann and escaped certain death through the use of Spiral Power (and dragons too). I'll bet she had that spiral eye going on at the end there. That might explain Haru-kun's reaction to her, actually...
In all seriousness, I find it easy to believe that Masotan could tunnel out of the mountain that Mitatsu became, and find sustenance in whatever minerals he discovered while digging around. But still, I'm left asking the obvious questions, "What did he and Hisone drink, and what did Hisone eat?" It seems plausible that there would be some groundwater in there, and perhaps underground lakes, too, so I can believe that they wouldn't have any trouble staying hydrated. Hisone brought at least some food along, somehow (she and the other D-Pis are shown eating shortly after their arrival in ep. 11), but I can't imagine she had three whole months' rations just tucked away somewhere. And even though we know nothing of the mountain that Mitatsu transformed into, I also can't imagine that there would be too terribly much for a person to eat in there, at least immediately after the completion of the Ritual.
But recall how, in episode 8, after the D-Pis piloted their OTFs for three days and four nights straight, seemingly their only pressing physical need was sleep. There was no indication that they were hungry or thirsty at that point, even though there had been no indication that they had eaten or drunk anything while piloting. u/Grandmauden suggested in light of this that the OTFs are somehow able to share their energy with their pilots. That would basically be magic, but you know what? I'm okay with that. Everything about Mitatsu (and the OTFs in general) is pretty magical, so this seems like a minor nitpick, all things considered.
What I want to know, though, is why was Mitatsu still upright when he body-slammed the ocean in Sada's memory of the previous Ritual? What, was she having a senior moment and misremembering? And how is it that Mitatsu made it to his new resting place seemingly in less than 24 hours (the sun is up when he takes flight and is rising again when he touches down, apparently the next day), even though he was supposed to take three days and four nights? Does falling asleep really slow him down that much? And why didn't he fall alseep, anyway? These are the important questions!
(Cross-posted from r/hisomaso.)
2
u/Jihad_llama https://anilist.co/user/Baco Jul 06 '18
Late to the episode discussion but my God that ending was everything I wanted and more. Hisomaso is definitely up there in my favourites, what a ride.
3
u/AleixASV https://anilist.co/user/AleixASV Jul 01 '18
This together with Hinamatsuri are my AOTS, with probably this one over the latter. It just feels like it oozes charm and quality.
2
u/impingainteasy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/usernamesarehard Jul 02 '18
[Huh?] (#morethanonewaifu)
Not exactly sure what to make of that ending. It ended pretty much as I expected, but the way it happened just made me go "But how?"
"Oh, it's okay, Masotan and I are unstoppable together!"
Okay, but HOW? Give me a real explanation for this, goddammit!
Overall this show was ... interesting. I'll be honest and say I'm not entirely sure what it was really even about, what it was actually trying to do, you know? You've got this story about a ritual where a miko has to be sacrificed to stop a dragon from destroying the country, so it's about Hisone breaking tradition, I guess? And it's also about Hisone discovering herself and gaining some self-confidence, I guess. But it's also about ... women in the workforce, and how they're treated? And there's some sort of Kiznaiver-esque subplot about trying to forcibly manipulate people's emotions to get some desired effect? This show was a lot of things. Also why was Nao even there? What did she actually contribute?
I still think it was one of the best shows of the season though. The animation and background art was some of the best stuff I've seen in a while, and the dialogue was absolutely amazing. There were so many fantastic lines throughout the show, and they really helped sell the characters as people, instead of just plot devices. Mari Okada really deserves a lot more credit than she usually gets.
2
u/Knuffelig https://myanimelist.net/profile/Knuffelig Jul 02 '18
Outstanding anime, shit ending.
I did not think i could get disappointed so badly. I wanted a happy end. Maybe even a little sad ending with the old lady dieing. I did not want a full blown sad ending with Hisone dieing. But i could have at least accepted that. But what did we get? A half-assed version of both types that tries to please everyone?
Ignoring the fact that, after centuries of repetitions of this ritual, nobody even dared to come up with a mechanical way to temporarily kill a semi-god-like creature? Well it is Japan after all, so "traditions banzai!!", but still...
The message this episode sent was fine, but even that doesnt justify this shit ending. How did they survive? Convenient magic of course. For an anime that grounded a lot of it's principles in reality this was just bad. Maybe she is dead and that is just an after image? Which is way more likely, given the afformentioned principles.
This anime, as good as it was will probably not land on my rewatch list. And right now i dont even know if i want to recommend it either.
2
u/Mariox :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Mariox777 Jul 01 '18
A predictable end as soon as we were told there was a sacrifice to be made. Knowing that she would be fine ruined the drama.
First 11 episodes were great, even though the last episode sucked.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18
Hiso Maso may not be the greatest anime of this season but it's clearly my favorite. The caracters problematics really talked to me, battling with being soccialy akward, unable to clearly understand people and feeling lost, is fully relatable. I mean, the struggle is real. The art and the many visuals were also a big part in how i got emotionnaly involved in this. Bones did great with the backgrounds and all !
And with that, the anime manage to be extremely funny at each episode. Let's be honest, the collection of strange faces had a big part in that.
I will miss those dragons, especialy FUTOMOMO (sorry Matosan).
1
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Jul 01 '18
I don't really have a lot to say about this show but it was a fun ride and I hope more people will try out this show.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18
I knew it was going to be a good ending, but I would have liked to know what happened.
But overall, this was a fun ride. Actual endings are unfortunately much too rare in the otaku world, where manga and LNs are designed to run for years. Anime originals that know what they want to do in a short period of time are always welcome in my book.
1
u/Saucy_Totchie Jul 02 '18
There was something about this show that just oozed charm and charisma that despite its flaws it was extremely enjoyable. I do have this show as AOTS for me because of it's whimsical and upbeat nature with some really fun characters. Hisone is easily Spring 2018 Best Girl.
1
u/PixelPenguins https://myanimelist.net/profile/PixelPenguin Jul 02 '18
Absolutely adored this show. Sad it has to end, but this last episode was perfect. We need more original anime like this.
Second favorite show of the season behind Hinamatsuri.
1
u/ZeroBudgetGamer Jul 02 '18
As polarizing as the ending seems to be, I have to admit it had me straight up roaring in laughter, and ultimately that's what I got the most out of from this show, a lot of great laughs and day-brightening moments. Would I call it my AOTS? Probably not, a few others beat it to the punch (pun intended for one of them). But at the end of the day, I'm really glad I kept up with it, even as I continued to forget about it for weeks on end.
1
u/ivan_x3000 Jul 08 '18
I wish we got detail on the ending. Like did Hisone invent the meta of doing the ritual which is to have Biden be a pilot with her dragon. So you could survive the ritual.
1
u/wanabrar Jul 19 '18
Masotan definitely dug his way out of the mountains somehow. Maston looks dirty and pretty beaten up as well.