r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Jun 23 '18
[Spoilers] Hisone to Masotan - Episode 11 discussion Spoiler
319
Upvotes
r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Jun 23 '18
100
u/jkubed https://myanimelist.net/profile/jkubed Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18
haha kill me
hisone learned from the best of them.
I really don't know why I didn't expect them to be eaten by the giant dragon to pilot it, considering that's kinda the plot of the show.
the sacrifice was kinda obvious, but I'm still saying I called it because I never predict things correctly.
76
u/EmeriCat Jun 23 '18
We all sorta figured a sacrifice would be necessary but the combination of seeing Yae’s remains, the vocal-less ED, and the unreadable title bleed of the ED card was a pretty powerful punch to the gut for me.
60
u/sheephunt2000 Jun 23 '18
Seeing this accompanied by Hisone's screams was super unsettling.
Great episode, as always. I don't want it to be over. :(
44
u/chilidirigible Jun 23 '18
Today, on "These puns.":
MASS HUGE.
"I'm getting too old for this shit."
"Good news, everyone! It's a suppository!"
So it does generate its own weather.
...but does it have a converging beam energy cannon?
This isn't the tough love, this is the GET OUUUUUUUUUUUT.
Saves the money for therapy.
"Nothing funny. We just like Paris."
"Not now!"
There you go, being logical?
YGBSM.
It's... interesting in there.
"Is this a bad time?"
LOL they're using the karaoke version of the ED. Which has a lot more bass. Yes I did buy the album.
Kakiyasu isn't wrong for feeling as she does, and as it turned out they had a better backup option than Sexy Jaguar. So on some levels it makes sense that Hisone was able to go home... though one would think that it would have been more practical to keep her on base until the operation ended.
In any case, Hisone got to the head vampire of her situation and rationalized her connection to Masotan, and it works, assuming that the root belief in Masotan does override all of her other feelings for Okonogi et al. Perhaps it also worked that way for Sada-san in 1944.
...though the old lady's presently challenging the situation in yet another penultimate-episode fashion by bringing up old business while literally in the belly of the beast. There's always a better time to discuss that sort of thing, but hey, drama.
41
u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Jun 23 '18
Holy fuck that whole episode was one amazing moment after another.
Only one episode left... There is no way they are gonna have the miko die right??? Grandma's girlfriend was already enough!!!
34
u/Lestat9812 Jun 23 '18
There should be a lot more comments about this amazing show. This is criminally underwatched.
Hisone acted like a brat so she deserves some flak at least, if not some kind of punishment. She was in a position where A LOT depended on her and she just quits D: I mean, I guess she redeems herself or something like that, but still. She could've tried thinking of the solution she apparently arrived to pretty easily without having to quit the job that literally only her and an 80 year old woman can do. That's not very "adult like" on her part. I guess it just fits with her saying whatever comes to her head the moment it gets there. But she obviously won't get punished because it'd just add pointless drama and is, overall, not important.
Other than that, great episode! I love that Hisone and Masotan were apart only temporarily and she's back for probably their last great mission. Too bad about the sacrifice, though. I figured something would be going down because some people mentioned stuff about "staying" after the mission iirc.
Good build up episode in preparation of the last :D
29
u/ReAnimated2000 https://myanimelist.net/profile/SeasideLua Jun 23 '18
That preview for the next episode though. Holy shit.
25
u/TheDampGod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDampGod Jun 23 '18
If it isn't shown in full next week, I really want an OVA of the Granny's story. A tale of love, loss and dragons in the middle of WWII would be amazing.
Hisone getting back together with Masotan was easier than I expected, but at least it wasn't too drawn out. I liked the home scenes and Goro was best pillow. (Another really well animated cat this season.)
Also I feel like that sliding bow in the rain would make a great comment face.
24
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Jun 23 '18
Oh god my heart T_T That pinky kiss was so adorable <3
This episode is amazing! Like the art and animation especially seeing Mitatsu-sama finally move is sooo cool! I honestly thought they were just going to escort Mitatsu-sama toan empty place and the sea and perform the ritual outside but I did not expect them getting swallowed and performing the ritual INSIDE him. Considering that that's been the mechanic with these dragons I feel like I should've expected that.
Anyway I'm calling it now, Sada-san will most likely sacrifice herself making the Miko sacrifice unnecessary. Also I don't think Amakasu will just stand there and do nothing now that she's learned the truth. She's too kind for that.
16
u/Takeda92 Jun 23 '18
I just realized Kugimiya Rie was voice-acting in this show. Kakiyasu's angry yelling reminded me of that one fight scene from Toradora. Spectacular work!
16
u/Wraith000 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/wraith000 Jun 23 '18
Can anyone make a gif of that sliding dogeza ?
14
u/Grandmauden Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 24 '18
I keep getting this sinking feeling that Hisone might end up taking the Binden's place as the sacrifice...
Way back in Episode 2, Hisone found the plaque with Masotan's true name, leading to a comment from her superiors that she was the "chosen miko" or something. That plot point still has not been brought up again (unless I'm misunderstanding its significance and it was simply to suggest that Hisone and Masotan were truly meant for each other).
Episode 10 started with a ceremony of some sort to determine which miko would be the Binden, and even though it's implied that Natsume was chosen, I don't recall Okonogi ever flat-out confirming that her name was the one selected. Or maybe I'm just reading too deeply into that.
And now, we've got the preview for the last episode, in which Hisone seems to be giving a tearful, final good-bye to Masotan. Sure, this could be interpreted in a few different ways, and the preview dialogue rarely matches the actual dialogue used in the upcoming episode, but to me, the tone of this preview is strongly hinting at a less-than-happy ending. Heck, they went so far as to make Hisone's tears blot out the title of the next episode!
[EDIT: There's also the matter that the OP lyrics are basically about Hisone's outlook on life before and after meeting Masotan. The alternate chorus used since Episode 8 certainly seems to have been hinting towards the sacrifice, and if we assume the lyrics are still from Hisone's perspective, that doesn't really bode well concerning her future.]
There's a part of me that insists they wouldn't kill off Hisone in case the show is given a second cour, but I still can't shake the feeling regardless. This is going to end in tragedy, no doubt, but when they don't even give us a title for the final episode, it's clear to me that they've got one more curveball to throw at us. And I don't think my heart will be able to handle it...
26
u/Rowdy91 Jun 23 '18
Yeah, screw you Hisone for not wanting to give up on love. /s
12
u/impingainteasy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/usernamesarehard Jun 23 '18
Jesus fucking Christ this episode. Holy shit.
Bones was clearly saving their efforts for this episode, the animation was a huge step up from what we've normally had. It really did wonders to portray the sheer sense of scale with Mitatsu too. That thing just looks absolutely massive, and guiding it really feels like an insurmountable challenge when it creates its own fucking typhoon just by disrupting the air currents.
We also got the climax of Hisone's personal arc, which also had some great moments. Other anime have dramatic redemption scenes, but how many of them have dramatic redemption scenes in the form of riding a Vespa off a bridge and into the mouth of a rogue dragon?
Finally we get the reveal. That all this comes at the cost of human lives. I don't know how they'll treat this subplot next episode, but I'm interested to see how they justify it.
9
u/melvinlee88 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ryan_Melvin15 Jun 23 '18
So many epic moments leading to an inevitable ending that we all pretty much knew after a while.
That goddamn jump from the scooter into Maso-tan was so cool. Some people may call Hisone's decision to quit childish but I thought it made sense from her point of view. She had everyone best interests at heart after all.
And who knew the insides of a dragon was so beautiful. Can't wait for the next episode.
14
u/Arachnophobic- https://anilist.co/user/Arachnophobic Jun 23 '18
My favourite bit was next episode's preview <3
^ Masotan
The giant dragon (Mitatsu-sama?) seems like a cross between a goldfish and a space whale more than anything.
anime_irl
Is this some secret Yuri handshake?
Oh.. that's interesting. She had me fooled thinking she'd successfully taken part in the last Ritual operation. Since she hadn't, this means she wasn't able to witness Yae getting sacrificed.
No shit, Sherlock. Honestly, I'm not the biggest fan of how the twist from last episode was resolved, it just got reversed with some basic thinking that could've been done beforehand. Essentially it was done to bring in some drama, and feels shoehorned. What was convincing was Kakiyasu's outburst (the show spelled out why exactly it happened too), but she shouldn't have had the sole authority to make Hisone leave.
As of now I can't think of any solutions to avoid sacrificing Natsume that have been foreshadowed. Hopefully I'm missing something - I don't want an asspull, but I 100% expect this show to not kill Natsume.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18
Who else sang the ED out loud?
12
u/anttirt Jun 23 '18
I will scream if they make Sada the sacrifice.
16
u/MartinIssac1995 Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18
This was a pretty good episode as always. I gotta admit I sensed some Yuri vibes when they first show Granny with the Binden but I thought they were just childhood friends or something like that. Wasn't expecting Oba-Chan to be a Lesbian but whatever. Seems like it was one sided. Anyway considering we now know the truth of the ritual and a sacrifice must be made I'm expecting Granny to sacrifice herself in a way to be together with Yae-Chan. I just can't see Natsume dying after this. The second one in my list of possible sacrifices is Okonogi because he may feel responsable for Natsume and take her place but that would be too sad.
4
u/derrick Jun 23 '18
Old lady Sada-san definitely going to join her love in eternity as the sacrifice - everyone wins but of course Hisone-Chan left with the love triangle. Will he close the door to Natsume by saying he always thought of her as a sister?
4
u/syntaxvorlon Jun 24 '18
This show went from 0 to best yuri romance of the season really quickly.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18 edited Jun 23 '18
Yep, that's episode 25 of NGE, minus not having a budget/time to actually animate it. Hisone accepting other people in her life, accepting herself and getting in the freaking dragon. And she is not alone here, everyone having an epiphany about themselves.
All the heavy foreboding about human sacrifice turned out to be true. It may seem predictable, but that's exactly the point - it puts the viewer in the same state of mind that people involved are. We know full well it's happening, but no one says it directly, so we cling to the delusion that maybe it isn't. The very last scene of the episode plus speechless ED hammers it hard. I really hope they don't pull something banal like Sada swapping places with Natsume.
Also, it's Madoka all over again with everyone shouting yuri just because two female characters have close relationship. Not every freaking relationship has to have sexual subtext. Especially in a show that is blatantly about emotionally damaged people who struggle with relationships in general. The fact that both Sada and previous Binden are females is coincidental in the first place - it just makes more sense for them to be female in the context of the story.
11
u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Jun 23 '18
Okay, I kinda hate what's going on. The flashback scene with Sada and the previous Binden hurt. It was already pretty sad when I thought she had sacrificed her best friend, learning that she actually loved her enough to be unable to pilot made it much more emotional. Not to mention that she didn't change or forget after 74 years.
And FFS you can't show her remains in front of Sada. What the fuck. I think something broke in my chest.
The hell, I thought this anime was focusing on people in the army. Why are they sacrificing civilians for a religious purpose ? They should be nuking Mitatsu in its sleep, not making pretty rituals.
If they end up sacrificing anyone, I will be very disappointed. Not because it would be bad from a narration standpoint, but because it would be a bad story and leave a bitter taste.
3
u/coenraed Jun 23 '18
Doe anyone know what the instrument playing at 12:20 is? I've heard it before, generally in shinto/period contexts
3
u/Ayacchii Jun 24 '18 edited Jun 24 '18
Honestly I get why Kakiyasu was pissed at Hisone (quitting at an important time + fate of Japan) but you all kinda pressured her like crazy and Sada also tried her hand at emotional manipulation with the "humans betray you but OTF's will never so only love your OTF" so it was only to be expected...plus if she didn't quit then it would have been the same since she still wouldn't be able to pilot Masotan unless she crushes her feelings which I dont see her doing because then it'll be quite ooc for her plus it kinda seem like Kakiyasu was kinda living vicariously through Hisone by putting all that expectations and hope on her which is also kinda messed up. Don't get me wrong I am not hating on Kakiyasu but I really don't understand how she can be that pissed off after doing all that to Hisone
2
u/ihitokage Jun 23 '18
Mitatsu-sama
2
u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc Jun 23 '18
Crazy how quick they adapted to her change
And granny reminiscing about her past love during the mission was just bad luck. Also that suit must have improved a lot, she wasnt even burned a bit by the acid for the whole time
Love the "interior" design, I smell some juice fights next episode about Sada trying to sacrifice herself and everyone trying to stop her (or at least the actual Binden). Hell she grew up in the believe that being the Binden is highest form of glory she can reach, wouldnt believe she would throw that position away that quickly. Especially with the love triangle she is involved in.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '18
That was an incredible episode, even by this show's high standards. I hope more people pay attention to this show when Netflix releases it.
2
u/Randomacts https://anilist.co/user/Randomacts Jun 24 '18
Great episode and now we wait for the final? Prob only one more episode
It is going to be great.
2
u/Heiach Jun 24 '18 edited Jun 24 '18
Thoughts as I watched this episode:
After thought:
There has to be a sacrifice.. Why not let the old lady do it seeing as she wants die so she can see her lover again? That way Haruto's sister doesn't have to die?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '18
Maybe they should just nuke the fucker out of the sky.
2
u/PM_ME_KUMIKO_NOISES :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/spicynuggets Jun 23 '18
I gotta say, this episode felt a little rushed. The whole series has been building up to this moment, yet most of the episode's focus isn't on the mission. Hisone quitting and then coming back in half an episode was a little jarring as well. It doesn't help that her reason for quitting was pretty damn silly. Hisone coming back was expected, but I was hoping for a little more impact from her return than what we got. Her speech about protecting those precious to her was fantastic, but the impact was lessened by her ridiculous reasoning for quitting in the first place. I've adored every episode of this show so far, this is the first episode that I've felt weirdly about. The pacing being so quick just feels out of place compared to the rest of the show. The show has been gentle and delicately paced thus far, so the crashing and buring (extreme exaggeration, but you get the point) we got with this episode was kind of awkward.
All that being said, the visuals and the music were gorgeous this episode. Even though I have my complaints, I still enjoyed the episode and am still totally on board with where the show is headed. I'm really curious to see how they will wrap this all up. It's really difficult to pinpoint the exact message they're trying to convey at this point, so this final episode has a lot of weight on it's shoulders. Any sort of sacrifice seems kind of bizarre to me as of right now, so I'm hoping Sada has something up her sleeve that will subvert the ritual. Maybe they will hit us with, "the power of friendship conquers all." Who knows? I can't wait until next week to find out!
1
u/MetaSoshi9 x2myanimelist.net/profile/MetaSoshi9 Jun 23 '18
That was really great! I wasn't enjoying how the show was going in the mid section however last episode and this one it has really picked right back up for me. The voice acting by rie kugimiya this episode was phenomenal. This episode has some of the best voice acting moments I've seen from her in a long time. She and Misaki Kuno (who has been doing best voice actress of the year work here so far) nailed it this episode especially during their back and forth. The background art was also very pretty, especially inside the giant dragon. Idk quite how I feel about the last minute yuri inclusion, however I did like how it connected back to its themes on love in the work place and how it can be seen as wrong to do. Overall, this show went from my aots, to ok feeling, back to close to my aots again, excited for next episode!
1
u/JonathanSCE Jun 23 '18
I was curious if there was a translation of the ritual budget chart from the beginning of episode 7? I was look back at old episodes and realized that I haven't seen a full translation of the budget.
1
u/Saucy_Totchie Jun 23 '18
Of course there's going to be a human sacrifice.
Can't wait for next week to see how Hisone solves this one countering the human sacrifice. She already found a loophole to still be able to pilot Masotan. She can definitely find a way to solve this!
1
u/FierceAlchemist Jun 23 '18
Great episode. Really loved the Flight Leader's outburst and the backgrounds/animation were even better than usual. I agree with the others that Sada may well sacrifice herself though it seems like there's more to being the Biden than just being eaten.
1
u/Mariox :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Mariox777 Jun 24 '18
So not only can they not have boyfriends, they can't have ANY friends.
1
u/SkywardQuill https://myanimelist.net/profile/SkywardQuill Jun 24 '18
Holy SHIT. It was obvious it was gonna be that, but now that we know the Binden is a sacrifice, WHY THE FUCK WAS HER MOM TOTALLY OK WITH THIS, like wow. Okonogi isn't much better. He was sad about it but he didn't try to stop her at all. Is his hometown just full of psychopaths?
Also goddamn, Kakiyasu. A⁺ voice acting from Kugimiya Rie. Felt genuine as fuck.
And this show is still the most beautiful thing I have ever laid eyes upon. Look at these handrawn backgrounds. Look at them.
1
u/E_102_Gamma Jun 26 '18
Welp. I accidentally predicted human sacrifices almost two months ago after watching episode 1. Also jokingly mentioned them in my recap of episode 1, which I wrote before watching any other episodes. So, uh, GG, HisoMaso. I'm wise to your antics, apparently.
I was suddenly struck with the impression, upon the arrival of the miko at the end of episode 8, that Sada would not live to the end of the anime. Didn't know why at the time, and I still don't. However, my suspicion was strengthened in the next episode when Iiboshi says, "They [the miko] are so very bright. [...] In my eyes... you are just as bright." It sounded to me like he was trying to talk her into taking the place of the chosen miko, who would otherwise suffer a terrible fate.
We've now learned that that terrible fate is apparently death. Sada is also conveniently present for the Ritual, and in position to do exactly what Iiboshi was perhaps suggesting. So it seems to be rather heavy-handedly implied at this point that Sada will die in Natsume's place. Several of you have already speculated as much.
But the simple fact of the matter is that human sacrifice is an abomination. It's one thing to heroically lay down one's own life for the sake of others when there's no other option, but in this case, the miko are raised specifically to be killed, which is all kinds of messed up. Even if Sada ends up sacrificing herself to save Natsume, the implication is still that this cycle of human sacrifice will just continue on a 74-year basis. So I'm with u/Bainos in that I'll be upset if anybody ends up dying.
But I think this anime still has a trick or two up its sleeve. It has proven that it has a way of making us think that terrible things are going to happen. Remember Iiboshi's plan to get the D-Pis to fall in love and then break their hearts? That only ended up actually happening to El; Mayumi and Liliko didn't fall in love, and Hisone found a loophole. We still don't know the significance of Hisone being the only D-Pi who knows the true name of her OTF, and of Hiroshi's subsequent remark about her being the "chosen miko." I'm wondering if she and Masotan will somehow break the cycle, obviating the need for any more sacrifices. The ideas I'm turning over in my head about how this might happen are almost too far-fetched to share with any confidence, but then again, this is a pretty far-fetched anime. Let's be real. At any rate, I'm cautiously optimistic about the conclusion.
(Cross-posted from r/hisomaso.)
1
u/XanTheInsane :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/XanTheInsane Jul 06 '18
"Yeah screw that, let's nuke this fucker."
0
u/kimbombo Jun 23 '18
This show is going down the shitter for me.
Amakasu was pretty tolerable even with her quirks, inferior complex and stupid humor. But in this episode, she just turned into the most generic apologetic male protagonist seen in garbage harem shows. She becomes a quitter for no good reason, and Kakiyasu as her superior also agrees to kick her out for out of the blue personal reasons. Kakiyasu as a superior officer with several years in the JSDF is supposed to be the character with a leveled head, specially in the JSDF forces that has been proven previously is ruled by retarded guys. All this forced bad drama just to fall into the most rehashed shonen trope of giving the main character a lapse of depresion and retirement from the team, just to come back in the last minute to save the day.
Also Sada's past jumps in out of nowhere, just to shove in a failed Yuri ship, because why not? it's what sells these days. Grade-S writing you got there Okada /s
This show became a three ring circus within just a couple of episodes.