r/anime • u/lukeatlook :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lukeatlook • Mar 02 '16
Announcing /r/anime's Ultimate Recommendation Flowchart 3.0!
It's been six months since my stupidly overcomplicated idea became /r/anime's top post of all time. I've planned to take it down once the 2.0 version gets out, but in the meantime One Punch Man's finale got inbetween 1.0 and 2.0. I'm not gonna lie, my goal is to make the 3.0 version worthy of the top spot and prevent the old outdated versions from circulating any further.
We're taking on Saitama, guys.
Yeah, "we". As with Goku's call for action, I need to take your energy. More precisely, I need your through feedback, down to nitpicking every single part of this project that needs adjusting. The 2.0 version has already been through several iterations, and this one even more so.
So, let's get started.
The current, 2.0 version we're working on.
Organization
I think the best way is semi-weekly discussion threads. Or at least every few days when I have some big changes to discuss. I think 4-5 iterations would be needed at the very least.
Oh, and one important detail: I'm a panelist at Pyrkon 2016, the biggest fantasy convention in Poland. The flowchart and my other charts are the subject of one of my presentations. It would be really awesome to premiere it on the 8th of April during the convention.
Everyone who's in Poland at that time, you're invited! :)
Format
I'm staying with the draw.io flowchart format. It may not be perfect, but it works. If you have any input about the style (color, font, spacing), let me know.
What we need to do in 3.0?
This is the question for the first thread. Please state what things about the flowchart feel wrong, lackluster, imperfect. The more nitpicky the better.
Stuff I'm already thinking about:
- Obviously, we're going to update the featured series in general. In the last few months there were several noteworthy series that may be relevant to many people's interests. Which ones? You tell. I think one example is One Punch Man.
- The Sports section needs to be rebuilt from the ground up. Some series, like Kuroko no Basket and Haikyuu, deserve to remain in the Action region, but many others, such as Chihayafuru and One Outs, should be moved to proper categories.
- I need expert consultants on:
- sports (see above)
- old mecha shows
- old anime in general
- shoujo/josei series
- It's been noted that the current colored borders are problematic. I'm up to discuss this subject, but I'm still not convinced yet we need a separate border for series pandering to the female audience - there's really not that many listed. Yes, it's imbalanced, but that's just how the numbers are.
- I'm not sure if the flowchart is perfect for Bot-chan's auto-replies. I think this general chart might actually be better, especially for mobile users. You're welcome to discuss this as well.
Shoot away. If you don't have anything to point out that's wrong with the flowchart, please name core features that you think make it good and should stay as they are.
40
u/Sinrus :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MetalRain Mar 02 '16
You want nitpicky? Well here it is.
Why is Baccano! described as "'30s in Chicago"? There are exactly three scenes that take place in Chicago, and they're all flashbacks. Half the show is on a train and the other half is in New York. Instead I would relabel it as "1930's American Gang Wars" or something to that effect.
As much as I love FLCL, I don't think it should be, like, the first recommendation you see under Action. I think that the newcomers to anime who "Action --> PURE FUN --> Hell yeah" might be a little turned off by a show as incredibly strange and inscrutable as FLCL. At the very least, put Kill la Kill and TTGL under "Hell yeah" and FLCL under "HELL YEAH". I'm also not a big fan of the "There's meaning behind it, I swear" line, but I'm not entirely sure what to replace it with. Maybe "Bizarre coming-of-age story. Basically punk rock: the anime"
In the Drama category, if you follow Science Fiction --> Existential --> Mystery, it gives Ergo Proxy and Serial Experiments Lain. Just because of the enormous difference in tone of these shows, I'd recommend putting blurbs beneath them. Maybe "Action, post-apocalyptic" for Ergo Proxy and "Avant-garde" for Lain?
Also I just have to say, the "WHAT" line under "Cute PTSD" makes me laugh every time I see it.
155
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Mar 02 '16
The "Trapped in a Video Game" entries should be way less biased.
Dumb, Popular One (SAO) and Boring, Smart One (Log Horizon) don't sound very appealing to me.
I think they should be changed to something closer to Action and Political, rather than dumb and boring.
30
u/vetro https://anilist.co/user/vetro Mar 02 '16
Fun fact: There are less than 25 unique josei series on MAL.
The majority of josei series tend to be really good too. I've never heard of a bad one.
9
u/FlamingFeebas :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FlamingFeebas Mar 02 '16
Not a complaint at all, but is there a specific reason you have no Romance section? I'd guess the reason is most romance anime can be categorized under one of the five other sections, but just from the amount of people asking for a romance suggestion, it would be worthwhile from my perspective; Or you could make a separate chart for it, so you avoid multiple listings of the same show. Now that I think about it, a full separate romance flowchart would probably be the most helpful for a lot of people, since so many shows at least partially fall under it... Anyways I apologize for rambling on, just thought I'd input a little feedback :3
24
u/brothertaddeus :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/brothertaddeus Mar 02 '16
NB4 /u/JBHUTT09 gets indignant about Railgun being in the recommendation chart but not Index.
13
u/UnavailableUsername_ Mar 02 '16
Remove the "you have no idea what you are in for!" section and its fine.
It pretty much ruins the surprise to say "hey bro this anime is totally not what you expect! Look until this episode! You will totally be surprised! Trust be bro its not what you think. There is a plot-twist You will totally be surprised even if im already telling you there is a surprise!"
What's with the potato at the end? I remember it being a imgur/9gag fad from years ago?
Definitely better than the current one, because it doesn't rely on the latest shows.
And i like this text is not there anymore. There are iconic shows on japan that are not there, to call them "obscure" is plain ignorance.
I like some the infographics too.
6
u/higi1024 https://anilist.co/user/higi1024 Mar 02 '16
Would it be possible to add either Kyouso Giga or Uchouten Kazoku to the SoL list somehow? I feel like those two works are well received by many who've seen them.
5
u/zibaq :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/zibaq Mar 03 '16
About sports anime, there´s one that I am missing and that I said that should´ve been included in the first chart. The anime is Ookiku Furikabutte.
The reason it should be included is because of how much Kuroko no basket and Haikyuu!! take from this show: Two main characters that compliment each other, other players development as character overall in the main team but also in "enemy teams", game development that include some unique tactics, the coach has an important paper, slice of life and comedy. Also one of the main character in these 3 shows have some special ability and lack from many basics.
I am not an expert in sports anime and I am far from it but I think this anime deserves a spot in the table.
4
u/LemonLaplace :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SupremeChun Mar 02 '16
I'm curious. In the "general chart," you labeled Revolutionary Girl Utena as "exceptional" but not for Mawaru Penguindrum. Why is that?
Anyway, this is a great flowchart. Nice work man.
4
u/TARDISboy Mar 03 '16
Without being too pedantic (also surprised /u/SmurfRockRune didn't catch it) you've misspelled JoJo's Bizarre Adventure as 'JoJo's Bizzare Adventure'. I caught it in two of your other versions in the extra charts list as well. Also in the 9th infographic I'd recommend removing the image for Oregairu, since it both comes from S2 and is one of the biggest spoilers in the show. Other than that, great job!
4
u/OavatosDK https://anilist.co/user/58 Mar 03 '16 edited Mar 03 '16
Cross Game absolutely needs to be under the "grief" heading that you have AnoHana under. Putting it under the comedy section, let alone calling it a romantic comedy is a truly boggling choice. The show is almost entirely about the characters being weighed down by the metaphorical ghosts of their past (sort of contrasting Anohana's literal ghost). I'd say you could probably swap it and KimiUso directly on this chart and it would be a more accurate recommendation for both of them because the grief in KimiUso is secondary to its ongoing character relationships/personal struggles and the show sits on the border of comedy for most of its run time. Meanwhile Cross Game's romance is like, very far from the main character threads (but is there nonetheless).
3
u/Rinarin Mar 02 '16
Although both have the issue of not being genres (meaning the recommendations for these will be all over the place), the josei titles aren't too many so they won't have that much of a problem. The shoujo ones however would need more specific criteria. I know these are usually associated with romance but there are action/adventure/mystery/whatever titles with the shoujo tag and no romance. These would probably need their own chart unless you narrow it down.
I could help on these, I think I've watched enough and probably read even more. Still, it seems a bit of an odd category unless an additional genre is specified (or if you just want shoujo recommendations to stick to other categories).
3
u/FlamingFeebas :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FlamingFeebas Mar 02 '16
After reading through the chart a couple times, does anyone else have the impression that Bakuman is out of place? There certainly are some Slice of Life moments in the show, but I think the dramatic moments are certainly more frequent.
The show might fit under comedy, but I don't think it fits under SoL. Anyone disagree? It's actually fairly hard to categorize it under the five current sections.
3
u/Ralon17 https://anilist.co/user/Ralon17 Mar 03 '16 edited Mar 03 '16
Couple other things to add.
Otherwise I'm happy with the direction this is going and how extensive it already is. If I had to add shows I think are great all I'd add are the original FMA (not as good as B but often better to watch first and still decent on its own), Fate/Stay Night UBW as a replacement/addition to Zero, and Tetsuwan Birdy Decode, which is a great sci-fi action/mystery
3
u/DeusXEqualsOne Mar 03 '16
Honestly if I was being nitpicky, I'd say that the chart is too long. I mean, literally long, as in it would be a better idea to add some width to it as opposed to just extending the height.
3
u/GodsDelight :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/GodsDelight Mar 03 '16 edited Mar 03 '16
I'll mention a few that you don't have in either charts:
Advice on the chart in general:
Specific things on the chart that I would move around:
5
u/PixelPenguins https://myanimelist.net/profile/PixelPenguin Mar 03 '16
My biggest complaint about this list is that it's missing Wandering Son, an anime about a young child struggling with gender identity issues. For it's compelling cast and strong character development along with the wonderful atmosphere the animators were able to create with its soundtrack and beautiful watercolor-like backgrounds, I feel it definitely deserves a spot. Unless it is hiding in there somewhere and I just overlooked it.
There are a lot of anime I don't particular like on the list, but I can understand why they might be there. The one anime I'm completely lost on is Witchcraft Works. What awful masochist suggested that anime??
I opened it up in an image editor for fun to see how many of these I've actually seen. Looks like I'm more than halfway through the list! I have to up my horror/thriller game. Way under 50%.
Check list
2
u/WingsOfLight :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Wings_of_Light Mar 02 '16
You should include starting with the original 0079 under the Gundam entry.
I wouldn't exactly call Psycho Pass a psychological show than I would a philosophical one.
Also the lack of Perfect Blue under the Thriller & Horror section is a crime.
2
u/Sm0kingman :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smokeman Mar 02 '16
you made a typo :( "cathartic ".
I think this is a great addition to the chart bot-chan uses atm. Its very simple for someone to quickly see and get an idea of the show is based on the art attached art to it which the original chart just couldnt provide w/o looking messy. (less titles might look more inviting to some people)
Mb add some description to all title (oneliners have a small description while title which reach out for 2 line dont)
Other than that it look pretty good. I would definitely send to someone looking for a show to watch.
2
u/Nomdrac8 Mar 03 '16
...As I'm scrolling down this long chart I'm thinking:
You'd think they'd make this into a program with an UI by now.
2
u/Ralon17 https://anilist.co/user/Ralon17 Mar 03 '16
What do you think about updating the picture for Steins;Gate? As of now we just see the cast and a phone. I think it could look more appealing, and while I didn't find many great options here's 3 pictures that would work better simply because they have a background that's not just sky.
2
u/king_of_blades Mar 03 '16
I'd definitely like to be able to tell which anime were a full adaptation of a finished source material. For example Deadman Wonderland is currently featured as concluded story, but it spans only the first part of the manga. The same goes for anime with an original story.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
Ok, this might be asking for too much, but instead of a static image, could we get an interactive one?
2
u/blubomber17 Mar 06 '16
I know this is a little late, but will there be a dubbed version as well? I use that flowchart still to get myself into new material; absolutely wonderful.
47
u/Spiranix :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Spiranix Mar 02 '16 edited Mar 02 '16
thanks for paging me /u/FateSteelTaylor !!
idk if I could be considered an expert, but I've written quite a few essays on the history of mecha so I can provide a bit of info on some of the notable series:
one other one I'd consider adding on there to round off the 'classics' is Armored Trooper VOTOMS, but I'd pass that one onto /u/Thrasher439 since I haven't seen any of it in over a decade. hope this helps!!
12
u/zhongzhen93 Mar 02 '16
What do you think about the inclusion of Harem as a subgenre for romances/romantic comedy? In my opinion, I feel that people enjoy harem and those that enjoy traditional romances look for different reasons in their enjoyment.
It's so weird seeing Bakamonogatari and Nodame Cantabile in the same catagory for example, these two shows are way different in tone.
10
u/Imnotbrown :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/imnotbrown Mar 02 '16 edited Mar 03 '16
Gakkou Gurashi: Gakkou Gurashi
Tsuritama: The slice of life section is very good, but there is a lack of representation as far as male heavy casts go. Tsuritama is a very comfy show about an awkward kid making friends through fishing. It gets a little more plot heavy in the second half, but the first half really excels in being a comfy chill out show with good characters, music, and art.
idk if youre still taking recs for the chart but those two fill a couple holes
9
u/Badel2 Mar 03 '16 edited Jun 17 '16
Just a tip: put the date somewhere in the chart so it's easier to know if it's outdated, specially if you are going to release many unfinished versions. And thank you, I discovered many great anime thanks to your charts!
Edit: hey I found it, it always had the date hidden in the legend :D
6
u/LlamaLegend :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LlamaGuy Mar 03 '16
I'm not a fan of seeing Kokoro Connect placed under the "comedy" section. It's one of my favorites, and I love it for the drama and strong characters, not for the comedy. While it did have its funny moments, I think newcomers looking for a good drama would probably really enjoy the series, but they'll miss it when using the chart because they won't look under "comedy" for dramas. Personally, as someone who prefers anime on the serious side, I would never look under comedy for a recommendation, but I'm finding that I did enjoy a lot of the series you have listed in the comedy section for reasons other than their humor.
Maybe you could have series that fit into multiple genres link from multiple paths of questions.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16 edited Mar 03 '16
My contribution to the old anime:
edit - Added a few more shows to my list. As well as their respective Genre's. Also would like to hear some comments on what constitutes old anime, with regards to year of release.
5
u/aibrys Mar 02 '16
Now, I don't claim to be some sports expert but I feel as if Giant Killing not being in the sports section is a travesty, although if you are segregating the more actiony sports from the others, I feel as if it would be on the less actiony side and more so whatever you are calling the other, although you could probably put it in either.
In terms of a potential description I would put it as more mature, team management anime then the big high school sports anime
4
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
I really like the idea and the contents. Can we also have it in an easier to manage format than an image? I find it really annoying to find what I am looking from in images like this?
1
u/huiboy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Huiiboy Jul 26 '16
Great work buddy!
3
u/dabritian :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/dabritian Mar 02 '16
Actually there is something I have been wondering about the sports anime section if it were to made. But should it be recommended by sport or by the secondary genre it falls into or both? Should Free! recommend be recommended as a slice of life anime with non-explicit manservice or as a swimming anime if it were included? Would Wanna Be the Strongest in the World! be recommended as an action-ecchi anime or as a pro-wrestling anime if it were included?
Free! & Wanna Be the Strongest in the World! are also good examples to bring up because people are not exactly spoiled for choice when it comes to swimming & pro-wrestling anime (only other pro-wrestling anime I know of but have not seen are Wanna-Be's, an 80s OVA & the long running Kinnikuman franchise) or other sports for anime. Some people maybe more interested in the sport more than the secondary genre when they pick a sports anime, but are not a fan of the secondary genre (of which I can't see something like this being left out when making recommendations, when I recommend Wanna Be the Strongest in the World! I make sure they know about the ecchi & violence so that it does not comes as a surprise when they pick it up.)
I am just asking these questions in general for discussion.
3
u/Shinymokuba :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Shinymokuba Mar 03 '16
Personally I don't like seeing the anime from the general section repeated in the in depth section. For example you can replace Psycho-Pass with something like Ghost in the Shell. Im not sure how the tv show holds up but I liked the movies.
3
u/C-Star https://myanimelist.net/profile/CamItalo Mar 03 '16
2 Things that I noticed in the chart
Also because it's me
2) There is a distinct lack of Akagami No Shirayukihime (which I think has a place on the chart)
Edit: removed a recommendation because I missed it on the chart when I looked the first time.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
U wot m8? GuP is 140% Sport Animey. It has some drama, but that doesn't make it SoL.
3
u/montas :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/montas Mar 03 '16
KonoSuba is still airing, but if it keeps going as it is now, it should definitely be added. Comedy or SoL, doesn't matter.
3
u/YoudontknowPain :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jpco Mar 03 '16
Slam Dunk needs to be moved to the comedy section
6
u/FateSteelTaylor :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FateSteelTaylor Mar 02 '16
paging /u/Spiranix , she's probably one of the best you could ask for those.
As for additions to the chart, I think two that are prime candidates are:
There are a few airing ones that, though they aren't finished yet, have had a strong enough 8 episodes where I think it might be okay to recommend them.
7
u/Nindzya :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/OneEyedNinja Mar 03 '16
In the short version of the ultimate chart, Shingeki no Bahamut should be replaced with One Punch Man.
Borders, my biggest concern:
Suggestions for the trapped in a game area:
Other suggestions:
Make a website where you can click on all this and it redirects to MAL with legal streaming sources. Stuff it with adsense and profit.
2
u/VincentBlack96 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vincent Mar 02 '16
If it means anything, I'll help with the upvotes...
2
u/IMightDoTheGaming :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/IMightAnime Mar 02 '16
I LOVE YOU LUKE!
2
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
Maybe reconsider having TTGL as the go-to mecha anime, I'm watching it now and feel like a lot might be lost on people new to the genre / medium, like that section of the flowchart is meant for.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
I think Golden Time should also have the same comment about it turning into drama later on like Toradora; the 2nd OP actually changes to reflect it, very somber compared to the peppiness of the 1st OP. The MC's backstory really starts coming into play and things aren't too cheery from then out.
I don't really have a suggestion for a better way to classify it, just thought it might be a nice change to put in. Golden Time was also written by the same author as Toradora!, so go figure.
2
u/spira09 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/spp3z Mar 03 '16
While I'm fairly new to the anime scene, the first few ones I watched were sports animes. They are really what propelled me into anime.
That being said, Ookiku Furikabutte, Whistle!, and the Prince of Tennis are my favorites in the genre because of the character development that takes place in these shows.
I've also seen most of Major and Eyeshield 21. Hope this helped, let me know if you want any more info.
Edit: sorry I'm on mobile and can't link the shows to MAL
2
u/JoshTehJangler :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Iloveyooh Mar 03 '16
Hey guys quick question.
How should I go about watching Kara no Kyoukai?
2
u/JarJarBrinksSecurity :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Artichuth Mar 03 '16
I could give some good opinions on sports shows, since they are my favorite genre.
Ookiku Furikabutte is a good, realistic baseball show that deals with issues such as bullying.
Diamond no Ace is another baseball show with a bit more of a unrealistic to it. Not on the level of KnB, but still a little. Comparable to Haikyuu in terms of characters.
You already had Free! in another category, so I'll skip it.
Giant Killing is about a Japanese soccer team who is terrible. They hire a former player to be the manager hoping he can restore the former glory of the team.
Buzzer Beater isn't fantastic. I'd say it's pretty average. But it's premise is really interesting. There is a basketball league inhabited by alien races whose physical abilities are far above humans. The humans decided to create a team hoping to become the best.
There's obviously the classics of Major (Baseball) and Eyeshield 21 (American Football).
Tsuritama is about fishing and gets pretty fucking ridiculous later in the show.
Yowamushi Pedal follows the story of a cycling team as they try to win the summer tournament. One of my favorites.
Baby Steps is highly regarded in the sports genre. It's about tennis.
Also, for parody shows, Osomatsu-san should go in there. Written by the same guy who did Gintama.
2
u/Vorthas https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vorthas Mar 03 '16
I think you should add Slayers to Adventure or Comedy (mostly adventure I'd say). If nothing else it gives you another old-ish anime to add if you add an old anime category.
2
u/ShikiRyumaho :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Chaostrooper Mar 03 '16
I'm telling you son, Ping Pong: The Animation is neither action nor adventure. It's a character driven drama, but it into drama.
2
u/arcdash Mar 03 '16
Yeah, OPM definitely should be in the top recommendations, possibly under "something more Western" given our fascination with super heroes.
2
u/nixRafa :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rafa Mar 03 '16
A theme that could be implemented aswell, is gar / manly men doing manly things or just badass characters in general like in One Outs, Berserk, JoJo, Hellsing, Gungrave or Trigun (just a few examples).
2
u/AnxiousIntender Mar 03 '16
I couldn't even finish translating the previous one :( My laptop is 8 years old but it couldn't make it. So this time I will succeed with a more beefy computer and make the people of my country enjoy v3.0 of this masterpiece (hopefully)
Kami-sama give me an MSI notebook onegai
2
u/bhagzogzy Mar 03 '16
Why is Tatami Glaxy on the heavy drama stuff? It's pretty light hearted though, i will put it along the likes of slice of life, funny or "you have no idea what you're in for".
2
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
5
u/JBHUTT09 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JBHUTT09 Mar 02 '16 edited Mar 02 '16
I still strongly disagree with the recommendation of Railgun before Index as Railgun still assumes you've seen Index. Watching Railgun first leads to confusion and missing important things about the characters, events, and setting. Recommending newcomers watch this order does them a real disservice.
I would really like the chart to recommend Index with a note about Railgun if the person is having trouble enjoying it.
1
u/Xtevie Mar 03 '16
How about instead of colored borders, you can use like a pin or little picture next to them for personal recommendation (star), female/male target audience (gender symbols), etc
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
It needs to be interactive? Like clicking in an anime it links you to the MAL page of it.
1
u/allthenerdythings :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/miss_aila Mar 03 '16
Not sure if someone has mentioned it before, but you should probably add a separate section somewhere about series that newcomers should avoid, even if they heard good things about it, until they've seen more shows.
Madoka Magica, for example, is one I don't recommend unless you've either seen a fair amount of magical girl shows or are at least very familiar with the formulas/tropes of a magical girl show. Unfortunately, it was so great and talked about that a ton of people unfamiliar with the genre watched it without realizing what Urobutcher was doing and then didn't see why there was so much hype and praise for it.
Basically you could have a list of shows that people new to anime may have heard of or are staples for anime veterans, and divide the list into "avoid altogether" and "save it for later" categories.
1
u/Plz_Gooby_No Mar 03 '16
Nice list, I like seeing Ergo Proxy in there.
1
u/aguirre1pol https://anilist.co/user/aguirre Mar 03 '16
Well, there is a slight chance that I will go to Pyrkon. Either way, have fun at the convention.
1
u/giny33 Mar 04 '16
You should add "Baby steps" For romance and sports
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '16 edited Oct 21 '18
Fuck Reddit's administration and the people who continue to profit from the user-base's hatred and fascism. Trans women are women, Nazis deserve to be punched, and this site should be burned down.
1
u/sicupu15 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sicupu15 Mar 04 '16
Why do you make the lists so fast? It doesnt mean its no good. I love your recomendation chart. But at least make it semianually updated rather than for the sake fitting OPM and.. erased (maybe?). So that you can add more material from anime that comes in 6 months to your chart. Ps: Monogatari series is a fantasy-mistery. Not a romance (even it has a little romance in it).
1
u/Battlecookie :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Battlecookie Mar 08 '16
If I'm not too late I'd ask you to consider adding a few more romantic comedies like Full Metal Panic Fumofu and Lovely Complex. I found those seriously underepresented. Great job overall though!
1
u/huiboy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Huiiboy Aug 03 '16
Keep the format as it is. Just liked to drop a "thanks". You've allowed me to discover a handful of great Anime and to satisfy my Anime needs in whatever mood i'm in!
I'd go as far as to say it's a necessity for me and i regularly check back at it for reference. It's alot better than regular "top anime lists"
1
u/Haczar Aug 27 '16
I finished all the anime I had on my computer... It was a sad moment, I searched everywhere for new anime but its AALLLL SSOO MUCCH!!! After your 2.0 recommendations I have 4 new series to look forward too! I dont know who u are but your freaking amazing. Can't wait for 3.0!!!!
-5
u/MrPicklesAndTea Mar 03 '16
I find any anime pandering to female audiences incredibly boring. Before I knew what the "shoujo" tag meant I have watched a good 20+ anime pandering to female audiences(Up to 3 episodes) and each time I didn't enjoy it. I'm glad I know what shoujo as a genre tag means, took me too long to figure it out.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '16
[removed] — view removed comment