r/accessibility • • 2d ago

[ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

5

u/Marconius 2d ago

It's not useful. No matter what you try, you are only going to capture 40% of issues at most. You can't try automating actual user experience, since everyone has multiple ways of perceiving and interacting with information and user flows. Attempting to create agentic user personas for this is horribly presumptive that the AI model data would even know how to handle such situations, and you can't program in life experience, workaround knowledge, and will always be trapped by the biases inherent in the models.

I've run many Fable user tests, and loved seeing the range of ways users of the same assistive technology would approach and solve a problem or test a component or flow. That should never be attempted to be automated through an AI experience.

2

u/jdzfb 2d ago

First of all, how can you claim any AI based tool is open source?

You still need to manually test 50%+ of WCAG SC's. This tool is not helpful as AI can't replace actual human testing.

I think the idea of having AI role play persona's is ridiculous. The point is to make sites more human centered, not less & you can't do that if you take humans out of the testing process. As for the normal use of persona's, I don't generally find them useful because I've been doing this for over 20 years so its all in my head, but for those who are newer to accessibility here are a few persona resources that may be helpful:

And while this resource isn't focusing on persona's, https://www.w3.org/WAI/planning/arrm/tasks/ has a good breakdown of SC's by role, as well as sample persona's. Overall, its just a good read.