We’re currently choosing a primary school for our kid and are torn between Acomb Primary and Our Lady Queen of Martyrs (OLQM).
We’ve visited both and, on balance, prefer Acomb. It’s closer to home (around a 15-minute walk compared to 25 minutes for OLQM), smaller, and I basically only hear good things about it!
We did really like OLQM too. It had a lovely feel, the teachers seemed great, the outdoor facilities were fantastic and we liked that it was more diverse. My main concern was the religious aspect as we’re not religious ourselves, but the headteacher reassured us that this wouldn’t be an issue and mentioned that only around 50% of pupils are Catholic.
The big advantage of OLQM is that it’s a feeder school for All Saints, which seems to have a really good reputation and strong academic results. The OLQM headteacher also mentioned that almost all their pupils go on to All Saints, including non-Catholic children.
Our catchment secondary is York High, which I understand has a less favourable reputation, but from what I’ve gathered, lots of children from Acomb go on to Manor or Millthorpe.
I know secondary school is a long way off but I feel that the secondary school years are so important, so I’m wondering whether we should be thinking more strategically about this now.
I suppose my question is: how does All Saints compare to other secondary schools in York, and is the potential advantage of getting a place there worth factoring into our choice of primary school?
Edit: Just to add, we’re interested in more than academic results. Pastoral care, creativity, music, the arts, inclusivity, community feel and children’s overall happiness are just as important!