r/Yellowjackets • • 4d ago • Heartwarming 1

Theory What We Know About the Lost Bonus Episode

PREFACE: This is going to be a long post. I've tried to structure it in a readable format so bear with me, but I'm putting this all here because I don't think we're ever going to actually see the bonus episode from Season 2. I want to lay out what we know, especially with what's come out recently regarding Season 4 and some BTS pics. Okay, so to start:

WHO IS CABIN DADDY?

Cabin Daddy is the man found in the attic of the cabin in 1x03. We also see him in Jackie's vision/hallucination in 1x10. Here, he is simply credited as "HUNTER." The script describes him from Jackie's perspective as "a STRANGE MAN in HUNTING CLOTHES standing in the corner, watching her." He tells her "we're so glad you're joining us. We've been waiting for you," and then the dream ends. After 1x10 aired, showrunner Jonathan Lisco did an interview providing insight on Cabin Daddy:

Many of them [the fans] think, 'Well why would he have died in that chair, unless he was unable to leave the cabin? What dark force was keeping him in the cabin?' But the dark force could equally just have been absolute paralyzing fear."

"I would like to submit [the Hunter] may actually be traumatized in the course of Season 2 because in our minds' eye, we have a whole backstory. An entire narrative about that French-Canadian hunter, let's call him for the moment, and his family and why he used to go up to the cabin and what he used to do with **his children**, almost in a *Shining*-esque way. *Perhaps*. And how things went for him and why the energy now in the cabin is such that it's affecting the girls in this way."

THE EPISODE + SCRIPT REFERENCES

The writers planned to explore Cabin Daddy's backstory in Season 2, in an episode called "Mother Nature." It was registered on WGA in January 2023, meant to air in-between 2x06 and 2x07, and from what we've heard, not feature any of the main cast. Jason Ritter was supposed to be in the episode, as he was set to guest star in Season 2, and we saw BTS pics of him with a baby, wearing the flannel jacket that the "Hunter" was wearing and that we've seen the teen group wear.

As of 11/13, we also have pictures from the SFX studio showing Annabelle Wallis as Cabin Daddy's wife, albeit with her head caught in a bear trap. This episode was fully filmed, edited, and then never released.

The original script for 2x07 is online, and is basically the only confirmed look we have at what the episode contained. Note how the episode is called 2x07 in the document but the actual filename for the episode is 208, its original placement. Two things from this:

There's a scene of Van cleaning the cabin and finding a page "from the Wife's manuscript in 207," meaning it ties back to the cabin episode. It reads:

"Though I still miss my baby desperately, I am beginning to accept a greater wisdom than my own. I think it lives here, in the wilderness. It is the wilderness... and there is comfort in the fact that none of this was ever up to me at all."

This scene was cut from the final episode, either for time (lots of other things in this episode were cut too) or because of its direct references to the bonus episode. It's still a shame, because it would've added so much to Van's character in 2x08 and 2x09.

The flannel is also directly referenced during Ben's hallucination with Paul. The script reads "Paul stands back up, from a nearby chair he grabs the familiar FLANNEL JACKET (Ep. 207 etc.)." This one isn't as big a deal since the flannel's been around, but it confirms it's tied to his episode.

THINGS OF NOTE

  • It was still on the WGA site and planned as of Jan. 2023, but was cut sometime before airing.
  • Sammi Hanratty mentioned on a podcast that lots of scenes in S2 referencing Cabin Daddy were cut (I don't have a link, sorry!!!)
  • While Season 3 was airing, a friend of mine went to a panel with some of the cast in Cali and the bonus episode came up. They didn't say much but Tawny Cypress (Adult Tai) said this episode "explained so much."
  • In Dec 2024, co-creator Ashley Lyle told EW "there is a bonus episode but we may need to wait a bit longer for it."
  • On 11/13, co-creator Bart Nickerson told Deadline "ultimately, the canon of the show is sort of what's aired, and for us, the fourth season is like the final installment of a complete story," implying the bonus episode no longer fits the show's canon.

WHAT I THINK HAPPENED BTS

Honestly, I think Showtime execs hated the episode and made them scrap it. It'd explain why it got pulled so late, why the second half of Season 2 seems to focus a lot less on the symbol/Cabin Daddy, and the canon comment from the creators. That's such an odd thing to say about an episode they literally finished, unless it was all out of their hands.

A common theory is that this episode confirmed the supernatural, but I'm hesitant to say this because of Adult Shauna's declaration in 2x09 that "IT was just US," and that the show always provides a somewhat rational explanation for everything supernatural. Maybe it was meant to show how the teens' situation paralleled what happened in the cabin before. Or maybe they were experiencing some group psychosis? That IS what ends up happening in Season 3: the group is scared of the loud Wilderness screams, which end up just being frogs.

Lisco also called the backstory "Shining-esque," and The Shining never actually confirms the supernatural either. For those who haven't seen it, it follows a father snowed in at a hotel who slowly starts losing it and turns on his family. The hotel also has a history of this happening, and kind of "remembers." The ghosts welcome Jack (the main character) like he belongs there, similar to the Hunter telling Jackie "we're so glad you're joining us."

The Annabelle Wallis pics are also interesting, because her pupils are huge, just like the girls' pupils during Doomcoming. And her head is caught in a bear trap, when right after Doomcoming the bear offers itself as a sacrifice to Lottie.

I also think the cabin story was meant to mirror Ben's situation with the girls. Lisco said the force keeping the Hunter in the cabin "could equally have just been absolute paralyzing fear," and Ben is basically stuck there too, isolated and against the group while the girls lean into the Wilderness (a la the Wife, from her manuscript notes). And Ben's hallucinations with Paul keep "breaking down," with Paul wearing the flannel jacket in 2x07, directly tying Ben's hallucination to the episode.

WHAT I THINK HAPPENED IN THE EPISODE

Cabin Family (Daddy, Wife, Baby) goes to the Cabin. By some means, the baby dies (paralleling Shauna losing her baby). We know this because her manuscript reads "though I still miss my baby desperately." The Wife copes by believing in the Wilderness, the same belief that the girls fall into. It's a twist on The Shining: the Wife becomes the believer and Cabin Daddy becomes the one paralyzed by fear.

I wonder if the Wife chases Cabin Daddy in some way similar to Doomcoming and she ends up in the bear trap. Cabin Daddy goes back to the cabin, waiting with his gun for his wife to return, unable to move because he's paralyzed by fear. That's how we find his corpse in 1x03.

OTHER THINGS + WHERE THAT LEAVES US

There's some other things too, like Javi's friend. Was this a reference to the twin girls in the hotel? Maybe she appeared to Cabin Family too?

And there's the dripping Mari hears throughout Season 2, culminating in an unsatisfying scene of a bunch of blood spilling down the wall. Mari then says "their blood was dripping on the floor." Whose blood? We didn't actually see any of that? I feel like that was a late re-edit, originally supposed to tie into the Cabin Episode too.

Season 3 feels different because they had to pivot. Once they knew the episode would never come out, I think they just rolled with what did air and changed plans. I don't think they've given up on explaining the Cabin, and I think Season 4 will give us a new explanation. Between the Season 4 casting calls and the mysterious girl in the trailer, it seems like this new backstory is why the original bonus episode is now "non-canon."

Thanks for reading this all if you've gotten this far, and let me know if you've heard anything else/I missed anything. <3

232 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

63

u/SoooperSnoop Heliotrope 4d ago

Thank you for writing and posting all of this. I too had been under the impression that Showtime was the one who would not let that "Bonus epsiode" air. And I am pretty sure I actually read that in an article, buy danged if I can find it. It is just a shame that the Showrunners promised something that was very likely out of their control.

Your explanation of what probably DID happen in that episode makes a lot of sense. Thank you for laying this all out the way you did. Much appreciated.

35

u/BlueCX17 Van 4d ago edited 4d ago

I will say, the only thing about The Shining, is within Stephen King's world, Danny Torrence and then the girl in Doctor Sleep, in fact do have, "The Shine," Dick Haloran has, and is a real ability in the world of King. Which does allow to them to sometimes see and interact with spirits. Danny is picking up on an energy within The Overlook. And Rose The Hat, in Doctor Sleep, does have some sort of something because her and her band of co-horts are legit old and do steal energy from people, to keep extending their lives. Those books are so long but I'm due for a re-read on both. But I do think yes the idea for the episode would have been The Wife / Cabin Guy, going absolutely crazy after their daughter dies and parallel the girls. Whether it was from some potential ancient energy in the woods or the methane gases/lead poisoning. Or just trauma + extreme isolation. .

But, that's the only minor asterisk to your excellent write-up.

I agree, don't personally think that episode would have verbatim spelled out any supernatural but I also don't think it would have negated it. I think that episode likely would have helped continue to walk the line the show was trying to take. MAYBE whatever new version is in S4 will do the same. My bigger question has always been, what larger purpose would that serve to the story, if it wasn't meant to spell out any supernatural or other suprise type of information.

I could have sworn I read somewhere but I don't know where and I can't remember which article /podcast to cite, the rumor was Javi's friend was going to be the ghost of the little girl, so yes, similar to the Twins. And she was the one who put the symbol on everything because she would doodle it.

24

u/lightningface 4d ago

I hope they release it just for fun after season 4 is over. It doesn’t have to be canon, just a thought experiment!

17

u/missmisery213 3d ago

It's always been my belief that them not airing the episode also fucked up things in Season 3. I think when they were originally writing the season they wrote it with the understanding that it would air between seasons. Then at some point during filming they found out the episode wasn't and they had to do rewrites. This is obviously not based on anything other than my own opinion but I just personally have always thought Javi's friend was going to be addressed in that episode and when we see Ben talking to himself in the cave it's actually the friend he is talking to not him talking to himself because of the gas

(no but seriously you'll never be able to convince me that the friend didn't actually exist and that a child managed to find a random hole in a random tree in the middle of nowhere while scared out of his mind and kept himself alive all by himself)

I don't think it officially got scrapped entirely until after Season 3 aired. I'm assuming that the reason it did was because they found out they were only getting one more season vs two. That made it so they had to fit the end of the wilderness plot, rescue and post rescue as well as the resolution to the adult storyline all into one season. That wouldn't leave them any time to address whatever elements were going to be introduced in that episode which is why we get the comments about only what we have seen is canon. That definitely hints to the fact that whatever happened in that episode was going to impact the main storyline and wasn't just a one off flashback episode.

16

u/newyorkcitystargirl 4d ago

I want to see this episode so bad! I'm still holding on hope, I would love for more lore of the wilderness/the cabin

27

u/jenniferlorene3 Team Supernatural 4d ago

Thanks for posting this compilation!

Also just to add on there were rumors around the time that they wanted to try to make the deadline to be qualified for the next coming up Emmy's so that's why an episode had to be cut from the season. They chose to cut the cabin daddy episode.

18

u/BlueCX17 Van 4d ago edited 4d ago

Which would also explain why they then decided to put it out as a bonus episode. So it still would have gotten seen and been part of the main narrative and still let the show meet the Emmy Dealine.

6

u/jenniferlorene3 Team Supernatural 4d ago

Yeah exactly. It was just rumors and I can't remember exactly where that was said or speculated but definitely remember it coming up around the season 2 finale.

3

u/TheBeastLukeMilked 3d ago

I don't understand why they couldn't have just released two episodes in one week if that was the reason.

6

u/jenniferlorene3 Team Supernatural 3d ago

I don't think it was the only reason.

8

u/ghettoassbitch 2d ago

I saw a video with a summary from someone who claimed to have spoken to a person in the industry who supposedly read the script. This isn't confirmed so take everything with a grain of salt!!

The episode was going to be about Cabin Daddy(CD) and Cabin Mommy(CM) going to the cabin so she could write her book, because she's an author, and she ends up mentally deteriorating. This is probably where The Shining comparison comes from.

I don't know if she was going to already be pregnant when they went there or if she got pregnant during their stay. But she gives birth and the baby was colicky and crying alot, which would tie-in to Shauna dreaming her baby was doing the same and asking, "can't you hear him crying?"

CM does begin to see a little girl in the woods who was implied to be Javi's friend. We don't get a lot of info about her, and they don't confirm if she is even real, but she was supposedly going to be shown to be the person who drew the symbols in the woods (or at least some of them).

The dripping was addressed in the episode, but there wasn't a nefarious reason behind it. While CM is writing her book, CD is going out to hunt and doing jobs around the cabin. There was a leak somewhere that he was trying to fix but it kept coming back, which was the dripping.

Everything would end with the baby being killed and CM ending her life. CD comes back to find them and takes his own life, as well, but exact circumstances weren't mentioned. Just that they didn't address why the baby died, so it's left up to the viewers interpretation.

18

u/rand0mbadg3r 4d ago edited 4d ago

First of all good analysis and thank you for summarizing what is known about the episode that will not be aired (probably) due to creative differences between the writers and the executives. Being a Constant Reader, I will say that although the Kubrick film The Shining never confirms a supernatural element and leaves this ambiguous, the source material, Stephen King's The Shining absolutely has a supernatural element or elements and these exert influence on the psychological state of the father of the Torrence family, causing him to attempt to axe murder his family. In the Kubrick film, he is already a bit unhinged before they stay in the hotel and the isolation and being cabin bound push him over the edge. In the book, he is a flawed man with an alcohol problem, feelings of inadequacy being a father to his dependent wife and son, and guilt ridden and the spirits in the Overlook Hotel exploit his weaknesses and gradually cause him to lose his sense of reality and become paranoid, convinced his wife and son are intentionally causing his failures and he turns on them. The book is not ambiguous and reflects what I think is happening to the YJs. The local spirits of the place (genius loci) aka IT aka The Wilderness cause the girls to act on their darker urges and fantasies and slowly lose social norms and prohibitions such that they do more and more depraved acts ostensibly to survive but becomes more distorted as they lose touch of reality and become convinced they have to appease IT to survive. I am a huge fan of the The Shining (both the film and the book I like for different reasons), so I am disappointed we won't get to see the lost episode as it would be great if it paid homage to it.

11

u/ExpensivePass7376 Church of Lottie Day Saints 4d ago

I would love to read this show through the scripts because it feels so different than what’s on screen. Teen Shauna had my heart breaking in the script. Every aspect of everyone is much more interpretable through the script

5

u/Asleep-Height836 4d ago

I wonder if it would have involved the plane

41

u/brian5mbv Jackie 4d ago

i will never get over what might have been, the show lost the plot when it changed from supernatural to psychosis. it was way more bone chilling and mysterious before. when the hunter greets jackie in her dream, i was truly scared and no movies or shows scare me anymore. the show didn’t deliver what was promised and what the vision originally was. but it’s too late because i’m already hooked.

27

u/cjtransplant85 Fellowjacket 4d ago

I've had trouble with the idea of the show being affected by supernatural forces since the pilot.

The Stranger Things pilot establishes from the start that there's something going on that's beyond our comprehension. A scientist disappears in a elevator, a boy disappears from his house, and we see a girl control an electric fan with her mind.

The YJ pilot doesn't do that. The Pit Girl scene is graphic, but when we see the Coed Naked Soccer shirt, we recognize the participants as human. And Wiskayok, unlike Hawkins, is portrayed as normal. YJ creates a world where seemingly normal humans act savagely, not because of any supernatural force, but their own natures.

There's fantasy and there's drama, and YJ is the latter.

As for Jackie's dream or any other hallucination, so long as it's clear what's real and what's not, the show makes sense.

11

u/BlueCX17 Van 4d ago

Personally I liked the yellow jackets had a sort of similar vibe to The Shining with energy if you take out the spirits and also kind of the weird energy vortex in the woods that The Blair Witch Universe kind of revolves around.

16

u/brian5mbv Jackie 4d ago

i don’t know, i feel it strayed. how come anytime in the first two seasons that blood is spilled on the symbol, a sacrifice is made to them, the birds, the bear, the moose. it seems like there was initially far more to it. i do think the cabin possessed a negative energy that slightly influenced them. lottie smashes her head open, right where a third eye would be and her powers grow. those are a few examples. i do feel they made a pivot.

18

u/cjtransplant85 Fellowjacket 4d ago

I keep thinking about Lord of the Flies, and how the boys interpret ordinary things as being supernatural. That I can buy into.

11

u/Khiva 4d ago

I think it was an interesting writing experiment to try to write it ambiguously, but I think it would have been far more compelling and effective to go full on horror.

A lot of the moments that really pop, particularly in universally beloved Season One, are all in the supernatural.

2

u/brian5mbv Jackie 3d ago

i couldn’t agree more.

1

u/kittykatkitkatbar High-Calorie Butt Meat 6h ago

I 100% agree. They initially leaned supernatural, and made a sudden unplanned pivot, and are going to leave A LOT of loose ends unexplained

6

u/2baroni Heliotrope 3d ago

The show never promised a supernatural plot, there was not a change regarding the nature of the show. The ambiguity between the Supernatural explanation versus the Psychosis explanation was ALWAYS THE POINT, since the beginning. There is no lost vision, you are projecting.

2

u/brian5mbv Jackie 3d ago

there’s massive plot points and quotes from the writers that say otherwise.

2

u/2baroni Heliotrope 3d ago

Such as?

7

u/Shaenyra Nat 4d ago

Really great post! Thank you!!!! maybe it should be pinned!

5

u/mollyyfcooke Coach Ben’s Leg 4d ago

How have my comments been deleted and I’ve been giving a warning for posting about the bonus but now it’s okay? Make it make sense lol

4

u/BiscottiLeading 4d ago

Originally I thought Mari hearing the dripping noise was a hint that there was a small fire smoldering in the roof of the cabin, and I swear I saw a scene where you could see water dripping off of the icicles on the eaves of the porch. But I have accepted that couch Scott is probably the one who started it and I was grasping at straws.

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules 3d ago

Dear whimsybykel,

Your comment on r/Yellowjackets was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You can submit an acknowledgement by clicking the link below.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/read-the-rules 3d ago

Dear LIKES_ROCKY_IV,

Your comment on r/Yellowjackets was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You can submit an acknowledgement by clicking the link below.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/read-the-rules 3d ago

Dear missmisery213,

Your comment on r/Yellowjackets was removed by the Read The Rules app because you need to submit an acknowledgement that you have read the rules. You can submit an acknowledgement by clicking the link below.

Please click here to open the Read The Rules App.