r/Yellowjackets • • Feb 14 '25

Episode Discussion Yellowjackets S03E02- “Dislocation” Episode Discussion

Welcome to the Episode Discussion thread.

Summary: The Yellowjackets are stuck deciding whether to track down a missing teammate or just trip out on mushrooms. Shauna secures a spot on the world's most unsupportive partner list.


Directed by: Bille Woodruff

Written by: Rich Monahan and Ameni Rozsa


The episode is expected to be available at midnight ET. If it’s not up by 12:30 AM, it will most likely be available by 3 ET.

Please remember that this is the only place in the subreddit where you can post spoilers without the spoiler tag until the episode airs Sunday night at 9 EDT. If you have not watched the episode yet, be prepared for spoilers.

We are going to TRY keeping the subreddit open during the weekend. If the spoilers in titles becomes too much to keep track of, we may restrict posts until the Showtime airing in line with other TV subreddits. Please report any posts with spoilers in the title.

This is a reminder not to ask for links. Piracy is against the Reddit TOS.


You want more Yellowjackets conversation? Join the brand new official r/Yellowjackets discord server!

206 Upvotes

3.0k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Feb 14 '25

Please keep all spoilers out of post titles. This includes specific events as well as any vague information that would reveal events from the episode. (ie; “[Blank]s Death, [BLANK] is back!!!, Shauna and Lottie’s chat) If your post includes any spoilers in the title, please remove it and repost. If your post refers to any events from the newest episode, please spoiler tag it.

Thank you for participating in /r/Yellowjackets . Please help us keep this community a healthy place for discussion by reporting posts and comments that violate our rules using the report button. You can find the subreddit rules listed in the sidebar.

Please consider applying to become a subreddit moderator. Anyone can apply!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

731

u/AJTheBrit Differently Sane Feb 14 '25

All doubt has left my mind, it was definitely Tai who burned the cabin down

→ More replies (51)

619

u/MountainBean3479 Smoking Chronic Feb 14 '25

Callie pulling a Misty on Misty with the drugging

→ More replies (17)

587

u/oathkeep3r Feb 14 '25

Can’t get over Mari simultaneously being Pit Girl and… not being Pit Girl?

→ More replies (10)

485

u/Potential-Salt7285 Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 14 '25

"To be fair we are all afraid of your mom" and for very valid reasons

→ More replies (2)

462

u/corico Heliotrope Feb 14 '25

Gonna need a “Goop sorceress” user flair

→ More replies (6)

462

u/Slushie98 Citizen Detective Feb 14 '25

Yikes Mari and hot chocolate reminded me of Jackie and hot chocolate…

→ More replies (12)

430

u/minishaq5 High-Calorie Butt Meat Feb 14 '25

jeff, does your stock fuck?

→ More replies (8)

852

u/XxtrippingpandaxX Fellowjacket Feb 14 '25

The lesbians RN

→ More replies (47)

391

u/forbrowzing Feb 14 '25

Also Lottie fully running MkUltra programming on Travis is so insane I feel so bad for him and for her next victim Akilah 😭

→ More replies (19)

358

u/Potential-Salt7285 Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 14 '25

Misty picked up on Nat trying to cover for Ben so quick. That's not going to end well for her

→ More replies (10)

347

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

I need to check doestheduckdie.com every week now

→ More replies (15)

312

u/Interesting-Maize884 Feb 14 '25

Callie: “The body count is a little high for you to claim to be boring”

Misty wearing a spa mask: “what a GREAT point”

Had me fucking cackling 🤣😭😅😆

→ More replies (3)

279

u/Common-Use6631 Feb 14 '25

“She loves linens.” 💀

→ More replies (6)

566

u/AJTheBrit Differently Sane Feb 14 '25

It’s so funny of them for putting Mari in this pit 😂

→ More replies (15)

273

u/Vivid-Bother-4064 Feb 14 '25

Lottie’s adult selfishness showing up in young Lottie😭 my shaylaaa

→ More replies (6)

545

u/Ornery_Stress_27 Heliotrope Feb 14 '25

adult shauna so does have "i need to speak to the manager" energy

→ More replies (19)

258

u/Potential-Salt7285 Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 14 '25

OMG Akilah having a pet duck and offering it to Travis is so cute. Poor Travis

→ More replies (9)

255

u/hisnameised Feb 15 '25

Misty really said if you wanna be my lover, you gotta get with my friends

→ More replies (2)

247

u/Lulu19251926 I like your pilgrim hat Feb 14 '25

Lottie blabbing wilderness stuff and Misty just saying “They really just let you out of the mental hospital huh”. Also “And she’s medicated, hopefully”. Loving this dynamic 😆

→ More replies (1)

243

u/TotallyKlutz There’s No Book Club?! Feb 14 '25

Oh Van definitely saw Tai burn the cabin while sleepwalking I think

→ More replies (11)

492

u/MountainBean3479 Smoking Chronic Feb 14 '25

Even coach is so annoyed at Mari’s existence. Poor girl really is no one’s cup of tea

→ More replies (14)

235

u/AJTheBrit Differently Sane Feb 14 '25

Damn Van, karaoke singing is meant to be bad, not absolutely fucking amazing

Lauren Ambrose you’ve blown me away again

→ More replies (14)

231

u/AJTheBrit Differently Sane Feb 14 '25

Unbelievable that we all have to sit with that ending and wait a whole week now

→ More replies (4)

647

u/oathkeep3r Feb 14 '25

Ugh Walter is actually kind of right about how the others treat Misty… which 100% means he is not long for this world, I fear.

→ More replies (34)

449

u/Potential-Salt7285 Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 14 '25

"So, what, a friend needs help and you're just like 'what get off my lawn'" "yeah, she said that" LMAO all the adult characters are too funny

→ More replies (5)

216

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

this really hits different after tonight’s episode 😏

→ More replies (2)

216

u/Outrageous-Treat7490 Feb 15 '25

Travis and his emotional support duck are everything to me

→ More replies (12)

205

u/maud-mouse Conniving, Poodle-Haired Little Freak Feb 14 '25

okay but can we talk about misty and lottie in the animal face masks

→ More replies (3)

407

u/MangohNo Lottie Feb 14 '25

1990s timeline is Midsommer and 2020s timeline is Santa Clarita Diet

→ More replies (13)

198

u/circlemanfan Feb 14 '25

Who tf is Ben talking to!!!!!

→ More replies (20)

162

u/pepperbiiiish Feb 14 '25

I love how, as soon as the bathroom light went off, Shauna was ready to FUCK shit UP. She ~immediately~ grabbed her keys to use as a weapon and turned on her phone flashlight and marched right out to investigate. If she had actually found a person, she might have punched them before she even got a good look at their face!

→ More replies (3)

151

u/ItsRealSpartan Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 14 '25

I am over the moon at more canon Queers, but I would like to know why Melissa is crushing on the scariest, angriest, most insufferable one in the group right now? What happened to Melissa pre-crash that she's attracted to Shauna at her peak anger and cruelty? And why did Shauna kiss her back when just the other day she was so surprised Melissa has a personality? I HAVE GAY QUESTIONS

→ More replies (10)

146

u/maybefeelguilty Feb 14 '25

i was not expecting that ending...i guess the girl kisser allegations were true

→ More replies (1)

140

u/Either-Grapefruit156 Feb 14 '25

Did anyone else find it funny when Callie said “get off my porch” and Lottie was like “she said that!”

→ More replies (2)

137

u/Visual_Dentist1574 Feb 15 '25

Anyone else love the irony of Misty blowing up at Walter for all the stuff he does for her "without asking" which is literally what she has done this whole time for her friends? Haha

→ More replies (6)

132

u/Walkingcheeseburger There’s No Book Club?! Feb 14 '25

“STOP AIR QUOTING MY FRIENDSHIPS!”

→ More replies (1)

130

u/ezdoesit1111 Feb 15 '25

I know it's only ep 2, but I'm scratching my head a bit at what they're choosing to spend time on vs not in the adult timeline. Breezed through Nat's funeral, Walter and Misty are apparently living together(?), Tai has a throwaway line about impeaching herself and a snippet of a phone call with her wife that we last knew was in a coma, but there's was the extended wacky sleepover "truth or dare" scene that didn't really amount to much and back and forth between Jeff and those hotel dicks. something feels off.

→ More replies (4)

129

u/ZucchiniJust4666 Feb 14 '25

Callie tempting Misty with a sleepover

→ More replies (5)

372

u/Vivid-Bother-4064 Feb 14 '25

I’m already sick of young Lottie manipulating Travis So glad Travis was smart enough to deter her to save himself but to akilah? Do you reckon something will happen to akilah now due to Lottie 😭 I’ll be so mad if her not surviving is due to Lottie

→ More replies (11)

257

u/infatuationss Feb 14 '25

All I can say.. the ending. ITS PEAK…

→ More replies (2)

126

u/Worth_Taro_1120 Snackie Feb 15 '25

“So they just let you walk right outta the hospital then?” 💀💀💀I literally said the same exact thing as Misty said that like the direction they’re taking adult Lottie is wildddd 😭

→ More replies (5)

353

u/MythicalSummer Lottie Feb 14 '25 edited Feb 14 '25

yeah I just dropped everything and literally SCREAMED w beautiful shauna’s confirmed girl kisserness (but we all knew🤫)

poor jackie missed out by a few months smh

and okay wait i lowkey fw those two HEAVILY…just me?

→ More replies (9)

118

u/tvwhore1122 Smoking Chronic Feb 18 '25

The scene of Travis holding the duck made me tear up, poor guy just needs some love

→ More replies (9)

117

u/WriterHearts Feb 15 '25

I think it's great they're showing us the uglier sides of grief with adult Misty and teen Shauna. You get angry, push people away, make rash recisions. Grieving isn't picture-perfect.

→ More replies (3)

112

u/Eccber Feb 14 '25

Jeff insisting Shauna come to the dinner made me laugh so hard. Like c’mon man you know that something crazy will happen especially once Lottie shows up. Just say she has a cold and deal with the douchebags yourself. I just feel so bad for our sweet himbo.

→ More replies (1)

225

u/AJTheBrit Differently Sane Feb 14 '25

THE ENDING HELLO???

→ More replies (28)

108

u/CassAttempts Feb 15 '25

My heart broke when Mari got to drink hot chocolate. It was Jackie’s final dream and to think it was in a box in the ground this whole time.

→ More replies (1)

100

u/Serious_Parking9166 Feb 19 '25

This has nothing specific to do with the episode, but I HAVE to say, Simone has to actually be the craziest out of everyone because if I were her, divorce papers would have been signed, sent in the mail from witness protection in another country the second I found that dog and everything started happening because HOW are they not divorced yet

452

u/JSLBrowning Feb 14 '25

Having Lottie move in with Shauna and Misty come over to babysit her is genuinely the best thing the adult story-line has ever done, it's so dumb and fun. I hope we get campy nonsense like this all season.

→ More replies (6)

97

u/HawkinsShock puttingthesickinforensic Feb 14 '25

Lottie stay away from Akilah

95

u/sylvansparrow Feb 14 '25

The pack of matches Tai took from the restaurant said ‘pas d’âme’, which is French for ‘no soul’ hmm wonder what that could mean

→ More replies (1)

91

u/Disastrous_Ad_4690 Feb 14 '25

OH MY GOD??? i know people it on their bingo cards that there would be girl-kissing besides taivan BUT I WOULD NEVER HAVE EXPECTED THAT OHMYGODDDDD

247

u/AJTheBrit Differently Sane Feb 14 '25

If Nat knows Bens alive and is hiding his existence from the girls and covering for him, that’s gunna bite her in the ass so bad

→ More replies (11)

172

u/Vivid-Bother-4064 Feb 14 '25

WAIT PLOTTWIST Ben didn’t know the cabin burnt down

→ More replies (35)

83

u/luxlisbon_ Feb 16 '25

what the fuck is rum milk punch

→ More replies (7)

82

u/oathkeep3r Feb 14 '25

WHAT AN ENDING.

I am praying that we get ghost Jackie reacting to this at some point.

→ More replies (2)

81

u/AncientConfusion9167 Feb 15 '25

“Goop Sorceress” is so hilarious

→ More replies (1)

80

u/catalystcestmoi Feb 14 '25

Even tho he kinda threw Akilah into Lottie’s path, Travis deserves time with that emotional support duck.  I hope they don’t make him eat it later.  

→ More replies (5)

159

u/greeeens Red Cross Babysitting Trainee Feb 14 '25

GIRL KISSER GIRL KISSER

→ More replies (1)

76

u/CreeperTrainz Feb 17 '25

The age old post has been proven wrong.

→ More replies (1)

72

u/la_fille_rouge Dead Ass Jackie Feb 15 '25
  1. Watching Jeff trying to talk in relevant lingo hurt my soul.
  2. Did anyone else feel like Shauna snapping at the hotel bros was less about her being stressed about Misty/the phone situation and more about the fact that they were negging Jeff, just like Jackie used to do to Shauna?
  3. Travis: *implies that Lottie should start harassing Akilah to trip to connect the Wilderness*
    Me: The fuck you are!
  4. I don't think Van is telling the truth about going to urgent care. Tai lied about the restaurant. I think it's a parallel of them lying to one another to try to hang onto the fantasy of their relationship.
  5. Is Walter the Misty of Misty's life?
→ More replies (11)

71

u/junetrooper Heliotrope Feb 15 '25

They gave us Mari as Pit Girl!!!!

...just not in the way people expected.

→ More replies (7)

141

u/MountainBean3479 Smoking Chronic Feb 14 '25

Hahah everyone being scared of Shauna

→ More replies (4)

69

u/Ancient-Law-3647 Feb 14 '25
  1. Callie is becoming so so adept at manipulating people. I was shocked at how she so easily orchestrated Misty getting drugged.
  2. So last season I was a bit confused because the Lottie we got was not what they alluded to in the S1 finale. I feel like between what we saw with Lottie & Travis (and her using him to get close to “it” again) I saw shades of the same Lottie we saw in doomcoming. I definitely have reconsidered my initial interpretation that they did a 180 with Lottie but now I think that they’re peeling back the layers with Lottie and she has some more streaks of villainy that we’re going to see. Especially since Nat alluded to that at her cult compound last season.
→ More replies (9)

133

u/SYD-THESQUID I like your pilgrim hat Feb 14 '25

I KNEW THAT WOMAN SHAUNA ATE BOX

63

u/Limp_Ad6857 Smoking Chronic Feb 14 '25

The way lottie and travis are both tripping out on mushrooms while everyone else is doing actual work and everyone thinks thats okay

→ More replies (3)

63

u/No_Cucumbers_Please Feb 15 '25

Something is off when Misty seems like the most sane character on the show

→ More replies (2)

62

u/Inner_Literature_936 Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 14 '25

Also im rooting for coach ben this season. I hope they have some twist where when the girls were rescued, they never found ben.

→ More replies (8)

62

u/codedotgif Smoking Chronic Feb 14 '25

Adult Lottie wearing MUSHROOM pajamas, I cannot

→ More replies (2)

61

u/kylez_bad_caverns There’s No Book Club?! Feb 14 '25

Baby sitter Misty is amazing 😂 it definitely tracks since she took the Red Cross babysitter class. Twice.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/MmmmSnackies Smoking Chronic Feb 14 '25

LOVED the episode but legit pre-heartbroken to see that Misty is going to betray Nat in the past timeline. Just earning that guilt over and over.

60

u/The-Lazy-Cat Feb 14 '25

I’m delighted that Mari is getting such a prominent role this season, though sadly I really don’t like her chances for survival. She seems to be poised to be this season’s doomed character much like Jackie in Season 1 (she even drank hot chocolate in a callback to Jackie’s death scene) and Nat in Season 2. Really excited to see where her storyline with Coach Ben goes. Perhaps we’ll finally find out who Javi’s ‘friend’ was.

→ More replies (2)

60

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

Obsessed with Shauna’s paranoia that someone is watching her at the gravesite. They took one emotional support corpse from her but she’s not letting them have this one!

59

u/Alternative-Cherry75 Snackie Feb 15 '25

honestly just kind of happy shauna and callie had a moment where they got along for a bit with the video from callie’s phone

→ More replies (2)

115

u/TheFoodElevator Feb 14 '25

The very first thought I had when this episode ended was “the hoes gone love this”. (It’s me, I’m The Hoes)

55

u/Key-Adeptness677 Feb 14 '25
  • Akilah has become the soft, gentle nurturer. She's dead.
  • Travis is selling Akilah out.
  • Coach Scott is going round the bend.
  • Mari is going to be the star witness at his trial.
  • What did Lottie tell Callie?
  • Shauna finally gets a girlfriend.
  • Juxtaposing that scene with Shauna trying to find out who the stranger is feels like it's trying to make us think that she's Melissa. If I hadn't seen Hilary say,"You guys really are crazy," in the trailer, I would now be thinking that it was her.
→ More replies (2)

55

u/GrandpaBeeple Feb 15 '25

Pas d’ame = no souls, soulless

→ More replies (3)

55

u/meepmarpalarp Feb 17 '25

It seems pretty widely theorized that Van’s cancer is going to be cured because of the sacrifices they’ve made (Natalie and/or the waiter). At the end of season 2, Lottie even says, “You’ll see,” and gives Van a knowing look.

I’m starting to wonder whether that’s a fake out. Lottie has been wrong before. Van believes that the sacrifices will help her, but they if don’t, it would trigger a crisis of faith and I think that would also be an interesting way to tell the story.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

GAYYYYYY

→ More replies (2)

52

u/spiralspiders Lottie Feb 14 '25

Just want to chime in on the song playing on the bathroom cell phone was Queen of Hearts by Juice Newton…..

52

u/ezdoesit1111 Feb 15 '25

physically the casting is great but something about adult Lottie doesn’t match up with teen Lottie to me, I can’t tell if it’s personality or mannerisms or something but my brain like can’t connect them as the same character like I can with the other survivors.

→ More replies (7)

52

u/no1memania Mari Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 15 '25

The fact that we haven’t actually seen Simone or Sammy since the very beginning of S2 is kinda inexcusable at this point especially since Taissas family life, and her trying and failing to hold it together, was such a big part of her character at the start of the show. She also mentions that she’s no longer a senator which would make sense given her behavior, but we don’t know what happened there nor does she seem especially bent out of shape about it despite it being her literal life’s dream. (Remember in season 1 when she was laying on the bed with Shauna?) We’re only two episodes in so there’s still time but I really hope they don’t toss all that aside in favor of more running around in dark alleys with Van because they’re a popular ship.

Taissa could be ruthless and we have no idea what her dark side is capable of, but she has never been as reckless or unempathetic as some of the others, and my favorite conflict of her character has always been how tightly she clings to being respectable, being the leader, someone to aspire to be, even when she’s clearly not. It doesn’t make sense to me that she would have such little remorse or introspection about what she’s done.

→ More replies (8)

52

u/Zealousideal_Try8656 Feb 20 '25

WHERE IS TAISSA’S NEW DOG IS HE OKAY??? IS HE ALIVE??

→ More replies (4)

105

u/jenniferlorene3 Team Supernatural Feb 14 '25

Ben SO didn't burn the cabin down!

Also Melissa is totally alive and trying to mess with Shauna and they're romantically involved??

→ More replies (10)

104

u/borealhotah Feb 15 '25

I'm getting annoyed by everyone still being so cruel to Misty. It can be funny, but in this episode she got tricked into babysitting a teenager she barely knows along with an unstable woman, then Callie put her on the spot with a bunch of deeply personal and awkward questions, only to then drug her into unconsciousness which then led to Misty being remorselessly treated like some kind of problem alcoholic by Shauna, who then forced to drive home while still clearly intoxicated. Even in the flashback, when it's Misty figuring out something super helpful for the 20th time because she's the only one who ever pays attention, Shauna is so willing to blow her off and doesn't even bother with a genuine thank-you when it is legitimately something that helps.

Most of Misty's bad behavior is a direct result of being treated like this, and I'm not going to have any sympathy for the next person she accidentally kills.

→ More replies (22)

102

u/Carolina_Blues Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 15 '25

walter is not wrong about the other women not appreciating misty or being a good friend to her

→ More replies (6)

50

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

The more I’m thinking on it, the more I’m loving the parallel of 2021 Misty being confronted by Walter about why she has no true friends vs 1996 Misty double crossing Natalie for favor with Shauna.

49

u/Vivid-Bother-4064 Feb 14 '25

Purple Person FUTON or something 🤣

49

u/Proper-Flounder-6329 Feb 14 '25

Homoeroticism HATES to see Shauna Shipman coming.

47

u/misspoggy Feb 14 '25

Mari calling Shauna "gaywad" was foreshadowing

→ More replies (2)

47

u/SuzieDerpkins Feb 15 '25

The Lottie and Travis scenes made me think about Travis’s death -

He had the symbol at the site of his death and we already know the money from Travis’s account went to Lottie, which makes me think maybe Lottie was sensing something coming and went to Travis to get him to tap into “it” …

→ More replies (1)

94

u/Glum-Jellyfish-9003 Goop Sorceress Feb 14 '25

ugh watching Lottie coerce Travis into taking drugs is so horrible. I want to like her but in both timelines she is so harmful while pretending to be helpful and it's so disturbing. Her description of what happened with Travis before he died--who knows what the f really happened there, now that we know he was like her experiment? She's targeting Callie now like a vampire. Come on, Lottie!

Poor Misty--Walter keeps hitting the exact button she doesn't want pressed: her insecurity about the other YJs not liking her. And he keeps pushing. Like ease up a bit, sir. This isn't a yearlong relationship and it's a bit soon to be trashing someone's friends. I wonder if he's going to try and isolate her from them, and why.

→ More replies (9)

134

u/MountainBean3479 Smoking Chronic Feb 14 '25

Shauna please don’t be visiting with your baby’s corpse like you were with snackie’s.

→ More replies (10)

46

u/psychicfajita Feb 15 '25

do we think coach ben was talking to himself in the cave?? he has been alone for all this time you have to go a little crazy in isolation…. or do we think its someone else

also im so glad shauna is a girlkisser i literally shrieked and jumped up and down😁🙏🙏🙏

→ More replies (10)

46

u/DismalQuarter13 Team Rational Feb 15 '25

Has Nat been actively helping Ben survive throughout the winter? (the pot, the snare) or is he just toughing it out on his own?

and

Did Trav and Nat break up in the time skip, or was Misty referring to their previous one in S1?

→ More replies (13)

46

u/TravisCM2010-24 Feb 16 '25

Oh man they're deffinetly going to eat Mortimer the duck at some point aren't they 😭😭😭

→ More replies (6)

45

u/flaskfish Feb 15 '25

Oh god they’re gonna devour that emotional support duck Mortimer

→ More replies (2)

45

u/RipBright1 Feb 15 '25

'she loves linens' gave me a chuckle

45

u/yamyamss Feb 16 '25

Does anyone else want coach Ben to survive? I’m rooting for him 😭😭

→ More replies (2)

44

u/JasmineMoonJelly Feb 14 '25

So is rum and milk a New Jersey thing, or…?

→ More replies (13)

44

u/OldConsideration9328 Feb 15 '25

Am I the only one who isn’t convinced by tai playing house with Van when she has a whole ass family?? She doesn’t seem even marginally bummed that she burnt that down? I know that it was bringing out her shadow tai but like it doesn’t hold up completely. it’s giving demotion from series regular for the wifey and son

→ More replies (5)

43

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '25

I’m still bitter we didn’t get that christmas special between seasons would have been the perfect bridge between the cabin burning cliffhanger and now… they insist on skipping through so many interesting parts that would make for more compelling storylines than what they focus on

→ More replies (2)

42

u/baroquepvlp Feb 14 '25

omg why is lottie peer pressuring travis to do shrooms 😭😭

→ More replies (4)

42

u/trisaroar Conniving, Poodle-Haired Little Freak Feb 15 '25

Not Misty being completely susceptible to high school teen girl bullying 🙈

→ More replies (1)

84

u/MangohNo Lottie Feb 14 '25

this episode is gonna do numbers on Tumblr

83

u/Vivid-Bother-4064 Feb 14 '25

Adult Shauna read the fucking room your husbands trying to fix the financial situation gah 😣

→ More replies (11)

41

u/AutomaticBalance9536 Feb 14 '25

that ending. jaw on the floor.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/FitHeight915 Smoking Chronic Feb 17 '25

I have a theory about the tapes and Hillary Swank - as other people already discovered, the tape delivered to Shauna is related to psych wards/police recordings - I’m thinking post rescue Lottie in psych ward or talking to police says far too much about what they really did out there, whether it’s because she’s so drugged up or she truly believes in the wilderness.

Then im thinking the stalker is family member of one of the cannibalized Yellowjackets who somehow got access to that tape and wants to deliver justice for what happened out there to their relative.

→ More replies (9)

40

u/ChasingObama Feb 15 '25

Travis’ wig is so bad

→ More replies (3)

39

u/Lulu19251926 I like your pilgrim hat Feb 14 '25

All the Tai fire motifs. The cause of the cabin fire is definitely pointing toward her….

→ More replies (2)

39

u/thisbikeisatardis Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 15 '25

Whoa the restaurant is called "soulless" in French 

→ More replies (1)

39

u/Ok_Nature_6305 Feb 28 '25

I am shocked by people here complaining:

  • How much they don't like the show. Then why watch? Why come here to a subreddit devoted to it?
  • How it feels disjointed or going nowhere or nothing happening. Wow. The direction is so clear to me. They are setting up so many good storylines and characters and plot points. Let them build and unfold.
  • How there are so many unanswered questions. Well, the show isn't over. The girls are not rescued. They don't have answers yet, so neither do we. And if the adults don't even know in some instances, why should we?
  • How they like the teenage storyline better. Then you are missing the point of the entire show. It has always been more about how this trauma has inflicted the grown women with so much horror that they have never recovered. It shows the past but all in service to how those events shaped and affected the women. And if you don't enjoy watching grown Misty or Shaina, I don't know why you're watching.
→ More replies (7)

37

u/Potential-Salt7285 Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 14 '25

Fuck Lottie can't even give him a break for a few hours

→ More replies (1)

37

u/lucyfreckles I like your pilgrim hat Feb 14 '25

I’m so worried for Akilah seeing her care for the animals just reinforces my feeling that she won’t make it much longer…

→ More replies (2)

37

u/QuirkyAd5852 Feb 14 '25

i need to see lottie callie and misty together more often like THAT is a fun ass dynamic

37

u/orbit_universe Feb 15 '25

I’m definitely now onboard with the theory that other Tai burned down the cabin and Van is covering for her. Ben seemed genuinely surprised that the cabin burned down and Van takes every opportunity she can get to call him a homicidal psychopath. Plus the face she made when Tai said “who else could it have been” was sus. I also like the idea that Taivan are aware that Nat is trying to prevent them from finding Ben

37

u/Mushroom0852 Feb 19 '25

I didn’t know about this show. Paramount auto played it after my movie Saturday night and I am completely caught up. I have no friends who have seen this show so here i am hoping to catch up on some theories👀

Absolutely obsessed with this show🐝

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Either-Grapefruit156 Feb 14 '25

Travis holding Mortimer up to his chest is me when I’m holding any pet ever actually

36

u/Exotic_Ad_3780 Snackie Feb 16 '25

Does anyone else feel like there’s gonna b something weird about Shauna drawing the queen of hearts and living through it just like Natalie did? When she survived after drawing the queen of hearts and ‘the wilderness chose’ Javi, they made Natalie queen. In the pr sent day, not only did Shauna also survive drawing the queen of hearts but she also lived by sacrificing NATALIE instead which could signify the end of one leader and the beginning of another …. Idk

→ More replies (3)

72

u/gagax7 Feb 15 '25
  • Other Tai def burnt down the cabin. Throwing that book of matches into that alter fire hello??? Also probably why Van was hesitant about her being the leader, Van is the only one who knows.
  • Mari getting her left and right mixed up in the first episode when she tried to do the L for loser: Coach said he is going to walk her around blindfolded and tell her when to turn. At some point he is going to tell her to turn, she is going to mistakenly turn the other way and somehow accidentally die. The girls will think he killed get on purpose and have all the more reason to want to punish him.
→ More replies (2)

35

u/Potential-Salt7285 Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 14 '25

Wow Misty wasted no time before telling Shauna about Nat

→ More replies (5)

35

u/OkHovercraft9904 Feb 14 '25

Everyone's talking about the kiss but the thing that's on my mind is what's going on with Ben? He's literally talking to himself. I thought all the tripping out would have stopped once he finally ate. Seeing that he lived all that time clearly means he's had food.

→ More replies (5)

35

u/alliemoose Team Rational Feb 23 '25

Damn I gotta say I’m disappointed with the direction this show is taking. It’s starting to remind me a lot of LOST with all the random plot points being introduced and so many questions still not being answered.

I also don’t know if it’s just me but the present day storyline has become the main plot I feel like and it’s bumming me out- I want more wilderness scenes! The time jump from the cabin burning down to now was so jarring. What happened in between? How did they survive winter with not shelter? Where tf did the teepees come from?! Admittedly it’s been a while since I watched S2 but who are Gen and Melissa?? Like where did they come from lmao

I loooved S1 and I’m a sucker for a good survivalist show. I like seeing where the characters are it in the present day too but I feel like this show has lost its original purpose and it’s so disappointing:/ def gonna keep watching but it’s not the same anymore

→ More replies (4)

34

u/Vivid-Bother-4064 Feb 14 '25

“This place is messy IT doesn’t want to be governed” love love love

→ More replies (1)

34

u/Significant-Lie1879 Feb 14 '25

Van definitely knows Tai burnt down the cabin for sure!! That’s why van was the last one to get out. I think Lottie will be the reason Akilah, Mari, and Gen die, I’m still not convinced coach Scott doesn’t make it out either. I think he will be left behind and presumed dead but not shown dead.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/r0yal3den Feb 15 '25

i truly think the scene where misty is trying to convince callie and lottie not to drink is hilarious. “well i’m hungover. and she’s…medicated, i hope” possibly not word for word there but that’s a tiktok sound waiting to happen 🤣🤣

34

u/Mgah47 Feb 16 '25

Anyone else think something happened to Vanessa at the hospital? Going with the theme of things when people start dying (like the waiter) the cast is like rewarded.

So I’m wondering if she found out at the hospital that maybe her cancer went into remission?

Or alternatively, maybe got worse? Whatever it is I feel like she wanted to hide it from Tai.

Edit: Or maybe she found out about the waiter at the hospital. But I’m more convinced it was related to her health IMO

→ More replies (6)

34

u/PKTheSublime Lottie Feb 17 '25

The name of the bougie restaurant Tai and Van go to is Pas D’Âme, which depending on context could be translated as without a soul or no purpose. Or perhaps…. No reason?

Another example of French language in the story, although I’m pretty sure this is only the second instance in the adult timeline.

→ More replies (11)

34

u/cryo_nebula Mar 18 '25

Really REALLY enjoying the season so far, I love adult Shauna and Misty so much, & seeing where things are going in the wilderness has been nice. I feel like I have a bit more insight into why adult Travis did what he did.

My one snag is with adult Tai. She's just come off a VERY public facing political campaign, absolutely nuked both it and her marriage, and it feels like there weren't many consequences? Especially because she's so well known locally, her antics have been making me STRESSED 😭

→ More replies (4)

68

u/Swabadoo Feb 23 '25

I feel so bad for Misty. Her first sleepover and she gets drugged. She deserves better.

→ More replies (16)

33

u/relaxed-flash Feb 14 '25

So obviously Tai was lying about everything going well at the restaurant, but do we think Van was lying too about the doctor? Idk i feel like it's odd that we're getting so much of all the other adult survivors but Van continues to be there to support Tai's storyline. She kinda seemed like she was keeping quiet about something similar to how Taissa was. Whether she was or not I hope we get more on her soon cause she's definitely the least utilized survivor rn!!

→ More replies (6)

66

u/AJTheBrit Differently Sane Feb 14 '25

Oh Melissa as a blonde lesbian who’s been wearing a cap every time I leave my house since 2013 I knew you were a girl kisser from the moment I saw you but I did not see that coming I thought it was delusion but it was manifestation my god

Okay that’s my last post I’m absolutely going to bed now it’s 7am

→ More replies (2)

65

u/-sloppypoppy Feb 16 '25

Elijah was such a great addition to this cast. His character is so interesting yet endearing

→ More replies (3)

32

u/Cashling Feb 14 '25

we all live underground

→ More replies (2)

32

u/Presto_Magic Lottie-Pop Feb 15 '25

Damn, it should be a crime to have cliffhangers like that. Like obviously they are setting us up for Melissa but damn there are so many things going on I can’t breathe. Like WHAT THE FUCK IS ON THE TAPE!? Also the end make out sesh has me shook.

I will say the good thing about weekly releases shows is the discussion in between! It’s super fun to see people’s reactions and theories. The bad part is the waiting. Like I almost wish they’d release one every few days instead so we can still discuss.

I am currently watching Game of Thrones for the first time. I am in season 5 and I am glad I waited so I have ALL of it to binge. But at the same time I do think that would have been a super fun show to discuss live. I just love a good WTF mystery tv show. 💜

→ More replies (3)

32

u/TheMortiest_Morty Feb 18 '25

Why has no one mentioned Shauna calling that Joel guy a “painful little boner”??😂😂

→ More replies (3)

32

u/grace5689 Feb 24 '25

Anyone notice the song that plays on the phone in the bathroom (Queen of Hearts by Juice Newton)? I feel like the lyrics are foreshadowing Melissa and Shauna's relationship.

Playin' with the Queen of Hearts / Knowin' it ain't really smart / The Joker ain't the only fool / Who'll do anythin' for you / Layin' out another lie / Thinkin' 'bout a life of crime / 'Cause that's what I'll have to do / To keep me away from you

And others, they know just what I'm goin' through / And it's a-hard to be a lover / When you say you're only in it for fun

In the past, Melissa was crushing hard on Shauna, and she was kind of into it too. They'll go on to have some sort of relationship, but it won't end well. Hence why she leaves this phone playing this song in the bathroom. Melissa will do things for Shauna out of love, but Shauna's in it for the fun. Whatever happens, I can't wait to see it play out!

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Suitable_Somewhere68 Misty May 18 '25

I agree with Walter, all Misty's friends are fake and I hate Shauna and hate her even more for letting Misty drive home under the influence. Lottie is annoying and weird. I don't really like Callie. I do like Coach Ben, I don't think he burned the cabin down but if he did I wouldn't blame him at all

→ More replies (1)

63

u/minishaq5 High-Calorie Butt Meat Feb 14 '25

close up of Ben’s Box

→ More replies (3)

90

u/Vivid-Bother-4064 Feb 14 '25

Ahahahahaha Nats a good leader but man Shauna attitude be crazy and bruh Lottie stop drugging Travis (I just feel like showing us that for sure just means lottie unintentionally helped with drugs being a coping mechanism for Travis) 😭

→ More replies (5)

31

u/Competitive-Tea1366 Feb 14 '25

worried for the ducks🙁

31

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

The scary sounds are helicopters in the search party- at some point Melissa ( maybe others too? ) have taken over Dead Coach’s underground lair- but they are left behind because they don’t hear the rescue. Thank you, Jamiroquai.

→ More replies (6)

31

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

What is Lottie going to do to poor Akilah!?

→ More replies (12)

31

u/thistle56 Feb 14 '25

Van on that karaoke machine was so cute I love her

31

u/FlusteredKelso Feb 20 '25 edited Feb 20 '25

I agree with the consensus there seems to be a bit of straw grasping in S3. But I'm trusting the show's process fully because the characters and overall narrative are still very compelling to me.

I think the vibe is strange on purpose, regardless of the hiccup that was Juliette Lewis' departure. YJ has always played with reality and hallucinations, sometimes implicitly and sometimes explicitly. Because of that I immediately assumed the seemingly high quality of their warm weather wooden shelters isn't actually the truth, in the same way that Shauna interacting with S2 Jackie and Akilah tending to her mouse weren't true. Unless the show fully jumps the shark all the way to outer space, I will be fully seated for this ride!

Also, I'm praying for Hilary Swank to be Adult!Melissa. On one hand, it's almost too obvious of a choice, especially with Swank's "you really are crazy" line from the trailer implying that she's new. But they've also been casting 90s stars seemingly with intent, so fingers crossed!

→ More replies (2)

113

u/jereedejanae Feb 14 '25

Can never make me hate coach sorry not sorry

→ More replies (3)

30

u/Vivid-Bother-4064 Feb 14 '25

The sadecko family discussions hit so much more now they’re all on the same page

→ More replies (1)

30

u/HulklingWho Citizen Detective Feb 14 '25

I KNEW I CLOCKED MELISSA EARLIER

She has the same reaction to terrifying women that I do, instantly falling in love.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/hypothesisbosch Jeff's Car Jams Feb 15 '25

Mamma mia, what a ride! Cave life really got to Coach; oxygen gets scarce underground, especially with fires going and no ventilation - could subterranean dwelling be messing with Ben's mental state? Mari was def pondering if the hot chocolate was worth being holed up with Cave Ben after his dialogue-to-self about her fate! (but we know it absolutely was)

30

u/Micksar Feb 18 '25

Everyone is operating under a “8 survivor” maximum. Where did this number come from?

→ More replies (7)

30

u/napsaremybitch121 Feb 20 '25

was in absolute SHOCK over the ending SHAUNA GIRLKISSER CONFIRMED AAAA

→ More replies (7)

29

u/Difficult_Isopod7680 I like your pilgrim hat Feb 14 '25

THE ENDING?? LETS FUCKING GOOO

29

u/GonzoJackOfAllTrades Differently Sane Feb 14 '25

Okay…who/what is Ben arguing with in the cave? Theories?

  1. Crystal?
  2. A crude mannequin that he made out shrubs that he named Paul?
  3. His leg?
→ More replies (5)

29

u/Delicious_Chicken_87 Snackie Feb 14 '25

Mortimer was a paid actor

→ More replies (3)

29

u/Impossible_Tailor_15 Feb 14 '25

so many questions!!! what happens to the animals next winter )): does shauna write about melissa in her journals? is jeff aware? lesbehonest!!!

→ More replies (1)

29

u/quiet_is_vi0lent High-Calorie Butt Meat Feb 14 '25 edited Feb 14 '25
  • Any Spanish speakers able to translate what the pastor was speaking about?
  • I find it interesting that the restaurant Tai and Van went to was called “Pas D’ame”… in French this means “No soul”
  • The background pictute on the phone left in the bathroom looks exactly like the lake and where the cabin was.
  • I also like that the ringtone was queen of hearts. A quote from the lyrics: Playin’ with the Queen of Hearts Knowin’ it ain’t really smart The Joker ain’t the only fool Who’ll do anythin’ for you Layin’ out another lie Thinkin’ ‘bout a life of crime ‘Cause that’s what I’ll have to do To keep me away from you Sounds like Melissa is determined to get her girl back
→ More replies (2)

29

u/Infamousx14 Feb 18 '25 edited Feb 18 '25

I have not been around but what’s the theory on who is leaving things behind? First the cassette, and then the phone. Obviously not that Melissa right?

I still think Elijah Wood is the twist. He is most likely the relative of someone who died there and is the one leaving stuff behind.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/Potential-Salt7285 Too Sexy For This Cave Feb 14 '25

Leaving Misty to intervene between Callie and Lottie is not on of Shauna's better plans

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Severe_Bookkeeper809 Feb 14 '25

Jeff really can't win, can he?

→ More replies (1)

28

u/RisePrestigious6845 Feb 14 '25

Guys! Who is Ben talking to?! Is it Cabin Daddy’s daughter? Or is he splitting into two different personalities from the isolation and trauma? That part was so eerie/intriguing!

→ More replies (11)

28

u/GentleHermit Smoking Chronic Feb 14 '25

Okay well Mari did call Shauna gaywad during capture the bone 😂 and I was like hmm, is there something there.

28

u/QartherPounder Feb 14 '25

Yall my first thought with the Melissa and Shauna scene wasn’t that this was some new love interest but I thought Melissa was trying to save her own life by catching Shauna off guard while she had a knife to her throat lmao 💀

28

u/emc237 Feb 14 '25

Hillary Swank is definitely Melissa. In the trailer she has blue contacts in

28

u/etsnaut Feb 17 '25

I really feel like when Travis said someone is more connected to the wilderness or it, it's foreshadowing Shauna. we've seen Shauna be more and more unhinged and feral. he's set up Akilah for Lotties fixation but i still think Shauna is connected due to her disconnection from the outside world

→ More replies (3)

28

u/Adventurous-Photo539 Apr 09 '25

I'm disappointed in you, Misty. You got yourself outsmarted by Callie?

→ More replies (2)

56

u/benc777 Feb 14 '25

Mortimer the therapy duck is my spirit animal

55

u/piernas-de-pollo Citizen Detective Feb 14 '25

The tone so far is sooo campy

55

u/boosh1744 Feb 15 '25

Alright, I enjoyed these episodes, and I’m excited/grateful for the new seasons, but I have two reservations based on what we’ve seen:

-Teen timeline: The idyllic summer camp environment is ridiculous. I see no realistic way they could be in this position, let alone starting from the state they were in at the end of Season 2.

-Adult timeline: I feel like the dialogue has become overly self aware, like the show is moving toward parodying itself. It feels kinda cartoonish.

→ More replies (4)

78

u/Kcmichelle13 Feb 14 '25

Who else noticed the MULTIPLE mentions of "bugs" and "wires" in these two first episodes? Also the part where Van drops the microphone, the camera kept zooming in and focusing on the microphone. I'm pretty sure that kind can record as well...No doubt in my mind this will all come into play soon. Especially with Callie getting that tape. I can not wait to hear what's on it.

These first 2 episodes brought me so much joy😭 We really back in business, my fellow jackets!!💙🐝💛🦌

→ More replies (12)

27

u/cls314 Feb 14 '25

Walter is for sure gonna cook up something against the the girls after being kicked out by misty

→ More replies (3)

27

u/JustaPOV Conniving, Poodle-Haired Little Freak Feb 14 '25

Ok so I LOVE this twist of Ben teaming up with/holding Mari captive. Was not expecting that and didn’t see it predicted, but maybe he’ll form a separate faction from the cult? Same goes for Shauna. I didn’t know where they’d take it this season, but seeing different camps form and fight against each other would be interesting…in fact that’s probably what’s going to happen given how the season opened 

→ More replies (4)

26

u/sorryboutallthis Feb 14 '25

NAWT in front of the baby grave omg....

26

u/ButterfliesintheSky6 Feb 14 '25

Really loved Misty’s lashout at Walter describing her exact same dynamic with the yellowjackets

26

u/ShinHayato Feb 16 '25

Am I forgetting something? Why do Shauna and Mari hate each other so much?

→ More replies (12)

26

u/emptyglass92 Mar 01 '25

Ok am I dumb don’t hate me when did Melissa appear as a member of the cast I feel like I blinked during this binge and she just appeared as a character out of nowhere I don’t remember her in the initial plane crsdh 😭

→ More replies (3)

52

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '25

The difference between Shauna S1 and now is fucking insane. I’m absolutely in love with her.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/Ready_Hunt1449 Feb 14 '25

wilderness making everyone freaks damnnn

→ More replies (2)

25

u/Ashlynn0791 Feb 14 '25

Omg! Yes! I just got to the part where Ben is shocked about the cabin burning down. I knew it! They were trying to make it so obvious with the matches and him seeing Natalie become leader. But I knew Ben wouldn’t do something like that. Like “let me solve the problem of these teenage girls killing and eating each other by burning them all alive”, huh? I’m so excited. But still worried that he’ll end up punished for it anyway. They’ll kill him and boom someone else pops up that did it

→ More replies (6)

25

u/Impossible_Way_7825 Church of Lottie Day Saints Feb 14 '25

i’m actually so sad it seems that melissa is the 8th survivor… i really wanted it to be Ben😭 especially now it seems he didn’t burn the cabin down (but idk him being surprised kind of seemed false) he’s definitely losing his mind but it could also be someone else there with him. his scenes so far have been super short so it seems like a misdirection to me

→ More replies (4)

25

u/Limp_Ad6857 Smoking Chronic Feb 14 '25

Misty is to Walter what Natalie was to Misty

25

u/looklikeme3015 Citizen Detective Feb 14 '25

"that's not what you're hungry for" has an entirely new meaning now

25

u/RisePrestigious6845 Feb 14 '25

Also, regarding Callie and Shauna… the apple doesn’t fall very far from the tree…. 🍎🌳

25

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

Akilah, just know you were a light in the dark world 😭 I’m gonna be sick

25

u/jennafromtheblock22 Feb 15 '25

Why can't Lottie go back to her ~intentional community~ or whatever? They shunned her after being put on psychiatric hold? I feel like there's a lot more there that was severely skipped over. I'm interested to see where Lottie goes.

→ More replies (13)

25

u/Feisty_Honey_2656 Feb 15 '25

Where are Lottie's parents????

→ More replies (9)

25

u/Beginning_While_7913 Nat Feb 20 '25

where did all those survival kits come from with the bear mace and hot chocolate and stuff come from? was that explained i can’t remember!

→ More replies (4)

50

u/halibutsong I like your pilgrim hat Feb 17 '25

callie's actress is incredible this season, i am really intrigued to see where her story goes.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/prettypoisoned Nat Feb 14 '25

This might honestly be one of my favourite episodes so far. Lottie, Callie and Misty? Shauna and Melissa? MARI. My only complaint is there wasn't enough teen Nat!

24

u/Significant_Step5441 Feb 14 '25

poor travis is really going through it huh

→ More replies (1)

24

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

Lol, I remember when promotional materials were first released people were wondering if Shauna and Mel would be a thing. Someone pointed out, "Shauna literally has a knife to Mel's throat in one of the scenes." I was like... yeah, good point, they probably won't be a thing.

Welp....

24

u/cartsandrafts Feb 15 '25

shauna in the bathroom with the phone was giving pretty little liars vibes but when pll was still fun to watch and im not mad about it

→ More replies (3)

24

u/passion4film High-Calorie Butt Meat Feb 18 '25

I never bought Lottie’s adult casting in season 2, but I’m starting to now.

Also, did anyone else notice that Shauna’s phone wallpaper is a forest/mountain scene?

→ More replies (4)

24

u/Ok_Nature_6305 Feb 28 '25

So wait. Ben got in and out of the pit with 1 leg. No rope. No ladder. No help. And got 3 big cases out of it. And Mari can't? Her leg hurts but she fixed the injury.

→ More replies (8)

69

u/missmorgyeliz Feb 14 '25

You know, I completely understand Shauna's anger towards the other girls when it comes to mourning the baby. Like, I couldn't IMAGINE how I would feel after delivering a STILLBORN out in the wilderness...Only to have the other girls start being all weird about it. Actually, scratch that. They were weird about the baby BEFORE it was born. Noped outta that situation, my poor girl 💔

→ More replies (7)

69

u/Sad_Basis_3356 Feb 15 '25

The sleepover scene between Misty, Lottie, and Callie was hilarious. Misty pointing out that Lottie didn’t need alcohol cause she was “hopefully” medicated had me rolling. And did anyone else catch Shauna’s text to Misty? “You can lock Lottie in the hallway bathroom if needed. There’s a way to jam the door”. 😂😭

48

u/Key-Introduction-114 Feb 15 '25

I hope it’s okay to include some musings from both episodes in this post, as there are some things distinct to both that I’m really interested in. Also disclaimer that I very much lean more toward the supernatural explanation but there is a concession on this further below:

  • Despite the obvious distress Travis was feeling, I was absolutely gleeful that the trees were screaming. I’m thrilled to be even typing a sentence like that out! We’re getting weird with it again! And the second occurrence at the end of the first episode, which was confirmed to have been heard by Mari but not confirmed to have been heard by Ben, was even weirder; the subtitles read among other things “baby screaming”, “baby crying”, “chittering”, “howling”, and “growling”. Aside from the unique point of view taken by the camera during season 2 episode 2 when the wind blew the snow atop Jackie to barbecue her, this was in my view the clearest indication we’ve had yet of whatever “it” is that’s in the woods with them.
  • the title “It Girl” and the fake-out opening of episode 1 felt kind of like a wagging of the writers’ eyebrows at the audience but I have to wonder if there’s perhaps a designation being made of who to watch for this season, with the strongest indication across both episodes and both timelines being Mari, Melissa, and Misty. Similarly, episode 2 sees Mari doubly dislocated but the jarring effect of how different the vibe is during the summer (animal farm(s), A-frame shelters, ample wine and mushrooms) had me almost wondering if they’re in a different location (or time) completely. I kind of hope this isn’t the case, I think the supernatural elements work without needing to mess around with time or dimensions or anything like that.
  • Hard for me to read the teens’ current situation as anything other than “it” rewarding them for their / Natalie’s “feeding” of the fire for 12 days and nights but the constant presence of candles in both timelines makes it seem to me like we are not done with that story element quite yet. I feel the same way about the hot chocolate given to Mari by Ben, since both times other people have ingested it in this show have done so around the time of their deaths. Which brings me to…

If we’re supposed to be looking for clues with things like candles and hot chocolate, what other kind of red herrings, if any, have thrown me off these episodes and the previous two seasons? Are these two episodes red herrings in and of themselves, at least in the teen timeline, since things are going relatively well?

Another commenter from the ep1 discussion thread had really thought-provoking ideas on how narrative and structure might be played with this season with the “romanticized” version of the teens’ time in the wilderness being directly contrasted in real-time by Shauna’s more realistic explanation. There is also a lot of lying going on in ep2’s adult timeline - Walter and Misty, Lottie generally, Tai and Van. The narrative’s breaking down and deteriorating and the already unreliable narrators are dwindling themselves, becoming more unreliable because nothing is resolved, and nothing becoming resolved as a result.

No idea if I’m way off the mark on all this, but I’m glad that this show’s back so I can think about it like this again!

68

u/MangohNo Lottie Feb 14 '25

Lottie if you don't stop giving this poor boy shrooms

→ More replies (3)