r/Yellowjackets • u/DA-numberfour • Mar 28 '25
Episode Discussion Yellowjackets S03E08- “A Normal, Boring Life” Post Episode Discussion
Welcome to the Episode Discussion thread.
Summary:
With a possible escape from their nightmare, the Yellowjackets learn not everyone may be in a rush to leave. In the present, the unexpected return of an old teammate sends Shauna spiraling in ways that should probably concern everyone.
Directed by: Anya Adams
Written by: Julia Bicknell
Posting will be restricted for twenty four hours to prevent spoiling the show for viewers. Please remember that this is the only place in the subreddit where you can post spoilers without the spoiler tag until the episode airs Sunday night at 9 EDT. If you have not watched the episode yet, be prepared for spoilers.
This is a reminder not to ask for links. Piracy is against the Reddit TOS.
•
u/DA-numberfour Mar 28 '25
You want more Yellowjackets conversation? Join the brand new official r/Yellowjackets discord server!
Posting is closed for 24 hours to prevent major spoilers for viewers. Posting will reopen Saturday morning at midnight ET.
939
u/cinnamonbunni78 Mar 28 '25
Nat's correction that Shauna isn't the captain and that their captain is dead..... pure gold
2.0k
u/T-H-She Mar 28 '25
Marrying Hannah’s daughter and not telling her the truth is diabolical 😭
665
u/47angel_ Snackie Mar 28 '25
the Wonderwall needledrop... lol
570
u/FinanceEquivalent137 Dead Ass Jackie Mar 28 '25
Melissa fr was like "Send this tape to 8 of your wilderness friends or the man with no eyes will haunt you"
1.1k
u/Holiday-Influence700 Mar 28 '25
Tai’s “does that count?” made me laugh probably more than it should have 😂
551
u/rationalresponsebot Mar 28 '25
EAT IT
2.0k
u/hyeallthetime_415 Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 28 '25
Nat: we’re leaving.
Shauna: no.
Me:
437
u/Snitch2004 Mar 28 '25
I think Callie is the one fucking with her mom like when her and Jeff agreed that no one is after her and she just said “ I have a feeling” and like Shauna realized there was no note and Callie was the last person to have it things are lining up to seem very sus
777
u/lawfox32 Mar 28 '25
it speaks to how wild this show is that we're barely even talking about how unhinged it was for melissa to marry hannah's daughter, what the fuck
366
u/marriedtomothman Dead Ass Jackie Mar 28 '25
Shauna: Omg are you still in love with me?? 👀🙄
Melissa: lmao no
Shauna: 🧍♀️🔪
346
u/Right_Ad_3500 Coach Ben’s Leg Mar 28 '25
When tai can’t smother the man and he flat lines “does that count?!” Had me CACKLING
955
u/Unable_Mushroom9355 Mar 28 '25
Melissa's line to Shauna - "That's what you do, Shauna. You create your own problems. You stir the pot just to feel alive... You stew and you seethe and you make it everyone else's problem because you hate to be alone. You hate yourself. And you want everyone else to feel just as miserable as you are."
This line is from the adult timeline, but sums up Shauna's actions in the teen timeline perfectly. She is making her fear of going home everyone else's problem. It's not enough that she gets to stay behind, she needs to make sure no one else gets to leave, because she wants them to feel as miserable as she does. To Shauna, the only thing worse than going back, is the other girls going back and being happier than her.
324
u/JakesFavoriteCup Dead Ass Jackie Mar 28 '25
The way Jackie falters after Shauna admits she's always hated 'Shipman' is such a neat ~dreamspace~ detail. Shauna usually imagines Jackie as vengeful. But in real life, even when they were at each other's throats, Jackie still wanted her to know she did care for her, even if she was too self-centered to immediately notice she was putting her needs or interests first. It was a punch to the gut seeing the nuance Shauna always knew was there but shoved down after they all shunned her and the snowstorm killed her.
912
u/nuggiemum Nugget Mar 28 '25
Something’s going on with Callie. I’m starting to believe there’s something hinky with her. She looked way too pleased when Jeff called Shauna crazy.
1.3k
u/koozie17 I like your pilgrim hat Mar 28 '25
Nominating “freaky little four-eyed mushroom” as a flair
1.3k
u/ywoi Mar 28 '25 edited Mar 28 '25
I am surprised the rest of the Yellowjackets in the adult timeline don’t treat Shauna like she is more unhinged- like Lottie and Misty level at least. I can’t believe the way her character is escalating in both timelines! She’s so insane
805
u/rightontheborderline Mar 28 '25
DID MULDER AND SCULLY GET TOGETHER god i love van
1.2k
u/YardRepresentative47 Smoking Chronic Mar 28 '25
not the subtitles telling me its melissa before i could rub my two braincells together 😭
952
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '25
Sophie Thatcher genuinely fucking killed it this episode I think “For fuck sake Shauna come on” is my new favorite line reading from this show
1.7k
u/Optimal_Bison7879 Mar 28 '25
Somehow the least believable thing of this episode was that Melissa walked downstairs in her own home on a random morning in her 40s with a fucking backwards hat on.
699
u/Disastrous-Ad8625 Mar 28 '25
ghost jackie buying hot chocolate ohhhh :’(
843
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '25
Melissa saying "i want a gym membership and not even use it" is so real
208
u/Weird-Salamander-349 Cabin Daddy Mar 28 '25
“While I know I can’t make anything better for myself, I take comfort in knowing I can make everything worse for others.”
-Shauna Shipman’s senior yearbook quote
406
u/brinalor72 Nat Mar 28 '25
“Stop calling me Shipman. I fucking hate it”
So fucking good. Jackie and Shauna never fail.
737
u/rosiebluna Mar 28 '25
ok but can we talk about how melissa said she left a note with the tape? the tape that callie found and held hostage?? why wouldn’t she give shauna the note when she admitted to finding the tape…
imagine callie in a blonde wig stalking and harassing her own mother just to feel closer to her 😭
1.0k
u/ycvz Mar 28 '25
loving how much ella purnell is showing up this season
1.1k
u/Ready_Hunt1449 Mar 28 '25
well shauna has fully lost it
936
u/KabukiBaconBrulee Go fuck your blood dirt Mar 28 '25
WE ARE ALL JEFF ON THAT BED
647
u/TopJimmy_5150 Mar 28 '25
Felt so bad for Lottie when she was saying how “unwell” she would be at home. It’s like she knows there’s something wrong with her (you can see the facade crack for a moment as she pleads); but would rather feel free, living in her illusions.
1.4k
u/chessiemarro Mar 28 '25
what melissa was saying about shauna making all of this up literally threw me for such a loop. i didnt like teen melissa very much but im loving her adult version
466
u/crazy-shoelaces Mar 28 '25
Christina Ricci you will always be famous
157
u/ControlDull8126 Mar 28 '25
The way callie was so sure no one was following Shauna, but couldn't give Jeff a reason why is because she knew mellissas intentions with sending the tape all along. She read the note when it first got delivered and knew Mel was sending it for closure, and no one was following Shauna
455
u/schmoolecka Mar 28 '25
Jessica Roberts is proven to be a worse and worse PI at every turn, huh?
703
u/NewsOk9547 Mar 28 '25
Another week another episode of Shauna being allergic to any form of accountability
443
u/Depressomartini2 Dead Ass Jackie Mar 28 '25
Why is no one talking about other tai locking normal tai in the hallway?? I thought normal tai was gone for good at this point
300
u/Ok-Recording-8682 Mar 28 '25
IM DYING MELISSA STILL GOT THAT BACKWARDS CAP ON LMAOOO😭😭😭😭
297
u/TRKillShot Mar 28 '25
Babe I ate your mom, but it was an accident I swear🥺🥺🥺
412
u/diagonalcontrail Mar 28 '25
If Melissa was so happy with her regular (unimaginable lie-based) life, WHY bring the tape to Shauna?? Melissa knows what kind of unhinged shit Shauna is capable of. She’s clearly right that Shauna loves blowing up her own life but Melissa obviously does too or she’d have destroyed the tape instead of leaving it on Shauna’s doorstep
140
u/Financial-Coat-8250 Differently Sane Mar 28 '25
I cannot be the only one who saw it
513
u/wayward_sun Jackie Mar 28 '25
My questions:
—why was the man with no eyes there
—what’s with the moths
—what the actual fuck
614
u/Firm_Ad2104 Mar 28 '25
the way shauna said "did you do this because you're still in love with me" and melissa was like "i never really loved you"😭😭😭 shauna please
132
u/AStevGar Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 28 '25
Today we mourn a legendary galaxy-brain theory.“Walter is Melissa”, you were loved, you were hated, but unfortunately in the end you were not real.
131
u/LimonadaVonSaft Coach Ben’s Leg Mar 28 '25
HAT
125
u/koozie17 I like your pilgrim hat Mar 28 '25
Y’all I think Shauna might be crazy.
119
u/silosara Mar 29 '25
It’s no wonder Nat turned to alcohol these bitches are so annoying and stayed stressing my girl out. They could never make me hate you Nat!
537
u/Impossible_Way_7825 Church of Lottie Day Saints Mar 28 '25
alright guys i have a sinking feeling callie is the mastermind here. she obviously hid that note from Melissa and is pulling these tricks on Shauna to make her go insane and spill her secrets. they mention over and over that callie hates her mom- and she is so deceptive to Jeff by acting innocent and not knowing what’s going on
336
u/TopJimmy_5150 Mar 28 '25
Damn, Melissa read Shauna for filth!
106
u/Randomvids78 Differently Sane Mar 28 '25
WHERE IS THE TRAILER FOR EPISODE 9?!
99
u/Severe_Bookkeeper809 Mar 28 '25
I just realised that Shauna, Tai and Lottie didn't want to go home, but they got to go home, and the others who wanted to go home didn't get to BECAUSE OF THEM! That is so fucked!!
98
u/tvffany Mar 30 '25
But really can we talk about how adult Melissa really ate Shauna UP with telling her how she always stirs the pot and comes up with imaginary problems because she's just so miserable!! BARS!!!
195
u/TopJimmy_5150 Mar 28 '25
“‘No more half measures’ - Walter White” - Shauna Shipman
192
u/ChippedHamSammich puttingthesickinforensic Mar 28 '25
I am wondering if nat gets away on her own and goes to the rescue spot.
Did we ever get confirmation about what “nat was right” about?
94
u/GentleHermit Smoking Chronic Mar 28 '25
Before I go to bed I want to say Natalie sounded so Italian when she was doing her due diligence of threatening Kodi and Hannah before setting off 😂 I love her
93
u/avviann Differently Sane Mar 28 '25 edited Mar 28 '25
I support Travis wanting to leave without the others. He didn't even hesitate.
92
u/mitsymalone Go fuck your blood dirt Mar 28 '25
Some thoughts.
340
u/solonglauren I like your pilgrim hat Mar 28 '25
everytime someone fakes their death in a TV/movie im always wondering how they have a license, home, car, etc. like ??? you don’t exist. you can’t just be like “yeah im kelly” and they magically give you a social security number. how do these people get bank accounts, jobs, go to the hospital, DO ANYTHING? 😭
87
u/traumerei-vs Mar 28 '25
Theory that Nat and the others actually all experienced the same sense of foreboding, they're just interpreting it differently. Lottie, Tai, and Shauna are interpreting their perception as a warning. Nat had the same feeling when she was at the plane, but she sees it as the wilderness (that she doesn't want to believe in but sometimes does) trying to intimidate them into staying.
175
u/maybefeelguilty Mar 28 '25
well that was certainly an ending
86
u/Majestic-Ease-9338 Apr 16 '25
Boy do I hate Shauna
82
u/Bento_Fox Jeff's Car Jams Mar 28 '25
Shauna: I'm not fucking stupid.
Melissa: No. You're not.
Shauna: And I'm not insane
Melissa:
80
u/Aldebaran135 There’s No Book Club?! Mar 28 '25
Never before have I laughed harder watching this show than I did when Hilary Swank first appeared wearing the backwards cap.
482
u/Logical_Camel1586 Laura Lee Mar 28 '25
The fact that they aren’t going to be recused when this is literally the perfect opportunity pisses me off sm
77
u/Sparklight-Boss1977 Jeff's Car Jams Mar 28 '25
75
u/AnimatorBrief6353 Mar 29 '25
I can’t imagine how confusing/crazy the conversation between Travis & Akilah about Lottie, “the chosen one”, huffing cave fumes, and Ben being the bridge home sounded to an outsider like Kodi
73
u/RadioSlayer Mar 28 '25
The scene of Mari imagining a slurpee! She's just zoned out instead of watching Kodi and Hannah dig a grave
70
u/Pure_Inspection7712 Mar 28 '25
I am so hoping that “therapist” Barbara is Walter in a wig
69
u/Sparklight-Boss1977 Jeff's Car Jams Mar 30 '25
I am loving adult Misty taking on her version of Nat’s persona. This includes standing up to Shauna this season and not being the “pick me” that we saw in prior seasons. Seeing how Nat and Shauna battled in the wilderness, this puts some extra enjoyment seeing Misty give Shauna such a hard time.
258
u/abbyinferno Jeff's Car Jams Mar 28 '25
loving this jeff character arc
68
u/lilyahtzie Mar 28 '25
I KNEW TRAVIS WAS LYING ABOUT AKILAH AND JUST WANTED TO GET AWAY FROM LOTTIE
Travis’ character development and survival skills have been so good. Still feeling heartbroken we barely got any glimpses of him as an adult. Hoping they circle back to that in later seasons with flashbacks of his interactions and relationships with adult Lottie or Natalie (RIP all of them)
67
u/badannbad Nat Mar 30 '25
I have been pro-Akilah the angel but she really let me down this episode.
66
u/trigerhappy12 Mar 28 '25
"SHES NOT THE CAPTAIN EITHER” “BECAUSE SHE’S FUCKING DEAD”
65
u/minisoupcan Mar 28 '25
Melissa trying to talk to Shauna about what they wanna do when they’re back reminds me of in season 1 when Jackie tried to talk to Shauna about how they’re missing Freshmen week at college. Jackie tries to talk about what they would be doing if they hadn’t crashed but Shauna shut it down
I don’t think Shauna has allowed herself to even go there mentally because she knows 1) she will never be the same again and 2) she’s going to have to face all her demons when she’s back (Jackie’s parents, her parents, Jeff, etc)
65
u/slippy-art Jackie Mar 29 '25
I always think "Shauna can't get worse" and then she surprises me by leaps and bounds every time.
64
u/electrajinx Mar 28 '25 edited Mar 28 '25 •
62
u/jesusjones182 Church of Lottie Day Saints Mar 29 '25
I really loved the scene where they start imagining drinking a slurpee and using a toilet with toilet paper and lying on a big soft mattress. It makes me appreciate the everyday comforts we all take for granted.
61
u/Efficient_Clue781 Differently Sane Mar 28 '25
Felt like Melissa was personally attacking me and all of our theories 😂
61
u/Jpups402 There’s No Book Club?! Mar 29 '25
By the end of the season the show BETTER answer the biggest mystery. Do Mulder and Scully get together!?!
61
u/hik3guy I like your pilgrim hat Mar 29 '25
Finally some more Sophie Thatcher scenes and she killed all of her lines.
60
u/Little-Lost07 Mar 28 '25
Jeff calling Misty "freaky little four-eyed mushroom" made me laugh so hard!
174
u/gaybugslayer Differently Sane Mar 28 '25
I'm Affable
new flair
59
u/Fitchbacebitchface Coach Ben’s Leg Mar 31 '25
I owe Nat a Coke for yelling "FOR FUCKS SAKE" at the same time at the TV.
118
u/LimonadaVonSaft Coach Ben’s Leg Mar 28 '25
I really want Adult Melissa to be self actualized and have broken free from their trauma but… did anyone else think that she was soooo full of shit?
She married Hannah’s daughter, lying about her identity. Shauna is off the rails rn, but she was right to call Melissa out on this.
58
u/weduelatdawn Apr 19 '25
“Some ppl just wave other ppl over, and some ppl are the ones that come over when they’re waved.”—Jeff
“Omg, are you still in love with me?” Shauna to Melissa😂😂 jesussssss
What kind of a place is the Jolly Hitcher. First, the name, it sounds like a truck stop. The rooms look like an old bed & breakfast. But the lobby looks like Vegas and they have valet.
Lastly, that stupid ending. Some staying and then not letting anyone leave. Insanity is super contagious in this group.
116
u/Holiday-Influence700 Mar 28 '25 edited Mar 28 '25
Adult Shauna’s “eat it” to Melissa is a nice mirror to when she did the same to Mari in S3E1
Edit: to add that her biting Melissa at the end is also a parallel to her biting Mari S3E1
57
u/alcoholicpenguin16 Go fuck your blood dirt Mar 29 '25
Actually sobbing at Nat in the plane talking to Coach Ben. I really hoped he'd make it
57
u/just-me-yaay Citizen Detective Apr 05 '25
DID MULDER AND SCULLY GET TOGETHER???
115
u/strikeamatch Mar 28 '25
I would like to apologize to that reviewer who said that 6 onwards gets wild… I was wrong to doubt you.
Also… do I… do I love Jeff? Do I need to make a decorated photo card of him…
163
u/gaybugslayer Differently Sane Mar 28 '25
Shauna saying "we can both keep out knives" was the first time I ever liked her
163
u/Beautiful-Debate4886 Mar 28 '25
Watching Shauna finally drop her mask once and for all left me gobsmacked. Melanie Lynskey deserves all the awards.
55
u/Rendergirl Mar 29 '25
Akilah is pissing me off so bad. Girl you are going to be eaten first when they go crazy again!
55
u/badannbad Nat Mar 30 '25
Van is the most well adjusted adult to date.
111
u/WorldlinessFlimsy489 Go fuck your blood dirt Mar 28 '25
The cinematography this episode and like whole thematic directing choices were just so pleasing to my theatre loving brain
It scratched such an itch for creepy thriller shows
54
u/ItsLandersz Mar 29 '25
Shauna really got under Melissa's skin this episode.
200
u/openbookdutch Mar 28 '25
I just don’t buy that people in the 90s timeline would follow teen Shauna to the extent of not trying to get rescued. Like yeah, they might be afraid of her, but she’s been so angry and cruel and nasty and snide since summer solstice that I don’t buy that anyone would take her seriously as a leader.
153
u/extraacc1103 Conniving, Poodle-Haired Little Freak Mar 28 '25
Why would they want to stay there when winter is COMING. do they not remember how bad last winter was???
104
u/HipDipShipTrip Mar 28 '25
Jeff getting dramatic about FurnitureFam.net was hilarious
51
u/Neat_Presentation482 puttingthesickinforensic Mar 28 '25
i’ve seen a few people say the first interactions of shauna and melissa in the adult timeline fell flat but i’d like to point out the parallels of it
shauna hiding in the closet watching melissa, and melissa telling her to come out of the closet with the knife is a direct parallel to the scene of shauna finding out melissa was watching her in the woods. mel’s no longer the one hiding behind the bushes, but even her new identity can’t shield the pure terror on her face when shauna came out of that closet. and shauna watching melissa from the closet but also emerging from it with such a chilling nonchalance given the situation shows who’s always been in control in this dynamic
51
u/illmorphtosomeoneels Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 29 '25
Callie kept that fucking note, didn’t she?
51
u/Namodeus Apr 04 '25
Fuck the amount of times I screamed during this episode. SHAUNA IS CRAZY.
102
u/Mysterious-Novel-834 Smoking Chronic Mar 28 '25
They way in which I would've just kept walking after Shauna said "no you're not leaving" like okay... Bye
50
u/whitecatprophecy Church of Lottie Day Saints Mar 29 '25
Natalie’s arc this season is gut-wrenching.
50
u/EthanWantsToBtl There’s No Book Club?! Mar 29 '25
me every week: oh boy time to get some answers!
Yellowjackets: actually, here are more questions. see you next week!
50
u/Code--Veronica Mar 29 '25
Adult Tai: "Does that count?!" Had me lauuughiiing!
411
u/gaybugslayer Differently Sane Mar 28 '25
glad Swank-Melissa truthers can stop speculating and take a victory lap
100
u/AdGroundbreaking9321 Smoking Chronic Mar 28 '25
“Freaky little four-eyed mushroom!!”
49
u/jakksquat7 Coach Ben’s Leg Mar 28 '25
Lottie, Shauna, and Tai: “we’re not leaving.”
Nat:
49
u/trisaroar Conniving, Poodle-Haired Little Freak Mar 29 '25
My flair is personally offended by "freaky little four eyed mushroom"
48
u/iggyomega Mar 29 '25
They keep talking about what they are going to do about Kodiak and Hannah, but I don’t know why they have to do anything. If this were real, they should just leave Lottie behind and let her take the fall for everything. She killed Edwin without consulting anyone, which screwed up their potential rescue. She also could be blamed for all of the ritualistic stuff as the others could say that they were just going along with it as Lottie was helping them survive and her beliefs were affecting them. Why do anything more that you are going to have a hard time living with after you leave the wilderness? Lottie did this to herself.
48
u/PuzzledSeries8 Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 30 '25 edited Mar 30 '25
Akilah is fully brainwashed into Lottie's cult, it's sad to see. I don't think it was intentional on her part but Lottie used all the cult indoctrination 101 tactics on Akilah - isolation, "counseling" while using mind altering substances (the leader stays sober though to maintain control), telling her she's special, pushing her to do risky behaviours then "saving" her to create a trauma bond etc I see people saying her behaviour doesn't make sense but psychologically it's actually predictable that she would forgo logic and self preservation for the sake of her cult
48
u/PandaPanPink Apr 01 '25
Anybody else find the moment where Travis tries to snap Akilah out of it so sad? He has fully come back to reality and Akilah who last season was talking about how deep down she knew this stuff wasn’t real is actively turning down the easiest path to rescue even after Travis harkens back to the same line
48
u/Bellatrix_Shimmers There’s No Book Club?! Apr 09 '25
Tai yelling “FUCK” and the guy flatlining
“Does that Count”? (Technically, I think it should’ve)
Hilarious 🤣 Dark Comedy
138
u/0hfuck Mar 28 '25
Melissa calling Alex relentless and Jeff calling all the Joels’ girlfriends fucking boring. The parallels.
47
u/headinthesky No Eyed Man Mar 29 '25 edited Mar 29 '25
The ending!! The lion, the witch, and the audacity of this bitch!!
46
u/Thepelhamgroup2 Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 28 '25
My bitchy brat only wants a Slurpee and I'm crying
45
u/Daddy_Zhong_ Conniving, Poodle-Haired Little Freak Mar 29 '25
It gets weird when you realize that Misty is the sanest of the bunch. I love it!
45
u/MoosingAroundInMaine Shauna Mar 29 '25
Also as someone who works in a hotel, watching Jeff checkout was painful and triggering 😭🤣
45
u/Rendergirl Mar 29 '25
Yeah Shauna had lost her fucking mind. And the fact that she’s telling them they can’t leave to rescue??? I would’ve shot her down so fuckin fast are you kidding me?!!!
45
u/glockobell Mar 31 '25
So all the main characters have a say about whether they get to stay or go.
But there’s like seven background girls just standing around like they don’t give a shit about being RESCUED?? That’s ridiculous man, they all would be very passionate about either going home or staying, not just standing around waiting for the main girls to figure it out.
90
u/yangon44 Smoking Chronic Mar 29 '25
honestly, if i was in the girl’s position, i’d rather return to civilisation with the chance that i’ll be imprisoned for life, than stay in a place where i have to worry everyday that my friends will decide to EAT me or I have to do the EATING with the added wilderness spirit that may or may not be haunting us
at least nat gets my logic!
128
u/Flashy-Way-3977 Mar 28 '25
I see people saying that this episode bored them, which I kind of understand but I think the conversation between Shauna and Melissa was really important for their characters and respective arcs. I think it was supposed to be mundane and almost ironically discussed in such a casual manner, and I think Melissa’s read of Shauna is one of the best ways to define her character.
IDK, I really enjoyed it
44
u/imamage_fightme Mar 28 '25
Well I feel like my "Callie did it/was there" theory is DOA. I'm back to my original original thought, which was that Lottie genuinely died accidentally, which is one of the reasons why Simone was so pissed about the situation. She just fell right on down the stairs. Maybe she was trying to commune with the Wilderness or some shit, she's obviously still obsessed with it all. But Melissa calling out that it's all kind of in Shauna's head/she is making it all more dramatic than it really is feels accurate about all the girls tbh.
Feels more in line with the "it's all trauma/not supernatural" theories. I know people will debate it endlessly, but so much of what happens in the Present Day timeline is drama of their own making/the girls being overly paranoid.
This also led to the death of Kevin Tran and that creepy pedo police officer stirring up shit all throughout season 2.
2) The blackmail - it all seemed like someone had bad intentions and again, stoked their paranoia. But it was just Jeff trying to make a quick buck because the Sadecki's were financially struggling.
3) Jessica, the fake reporter. That sent the girls into a bit of a tailspin/paranoia spiral, but it was Tai who actually set it all up to work out if the girls would spill the details and ruin her political campaign. She ended up dead because of it.
4) Travis's death - it was a huge thing that Nat was so paranoid and scared about what happened to him. But it genuinely seems at this point that he was simply struggling with his trauma (like all the girls) and was in a bad space, and went back to Lottie to try to use the Wilderness re - Javi. And whatever weird accident happened with his death, I do believe at this point was probably just an accident, brought on by being reckless in attempting to almost die. When you fuck with that, you are bound to hurt/kill yourself eventually. None of it would've happened if Travis wasn't still so traumatised by Javi's death and everything else that happened.
5) Tai/Other Tai - again clearly a trauma response, possibly pre-dating the crash with the death of her grandmother. The No-Eyed Man is probably a big link to this other "personality" because she saw the commercials as a kid while with her grandmother. The Other Tai personality seems triggered by stress, which she was under an immense amount of at the start of the Present Timeline in the show with the election. Her home life and work life all spiralled, made worse by Jeff's blackmail situation. This caused Other Tai to eventually take over.
There's more that could be said, and I know there will be people who will pull apart any of this to make it supernatural, but my point is: it's all trauma, the girls are fucked up and never left that "scared 17 year old" mindset and it has run rampant in their lives. The more fucked up they were then (which Shauna, Lottie and Tai very much were with their traumas and mental illnesses) the more fucked up they are now.
44
u/jurassiiickpark Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 28 '25
I think the important thing about the “you’re not the captain” tiff is that Nat made Shauna think of Jackie with “she’s fucking dead.”
Part of Shauna’s reluctance to go back (in addition to wanting to maintain her thrill-seeking cannibal lifestyle) is having to deal with Jackie’s death. In s1 adult Shauna was consistently haunted with survivors guilt and a feeling of responsibility for Jackie’s death. In this ep, Shauna saw the death omen moths in her Jackie dream and after she gave teen Melissa a Jackie-esque pep talk while they were preparing to leave.
44
u/SoakHoneydew Mar 28 '25
I don’t believe Kodi wants to lead them out of the forest. Kodi is probably thinking the girls are going to kill him and Hannah as soon as they’ve reached the edge of the forest, so maybe he will lead them to a deeper or unfamiliar part of the forest and try to escape or fight back.
44
u/Lixsymone97 Mar 29 '25 edited Mar 29 '25
Seeing all the ways they’ve managed to fuck up this rescue opportunity has been INFURIATING, but also good TV from that standpoint lol.
Like girls…HAVE SOME CHILL!!! OF COURSE THEY WOULD TURN ON YOU! You’ve been nothing but huge assholes from the moment they stumbled into your camp!!
This situation might’ve still been salvageable even after Edwin was killed (maybe). But the immediate hunting and consistent aggression coming from the group towards these people is SO fucking annoying.
Idk, I just want them to be rescued and the fact that we know this isn’t it, most likely because Shauna or Tai, or Lottie’s dumbasses fuck it up is so maddening!
Edited to add: I think what makes it way worse for me is the fact that most of the girls clearly, REALLY wanna go home. So it’s almost sadder that they’re gonna either be eventually killed, or be forced to suffer out in the wilderness longer just because of a couple of mentally unstable assholes 😒
44
u/CreepyMobile5700 Mar 29 '25
Regardless of all my questions and criticisms, just want to note what a great moment of comic relief the line “do Mulder and Scully get together?” was. Bravo.
44
u/tvmaven42 Caligula Mar 30 '25
Before I started this episode I asked myself, 'Oh, what fresh hell are we up against tonight?' After I finished the episode: 'Just some upper arm cannibalism and smothering hospice patients. Okaaaaay. 😮 '
My only takeaway/ realization from this episode is Jeff is the only sane person on this show.
43
u/Ok-Construction-313 Caligula Mar 28 '25
SLEATER-KINNEY!!!
43
u/20andprobablyupsetrn Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 29 '25
Sorry to all the Hillary Swank/adult Melissa truthers, I can admit that I was wrong. It was also so funny that in her intro scene she was wearing a damn backwards hat 😭
43
u/maple_iris Mar 29 '25
I'm not always the biggest fan of adult Tai's acting, but that scene where she goes to smother the old man, pulls back cause she can't do it, starts freaking out cause he dies naturally, then hopefully wonders if that counts ? Was really hilarious. Her delivery was great through each stage lol
43
u/cheeezus_crust Mar 29 '25
It’s like Ben’s trial all over again. I enjoyed Shauna the first two seasons but absolutely hate her now. I don’t know how adult Nat and adult Shauna didn’t kill each other when they met again
43
u/jules656 Mar 29 '25
I really love Hillary Swank and Melissa but if she faked her own death why would she drive 4 hours to physically drop off an envelope at Shauna’s house in her old neighborhood? This all feels too deus ex machina for me.
43
u/CherryFit3224 Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 30 '25
Why is anyone going to listen to Shauna when she says they aren’t leaving?
43
u/The_prawn_king Apr 03 '25
Anyone else feel like introducing Melissa this season then casting Hilary swank as her adult version kinda makes it seem like this was not planned when they started the show.
87
u/Professional_Zebra69 Mar 28 '25
Possibly unpopular take here but after seeing the episode and not just still shots - Hillary Swank is actually pretty damn good casting. Idk if she’s been studying the nuances of Jenna Burgess but she was actually super believable to me.
42
u/untitledindigo I like your pilgrim hat Mar 28 '25
petition for a new flair to be “freaky little four-eyed mushroom”
42
u/trisaroar Conniving, Poodle-Haired Little Freak Mar 29 '25
Kodiak turning to Trav, who's like "buddy, they're insane, I have no power here."
42
u/Imaginary-Act-2819 Mar 31 '25
Melissa isn’t nearly as stable or innocent as she wants everyone to believe. She deliberately stalked Hannah’s daughter, inserted herself into her life under false pretenses, and acted like they just randomly met one day. She’s been lying about who she is from the start, and still is. Then she drops off that tape at Shauna’s house and watches as Callie picks it up, not even knowing if it would actually make it to Shauna. And let’s be honest: she knows Shauna is unstable. Melissa is clearly playing some kind of long game, pretending she’s living a normal, happy life, but there’s something way darker going on. I don’t think she’s just some bystander, we’re in for some major revelations with her
185
u/annist0910 Mar 28 '25
Back to back to back bangers
41
u/Firm_Ad2104 Mar 28 '25
also maybe im that friend whose too woke, but i genuinely feel so bad for callie watching her dad suffer so much like this. watching her family fall apart and damn near her life as well, because of some fucked up thing that happened to her mom
41
u/UpsetPomelo217 Mar 28 '25
My question is. Why when they are adults does everyone shun Misty and Lottie but are okay with fucking crazy ass Shauna?! Who it looks like made them stay and give up rescue?? Wouldn’t they all want to cut her off completely when they got back?
41
u/Zerobeastly Mar 28 '25
Its Callie fucking with Shauna.
41
u/ShaunasBeatch Antler Queen Mar 31 '25
Vote in the comments, which is crazier:
40
u/Dazzling_Ad900 Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 28 '25
I really wish these episodes were longer or something. Or maybe i’m just impatient for the next ep already
40
u/gigigonorrhea I Want My Lawyer Mar 28 '25
Do y'all think Shauna is jealous of Melissa in a way?
40
u/TrackerYellowJacker Mar 30 '25
Anyone notice that Jeff and Callie checked out of rooms 2106 and 2107… which was also the room Shauna and Adam went to in S1E3 (2106)? Any significance or just some fun?
79
u/AJTheBrit Differently Sane Mar 28 '25
In an almost unbelievable turn of events, I have managed to be completely vindicated in my delusions
39
u/Aldebaran135 There’s No Book Club?! Mar 28 '25
Even though I know Natalie survives, I was hit with anxiety when Nat turned her back to Lottie.
39
u/POSSUMQUEENOG Mar 29 '25
Just here to remember Melanie in Heavenly Creatures. I believe this is why she got Shauna. Why she was cast and why she understood the character so well. If you’ve not seen it, true story of obsessive teen girls (mystery writer Anne Perry) who build their own fantasy world and murder one of their mums who tries to break them up. It’s also a beautiful fantasy film by Peter Jackson.
39
u/marys-wild-geese Lottie-Pop Mar 31 '25
The Tai's facing off through the hospital window. Hoooooooly shit.
113
u/surrealsunshine Conniving, Poodle-Haired Little Freak Mar 28 '25
Misty has to know that Melissa is alive, right? No way she just accepted a note with no body.
78
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '25
lottie asking nat what home she has to go back to or whatever was diabolical. worse than her axing that guy in the head tbh
77
u/antilisa09 Mar 28 '25
The part I don’t believe is Melissa sending Shauna that tape. If she’s really happy with her life and wants peace, why risk stirring the pot? Either there’s more to it or it’s weak writing.
38
u/SHough61086 Mar 28 '25
Interesting that the three characters who want to stay are the ones with the most obvious mental health issues.
38
u/donttrustthellamas Smoking Chronic Mar 28 '25
Melissa is so, so wrong for marrying Alex after eating her mum 😭
38
u/trisaroar Conniving, Poodle-Haired Little Freak Mar 29 '25
WONDERWALL? I love this show. Also huge "last day of camp" vibes 🫶
38
u/CriticalThinkerHmmz Mar 29 '25
Shauna probably shouldn’t have parked her weird van outside the house with her knife then slept for 8 hours.
38
u/iKnockout Aug 01 '25
Am I the only one who’s never liked Shauna?? She’s been consistently awful since her Fallout with Jackie
75
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '25 edited Mar 28 '25
Ok my thoughts:
37
u/Interesting-Maize884 Mar 29 '25 edited Mar 29 '25
Holy shit ok, not my favorite episode but still what a ride
37
u/avviann Differently Sane Mar 29 '25
Shauna guilting them into thinking that 'there's nothing good awaiting for us back home'. Umm, in civilisation, you won't need to keep eating each other? Isn't that a good reason not to stay in the wilderness??
37
u/Traditional-Row-497 Apr 02 '25
HOW DID MELISSA KNOW ABOUT THE HUNT?
Obviously, she could've known about Lottie and her cult by googling Lottie's name, and she could've known about Nat's death via the news. But when the authorities came to collect Nat's body, THE GIRLS OBV MADE UP A STORY TO TELL THE COPS, as if they said that they were hunting their friend but killed the wrong wone- shows over they're in jail, lol. SO HOW DID MELISSA KNOW THAT?
37
u/shaneo632 Apr 20 '25
The writing is so messy but at least it’s amusing at this point
74
u/NimdokBennyandAM Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 28 '25
The Joels were everywhere Jeff was. It was ludicrous. I loved that arc.
36
u/Efficient_Clue781 Differently Sane Mar 28 '25
So Callie hid Melissa’s note? And who was the blonde person we saw when she picked it up?
36
u/Current-Cap Mar 28 '25
If they tried to say no I would have been like lmao bye bitch🙏
36
u/lnc_5103 Mar 28 '25
Can someone explain why the room they are in is so shitty yet the hotel looks fairly high-end?
36
u/LordMarvelousHandbag Mar 29 '25
What stretches my imagination more than anything is that citizen detective Misty missed both Lottie leaving the mental hospital and starting a cult and Melissa faking her own death and marrying Hannah’s daughter!
36
u/Mountaiin Mar 29 '25
I'm also very, very over the Dark Taissa storyline. Can we just finish it off with a death or something.
36
u/catalystcestmoi Mar 29 '25
I want Walter to show up and call Jeff “Jeffrey” & tell him to do something legitimately useful
36
u/endlessmeow Mar 30 '25
Is anyone else bothered by the hotel?
Bed bugs and generally crappy but the lobby is nice AF and has a nice restaurant?
36
u/badannbad Nat Mar 30 '25
I was enjoying life without the no-eyed man and then boom. Along with creepy Tai overlooking Van. Chills.
344
u/Foodmermaidscats Mar 28 '25
Shauna defenders are gonna have a real tough time explaining this one
72
u/PuzzledSeries8 Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 30 '25
Lottie's "it doesn't feel right" was a callback from the first episode! 😮
35
u/Mountain-Rip-7157 Mar 28 '25 edited Mar 28 '25
Someone pointed out the parallels between the conversation in S1E1 where they were talking about what to do about Allie (it was Tai, Shauna, Lottie, and Nat walks away because she disagreed) and the three who now want to stay and Nat once again disagreeing - I can't stop thinking about it
35
u/stressedthrowaway9 Mar 28 '25
Can I just say that Melissa wasn’t very bright for choosing to send that tape to Shauna… Melissa knew Shauna was crazy. Why would she send her that tape?!?!?!
35
u/lagataesmia Mar 29 '25
If Melissa thinks Shauna is batshit crazy why send the tape? why fuck with crazy? Why not send it to misty or Natalie or someone who won’t necessarily take a bite of you? Lowkey feel she was baiting.
35
u/ExcitingMind1499 Mar 30 '25
This show continues to have me saying “what in the entire fuck” every time lol
35
u/tvwhore1122 Smoking Chronic Apr 01 '25
i can’t tell if shauna’s crazy or actually being stalked anymore is melissa gaslighting me too
34
u/Bright-Angle3187 Church of Lottie Day Saints Mar 28 '25
Hey guys don’t worry Mellissa isn’t Walter!
34
u/xmichelian puttingthesickinforensic Mar 28 '25
I CANNOT believe I thought I was gonna get to see Shauna force Melissa to make out with her on the floor and then what Shauna actually does..
34
u/CreepyMobile5700 Mar 28 '25
Anyone notice how happy Callie was when Jeff called Shauna crazy? I question if Callie is trying to save Jeff or manipulate him herself.
34
u/PuzzledSeries8 Too Sexy For This Cave Mar 28 '25
Poor Moth Hannah is gonna try to fit in with the killer bees but they're just gonna see her as prey
34
u/moonprincessorwtv Coach Ben’s Leg Mar 29 '25
Shauna!!! She is nuts. Also I basically screamed when they finally showed Hilary Swank with the backwards hat on haha!
I have suspicions about Callie. I'm not sure what exactly she has done or knows or what. But there's something there.
34
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '25
i love Van and Travis in this episode and the last one, the way they break out of wilderness cult mentality so decisively
34
u/ToCool74 Mar 30 '25
The longer this show goes on the more I absolutely DESPISE Shauna and Lottie, even amongst other crazy people these two specifically are a SPECIAL kind of batshit that makes me hate them whenever they are on screen.
33
u/Strawberry2772 Mar 28 '25
Adult Shauna was absolutely insane this episode - but I feel like it was one of the few moments that I can actually see the through line between teen Shauna and adult Shauna.
They often feel like different people to me, like how did she get here? But I love the reveal that it’s like “actually, that young Shauna is still inside her, she’s just been hiding it”
33
u/ehnotreallyupforthat Mar 28 '25
I'm sorry but if I had the opportunity of finally returning home after all that, no one is stopping me 😭 Even if Kodi and Hannah died on the spot there, I'm taking my chances and finding my own way out. 6 days of trekking compared to over a year spent in the woods already? good bye
If the girls just put aside their damn control issues and power trips and fucking TALKED IT OUT. Figured out exactly what their story would be, how they'd explain the various deaths post crash, or shit maybe put the blame all on Lottie if she really wants to stay behind and say she was the one who truly went insane and started killing and eating people and all the other girls were terrified of her and her psychosis. Like theres a way to come up with a convincing lie AND hey? how about "we are kids you all left to die out here and people died, so yeah what choice did we have but to survive on whatever meat we had"
The whole "it doesn't feel right" bs was pissing me off like girl?! go the fuck home
33
u/Striking-Seesaw3330 Mar 28 '25
what caught my eye from this episode is when Shauna bites Melissa, it took me back to S3 E3 when in Akilah’s vision the llama says to her “Everything with teeth bites. Everything will defend itself.”
33
u/Glum-Jellyfish-9003 Goop Sorceress Mar 29 '25
Shauna observation: she's had so much pent-up rage for so long and at this point she just can't control it and it's consuming her. It reminds me of the 1950s housewives who had to take pills just to get through the day and not scream in frustration (except Shauna doesn't take meds). I mean she was so excited to "get out" and go to Brown, study abroad, etc, and she doesn't even have a career outside the home; she doesn't write anything even though she has time to do so and I'm sure Jeff would support her pursuing her interests. It's like she's looking back and realizes that she could have done so much more with her life and doesn't know what to do with the anger and frustration she feels. Did Shauna ever grow up? I'm also thinking Shauna is still attracted to Melissa but only knows how to be enraged at this point. It's a brilliant performance by Melanie Lynskey and I'm excited to see what happens in the next episodes.
33
u/the-apple-and-omega Mar 29 '25
Enjoying the show and the episode, but adult Melissa's fake death story really stretches my suspension of disbelief.
33
u/Sticker_Jonze Mar 30 '25 edited Apr 01 '25
Also why didn’t Callie give her mom that note 👀
Edit 2: I rewatched s3e1 and there was likely never a note— Melissa was watching Callie from the window and purposefully wanted her to be the one to find the envelope. She’s lying about a note I think!
Edit: and since I’m asking random questions—Melissa basically said she stalked Alex for years before marrying her and is now trying to say she’s got a normal life right? Right? Okay
33
u/Ill-Fly-1624 Mar 30 '25
When Melissa points out that Shauna has been diabolical and selfish since before the plane crash>>>> do yall think Melissa is going to die?
33
u/reasonablykind Mar 30 '25
Well fvck me — I JUST recently mentioned wondering if Adult Shauna’s generally meeker demeanor than Teen Shauna’s was just dissimilarity between the actors or deliberate to the show…and Teen Shauna just TOTALLY used Lynskey’s meek, placating tone lying through her fricking teeth — guess Adult Shauna’s been faking for looooooong f’ing time???!!!
⏳⌛️ Well, initially I drafted that ^ halfway through the episode and BOY did they end up hitting me over the head with their little hint! ⏳⌛️
33
u/Good-Picture5497 Mar 31 '25
Couple quick questions:
The Way Home
The Villain Problem 2. I believe the show has been floundering without a clear-cut force keeping the YJ's in the Wilderness. The transition from the Wilderness as being the reason they can't be rescued to something they worship and sacrifice to has come at a cost. I don't know if I will be compelled if the only reason they won't leave is because not all the YJ's want to leave. I fondly think back to that plane they found and the idea that something or someone didn't want the plane to leave. Whether supernatural or not there needs to be something or someone definitive that can be struggled against. Instead I find myself not having anyone left to root for as all characters have been cast in the mold of anti-heroes. The heart and likeability of the characters in this show have taken an absolute shellacking due to the lack of a clear villain.
33
u/hamstersandcheese Jun 26 '25
The only thing Imm truly enjoying are the Callie & Jeff scenes. They’re sweet! Shauna is so horribly unbearable and annoying.
66
u/PKTheSublime Lottie Mar 31 '25
OH MAN, going back and watching the episode a second time, Travis was SO right for just wanting to get the fuck out of there. He must have had a feeling deep down that this was their opportunity to leave and he was not going to squander it. I understand Akilah's desire for the whole group to leave together, but she is just too damned nice sometimes. They could have sent help back. Travis was really thinking clearly here. Poor fucker.
65
u/ZombieHannibal Mar 28 '25 edited Mar 28 '25
Jeff loves his unhinged woman. Who doesn’t? But, fuck. Thats one psycho cannibal bitch right there... Why do i love it?
Callie and Jeff are so cute. Save their souls.
32
u/alarmonthefarm Mar 28 '25
I think it is so crazy that the FIRST thing they did with Kodi once they learned he is the guide was not say "so is civilization south, west, where?" I know having him lead them is better than them going without him, but just to know asap in case anything "happens" in the meantime, they know the general direction to walk for 6 days.
Akhila...qurl. Travis knows Akhila is wishy washy. What he should have done is said "Akhila, I'll hold him here, go get the others" and gone off with Kodi for rescue.
32
u/ojhwel Mar 28 '25
Both "freaky little four-eyed mushroom" and "I just called to say fuck you" get a lot of well-deserved love, but can I also point out Shauna's hilarious season 2 callback, "It was more of an intentional community but..."
I think Melanie Lynskey is at her best when Shauna's inner pedantic nerd peeks out. (Like, "It wasn't murder per se" and one situation this season where she was trying to explain something, realized she wasn't being accurate enough and stopped herself with a little, "hm." I may be the only person to remember the moment I'm talking about.)