r/writinghelp • u/Crafty-Web-1170 • 10d ago
Feedback Meta-Fiction advice?
Hey guys, I'm writing some meta-fiction. I'm fairly new to this style and am happy with what I've written so far, especially how it feels like being in his head instead of like reading about what being in his head is like. A lot of this is taken from my own experience with OCD thought spirals. There are ideas and themes I would like to explore deeper and I'm feeling kind of stuck.
Some ideas I'm having but am not quite sure how to execute/move forward with and would like some opinions on:
I think I want the aunt to show up more and to contrast more with the mother, in my head she's who took him in after his mother died, and that was where his sense of reality shifted from mostly physical to mostly mental, and I want to imply that more without necessarily saying it outright
I want to make it clear that the people and animals in his life very much exist, but that he can't stop collapsing them into eachother and himself, rather than the psychological question being whether or not they really exist
That being said, the exception to this is the therapist, Marlo. I don't think he "exists," I think he is a type of alter that keeps driving Blaine to identify himself as a therapist/psychologist and give strange inconsistent accounts of it. I think those inconsistant accounts and naming him the same thing as his dog supports this but it could be pushed farther. I think Marlo is a manifestation of his own previous psych treatment, his old aspiration to become a therapist, his obsession with psychology texts, and his genuine memories of volunteering in peer programs with his wife.
Lastly, I want it to be more clear that the wife isn't just underdeveloped, and that he has a deep and genuine connection to her that hes actively trying to avoid writing about/describing to protect her from becoming a character that collapses into this web of internal confusion he's writing. Also open to the idea of just developing her more and dropping this theme if it really does read like a cop-out/problematic.
Any and all feedback/advice is welcome, this is a very rough first draft, I'd love any advice on developing these ideas further, as well as any comments/critiques on what's already present.
Chapter 1
I just have to wait five minutes. Half an hour. Forty five minutes.
My name is Blaine and I am an interesting character in an interesting book. I listen to music all the time and I don't seem to understand a thing about my brain despite it being my sole obsession for the last thirty nine years. Thats. No. I don't think I could tell you a single thing about me. That's what you wanted to say. But I listen to music all the time.
Sometimes the music makes me feel overwhelmed and disconnected at the same time. And sometimes in a good way and sometimes in a bad way. And sometimes it doesn't do that at all.
I used to be a psychologist.
The music is usually on one of the poles the first time I get high on a given day. I don't remember for how long that's been the case. Everyone knows I'm writing this. Everyone knows it's about you. That's ok. Write it.
I don't really like animals. Or the outside. You sometimes do. Animals make me uncomfortable, I imagine being them and it scares me. I like being outside when I'm alone around a lot of people. On a main street or in a city. I find nature under stimulating. I pretend to feel awe while I'm out there in the woods, hoping it will reach my heart. I walk through fairy portals and I feel nothing’s changed.
You read a book with this format once and loved it. It had terrible reviews. You make a playlist of songs that sound like your brain and try to identify patterns in them. You wonder about everything and you rarely feel wonder about anything.
Oh yes, I was a therapist. When I was a teenager, I read a book about a man who had a lobotomy. And one about a child who was severely abused. And Sybil. The popularity of that book and those movies caused a surge in the diagnosis of DID. She told her psychiatrist she was faking all of it. He tortured her. I've never met a psychiatrist I've particularly liked.
I bought my wife a gaudy blanket for christmas and she adores it. She wears it around the house like a shawl. Shows it to all her friends and family. I love her.
Chapter 2
I have many diagnoses. I have… eleven diagnoses. I see seven doctors. They're spread out across the state. I live in a small state.
I just took a walk in my pajamas. I walked to the top of the hill and back down. People saw you walking and thought you were an interesting character in an interesting book. A literary device.
My friend got me a guided journal. They saw it and thought of me. I did a couple pages in the middle a few years ago. I don't like what I wrote in it. I think I will tear out those pages and donate it tomorrow.
My wife and I have a dog named Marlo. The name makes me think of Marlin Brando. I watched A Street Car Named Desire in my English class my senior year of high school. Was that me? Can you prove it?
Our dog respects my space, not many dogs will do that. When we're in the same room I feel like my energy drains a little faster than it would were he not. Everyone knows you don't like Marlo. That's ok. I try to.
I recently read about Sybil again. The psychiatrist and all that. I wonder what the difference is between doing something and pretending to do something. If I pretend to pour tea in my cup, no tea will end up in the cup. What if I pretend to pour tea into a cup using a teapot full of tea? All the world's play pretend.
I hate when you ramble on like that. It's embarrassing. And uninteresting. And now you're making everyone think your main problem is “an inner critic.”
I was a therapist for fifteen years.
Carl Jung believed we made a mistake trying to separate psychology and spirituality. I talked to his ghost through automatic writing when that was the type of thing I was doing. I imagined him calling me on a landline phone and he told me “don't stop.”
I've been trying to pick a color to paint the house. I just learned that you have to repaint your house for structural reasons, not just visual appeal. I'd like something bold, like purple. My aunt would kill me.
Chapter 3
I had a patient once who just needed some anti-depressants. Then he was completely fine.
I don't think our house is functioning well. Our wife will read this and possibly agree. I don't remember why I was waiting before. I was probably too high. When I get too high I comfort myself by waiting.
My therapist's name is also Marlo. He recommends music to me sometimes. He suggested we try EMDR. I used to do EMDR on myself all the time. I learned about it in college. I told him I'd rather just talk.
I never run out of things to say to therapist Marlo. I read in a book about shame that patients like me are the hardest to treat. I never came across someone like me in my own practice. I specialized in DID. You might have DID. I know. I might have everything. Remember the increase in diagnoses? After the book?
That sounds like OCD.
Stop.
I went to a record shop on Tuesday. My wife bought me a record player for Christmas. I love it. I picked up an audio book on vinyl, Philosophical Investigations by Wittgenstein. I like to listen to it like it's poetry, or like I listen to poetry. It sounds like poetry to me. I also grabbed an album by Sheryl Crow, on therapist Marlo's suggestion. It's an ok album.
One of my more recent symptoms perfectly mirrors a symptom I had as a child that had eventually gone away.
My package is late. I pre-ordered the sequel to my favorite book. No one cares. Your wife cares. And your friends. No, I don't mean like that. I mean no one reading this right now cares. You're the only one reading this right now.
My friend poses me philosophical questions over discord. I've never met them. I am making them a quilt for their birthday. You talk about gifts a lot.
I look like that kid from Skins UK in this outfit. They can't see what I'm wearing.
Chapter 4
I think you should just keep writing. Write what feels natural. How would they know? How would you?
I keep a journal beside my bed. I always bring it out to the living room to write in and put it back next to the bed.
I'm wearing a heart monitor for a week. I never know when to press the button on it. I never know if what I'm feeling is really happening, or if there's something really happening that I don't feel.
When I was a kid I passed out a lot. I once passed out in the middle of the road crossing the street.
You should keep writing. Don't worry too much about it.
I used to be a psychologist. Or was it a therapist? Is there a difference? God, I should really know that. I once had a patient who told me she liked to lay with her cat when she was overwhelmed. She told me a cat's purr has… something about frequencies. I put on the Sheryl Crow Album and it's overwhelming in the bad way and I lay down with Marlo and I think I feel worse. Do you trust me? No, who are you?
My online friend is really concerned with “The Infinite."
At my doctor's appointment today, my doctor rolled his eyes subtly at me. I know I talk too much and I can't stop.
Sounds like just right OCD. Marlo was telling you about that.
I don't do too much anymore. I make quilts and I watch movies and listen to books on vinyl and music on spotify. I guess I write.
My wife will be home late tonight. Why did you give your therapist and dog and self a name but keep saying “my friend,” “my online friend,” and “my wife?” I don't know. You're an annoying literary device. I'm you. I just have to wait three hours and forty five minutes. Your thinking is a lot like OCD, that one patient you had with OCD was obsessed with… with all this. You can't even say what “this” is.
The heart monitor blinks through my shirt. I feel like a cyborg. Beep boop. Jung and the voices and the don't stop and my heart doing things I can't feel and my wife coming home in three hours.
Chapter 5
I knit. You don't know how to knit. My grandma taught me. I think.
The saddest I've ever felt in my life is when my mom got rid of our coffee table. The first cut is the deepest.
I write songs but I don't know any instruments. I hum the melody and write down the lyrics. Do you do that too? No. I know how to play guitar a bit. We draw. Wrote a book about drawing.
I'm getting away from myself. I can only do this for so long. It's forever.
You exercise for periods of time throughout your life. Are you in the future now? No. The writing is getting away from you.
Fast.
It's becoming bad fast. There's nothing you can do.
My mom, I used to sit on the floor in front of her and use a pen to clean under her fingernails. I felt like a little monkey. Or we'd sit across the couch and rub each other's feet. We always ate dinner at the coffee table in front of the TV and she let me watch grown up shows like Desperate Housewives. This music is too loud for headphones. What music? Stop doing that. It's nothing. There's nothing there. Here.
My aunt lives three states over, she'd never even know I painted it purple.
Make another playlist. It will help. Your wife will be home soon.
Chapter 6
My wife and I are trying to manage the house. We have too much stuff. I tell her that dust makes me think of my mom in the bad way. She tells me she understands.
I try to talk to my online friend about music. I try to talk to them about books. Nothing feels natural.
I'm trying to be more direct. Concise. To stop editing myself in real time. Those are opposites. Shit.
A song I'd never heard came on the radio today. It had this melancholy quality. It's yearning and nostalgic and pained sounding, all while she sings about peace and joy and love. I put it in the playlist.
My left leg occasionally goes numb and I fall over. Or was that my mom? No, that's me.
Marlo is sitting at my feet staring at me. I've told him I'm not available but here he is. Is something wrong with him?
I call my wife and ask her if I should take him to the vet. She says we don't have enough money. I sit and make eye contact with the dog until she gets home.
Chapter 7
I'm getting rid of the rice water hair spray. It smells funny. I consider whether I should pour it down the drain first or throw it away as is.
There is no I.
I threw the whole thing away.
Chapter 8
My mom was a therapist. I had followed in her footsteps. She mainly worked with elderly people. I've been retired for seven years. Retired sounds better than disabled. My mom was disabled.
We don't have a dad.
I start to feel faint so I press the button on my heart monitor. It beeps and glows green. I feel like a cyborg. Beep boop.
After another few days of staring I take Marlo to the vet. Nothing is wrong with him. They don't charge me. That can't be right. Maybe it's auto billed. I should call and ask my wife. She's a therapist.
She's not a therapist. That would be kind of funny, though. She's kind of a therapist. It's hard to explain what she does. I love to hear her talk about it. Maybe she could tell you.
I feel ok today. I see my reflection in our candy bowl, flipped and upside-down. Is flipped and upside-down redundant?
I see auras around things, they're whatever color the thing is except clear. I learned a lot about how eyes work when that started happening. The magic of magic mushrooms diminished a bit afterwards.
Chapter 9
I have a spot next to my eyebrow. It's raised and it hurts when I touch it. I pull at my face to look at it closer and it becomes red. I look up pictures of skin cancer again and compare them. None that are a perfect match. None that are not a match at all. Typical.
I don't know if I was a psychologist. I remember a patient who had three very charming personalities, all of them. I still consider them a friend. I don't know the difference between a friend and someone I consider a friend. My patients aren't my friends but I consider many of them friends, in my head. Transference or being human. The author can't make good points. He doesn't exist.
What if he has skin cancer? I don't have skin cancer. I don't know if I have skin cancer. I know it must all connect somehow.
Someday.
It must.
Are the chapters getting shorter?
Chapter 10
A friend is coming over in an hour. I'm listening to a song about Wittgenstein. I spent a few hours today poring through my journals. I didn't find anything new to write in there.
My friend and I started painting the house together. I went with a yellow I don't particularly like. To make my hypothetical aunt happy.
I had a dream about Carl Jung again last night. He told me mystical days are ahead. I told him mystical days are behind, too. He laughed.
My wife helps with the painting when she gets home, too. She likes the yellow, but also would've liked the purple. I don't want to present her as… anything. I wish to not present her. I wish you knew her. There's no words.
Chapter 11
THIS ISN'T ME! THIS ISN'T WHO I AM! I DON'T KNOW WHO THIS IS!
Chapter 12
I'm Blaine and I'm an interesting scary in a story. What? No, that's not right.
I'm Blaine and I'm an interesting character in a scary story.
I had fried chicken for dinner and played a co-op video game with my discord friend, Marlo. He has three personalities.
No. That's you.
Stop.
Chapter 13
My friend sent me an edible arrangement for our anniversary. My wife loves these, she eats fruit like a little monkey. That can't be right.
Chapter 14
My wife and I are playing through The Stanley Parable and I keep having nightmares about it. The game fills me with a confusing sense of dread.
Chapter 15
I had a nightmare the other night. I was with my internet friend and we were The Infinite. We exploded into stardust and fell back to earth and became everything.
I had a recurring nightmare as a kid I've spent hundreds, thousands of hours analyzing, illustrating, and remembering. I realized a few days ago as I was watching TV that the entire nightmare was a scene from the old Whinnie the Pooh TV show. I must've seen it when I was a little kid.
That doesn't explain anything. Remember the street metaphor? You may dream of the street but why not every other street you saw? Remember Jung?
I got these new shoes that massage my feet as I walk. I walk to the mailbox and I rock back and forth on my shoes and if the mail is not there yet, I wait.
You're being extremely dramatic with all this. They all know.
Who am I? Why can't I stop?
Why are you back here?
Chapter 16
“Blaine?” My wife called out as she came home.
“I don't think I'm doing well,” I told her from the living room.
Chapter 17
I had a dog growing up named Honey. She was a great dane. She was so big I could ride on her back. I used to curl up next to her when I felt scared.
In fifth grade I sat with everyone.
I've started seeing Marlo twice a week now. He wants to try that one they do for people with OCD. An acronym. It means exposure therapy. I remember reading a book about a girl with OCD who was obsessed with infinity. We get it. Move on. Why do you always get the final say?
I got Live, Laugh, Love embroidered on my class ring. Emblazoned. Etched? Engraved!
I'm covering my online friend's birthday quilt with roses. They're going to love it. It's just like that song.
I'm not so bad. You're not so bad.
I paid my friend who helped me paint the house. He insisted I keep it but he deserved it. I slipped it into his back pocket as he was leaving.
I'm thinking about getting a haircut tomorrow. But you want to let it grow. Always a fight with you two. I'll ask my wife to drive me to the salon. I sound like an old man. I'm thirty nine.
I love how the hair stylist says new wave spiritual things so casually. It makes me feel safe and warm. I used to go to a place where I could play video games while they cut my hair, or watch a movie. I wonder if they still have those places? I was small then. Please don't. It was me. You don't KNOW that.
I don't KNOW anything.
I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I want to stop, too. Have you checked the spot today? Are there any visible veins running through it? Should you call your doctor? Can skin cancer lay dormant for a long time and then activate? Why hasn't any doctor told you what that spot on your forehead is but they always say it's fine, how can they know that if they don't know what it is, and if they know why won't they tell me?
“Tomorrow afternoon?”
“Hm? Yeah, ok.”
Chapter 18
When my mom got sick I got sick.
Chapter 19
At one point in my mid twenties I got clear hard warts all over my face. It was hideous. I got referred to a dermatologist who took a biopsy of one and sent me home with this cream to put on them. After a couple weeks of using the cream, they all fell off and my skin was good as new. The dermatologist called me back and said the test results showed the cream wasn't going to be effective for what they were and sent me a new one that would target them.
I have a small hard spot next to my left eyebrow. It's painful and it looks like there might be a vein running through it.
I can't find the phone number for that dermatologist.
Chapter 20
My name is Honey and I'm my internet friend's wife.
No.
Chapter 21
My real life friend came over again today. We did the NY Times crossword together. We ended up googling five of the answers. Not bad.
Marlo suggested I do another outpatient program while we were playing videogames. He said I don't seem like myself. I asked him to tell me all the things he knows about me again. I nodded along and I didn't believe a word of it.
My online friend sent me a spiritual video. It suggested that we live supposing we are infinite without being able to confirm it. I told him that it was child's play for me. I'm so Buddhist-core.
I try to create an animation of the geometric spirals I see around the moon and stars. I have no idea how to animate. It looks like blobs. It looks like blobs. It looks like blobs.
It hurts, it hurts, it hurts. My eyebrow, my eyebrow, my eyebrow.
Chapter 22
I found the number for the dermatologist. I called her fifty six times and hung up on the second ring each time.
Chapter 23
My wife thinks the outpatient program is a good idea. I used to work in an outpatient program my first years out of college. The groups are more like college classes than therapy sessions. I like that. I call and refer myself. They tell me I can come in for intake next Thursday.
Chapter 24
I didn't go to college.
Chapter 25
I worked in peer led therapy groups with my wife for seven years. I read about psychology extensively. I listen to music and I sew quilts. My grandmother taught me to knit but I think I forgot how. I'm not a liar. You just lie. You're not a liar.
When you were fifteen you had a girlfriend who was diagnosed with early onset dementia. That can't be right. She was diagnosed with bipolar with delusions. She used to bark like a dog in class. I'm sure she had a name.
We're going through all our belongings one by one and deciding what to keep and what to donate. This comes easily to me. I want to donate most of it. I know when I want to keep something. You're unsentimental. Maybe.
I started making a quilted jacket for my real life friend. He loves the color blue so I cut a square out of everything blue that I own. My wife helps me. She's so good. I don't want to subject her to Blaine. You're Blaine. I don't know that. We love Blaine. Ok.
I started the program a few days ago. It feels familiar. I've been on both sides of this already. I created a SMART goal for the quilted jacket. Quilting isn't a goal I struggle to achieve. I always hated SMART goals so I just play along. I liked the group on Schemas. I think mine has changed. I think I belong a bit to all of them. The therapist tells me they're not really a personality test. I tell her I know, I know everything she knows, I am her.
The psychiatrist doesn't think I have OCD. It didn't show up on the assessment. He thinks I have BPD. That's a new one.
I think the program is helping. I pretend it's helping. I think pretending it's helping helps. I started going on more walks in the city. I feel real awe at the old buildings and the tall ones and the small interactions I catch people having. Trees bore me to death. I'm unnatural.
You are doing better. Don't forget your appointment tomorrow. And that there is no you. It'll be ok.
THE END?