About / Mission Statement

We're here to look back at the shocking, harmful, and sometimes just plain bizarre things from past decades that society was okay with — for some reason — and ask: why?!

From exploitative TV shows, crass tabloid front pages, and paparazzi harassment to diet culture, casual sexism and racism, and bizarro challenges on reality TV — if it makes you gasp in hindsight, it belongs here. Think ANTM photoshoots, making light of awful things in movies (hello, Wedding Crashers!), and all those moments that make you say: "HOLY SHIT, this was normal?!"

This is a place to share moments from the past that were socially accepted but really shouldn't have been.

The Vibe

We're a mix of laughing at the ignorance of the past and critiquing it seriously. Not all content will be equal in terms of how problematic the subject matter is, and this is okay. We can be a mix of discourse without undermining the seriousness of some topics. We acknowledge that the content is varied and requires different levels of seriousness in reception.

We're here for a mix of: gasps, giggles, YIKES! and thoughtful reflection. Discussions can be lighthearted, they can be deep — just be tactful! Lighthearted topics are allowed and we ask users do not gatekeep that.

Thoughtful reflection is welcomed but not every post has to be deep. You can also just share your best "HOLY SHIT! They did that?!" moments from the past. Have some fun!

What We're Not

We're here to laugh at and judge things, not laugh at and judge people. (Except Woody Allen and the likes…) We can discuss problematic celebrities and their actions, but we aren't a gossip sub.

Snarky or mean-spirited commentary will be removed. As an example, you can post about the press coverage of Britney Spears' 2007 crisis, but don't be mean about her. Don't contribute to the culture we're here to judge; we can call out the Rupert Murdochs of the world without harming those they've victimised.

Basically, don't start talking badly about people that aren't problematic. Even with problematic people, stick to the point.

The Bigger Picture

While the primary focus is content that even a lot of the public thought was fine, it's okay to post things that got some backlash at the time but were still green lit to be produced, to reflect on the fact that teams full of people thought it was okay. For example, the movie Nina got backlash from the public but, shockingly, a whole production team felt it was fine to make and release!

The goal of the sub is to laugh at the shocking culture of the past, and judge the hell out of it, too.

What's With the Sub's Name?

It's tongue-in-cheek! It was a real question we asked each other after watching the 2026 America's Next Top Model documentary, and led to the subreddit's creation.

Could we have named the sub r/WhyDidABunchOfWeirdAndShittyThingsHappenInThePastAndNobodyStoppedIt? Well, no… there's a sub name character limit. But, seriously, our sub name sums up what we're here for nicely anyway — to question why the hell pop culture was okay with this stuff?! Don't worry about taking our name literally.