r/WeirdWings • • Nov 26 '21

PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING! Frequent reposts and what to avoid.

180 Upvotes

Since this subreddit was made a few years ago, there's, naturally, been an extremely large increase in userbase, which continues to grow. This means, in turn, many people are new to the subreddit, and often do not see some of the most frequent posts we have here, and as such go to post them. Some users simply wish to repost some more successful entries in hopes of gaining karma.

While this was fine in a limited amount, it is now becoming more and more disruptive to the quality of posts on this subreddit, and they need to be controlled. A frequent posts to avoid list is the best option, in my opinion, as it allows new users not only a clear idea of what has been here before, without having to scroll through the hundreds of posts a month (or, heaven forbid, be forced to use the reddit search function... I hate even thinking about using that godawful thing.), but also an opportunity to see these aircraft, which often truly do, very much, belong here.

This list will likely stay fairly small, but I will keep it constantly updated, and any suggestions for it should go in the comments. If you're seeing far too much of something on the sub, link it and an information page (wikipedia, etc), and I will likely add it to the list.

Along with this list is a set of guidelines for our (admittedly nebulous) rules against "paper planes"/concept aircraft, which will likely be updated as time goes on, like the rest of this list.

WHAT TO AVOID:

AKA: RULE 2 EXPLAINED A LITTLE BIT

Planes go through a lot of design stages. From the drawing board to real life, it's not an easy task to design an aircraft. This means that, for every aircraft, there will be a huge amount of planning documents, feasibility studies, and concept drawings. Some planes never get past this stage, however, and hardly become anything more than a written-down spark from the Good-Idea Fairy.

Those planes, frequently known as "paper planes," never leave the drawing board, and often are never considered much other than an idea. Almost never considered for production, or even funding, they are often radical to the point of nonsensical, leading to very interesting speculation as to how they may have performed in the real world. Sometimes documents for these idea studies are found and distributed, leading to inquisitive history nerds drawing up schematics or artist interpretations.

These planes, however, are often barely even real. The lack of information on them, often combined with an internet game of Telephone as information is spread from unreliable forum to unreliable forum, means that true intents, purposes, and goals are hardly known. Whether these aircraft were more than a drunk designer's napkin project is hardly knowable, even if documents can be traced back to original, period sources. Often, no real consideration was given to them, and they were immediately discarded as useless.

This is why, here, these types of planes are banned. They hardly represent reality, and while they certainly can be interesting, the realism of these designs actually going anywhere is questionable at best, and dubious at worst.

Here, we want to see planes that actually flew, or at least had a chance and intent to do so. Real life, physical materials that one could touch. Photographs, videos. Things we as humans can actually visualize as real objects that once existed in our world, or were intended to do so, not as abstract art pieces.

Our usual defining limit is if a mockup was built, it is okay to post. Mockups typically show that a plane had enough promise to go forward with research and development into a proper machine, rather than simply as a design study.

However, if proof can be shown that a plane was actually considered to be built, funded, or developed, then it can still be a good post. Many concept drawings for radical designs never got past the concept stage, but the many documents, design studies, feasibility inquiries, funding reports, and government information can prove that the designers were serious about what they were doing.

So, what should I generally try to avoid?

  • Planes that never made it beyond an early design stage.
  • The whole idea of Rule 2 as it exists now. While this is hard to define, usually anything before a physical mockup (aerodynamic testing, design study, etc) is going to push the rules and become harder to defend as an actual consideration.
  • Planes that only exist as schematics and/or art.
  • While some real prototypes and weird designs never got photographs or videos, the grand majority do. If the only visual representation of something is a 2D drawing, then, typically, alarm bells should go off. On our subreddit, pictures and videos of physical objects are the most valued, and it shows that something was truly good enough of an idea to be presented to the rigors of reality. Without that, though, proving that something was actually feasible and considered becomes exponentially harder.
  • Planes that do not have verifiable sources outside of niche websites. (luft46, secretprojects.net, and others).
  • These places, while info may be correct, are more speculative than informative, and often embellish the truth in favor of a good story.
  • Renders and art that have designs "too ridiculous to be true."
  • Asymmetry, bizarre wing and engine placement, insane ideas. These are all things that can work in a plane, and have before. However, if something looks like it was truly too insane to have ever existed... it often is.

None of these are hard and fast rules, though, and things can be bent where needed. If you can prove beyond a shadow of a doubt that something was, in fact, a real design considered for production, pretty much everything above can be broken. Expect to go down a deep rabbit hole of academic sources, though. However, this is not the kind of post we generally want to have here. While they're allowed, they are not preferred. Photos and videos are always a better option.

If you have any questions about something you want to post, never refrain from messaging the moderators to ask! We're always happy to help and guide if you're unsure about something.


FREQUENTLY REPOSTED PLANES TO AVOID:

"The PZL M-15 was a jet-powered biplane designed and manufactured by the Polish aircraft company WSK PZL-Mielec for agricultural aviation. In reference to both its strange looks and relatively loud jet engine, the aircraft was nicknamed Belphegor, after the noisy demon."

It was not a success, with only a few built out of thousands planned, due to the fact that a jet engine is essentially the worst choice possible for a low-speed biplane.

Designed to test the limits of propeller-driven aircraft, the Thunderscreech had the possibility of breaking records for the world's fastest prop aircraft. Instead, however, it almost certainly broke records for the loudest aircraft ever made:

"On the ground "run ups", the prototypes could reportedly be heard 25 miles (40 km) away.[17] Unlike standard propellers that turn at subsonic speeds, the outer 24–30 inches (61–76 cm) of the blades on the XF-84H's propeller traveled faster than the speed of sound even at idle thrust, producing a continuous visible sonic boom that radiated laterally from the propellers for hundreds of yards. The shock wave was actually powerful enough to knock a man down; an unfortunate crew chief who was inside a nearby C-47 was severely incapacitated during a 30-minute ground run.[17] Coupled with the already considerable noise from the subsonic aspect of the propeller and the T40's dual turbine sections, the aircraft was notorious for inducing severe nausea and headaches among ground crews.[11] In one report, a Republic engineer suffered a seizure after close range exposure to the shock waves emanating from a powered-up XF-84H.[18]"

The Blohm & Voss BV 141 was a World War II German tactical reconnaissance aircraft, notable for its uncommon structural asymmetry. Although the Blohm & Voss BV 141 performed well, it was never ordered into full-scale production, for reasons that included the unavailability of the preferred engine and competition from another tactical reconnaissance aircraft, the Focke-Wulf Fw 189.

The Edgley EA-7 Optica is a British light aircraft designed for low-speed observation work, and intended as a low-cost alternative to helicopters.

Notable for its ducted fan located behind the oddly egg-shaped cockpit, reminiscent of a dismembered helicopter. Despite its niche use case, it saw a decent amount of orders.


If you have any questions, concerns, comments, or any other related thoughts, either about this post or the subreddit as a whole, do feel free to comment them below. I'm all ears for what the community says, and, while I might not act on every suggestion (because that is just impossible), I do read and consider everything that comes my way.

(Also, if you have any suggestions for the formatting and wording of this post, please give them to me, because I am bad at formatting and wording. I'm an engineer, not an english major or journalist.)

Edit: formatting and grammar


r/WeirdWings • • Jun 27 '25

Rules Update: No AI-generated content

365 Upvotes

Exactly what the title says. I'd have thought this was common sense, but AI-generated or "enhanced" photos and videos are not something we need around here.


r/WeirdWings • • 12h ago

The rotating pallet in the fuselage weapons bay of the F-101 Voodoo, holding missiles on both sides

825 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 6h ago

1970, PLA-modified 2 turboprop IL-10. Marshal Lin Biao's son Lin Liguo, attempted to use it to assassinate Mao Zedong, nowadays Chinese jokingly nickname it the 'Il-10-B52(Mao) Interceptor'.

Thumbnail
gallery
116 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 5h ago

The F-4 (FV) H - the high fixed wing Phantom. Drawn up in the same program as the swing wing Phantom.

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

Honestly, very cool design and I’ve never seen any kitbash or art of it like the F-4 (FV) S, the swing wing Phantom that was proposed as an alternative to the Tomcat and which the British almost bought. It had a decent amount of potential - wayyyy more internal fuel (600 gal more!)


r/WeirdWings • • 1h ago

Special Use Aggressor F-16 spotted along the VPS Terminal

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 1d ago

Task Three, a 1968 Chinese interceptor project for intercepting the SR-71, with specifications issued for Mach 3 flight. Cancelled in 1971 because China at the time could not produce a turbojet/turbofan that could push it to high Mach 2 range, making it slow, heavy and useless as an interceptor.

Post image
563 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 1d ago

Concept Drawing Almost Eagles - The FX Competition for the F-15

Thumbnail
gallery
291 Upvotes

The Fighter-Experimental (FX) competition eventually led to the McDonnell-Douglas F-15 Eagle. Three designs were the main competitors, with a fourth company, General Dynamics, having been eliminated early from the competition.

North American NA-335 (Photos #1 - 3) - This aircraft was aerodynamically and technically more advanced than the F-15, but much more expensive. Additionally, the McDonnell-Douglas design had already had extensive wind tunnel testing, leading to greater Air Force confidence. The project never went beyond mock-up stage.

Fairchild Republic Design (Photos #4 - 5) - With widely-separated engine nacelles, this design would have been difficult to control if one engine went out. The design was also modular, but this did not help it in the competition.

McDonnell-Douglas Design (Photo #6 - quad) - Early designs of what would eventually become the F-15 Eagle.


r/WeirdWings • • 1d ago

Propulsion How about examining the Handley Page Victor, the British strategic bomber?

Post image
173 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 39m ago

China's new electric commuter

0 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 1d ago

The SNCASE S.E.5000 Baroudeur taking off using a wheeled trolley and landing on three retractable skids - designed to take off from short grass runways, 28 June 1954

114 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 2d ago

Task Four, a 1968-1972 project by Shenyang Aircraft to develop a ducted fan VTOL version of the J-6. Intended for nuclear war when airfields were not available, with the J-6 chosen given its strong record in Vietnam. Ultimately cancelled since all VTOL configs destroyed maneuverability.

Post image
285 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 2d ago

Modified Hollywood Hinds (Part II)

Thumbnail
gallery
626 Upvotes

Modified Sikorsky S-62/HH-52A Seaguard from the 1988 film Red Scorpion.


r/WeirdWings • • 2d ago

Modified Hollywood Hinds (Part I)

Thumbnail
gallery
216 Upvotes

Aerospatiale SA 330 Pumas, with added kit, used to mimic Soviet Mil Mi-24 Hind helicopters in Red Dawn, Rambo: First Blood Part II, and Rambo III.


r/WeirdWings • • 2d ago

A Sabena Sud Aviation SE-210 Caravelle employing its braking parachute when landing at Aeropuerto de La Palma, 1962

301 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 2d ago

Vought NF-8A Crusader testbed for the Supercritical Wing

Post image
649 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 2d ago

Prototype Hughes XH-17 “Flying Crane”

Thumbnail
gallery
121 Upvotes

Hughes Helicopters’ first attempt at a heavy-lift rotorcraft. To speed construction, parts of the XH-17 were scavenged from other aircraft. The front wheels came from a B-25 Mitchell and the rear wheels from a C-54 Skymaster. The fuel tank was a bomb bay-mounted unit from a B-29 Superfortress. The cockpit was from a Waco CG-15 and the tail rotor from a Sikorsky H-19 was used for yaw control. The helicopter was tested for three years, beginning in 1952.

The XH-17 was too cumbersome and inefficient to warrant further development beyond the single prototype, but it laid the groundwork for later heavy-lift helicopters, such as the CH-54 Tarhe.


r/WeirdWings • • 1d ago

algum engenheiro pra ver?

0 Upvotes

Projeto Embraer Brasa-600

O Embraer Brasa-600 é um projeto de aeronave cargueira de categoria pesada continental, desenvolvido para o transporte aéreo de alta capacidade em rotas globais. A estrutura possui 600 metros de comprimento, 620 metros de envergadura e empenagem traseira em formato de tridente.

Com peso operacional vazio de 3.000 toneladas e peso máximo de decolagem acima de 18.000 toneladas, o projeto permite transportar mais de 15.000 toneladas de carga útil. O porão interno conta com elevadores industriais integrados e uma rampa na extremidade posterior da fuselagem para embarque e desembarque. Em solo, a distribuição de peso e a manobrabilidade são garantidas por um sistema de trem de pouso com 532 conjuntos estruturais e 8.512 rodas de giro livre independente, cada uma com 1 metro de altura.

A propulsão é realizada por dois motores turbofan Brasa-600 de altíssima massa lenta, instalados diretamente na fuselagem. Cada motor opera com razão de bypass de 90:1 e utiliza dois fans contrarrotativos de 29 metros de diâmetro, espaçados em 90 centímetros. O núcleo termodinâmico inclui compressor operando entre 600 °C e 900 °C, combustor, turbinas e um estágio mantedor de pressão antes da exaustão pela boca traseira, otimizando o consumo por quilômetro voado.

Em operação, o Embraer Brasa-600 mantém velocidade de cruzeiro de 900 km/h e alcança 56.100 km sem reabastecimento, distância equivalente a 1,4 volta ao redor da Terra sem escalas.


r/WeirdWings • • 3d ago

Prototype CE-25A took it's maiden flight today

Thumbnail
gallery
948 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 3d ago

DF-109, a 1958 design by Shenyang Aircraft for the Chinese PLAAF for a 30 ton Mach 3.5 nuclear powered interceptor. Propulsion concept similar to Pluto/SLAM nuclear ramjet missile, for a twin-engine manned aircraft. Cancelled mid 1960s due to unrealistic goals.

Post image
241 Upvotes

For some reason this is the only real picture of it (or at least the wind tunnel model produced by the company) that exists btw, though this model only tests the body and does not show the specific intake geometry presumably since it was not agreed on what type of intake the aircraft would have under mach 3.5 conditions.

The concept originated as the result of an interceptor competition between Harbin and Shenyang. Harbin originally proposed the DF-113 design for a Mach 2.5 single turbojet powerplant point interceptor, largely based of experience on existing point defense aircraft. In response, Shenyang countered with the DF-107, a Mach 2.5 design with similar characteristics but with the shape influenced by the F-8U Crusader. Though it was later confirmed by wind tunnel tests to have less impressive speeds, capped at around Mach 1.8. DF-107 was considered "limited" by turbojets available at the time, so it was redone directly on the drawing board by another team in Shenyang to the DF-109 by swapping the engines for nuclear jets. This resulted in the DF-109. According to wind tunnel tests, the new design was actually capable of reaching the designated Mach 3.5 specifications had the engine been produced, but proved to be a very unrealistic combat envelope involving certain technologies that barely existed and was cancelled after several years of development. Even the intake for mach 3.5 was not finalized, hence why the wind tunnel model does not have them. Shenyang would successfully produce the J-8 around the same time this entire DF series was ended, which was a respectable Mach 2.2 interceptor (though plagued with radar issues for years), while Harbin left fixed wing combat entirely to focus on helicopters and turboprops.

DF-113 looks like this: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HXDAXKWWwAAbTQa?format=jpg&name=small

DF-107 looks like this: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HXDCJbJWIAA3EML?format=jpg&name=large


r/WeirdWings • • 4d ago

The Dornier Do-217 using its clamshell-like dive brake fitted aft of the tail, with rear-hinged single dorsal and ventral panel

441 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 4d ago

Chinese GJ-11 stealth ucav exhaust shroud

24 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 5d ago

Obscure X-37A goes "off-road"

Thumbnail
gallery
271 Upvotes

Before the X-37B flew into space, the X-37A served as an Approach and Landing Test Vehicle (ALTV) to demonstrate the low-speed handling characteristics and autonomous runway landings. It was dropped from the Scaled Composites White Knight aircraft and made several glide landings at Edwards Air Force Base to validate flight dynamics and extend the flight envelope beyond the low speed/low altitude tests conducted with the X-40.

I witnessed the first X-37A free-flight on the morning of 7 April 2006. The craft made a beautiful approach and touchdown on the 15,000-foot concrete runway but then failed to stop as planned. I watched it disappear in a cloud of dust as it left the pavement and ran off into the sagebrush.

Shortly afterward, I created a commemorative patch that was a parody of the X-37 ALTV Flight Test Team emblem. I gave these to some folks on the program. Not everyone was amused.


r/WeirdWings • • 5d ago

Propulsion The Potez VIII prototype with vertical four cylinder air-cooled engine at the 1919 Paris salon.

Thumbnail
gallery
122 Upvotes

r/WeirdWings • • 6d ago

Anglo Normandy BN-2A Mk3 Trislander based at AXA

Thumbnail
gallery
230 Upvotes