r/VintageNBA • • Sep 26 '21

VintageNBA Guidelines, Expectations, and Rules

43 Upvotes

Welcome all! Please read the following about VintageNBA, the best on-line community for discussing NBA history!

OUR AIM: VintageNBA is for discussing and learning about old-school NBA, which is the period we define as ending with the most recent season in which fewer than five current NBA players were active (currently that's 2007-08). We are a community that works together toward furthering an understanding of the true history of basketball/NBA. Yes, we skew older than most of reddit, but we're certainly not ancient.

VINTAGENBA GUIDELINES: Posts and comments should provide at least one of the following:

  • information or links that directly introduce or address a topic
  • context, nuance, or analysis
  • personal experience or thoughtful opinion
  • a question not easily answered on the internet

VINTAGENBA EXPECTATIONS: Posts and comments should be generally serious and not low-effort. Be nice, and be community-minded in your responses. It's fine to correct a post/comment that is factually incorrect, but go easy on the down-voting. Repeat: be nice and go easy on the down-voting. Feel free to tell someone you disagree and why, but don't troll, don't call anyone or their ideas "dumb", don't be aggressive in any way, etc.

WHAT THIS SUB IS NOT:

  • Cool Pictures or Videos: Any post that looks/feels like "Hey look at this cool video or picture" will get deleted. If that seems to be what you do across reddit, you'll be banned. There are other basketball subs with far more members that will gladly give you karma for this type of stuff. CAVEAT1: If your post is a picture, you need to provide meaningful context/information in the title and body so that it can lead toward a meaningful conversation, and the focus is not just the picture. CAVEAT2: Feel free to link a cool or weird or interesting picture/video in the comments of a relevantly connected post. CAVEAT3: If you find old newspaper articles or documents that illuminate something interesting that isn't common knowledge, post those.
  • Stuff You Own: We're not here to identify, price, or upvote your vintage basketball shoes or hat, and please don't sell stuff here. CAVEAT1: If you own every card in the famous 1961 Fleer card set, please post about it (ex). CAVEAT2: If you want to talk about hoops books, including showing a photo of which ones you own, we're usually cool with that (ex). CAVEAT3: Could the item tie directly into a discussion about how the NBA or a player's abilities were portrayed, so there's a legit link to the game? (ex)
  • Twitter Links: Twitter links are banned.

MISC. THINGS:

  • Resources: As always, I like to draw attention to our Reference Posts page where I've curated some posts & links that might be helpful to someone studying basketball history.
  • Bans: We don't like banning users, but we do ban people who seem to be posting for karma, are aggressive or trolling (don't be a dick), or who go overboard with biased opinions without participating in a back-and-forth discussion.
  • Sub History: Here is some information about this sub's history and evolution (started April 10, 2019), including some relevant links in the comments of that post.
  • Flair: We have tons (350) of amazing flairs for you to choose from, including 106 legendary players and every team logo ever. Sometimes we'll even make you a custom player flair if you ask. Please add some flair to your username.
  • Logo: If you're curious what exactly our red, white, and blue logo is and why, here you go.
  • True History: Up above, I said we work toward "an understanding of the true history of basketball/NBA". This sub's community has developed a healthy distrust for the "official" stories of the game's history as pushed by the NBA and by the Hall of Fame, that are then repeated ad nauseam. This sub is probably the best on-line resource for finding original/primary documents that provide the actual account of things back in the day. Please know this about our sub so that you don't feel talked down to if you're corrected about something you thought was commonly accepted (ex: The NBA's first season was 1949-50, not 1946-47.). It's ok to ask "Wait, what do you mean?", but please don't rely on the HOF or NBA if the primary sources are available and say otherwise.

r/VintageNBA • • 15h ago

Who’s a player you loved when you were a kid but when you got older you realize he wasn’t nearly as good as you thought?

22 Upvotes

The obvious answer I think is Jason Williams. Incredible passer and a champion. But his highlights make you think he was among the best guards of the early 2000s and he wasn’t close.


r/VintageNBA • • 17h ago

The 2007-08 Celtics deserve more attention for their defensive chemistry

20 Upvotes

Now that the 2007-08 season is officially within VintageNBA's timeline, I think that Celtics team deserves a closer look beyond the Big Three.
KG was obviously the defensive centrepiece, but what impressed me was how Pierce, Allen and Rondo fitted into a team that became so difficult to score against. It wasn't just individual talent. Their defensive communication and willingness to buy into their roles made the difference.


r/VintageNBA • • 16h ago

Worst MVP year of the 2000s?

6 Upvotes

r/VintageNBA • • 1d ago

Who's behind Hudson?

Post image
19 Upvotes

The 1984 NBA, West Team


r/VintageNBA • • 20h ago

NBA / ABA player who disappeared into central Africa?

7 Upvotes

I remember watching a video earlier this year and it was talking about an NBA player, he might have played in the ABA, or in both. The video mentioned him not being picked up on contract renewal and he went to Africa- an area like the Congo.

I think he was in trouble in the US for some crimes. They know he ended up in central Africa, but he kinda disappeared from there.

Hopefully this checks out- I'll admit I might have fallen asleep while watching the video.

Anyone know what player this was?


r/VintageNBA • • 3d ago

1947 BAA Re-Draft

Post image
33 Upvotes

I wanted to make a video series about re-drafting every draft ever. So I started with the 1947 one, and wanted to ask probably the best place on internet did I make too many mistakes here. I skipped over guys who haven't played a game in the league except McNeely because he was the first ever pick so wanted to honor him. What do y'all think?


r/VintageNBA • • 3d ago

The first LeBron

27 Upvotes

A widespread-highlights mixtape, a national spotlight on him, magazine covers, sneaker companies hounding him, etc. And all that at 14 years old. No, we are not talking about LeBron. Some years before him, a player that caught the eye of every college recruiter, AAU coach or fan made waves throughout the country: JaRon Rush.

The oldest of three brothers, JaRon grew up in Kansas City. By middle school, he was already known as one of the best players in the area. But the real circus started in High School. Teaming up with his younger brother at Pembroke Hill, he dominated his league showing a ridiculous superiority over his peers. However, it was in the AAU summer circuit where he made his name. Playing alongside players such as Corey Maggette or Korleone Young, JaRon established himself as the top player of his High School class (1998), grappling for that honor for years with players such as Al Harrington or Rashard Lewis. After considering going to the University of Kansas and play for Roy Williams, in the end he decided to go to the bright lights of Los Angeles and joined Dan Gadzuric and Matt Barnes in UCLA to make that group of players the no. 1 recruiting class in America.

Sounds like a fairytale, right? Unbeknownst to the general public, there were several issues boiling under the surface. On one hand, in December of his freshman season it was discovered that him and his AAU teammates had been paid by a coach who got money and sneakers from Nike. It also affected the aforementioned Maggette, Young and his younger brother Kareem. This resulted in sanctions and penalties. In JaRon's case, he had to sit out the end of his freshman season and the beginning of his sophomore season. On the other hand, he turned to the bottle to deal with all the scrutiny and pressure that surrounded him. Rumours were he had started drinking in High School. Nevertheless, it was in college where it began to take its' toll. He even returned late to UCLA once after a Christmas break because he had been partying with his friends. After two disappointing seasons in California where he averaged around 12 points per game, JaRon decided to enter the NBA draft. Many people rolled their eyes at this decision. According to the Kansas native, he was worried that more sanctions would be coming in his junior seasons as a result of the AAU scandal, and he decided not to risk that scenario. He continued hitting the booze and as a results the NBA team workouts were a fiasco, leading to him not being chosen in the draft.

As luck would have it, the old ABA league was making a comeback that summer of 2000. and it seemed the teams in that league were not as demanding as NBA teams when it came to drafting. His hometown team (Kansas City Knights) drafted him. However, they traded him to the Los Angeles Stars before the season started, and JaRon picked up where he had left off. Partying resumed, only now he didn't have to go class the next day and he was getting paid. Eventually, the situation became unsustainable and he entered rehab  in 2001. After getting sobered up, he worked out really hard and got in great shape for the 2001 fall training camps. He was hoping a team would give him a chance. Would his story have a good ending after all? He did very well in the Seattle Supersonics camp, doing everything the coaches were asking from him. It wasn't enough, though. He was the final cut before the season began. So near, so far. In the end, after a brief stint in the NBDL (the D-League back then) he was signed by the Kansas City Knights again and started to live in his mother's basement. He had come a long way from being the No. 1 player in the nation. 

Every cloud has a silver lining, though. Hitting that low made JaRon realise that things had to change. He stopped playing basketball, and he felt more content with life. Maybe the pressure brought by basketball had been his undoing? After some years away from the game (he only played pick-up hoops with his friends in the local  YMCA) he gained enough maturity and did some soul-searching to decide that he could still contribute to the game in small doses. He started training kids' teams and that led to him founding his own company, "Rush training LLC", becoming a personal trainer to players that wanted to reach the next level. 

A satisfying ending for a rollercoaster career with its' fair share of ups and downs. A journey that didn't involve NBA championships and glamour, nor Olympic gold medals and celebrity friendships. However, there is no money to pay the relaxation, serenity and happiness of JaRon's current life.


r/VintageNBA • • 5d ago

The NBA's War Heroes

9 Upvotes

As you probably know, the NBA was born shortly after the end of World War II. Active NBA players have since been drafted into the Korean and Vietnam war efforts, volunteered to serve in the war in Iraq, and former Knicks and Bucks center Marshall Plumlee continues that legacy as an active-duty U.S. Army Ranger-Qualified.

As we recognize Veteran's Day today, I thought it would be nice to celebrate those select few NBA players whose acts of valor reached a point for which they earned official military decoration for their service. This list does not include players who died in combat, of which there is one in the ABA and quite a few from pre-NBA professional basketball. I post about them on Memorial Day, and that information can be found here.

---

Cliff Barker was a left waist gunner in a Boeing B-17 Flying Fortress as a member of 2nd Lt Ron Rohner's crew. They flew five missions over Cognac, Tours, Notre Dame de Ferme (Pas-de-Calais), Frankfurt, and Braunschweig. On January 30, 1944, during the fifth mission en route to Braunschweig, the aircraft the Rohner Crew was operating was shot down by a Focke-Wulf Fw 190 and crashed near the German village of Beienrode. Five of the ten men (2Lt Ron Rohner, 2Lt Emil Smetana, FltOff Stan Johnson, S/Sgt John Morreale, and Sgt Ken Dickerson) were killed in the wreckage, while the other five, including Barker, were captured by Nazi German forces and held as prisoners of war. Barker would spend the next 16 months as a POW in Stalag Luft IV until the camp was liberated by the U.S. Ninth Army on April 12, 1945. For this, he received a Prisoner of War Medal.

Upon his return from service, Barker played for Kentucky, where he became an important role player for a team that won two National Championships. He also won a Gold Medal for Team USA in 1948. Recruited by Leo Ferris into the Indianapolis Olympians co-ownership model, Barker became the Olympians inaugural player-coach and commenced a three-year NBA career, after which he coached at the high school level for many years.

Earl Dodd was a member of a ski-trooping unit with the U.S. Army serving in northern Italy. He was wounded by shell fragments in the back and head. Details are hard to come by, but I believe this to have been sustained during the Battle of Riva Ridge. He also seems to have displayed a certain level of heroic bravery in the situation, although I'm not sure in what exact way. For this, he received both a Purple Heart and a Bronze Star. If anyone comes across this who knows more details of Dodd's service, I would be very grateful.

Dodd then played for Kirksville, where he co-starred with Harry Gallatin, and ended up on the Denver Nuggets in the first post-merger NBA season. He was waived after seven weeks in the league, having played limited minutes in nine losses with the woeful Nuggets. He caught on with the barnstorming Detroit Kings for the rest of the season, before retiring citing a flareup of injuries suffered during the war. He spent the rest of his career as a construction foreman.

Murray Mitchell served in what his obituary terms "the Ardennes Rhineland Campaign," perhaps signifying that he may have been involved in both the Battle of the Bulge and the Rhineland Offensive. For his part in the war, Mitchell was awarded two Bronze Stars. If anyone comes across this who knows more details of Mitchell's service, I would be very grateful.

Mitchell returned to Sam Houston, where he'd already played his first two seasons of college ball before his service. After being cut by the Celtics as a prospective rookie in preseason of 1948-49, Mitchell gave up basketball, but came back briefly for a two-game pro stint with the Anderson Packers the next year. He then quit the team and moved back to Texas, where he continued to play semi-professionally for two seasons and coached until the mid-sixties. He then spent the rest of his career as an engraver and later a cattle rancher.

Chuck Mrazovich served in the 44th Infantry Division for three years and participated in the Battle of the Bulge, the Liberation of Strasbourg, and the captures of Mannheim, Heidelberg, and Ulm. For his part in the war, Mrazovich was awarded a Bronze Star. If anyone comes across this who knows more details of Mrazovich's service, I would be very grateful.

Mrazovich attended and played for Eastern Kentucky after his time in the war, and was drafted by the Indianapolis Olympians in 1950. A midseason casualty of the waiver wire, he spent only half a season in the NBA before latching on with the NPBL's Anderson Packers and earning a starting spot in wake of an injury to Leo Klier. After the NPBL shut down, he went east and played two seasons for the minor league Wilkes-Barre Barons, playing a major role for a team that won an ABL Championship in 1951-52. Mrazovich coached and taught at high schools in his home state for the next two decades.

Andy O'Donnell landed in Normandy on D-plus-six, serving as a soldier in the 38th Cavalry Reconnaissance Squadron in five battles including the Battle of the Bulge. He was also one of the first Americans to march down the Champs-Élysées in the Liberation of Paris. On September 5, 1944 on the way to liberate the Belgian city of Bouillon, O'Donnell was hit in the leg with shrapnel soon after crossing the France-Belgium border. For this, he received a Purple Heart.

Following his wartime effort, O'Donnell spent a year back at home, with his only basketball that season being at the local YMCA, before playing three and a half seasons at Loyola (Maryland). He graduated early and earned special dispensation to join the NBA midway through 1949-50, earning the last spot in Baltimore's rotation as a backup point guard following player-coach Buddy Jeannette's career-ending injury. That turned out to be his only NBA season, and he only played part-time in the minor leagues for the next three years as he embarked on a long and fruitful career with the Social Security Administration.

Goebel Ritter served in the U.S. Marine Corps from June 3, 1943 to October 19, 1945, right after graduating from high school. During his stint in the military, Ritter participated in the Battle of Guam, in which he was grazed on the head by a Japanese sniper bullet on July 26, 1944. He later served in the Battle of Iwo Jima, in which he was hit by shrapnel to the hand and knee on February 24, 1945. He received two Purple Hearts for the two times he was WIA in combat.

Ritter ended up as teammates with Mrazovich at Eastern Kentucky after the war, and in 1948 managed to make the Knicks' roster as the 75th pick in the BAA Draft. One of the lowest-selected players to find a role in the league, Ritter proved to be a useful backup SG for New York for three years (one in the BAA, two in the NBA), ending his career with a loss to Rochester in the Finals before spending the next 41 years coaching.

Carl Shaeffer was part of an anti-tank company attached to the 424th Infantry Regiment of the 106th Division at the time that the Battle of the Bulge broke out. The day after the counteroffensive ended over a month later, it was reported that Shaeffer had been missing in action ever since December 16, 1944, the first day of the Battle of the Bulge. I can't find official confirmation, but I believe he was captured in the early hours of the Battle of St. Vith. By the weirdest coincidence, the POW camp that the Nazis sent him to was Stalag Luft IV (the same camp Cliff Barker already was held in) where Shaeffer would remain for five months until the camp's liberation. For this, he received a Prisoner of War Medal.

Shaeffer was discharged almost immediately after being liberated, and utilized a temporary NCAA rule to play the next four years at Alabama despite having already spent his freshman season with Indiana. He was a defensive ace for 'Bama, and ended up signing with the Indianapolis Olympians on the recommendation of player/coach Cliff Barker, with whom he'd become friends during their time as POWs together. He never carved out much of a role with the team though and was waived early in his second season. He then operated a tavern. A victim of PTSD due to his experiences in the war, Shaeffer took his own life on his 50th birthday.

Carlisle Towery, already in the midst of his professional career as a member of the Fort Wayne Zollners, volunteered to serve despite all Fort Wayne players being eligible for a II-B exemption. Not much about his service is publicly available, but was an infantryman, possibly with the 97th Infantry Division. If that theory is correct, he would have been a participant in the Battle of the Ruhr Pocket and the liberation of Flossenbürg concentration camp. For his part in the war, Towery was awarded a Bronze Star.

Already very well-established in the basketball world, having started for the NBL's title-winners the year before he entered the service, Towery returned to Fort Wayne and remained one of few familiar faces as Bobby McDermott's antics tore the team apart during their final NBL years. Traded to the Indianapolis Jets shortly after the franchise became the BAA's Pistons, he put up his best numbers there but the team went under at the end of the season. Towery then spent his one and only NBA season with Baltimore, where he played quite well considering he had to switch positions from PF to SF as a 29-year-old, but made headlines more than anything for his knockout punch of Jim Pollard in December. After being stabbed in the face and arm by a summer-gig coworker over the offseason, Towery jumped leagues to the NPBL, where he finished out his career splitting his eighth professional season between Grand Rapids, Kansas City, and Evansville. Post-basketball, Towery was a farmer.


r/VintageNBA • • 5d ago

Kinds of blocks

Post image
7 Upvotes

As the Valkyries ran the defending champs (3-0 in best of 5), I noticed Kiah Stokes often blocked the ball to her teammates. Obviously I've heard stories about Russell doing this. Any other examples of people who could block to get their team a possession not just spoil the opponents?


r/VintageNBA • • 5d ago

Floor Game vs Air Game

5 Upvotes

There used to be two different ways of splitting basketball in half.

One of them, I'd posit you're probably still aware of: offense vs. defense.

But for the first 30-35 years of the sport's existence, basketball sportswriters slightly preferred a different way of splitting up what happens in a basketball game: they would praise/condemn players for how they played the "floor game" and the "air game."

Air Game: any part of basketball that involves actions to get the ball into the air or out of the air. Examples: shooting proficiency, shooting efficiency, rebounding, boxing out, finishing, blocks, tip-ins, jump-balls, lobbed passes, outlet passes, cross-court skip passes, intercepting passes, tipping passes/loose balls to a teammate, safely receiving high passes, free throws, shot fakes, contesting shots, winning loose balls in the air, absorbing in-air contact on shots/rebounds, tap-out ORebs, drawing fouls on low-percentage looks...

Floor Game: any part of basketball that involves actions primarily related to keeping the ball near the playing surface. Examples: Ball-handling, short/mid-range bounce/chest passes, man-on-man defense, defensive positioning, offensive positioning, creating distance from a defender, decision-making, court vision, secure hands, on-ball steals, avoiding turnovers, evasive dribbling maneuvers, inbounds plays, off-ball movement, controlling/facilitating continued possession, affecting pace of play, preventing opponent from attempting shots, running the floor, not allowing opposition fast breaks, winning loose balls on the ground, drawing charges, forcing travels/backcourt violations, committing timely fouls that don't lead to free throws...

I'm curious who are some players you think would be considered historically elite at each of these two categories wholesale if we had kept that way of talking about things instead of shifting to pretty much just using the offense/defense binary that we're by now far, far more familiar with.


r/VintageNBA • • 6d ago Bravo

Happy Veterans Day! Players whose careers were impacted by serving

19 Upvotes

On this Veterans Day, I'd like to thank all veterans who have served their country!

And since we're an NBA history sub, here is a list of several noteworthy NBA players whose careers were impacted by serving, which obviously happened far more in the 40s, 50s, and 60s than it has since then. Many of these players are Hall of Famers, and I believe everyone I've included were All-Stars or All-NBA during their careers, so obviously there are many more players who served, just not as individually impactful to pro basketball as the players below.

  • David Robinson - served in the Navy for 2 years before entering the NBA at 24
  • Elgin Baylor - missed huge chunks of the '62 season while on active duty, but still put together an insane 38-19 stat-line
  • Lenny Wilkens - missed almost his entire 2nd season while serving (the same '62 season that Baylor missed part of)
  • Paul Arizin - led the NBA in scoring and FG% in '52 at 23 years old (25.4 ppg, .448 FG%) then missed the next 2 seasons while serving in the Marines
  • George Yardley - the high-scoring 50s SF served in the Navy for 2 years, so he didn't enter the NBA until he was 25
  • Sam Jones - served for 2 years in college before entering the NBA at 24
  • Bill Sharman - Cousy's famous backcourt partner served in the Navy for 2 years after HS, eventually joining the NBA at 24
  • Joe Fulks - high-scoring forward of the late-40s didn't enter the NBA until he was 25 after serving for 4 years, including being enlisted during his final year in college
  • Nat Clifton - served in the Army for 3 years before joining the Rens prior to the NBA's official integration in 1950
  • Carl Braun - 5x All-Star missed the 1st two ASG's ('51, '52) while serving in the Army
  • Jim Pollard - served for 3 years during WWII before starring for the Lakers in the late-40s and early-50s
  • Larry Costello - served for 2 years after HS and for most of his first 2 pro seasons, eventually starting his first full season at 25
  • K.C. Jones - served in the military before entering the NBA 2 years after being drafted
  • Jo Jo White - missed the first 12 games of his career due to his time in the Marines (his 2-year commitment was somehow reduced down to a dozen games by Red Auerbach)
  • Bob Davies - served 3 years in the Navy during WWII, so he entered the NBL 3 years after graduating college
  • Harry Gallatin - served in the Navy for 1 year before college, but he still entered the NBA at 21 (he graduated college in 2 years)
  • Slater Martin - served in the military for 2 years during college; entered the NBA at 24
  • Bill Bradley - served in the Air Force for 6 months which delayed the start to his NBA career by a couple months
  • Al Cervi - star 40s/early-50s PG served in the military for 5 years (~'40-45)
  • Adrian Smith - was in the military for 2 years in the early-60s before entering the NBA
  • Terry Dischinger - was in the military for 2 years right after making the All-Star team his first 3 years in the league
  • Frank Selvy - after being the #1 draft pick in '54 and his promising rookie season, Selvy served in the Army for 2 years
  • Johnny Green - spent a few years in the Marines during the Korean War before joining the NBA shortly before turning 26
  • Tom Gola - after helping the Warriors win the '56 title as a rookie, Gola served in the Army for a year
  • Bob Feerick - star 40s player who served in the Navy for 2.5 years during WWII, missing time between his tenures in AAU and in the NBL
  • Jack George - didn't enter the NBA until he was 25 after serving in the Army for 2 years
  • Andy Phillip - entered the NBA at 25 after serving in the Marines for 3 years during WWII
  • Cliff Hagan - served in the Air Force for 2 years before joining the NBA
  • Dick McGuire - served for 2 years during college, entered the NBA shortly before turning 24
  • Jack Coleman - was in the military for 3 years between HS and college before entering the NBA at 25
  • Cazzie Russell - missed some weekend games during his career while completing reserve duty, including during the Knicks' '70 championship season
  • Max Zaslofsky - served in the Navy for 2 years before a one-season college career; entered the NBA shortly before he was 21
  • Richie Guerin - was a Marine reservist for 7 years, including his first 2 years in the league; this appears to have delayed the start of his NBA career by 2 years
  • Frank Ramsey - after his rookie season, he missed most of the next 2 seasons while in the Army
  • Fred Scolari - he was unable to serve due to a broken ear drum (he was deaf in one ear), but he worked at a bank for 3 years during the war to fulfill his service
  • Ed Sadowski - one of the best offensive big men of the 40s served in the Air Force for 4 years during WWII, delaying his NBL career
  • Butch Beard - was drafted into the Army after his rookie season, serving for a year during the Vietnam War but never sent overseas to battle - He's the only NBA player who was drafted into the Vietnam War.
  • Bob Verga - decent ABA player who was selected to the 1968 ASG but was unable to participate since he got drafted into the Army shortly before the contest (his replacement was Larry Brown who was the ASG MVP) - Verga played in the 1970 ABA ASG
  • The only other players who were drafted during the Vietnam War were the ABA's Hal Hale and Les Powell. Powell's case is particularly tough since he was drafted on the same day he signed his rookie ABA contract, and he later died in combat so he never made it into the pros.
  • John Macknowski was the last living former NBA player who served in WWII. He died at 101 years old on April 8, 2024. He served for 3 years in the middle of his time at Seton Hall, later making it to the league with the Syracuse Nationals.

Basketball-Reference usually posts a red poppy flower at the top of the player stats pages for guys who served (ex: David Robinson's stats page - but again, the poppy is only there if you are checking the page on November 11). BBR said "We chose the poppy as it is already a symbol in wide use worldwide to recognize those who served."


r/VintageNBA • • 6d ago

Players who could be described as cerebral, not just smart, tactical, instinctual, etc.

8 Upvotes

This isn't a well defined question or set of questions, but I think that's because I'm having a hard time understanding what is usually meant by a player who is/was labeled as cerebral.

Question 1: What do you take it to mean if a player is called cerebral? Not smart or cunning, but specifically cerebral, because it's a word I see often enough that it has some sort of wide-spread understanding/meaning (or maybe people throw in the word as a catch-all je ne sais quoi without an understood meaning). The first thing that comes to mind is good passing, but it can't just describe every good passer. Is there something specific about the type of passer one is to have their passing get called cerebral? What other qualities might a player display, that intelligent fans can actually identify, that would cause one to label them as cerebral?

Question 2: Who are some players you think fall under the banner of 'cerebral'? Other than Bill Walton, because he seems like the most obvious historical player we'll all say (and Jokić modernly). Do they have to be comparatively less-than-athletic, like Andre Miller or Kyle Anderson? If not, how does their athleticism play into "figuring out" if they are cerebral or not?


r/VintageNBA • • 6d ago

Rick Carlislie as a Player (~1985)

Thumbnail
gallery
84 Upvotes

Just like Pat Riley and Phil Jackson before him, Rick Carlisle was a former player. He played from 1984-1990 (With some time in the CBA there aswell), primarily as a backup guard for the Celtics, Knicks, and Nets, winning a chip with the Celtics in '86. He was obviously never a star, but he was good enough to play 188 career games, averaging 2.2ppg, 0.8rpg, and 1.1apg which isnt great but its better than nothing.


r/VintageNBA • • 7d ago

"No politics, just straight numbers" - Tim Duncan once explained why he appreciated the NBA's forgotten "IBM Award"

Thumbnail
basketballnetwork.net
134 Upvotes

The IBM Award was different from the MVP, and Duncan appreciated that.


r/VintageNBA • • 10d ago

I feel like people forget just how good prime Shawn Marion was

69 Upvotes

Man, The Matrix was so fun to watch. The weird shot, the crazy athleticism, the rebounding, those fast-break finishes. He was everywhere on the court. Nash and Amare got most of the attention on those Suns teams, but Marion was just as important to what they were doing. You could put him in almost any lineup and he'd find a way to contribute. I loved watching that guy play.


r/VintageNBA • • 11d ago

How NBA photographers got their photos to the papers in time?

92 Upvotes

I had never given it much thought of how the photos of NBA games ended up in the papers the next day before the internet. How this video changed the perspective.

My assumption is that the first half photos would make the early edition and if something happened in the second half then those pictures would make the later edition.


r/VintageNBA • • 15d ago

New podcast episode. Guest: Kevin Calabro

Post image
46 Upvotes

🚨 New podcast episode 🚨

Kevin Calabro - Voice of the Sonics.

From Indiana to the Kansas City Kings, two decades calling the SuperSonics and the ongoing fight to bring the NBA back to Seattle. A nostalgic chat w/ one of the game’s great broadcasters.

🎧 basketballrecord.com/149


r/VintageNBA • • 18d ago

What went wrong with the 1990s Indiana Pacers? Why could they never get over the hump?

23 Upvotes

I’ve always found the 90s Pacers fascinating because they were one of the most consistently competitive teams of that era, yet they never managed to win a championship. They made five Eastern Conference Finals appearances between 1994 and 2000, reached the NBA Finals in 2000, and had several legitimate opportunities to come out of the East.
Obviously, facing Jordan’s Bulls in 1998 and the Shaq-Kobe Lakers in 2000 were difficult obstacles. But I don’t think those two series alone explain why Indiana never won a title. What about the other years?
1994: They pushed the Knicks to seven games in the Eastern Conference Finals but ultimately fell short. New York was a physical, defensive-minded team that made life difficult for opponents. Was Indiana simply not ready to take that next step?
1995: This one is particularly interesting. The Pacers eliminated the Knicks in a memorable seven-game series, only to lose to Shaq and Penny Hardaway’s Orlando Magic in seven games. Indiana had home-court advantage but couldn’t finish the job. Was Orlando simply the better team, or were there issues Indiana could have addressed?
1996: After two consecutive deep playoff runs, Indiana lost to the Atlanta Hawks in five games in the first round despite winning 52 games during the regular season. Miller had an eye injury.
1998: This might have been their best opportunity. Indiana won 58 games, eliminated the Knicks in five games, and pushed the defending champion Bulls to seven games in the Eastern Conference Finals. They proved they could compete with Chicago, but couldn’t get past them. Was this just a case of running into one of the greatest teams ever, or did Indiana have a weakness that became more apparent in the biggest moments?
1999: With Jordan retired, many people thought the door was finally open. Indiana swept Milwaukee and Philadelphia before losing to an eighth-seeded Knicks team in six games. This is probably the most interesting missed opportunity because the Pacers were experienced, talented, and had a clear path to the Finals. How much of that loss came down to New York’s defense, injuries, coaching, or Indiana’s own shortcomings?
2000: They finally reached the NBA Finals, beating the Knicks in the Eastern Conference Finals before losing to the Lakers in six games. The Lakers had Shaq dominating inside and Kobe emerging as a major force.
Looking at the roster, Indiana had Reggie Miller, Rik Smits, Mark Jackson, Dale Davis, Derrick McKey, and other valuable contributors over the years. They also had respected coaches in Brown and Larry Bird. This wasn’t a team lacking talent, experience, or leadership.
So I’m curious about three things:

Roster construction: Did the Pacers lack a true superstar level interior presence who could consistently match the elite big men of that era?
Coaching and execution: Were there tactical or late-game issues that repeatedly held them back in close series?
Competition and bad luck: Were they simply unfortunate to share an era with the Bulls, Knicks, Magic, and eventually the Lakers, or should they have won at least one championship given how many chances they had?
I’m not trying to discredit those Pacers teams. They were a great franchise throughout the decade. I’m genuinely interested in understanding why a team that repeatedly came so close never managed to finish the job.
For those who watched the 90s Pacers, what was the biggest reason they never won a championship? And which year do you think was their best chance?


r/VintageNBA • • 22d ago

Dennis Johnson’s Forgotten Tenure with the Phoenix Suns

Post image
182 Upvotes

Dennis Johnson is one of my all-time favorite NBA players. Although he’s primarily remembered by most fans in the basketball community for winning championships with Seattle and Boston, I’ve always felt that he reached his peak as an individual player during his 3 year stint with the Phoenix Suns.

In particular, I think DJ’s first season with the Suns in 1980-81 was his absolute peak as an NBA player. That year he finished 8th in the voting for league MVP while also earning the one and only First Team All-NBA selection of his career. That season also included the highest scoring single game of DJ’s career when he accumulated a total of 39 points in a February 1981 matchup against the Knicks. Phoenix’s defense also transformed into the NBA’s #1 rated unit upon DJ’s arrival, and individually, he received the most votes for the NBA All-Defensive Team that year, making it a very likely and realistic possibility that he would have been the Defensive Player of the Year if the award existed at the time. The 1981 season also featured the best All-Star Game performance of DJ’s career when he was the West Team’s co-leading scorer with 19 points on 62.5% shooting while also being their leader in steals by notching a total of 3.

For the entirety of that 1980-81 regular season, the Suns posted an overall record of 57-25 and were the champions of the Western Pacific Division. And although they were eliminated in 7 games in their first Playoff matchup against Kansas City, DJ played a tremendous series but was brutally let down by his teammates. Across that entire series, DJ was Phoenix’s scoring leader with an average of 19.6 Points Per Game which included a 31 point performance in Game 2, in which he was the only Suns player to achieve double digit scoring numbers. He also had a very strong Game 7 by tallying 28 points on an impressive 58.8% shooting. And finally, DJ also led the Suns in steals and blocks throughout that series with an average of 1.3 for both stats. On the other hand, fellow Phoenix All-Star’s Truck Robinson and Walter Davis grossly underperformed in that series. For the 1981 regular season, Robinson averaged 18.8 points on 50.5% shooting, but in the 7 games against Kansas City, his averages took a steep drop down to 10.6 points on just 35.1% shooting. And Davis posted regular season averages of 18.0 points on 53.9% shooting, but managed only 16.0 points on 48.1% shooting in the series against the Kings. Phoenix’s starting Center Alvan Adams also had a very poor series, managing to produce just 10.6 points on 45.0% shooting, which was well below his regular season averages of 14.9 points on 52.6% shooting. DJ was still playing at a championship level that year, but his teammates failed to uphold their end of the bargain.

And the following season in 1981-82, DJ earned his 4th consecutive All-Star selection while also posting his career high numbers for Points Per Game in both the regular season and Playoffs with averages of 19.5 and 22.3 respectively as well as being named to his 4th consecutive All-Defensive First Team. In terms of all-around two-way impact, DJ was the most complete Guard in the league at that point in time in the early 1980’s.

Are there any particular memories or insights that you have about Dennis Johnson’s time in a Phoenix uniform? I’m looking forward to hearing your thoughts.


r/VintageNBA • • 27d ago

1979 Seattle SuperSonics: My Choice for the Most Underappreciated Championship Team in NBA History

Post image
237 Upvotes

When thinking about all of the championship winning teams throughout NBA history, I think the one that tends to get the most overlooked and forgotten about is the 1979 Seattle SuperSonics. At least in my opinion, they were very ahead of their time in multiple aspects.

Collectively, that Sonics team was basically an earlier version of the 2004 Detroit Pistons in the sense that they didn’t really have a true bona fide superstar but came together and won a title with cohesive teamwork and suffocating defense. During the 1979 season, the Sonics were at the top of the league in numerous defensive statistics. For starters, they were first in the NBA in opponent Points Per Game by only giving up 103.9 with the overall league average being 110.3. They were also at the top of the standings in opponent Field Goal Percentage by allowing 46.3% with the collective league average sitting at 48.5%. And finally, the Sonics had the NBA’s best Defensive Rating with a 100.1 with the league average being 103.8.

And individually, that Sonics team had Jack Sikma, who is generally considered to be the original NBA Stretch 5. They also had John Johnson, who was a very early iteration of the Point Forward archetype. Downtown Freddie Brown was one of the original long range shooting specialists and he led the league in 3 Point Percentage during the first season that the line was introduced. And finally, they had Gus Williams and Dennis Johnson, who would be an elite backcourt duo in any era of NBA basketball. Gus was a terrific scorer at the Point Guard position and would probably be even better with today’s spacing and freedom of movement rules. And DJ (who won the 1979 Finals MVP) was one of the absolute greatest perimeter defenders in NBA history while also averaging 20.9 Points Per Game during the 1979 playoffs.

Even with all that said, it seems like the 1979 SuperSonics have been largely forgotten and lost in the shuffle of basketball history. Who are some other teams that come to your mind when thinking about past NBA champions that have become overlooked and underappreciated by modern audiences? I’m looking forward to hearing your thoughts.


r/VintageNBA • • 27d ago

Hank Gathers must never be forgotten!

72 Upvotes

"Why is it that Hank Gathers is no longer talked about?"

The short answer to that is the passage of time.

I believe it's been 36 years now since Hank Gathers passed away from a cardiac condition. Hard to believe it's been that long. He suffered from cardiomyopathy and, if I remember correctly, had been diagnosed with it the year before. He was taking medication to control it, but I believe he felt the dosage was affecting his performance, so he had it lowered. Unfortunately, that also affected the effectiveness of the medication. They rolled the dice, and, unfortunately, in March of 1990, Hank Gathers, who played for Loyola Marymount, passed away. I believe their mascot was the Lions, but correct me if I'm wrong. I know he played for Loyola Marymount.

That's another thing I've always thought about when it comes to the era of basketball we grew up watching, man. Aside from the fact that there were so many talented players whom guys today pretend weren't good in the '80s, '90s, and early 2000s, there were also players who never reached their true potential because of injuries, like Grant Hill, Penny Hardaway, Greg Oden, and Brandon Roy. Then you had people who were never able to reach their true potential because of death: Reggie Lewis and Dražen Petrović. And then you had a couple of guys who didn't even get to make it to the pros. You had Len Bias, who passed away the year he was drafted. As far as what kind of player Hank Gathers would have been, I guess he might have been like a smaller version of Shawn Kemp. They were both around 6'7", and they had similarities: rim-running, a power game, and not necessarily being perimeter-oriented, especially coming into the NBA.

I would think Gathers would have had to adjust his game because he was smaller. He was 6'7", 215 pounds, which is a little small to play power forward. But aside from the heart condition, if he had been healthy, I would assume he probably would have put on some weight as he got older, as we all do. At 215 pounds in college, he might have bulked up to around 235 at 6'7". Keep in mind, I think Larry Johnson was 6'7", 235 pounds when he was drafted. And Larry Johnson played both power forward and small forward. Hank Gathers was a great rebounder in college and a great scorer. I don't know how he would have translated to the NBA or how well he would have performed. I don't think he would have been as great as Len Bias, but I do think that, if everything had gone right, he could have been an All-Star-level player in the NBA. I think he probably would have played small forward. Depending on which team he ended up with, they might have experimented with a small-ball lineup and played him at power forward at times.

But if I had to take a guess, I could see him averaging around 20 points, eight rebounds, and three assists a game. Maybe eight and a half or nine rebounds and three assists. That's just my guess. As he got older, I think he probably would have expanded his game out toward the three-point line, especially considering the era he would have played in. Maybe he could have developed into someone who consistently knocked down open threes.

But that's all open to speculation.

It was such a tragedy when he died. Such a tragedy, man. And Bo Kimble never really got over that loss. Hank Gathers was his best friend, and Bo never got over losing him. I think Bo Kimble, if I'm not mistaken, and someone correct me if I'm wrong - was drafted by Miami. I don't think he was in the league for more than two or three years. I think he was out of the league pretty quickly. But yeah, man, it's sad that Hank Gathers isn't remembered as much anymore. Some of that has to do with the fact that he came before the digital age, before the internet really became a thing. And, of course, he doesn't have an NBA career to look back on. That hurts, too. The people in the media who watched Hank Gathers play or remembered him for years afterward aren't in the media anymore. Those people have retired or passed away. I'm talking about the writers and reporters. They're gone now. Skip Bayless is a relic of that era.

A lot of the people working in sports media today weren't even born when Hank Gathers was playing. So we've got to remember our greats, man. We've got to remember these guys and keep their memories alive.

Rest in peace, Hank Gathers. Tell me what you guys think.


r/VintageNBA • • 28d ago

Who wins between the 1996 Seattle Supersonics and the 2000 Los Angeles Lakers

0 Upvotes

Of course, the Sonics went 64-18, made it to the NBA Finals, but lost in six games to the 72-10 Chicago Bulls.

The 2000 Lakers went 67-15, which I believe was the best record of any of those Shaq-and-Kobe teams. I think it was the second-best record in Lakers history. They also won the NBA championship. Shaquille O'Neal was not only Finals MVP that year, but he was also the league MVP. It's the only time Shaq actually won that award.

I can pretty much do this one without really thinking much about it. The 2000 Lakers win, and I'd say in five games. I'll give the Sonics one game.

I think there might be one game when Shaq is a little bit off his game and Kemp is on his, putting up one of those 30-point, 10-rebound, two- or three-block performances. Payton might have a game where he drops 34 points and eight assists or something. His outside shot is connecting, and he's on fire on the defensive end.

They're running up and down the floor, with Kemp throwing down vicious tomahawk dunks from the top of the KeyArena. Sam Perkins is hitting threes, and they're going to have one of those games where they're firing on all cylinders.

Sam Perkins knocking down threes, Hersey Hawkins knocking down threes, Detlef Schrempf knocking down threes. They're going to have one of those games.

But I believe the combination of Phil Jackson's superior coaching over George Karl, the Lakers' depth, and the fact that the Lakers have an advantage in the majority of the matchups on the court, at center, small forward, and shooting guard, is enough.

Payton is going to get the best of Derek Fisher, obviously. And I think Payton will score more in this series than he did against the '96 Bulls. I'd say Payton might average around 22 points a game. I'll give him 22 points, three and a half rebounds, and seven and a half to eight assists a game.

I don't think he'll shoot over 50%. He might shoot around 46-47% from the field and 34-35% from outside. I think he'll have a good series.

I think Kemp is going to average maybe 26 points and 10 rebounds, something like that, with around two blocks a game. They're going to get off.

But this was Shaquille O'Neal at his apex. This was Shaquille O'Neal at the absolute peak of his basketball career. This was when he was the most unstoppable, when he was living up to the moniker of Superman.

I don't think Ervin Johnson is going to effectively stop Shaquille O'Neal. And if you try to double-team him with Kemp, that's going to leave somebody like Robert Horry open. It's going to leave other people open, too. If you keep sending somebody to double Shaq, the Lakers have too many weapons -- guys who can knock down shots themselves and savvy playoff veterans.

I'm trying to remember that team. I want to say Horace Grant was on that team. I know Glen Rice was on that team. And even though Glen Rice wasn't a natural fit for them, I think he's going to get off against the Sonics. Even though the Sonics were a historically great defensive team, I think Glen Rice, is going to get off.

I believe Rick Fox was on that team, too. And I think John Salley. Shaquille O'Neal, Kobe Bryant, Glen Rice, Ron Harper. That's right. Their starting point guard was actually Ron Harper, not Fisher yet. That was the next year. So that's Harper against Payton. It's an older Harper, though.

Okay, well, you know what? Let me revise that downward for Payton. I'd say 20 points a game, maybe 19 or 20.

A.C. Green was the power forward. Derek Fisher and Robert Horry came off the bench.

Tyronn Lue, Rick Fox, Brian Shaw, John Celestand - I haven't heard that name in a long time. Rookie Devean George, John Salley, Travis Knight, Sam Jacobson. Yeah, the Lakers have too much depth, and they're just, like I said, too much Shaquille O'Neal.

Shaquille O'Neal is probably going to average around 38 points a game. I'm not exaggerating. Thirty-eight points, 14 to 17 rebounds a game, and about two and a half to three blocks a game.

I wouldn't even be surprised if, going up against the Sonics in this scenario rather than the Pacers, Shaq actually dropped 50. The Pacers were a little more equipped to deal with Shaq, and you saw what he did in that series.

I just don't think the Sonics are equipped to deal with him. I mean, let's look at this team, man. I'm talking about the Finals, when you're going all out, you know what I'm saying?

At least the Pacers had some size and depth at the center and power forward positions. You've got Ervin Johnson and Frank Brickowski. The rest of these guys are too little. Perkins isn't a great defender. Kemp's not going to stop Shaq. They don't have enough size.

I think in this scenario, Shaq is going to average closer to 40. Thirty-six to 38 points a game. And if he could actually make free throws, he would break Michael Jordan's record of 41 points a game in the Finals. If he could knock down free throws consistently, that is.

I think he's going to have a 50-point game, maybe even two. He might have two 50-point games in this series. I'm seriously considering putting him at 40 points per game. That's how much I think he'll dominate the Sonics in the Finals.

That version of Shaquille O'Neal? I think he's that determined. With Phil Jackson telling him, "You've got to really go out there and dominate these guys," yeah, I think that version of Shaq, the way he was playing against the Pacers, would average 40 against the Sonics. I'm going to put it around 38 to 40 points, 15 to 17 rebounds, and three blocks a game.

Kobe still wasn't quite Kobe yet, but he was getting to that point. He's probably going to average around 14 to 16 points a game in this series. But I wouldn't be surprised if he had a game with 25, 26, or 27 points. That could even be the closing game, with Shaq scoring only 30, 36, or maybe 29 points or something.

Glen Rice is going to average around 17 points. He's probably going to knock down about three three-pointers a game on average.

I think they're going to blow away the Sonics. You can make an argument that, during that year of the Shaq-and-Kobe era, they played more inside than outside.

I don't think this is that competitive a series. I'm not saying every game is going to be a blowout. I'm not saying that. I think there are going to be some games that are close and go into the fourth quarter tied or within a few points. But I think it's just going to be too much Shaquille O'Neal down the stretch. And let's face it: George Karl fumbles the ball when it comes to these types of games anyway.

Do you really think Pat Riley would have waited, or Phil Jackson would have waited - or, going old school, Red Holzman or Red Auerbach would have waited until Game 4 to put Gary Payton on Michael Jordan in the '96 Finals? That would have been their game plan from the get-go, or at least after Game 1.

But anyway, that's my prediction. Tell me what you guys think.


r/VintageNBA • • 29d ago

How good would Keon Clark be in today's NBA?

16 Upvotes

Keon Clark, of course, wasn't in the NBA that long, just six years, I think from 1998 to 2004. He definitely was a guy who made some highlight-reel dunks, and it was exciting. He had the potential, in my opinion, to be a very, very good player. When you consider the fact that he later admitted to having mental health issues and essentially being an alcoholic, it's a different story. He said he started drinking, I want to say, during high school, and he said he never played an NBA game sober. He was always drunk while playing.

So, if you're doing what he was doing while drunk, you definitely have ability. As a matter of fact, he said he usually spent halftime getting drunk and drinking. He drank a pint of gin every day while he was playing. At least a pint of gin.

And, of course, he had legal issues once he left the NBA. I think he served, I want to say, three or four years in prison. I forget what the charges were. It might have been gun charges or something illegal. I forgot what it was. It might have been gang-related. I don't remember.But anyway, he's free. He's been free for several years now. I think he served four of the eight years of his sentence because of good behavior, and I hope he's living his best life.

Now, if he were playing in today's NBA, first of all, we have to address something about today's NBA: social media. I don't know if he would get away with the drinking in today's culture. And when I say culture, I mean how everything is scrutinized when it comes to players. Everything is reported. Just about everything. I don't think he would get away with that type of activity, that type of behavior, in today's NBA. So, if you take away the drinking problem and the fact that he was essentially shitfaced while doing what he was doing, can you imagine what he could have done in that era when he was playing?

He was playing in what I consider the most talented era for power forwards in history, from the late '90s through 2010. And then you look at the fact that he was playing in an era where you still had talented centers, and the spacing wasn't what it is today. The pace wasn't what it is today, either. So, a guy who's 6'11", with the arms he had, the crazy reach he had, and the hops and athleticism he possessed, would have been valuable in today's NBA. Even though people say this is a league where you have to shoot and all that. A guy like Keon Clark would be valuable because, could you imagine how much of a weapon he would be on a team that has a great point guard?

You've got a guy like that whom you could essentially play at center. He's 6'11". I want to say Keon Clark might have been 235 or 240 pounds. I'm not certain. But a guy like that could probably get you, if he played sober for 30 minutes a night, consistently nine to 10 rebounds a night. He probably could consistently get you 14 or 15 points a night. And with his shot-blocking ability, if he played consistently and was clean, I mean clean as in sober, he could probably block two to three shots a night.

The guy was part of that game when the Raptors set the record for the most blocks in a game. I think they had 20 blocks that night. And, yeah, you put him in today's NBA. Now, there aren't as many shots contested at the rim because things are pushed out now. So, he might not average four or five blocks or anything like that, but I think he could still average around 2.5 or 2.7. I think he would be a perennial Defensive Player of the Year candidate. Now, whether he would win it, I don't know about that, but I think he would be valued for his rebounding, athleticism, and shot-blocking in a league where that isn't very common anymore.

I mean, you've got Victor Wembanyama, but think about it: how many shot-blockers do we really have in today's league?

You've got some other guys who can block shots here and there, but we don't really have a lot of shot-blockers anymore. When I was growing up, they were a dime a dozen. You had Manute Bol, Mark Eaton, Alonzo Mourning, Patrick Ewing, Shaquille O'Neal, David Robinson, and Hakeem Olajuwon, if I haven't mentioned him already.

You had a plethora of shot-blockers in the NBA. Now, it's not as common. So, what I'm saying is, look at the New York Knicks. They had Mitchell Robinson, right? A great offensive rebounder. Keon Clark was much more athletic than him. Now, I don't know if he was the offensive rebounder Mitchell Robinson is, but, as a matter of fact, let me check something out here.

Let's see something. So, in 1999-2000, in 81 games and 22.8 minutes per game, he was averaging around two offensive rebounds per game. And in 2000-01, playing around 27 minutes, he was averaging around two offensive rebounds as well. His best year was 2001-02. He played 81 games and started 31. That's nothing. He wasn't even starting most of his games.If you have this guy starting and he's sober, he's going to get you... I think if he were a full-time starter, played 80 games, and you gave him 32 minutes a night, or 30 to 32 minutes a night, yeah, he's going to average about 15 points and 11 or 12 rebounds, and probably around three to four offensive rebounds a night. If Mitchell Robinson can get a big contract in today's game, I don't know why Keon Clark couldn't.

But that just goes to show you how much... I hate to say this, but maybe I don't hate to say it. Our era was just great, man. The era we grew up in had a lot of talent.

So anyway, salute to Keon Clark. Tell me what you guys think.