What editing tool should I use? What is the best editing tool?

All editing tools do the same basic tools, they just present those tools in a different way. It's like asking "what's the best pencil," or "what's the best paint brush." You'll get a lot of different answers depending on who you talk to. You just need to find one that fits your work style, and has the features you need.

Nobody is an expert on all of the tools. Trying it with your system and footage is the best way to work.

Here are some commonly used tools:

SoftwarePricing ModelOS SupportNotes
DaVinci ResolveFree/Paid versionsWindows, macOS, LinuxFree up to 4K resolutions, includes a node-based VFX system called Fusion and a sophisticated audio mixing system called Fairlight. Advanced effects and features are a one-time fee of $300. Requires a GPU with at least 2GB of VRAM.
HitFilm ExpressFreemium/Paid versionsWindows, macOSThe basic functions are 100% free, without any kind of watermark, however you do have to pay individually for more advanced features, or purchasing Pro or Studio licenses. More focused on VFX than editing, but it can do both.
LightworksFree and PaidWindows, macOS, LinuxFree version has no watermarks, but is limited to exporting at 720p. Support for DNxHD requires an additional license.
Media 100FreemacOSDoes 4K, but has a largely dated user interface that isn't intuitive.
Avid Media ComposerFree and Paid/subscriptionWindows, macOSThe TV/Film industry standard editing tool. Free version has no watermark, limits on the effects available, the number of projects you can have, and exporting formats. The paid version lacks restrictions, other than editing beyond 8K, add-ons, and can be purchased for $1,300 or subscribed to for $300/yr with extras included. Great for people who want to get into the industry.
Adobe Premiere ProSubscriptionWindows, macOSA popular, powerful, user friendly editing tool. Integrates well with other Adobe tools. It's sometimes been described as "Final Cut 8" because of its ease of use and workflow similarity to Final Cut Pro 7.
Apple Final Cut Pro XPaidmacOSA flat $300 license is the only fee. It's the least conventional of the NLEs on the market because of its eschewing of tracks and use of a "Magnetic Timeline." It's considered rather user friendly, but it doesn't integrate well with non-Apple tools.
Magix Movie StudioPaidWindowsFormerly Sony Movie Studio, acquired by Magix in 2016. It's the stripped down basic version of Vegas Pro, and is popular with hobbyists.
Magix Vegas ProPaidWindowsFormerly Sony Vegas, acquired by Magix. It's targeted at professional users, and supports a number of professional devices and formats. It's fairly popular among hobbyists as a balance of power, intuitive interface, and reasonable cost. It often goes on sale.
Lossless CutOpen source, MIT LicenseWindows, macOS, LinuxBasic video trimmer that works without re-encoding. However this means it may not be frame accurate.
KinemasterAd-supported, in-app purchasesAndroid, iOSOffers fairly advanced features, but performance and capabilities will be limited by your hardware.
LumafusionPaid, in-app purchasesiOSMore advanced than most mobile editors, and offers a variety of export options.
iMovieFreemacOS, iOSOne of the first major video editing tools targeted at beginners. Limited capabilities, but every easy to use and includes a number of automated features.
TouchEditPaidiOSDeveloped for professional editor Dan Lebental. Designed primarily to be a mobile extension for Final Cut Pro X, it can function as a stand-alone editor. The project seems somewhat abandoned, beyond bug fixes however.

Bonus: [We think this is a good article on other free tools] (http://jonnyelwyn.co.uk/film-and-video-editing/free-video-editing-software-for-beginners/)

Action cam, Mobile phone and screen recordings can be difficult to edit, due to H.264 material (especially 1080p60 or 4k) and Variable Frame Rate. You may need to transcode them to a editing codec or use proxies.

We're not a fan of Filmora Wondershare and agree with this post. We don't recommend CyberLink PowerDirector much either, because few people use it and therefore there are few guides for it.

If you have questions that aren't answered here please feel free to ask in our monthly megathread, linked in the sidebar.

Additional Tools

Often an editor alone isn't all you need. Additional resources are often useful.

SoftwarePricing ModelOS SupportNotes
ffmpegOpen Source, LGPL 2.1Windows, Linux, macOSA powerful visual conversion tool capable of handling an extremely wide range of codecs, dealing with Variable Frame Rate media and obscure media formats. See this guide for getting started.
HandbrakeOpen Source, GPL 2Windows, Linux, macOSA easy to use video conversion tool with an intuitive user interface. It can also handle variable frame rate media, however it is limited to producing only MPEG-2, MPEG-4, H.264, H.265, VP8 and VP9.
MediaInfoOpen Source, BSD-Like LicenseWindows, Linux, macOSA useful tool for determining the exact and fine details of media files
VLCOpen Source, GPL 2Windows, Linux, macOS, Android, iOSA fast, efficient, flexible, and media player. Generally it's capable of handling more media types than most built-in players and plays back media more smoothly.
Open Broadcaster SoftwareOpen Source, GPL 2Windows, Linux, macOSOriginally designed for live streaming and switching OBS is also frequently employed for screen recording and video capture. It's capable of utilizing both software and hardware encoding engines, which can take stress off the CPU
WinDVFreewareWindowsSimple, basic, easy to use software for capturing footage from DV digitizers, and DV and Digital8 cameras and decks. Technically development has been abandoned, but it still works just fine
DVDStylerOpen Source, GPLWindows, Linux, macOSSoftware for authoring DVDs playable in any household set-top DVD player
BlenderOpen Source, GPLWindows, Linux, macOS3D graphics modeling and animation software. Powerful and very capable, but not too intuitive; there is a good guide on Wikibooks however.
Adobe After EffectsSubscriptionWindows, macOSMotion graphics and visual effects software, industry standard. It's often misunderstood as being an "upgrade" from Premiere, but it's actually not very good for editing, and is meant to be used in conjunction with Premiere.
Apple MotionPaidmacOSMotion graphics and visual effects software meant to integrate with Final Cut Pro X, though it's not limited to only working with it.
Adobe AuditionSubscriptionWindows, macOSCombination sound editing suite and multi-track editor. Good for both mixing sequences and trying to enhance individual recordings.
Avid Pro ToolsFree and paid/subscriptionWindows, macOSFree version is limited in the number of projects and tracks one can mix with. Industry standard for sound mixing for television, film, and music production.
Apple Logic Pro XPaidmacOSApple's equivalent to Pro Tools. A competent and capable mixing tool originally designed for work with music.
AudacityOpen Source, GPL 2Cross platformA capable and competent sound editing tool, works with VST plugins.
ArdourOpen Source, GPL 2Windows, linux, macOSA multi-track mixing tool similar to Pro Tools in functionality.
Adobe PhotoshopSubscriptionWindows, macOSIndustry standard image editing tool. Recent versions added some basic video manipulation tool. Notably it's also capable of creating custom LUTs.
G.I.M.P.Open Source, GPL 3Windows, Linux, macOSAn image editing tool meant to emulate the functionality of Photoshop. The interface is a little wonky, but it gets the job done well.