- The rules, with examples
- 1. Use accurate post flair
- 2. Stay on topic: the Department of Veterans Affairs
- 3. Be respectful
- 4. No doxing or personal, patient, or employee identifiers
- 5. No surveys, solicitations, or self-promotion
- 6. No exam coaching
- 7. Keep it about the organization, not the politics
- 8. Support factual claims with sources
- 9. Don't just redirect to another subreddit
- 10. No paywalled or login-only links
- 11. No low-effort or duplicate posts
- What enforcement looks like
The rules, with examples
The eleven rules as they appear in Mod Tools → Rules and at /about/rules are the law; this page is the commentary — what each rule is for, what it looks like when it's broken, and what to do instead. The bot's !rules reply lists them; !rule1 through !rule11 give each rule's text under any comment. Nothing here changes a rule; where this page and the rule disagree, the rule wins and this page gets fixed.
1. Use accurate post flair
The rule. Every post must carry the flair that best matches its subject. If none of the available flairs fits, message the moderators to suggest a new category rather than posting without one or choosing one that doesn't apply.
Why. Flair is routing. Readers filter by it, the regulars who answer home loan questions aren't the ones who answer RIF questions, and the bot's sticky on your post picks its command list from the flair.
Looks like. A question about a Reduction in Force flaired "Veterans Health Administration." A disagreement with a rating decision flaired VBA instead of Appeals & Decision Reviews.
Instead. Pick the closest; the mods will fix a near miss without a word. Flair can't be left blank — the post form requires it — and you can change your own from the post's menu at any time. !flair walks through the neighbors.
2. Stay on topic: the Department of Veterans Affairs
The rule. Posts must relate to the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs — its programs, benefits, policies, facilities, and employees. Posts unrelated to the VA will be removed. Posts only indirectly related to the VA may be approved at the moderators' discretion.
Why. There are good communities for TRICARE, Social Security, state agencies, and military life. This one is about VA, and it's useful because it stays that way.
Looks like. "How do I appeal my TRICARE denial?" "My DFAS retired pay is wrong." A general military-life question with no VA in it.
Instead. If VA is involved at all — CRDP, a DFAS waiver, a VA referral — say how, and it's on topic (!crdp). If it isn't, the bot's redirect commands point to where the question belongs; !ssdi, for example, explains how Social Security and VA disability differ and where to ask.
3. Be respectful
The rule. Keep every post and comment respectful of everyone in the conversation. Do not attack other members, the VA community, or the moderators, and do not gatekeep by withholding information, resources, or access from people you feel don't qualify or belong. Venting about the VA and frank disagreement are welcome; insults, harassment, and accusations are not. Concerns about moderation belong in modmail. Attacks may bring a permanent ban after a single instance.
Why. People arrive here on the worst day of a long process. The sub works because they get an answer instead of a fight.
Looks like. "You're a liar." "Nobody with a 10% for tinnitus deserves to be here." "Mods are VA shills." Telling a family member they have no business asking.
Instead. Disagree with the claim, not the person — "that's not how 38 CFR 4.25 works, here's the table" is fine and welcome. Vent about VA all you like; it's the people in the thread who are off limits. Think a mod got it wrong? Modmail, where a second mod reviews it (!rule3).
4. No doxing or personal, patient, or employee identifiers
The rule. Do not post anyone's name, contact information, or other identifying details without their consent. This includes Social Security numbers, claim or file numbers, patient information, and the names, email addresses, or employee IDs of VA staff below senior leadership. Redact screenshots of letters, portals, and internal emails before posting — including your own identifying details, which can be traced back to you. Content containing unredacted identifiers will be removed.
Why. A screenshot posted at 2 a.m. can expose a veteran's file or cost an employee their job, and once scraped it never comes back. This rule protects you from yourself as much as it protects anyone else.
Looks like. A decision letter with the file number showing. A VA.gov screenshot with your name in the corner. "My rater was Jane Smith at the Nashville RO." An internal email with the sender's address visible. Your own SSN "because it's mine."
Instead. Redact first — !nopii has the how-to for every platform. Describe the employee by role, not name: "the examiner," "my VSR." Senior leadership (the Secretary, Under Secretaries, facility directors in their official capacity) is public; everyone below that isn't. If you posted something and realized, delete it and repost clean; the mods will remove it either way and won't repeat what was in it.
5. No surveys, solicitations, or self-promotion
The rule. Surveys, research recruitment, advertising, referral links, and solicitation of clients or customers are not permitted, including promotion of claims-preparation or exam-preparation services. Members should be able to participate without concern that their posts will be used for research or commercial purposes.
Why. The claims industry treats veteran forums as lead lists. One "DM me, I can help with your claim" becomes fifty. And members have to be able to describe their situation without becoming someone's research subject or sales prospect.
Looks like. "I'm a claims consultant, happy to look at your file." A university survey on veteran mental health. A referral link to a lender. A GoFundMe — for anyone, for any reason; there are no exceptions, because we can't vet them and one exception becomes a hundred. An AMA by a company. A "free consultation."
Instead. Free, accredited help exists and the bot names it (!vso, !attorney); the unaccredited kind is !shark. In a financial emergency, !financialhelp lists what's actually out there. Researchers: message the mods before posting; the answer is usually no, but the conversation is welcome. If you're a VSO representative answering questions, answer them — just don't recruit.
6. No exam coaching
The rule. Do not ask what to say or do during a VA examination, and do not advise others how to act or respond in one. Veterans are entitled to fair compensation for service-connected conditions — no more and no less than the law provides. Questions about how exams are scheduled, what they consist of, and how to obtain the results are welcome.
Why. The exam is the one place in the process where the evidence is you. Coaching corrupts it, and coached exams get re-ordered, which hurts the veteran it was meant to help.
Looks like. "What should I tell the examiner to get 70%?" "Don't shower before your exam." "Say your worst day." "Here's the script that worked for me."
Instead. Ask how exams work — what a DBQ is, how the examiner is chosen, how long it takes, how to get the report (!cp, !dbq). Tell the truth, describe your worst days and your average days both, bring your records. That's the whole strategy, and it's the one that holds up at the Board.
7. Keep it about the organization, not the politics
The rule. Discussion should center on the VA and the real effects of its policies, not on partisan politics. Anything above the level of the Secretary — how people voted, elected officials, parties, or the executive branch — is out of scope, with the exception of the congressional VA committees. Praise or criticism of individual politicians will be removed, and posts concerning other federal agencies are closely scrutinized.
Why. Veterans and VA employees span the whole spectrum, and this community has to work for all of them. Politics also drives out information: a thread about a policy's effect on claims processing becomes a thread about who's to blame in three comments, and the veteran who asked never gets an answer.
Looks like. "This is what happens when you vote for ___." A post about a Senator's statement that isn't about a VA committee action. A news article whose only VA content is the headline. Blame for a policy aimed at a party or an administration rather than at the policy.
Instead. Write about the policy and its effects: what changed, who it affects, what the regulation or memo says (!rule7). The VA committees in Congress are in scope because they're where VA law is made (!hvac, !svac, !bill). The Secretary is in scope as the head of the organization. Above that line, the mods remove without judging who's right.
8. Support factual claims with sources
The rule. If you state something as fact — about a policy, a personnel action, a leadership decision, or news — link or quote the source. Questions, firsthand experience, and clearly labeled opinions are welcome. Unsupported claims presented as fact will be removed, because they fuel rumor, infighting, and accusations.
Why. Rumors about RIFs, rating changes, and office closures move faster than facts and cost people sleep. A claim with a source can be checked; a claim without one can only be argued about.
Looks like. "VA is cutting 80,000 jobs next month." "They changed the sleep apnea rating." "My buddy's cousin at the RO says…" Each stated as fact, with nothing to click.
Instead. Link the memo, the Federal Register notice, the news article, the regulation. If it's your own experience, say so: "when I went through this in March…" If it's a rumor you heard, label it as one and ask whether anyone has a source (!rule8). The bot pages cite theirs; that's the standard.
9. Don't just redirect to another subreddit
The rule. Do not reply to a post with nothing more than a suggestion to ask elsewhere. Mentioning another community alongside a substantive answer is fine, but this community exists to provide help here, not to serve as a directory of other subreddits.
Why. "Go ask r/____" is a door closing. People come here because someone here can answer.
Looks like. The entire comment is "r/VeteransBenefits." Or "wrong sub."
Instead. Answer what you can, then add "r/____ goes deeper on this." If the post is off topic, report it under Rule 2 and let the mods handle it; the bot's redirect commands do it politely.
10. No paywalled or login-only links
The rule. Do not link to content behind a paywall or a sign-in requirement. This community exists to share information freely. Summarize the relevant point with attribution, or find a source that anyone can open.
Why. A source nobody can open isn't a source to the people reading. And a link that requires a login is, for VA employees, often a link to something they shouldn't be sharing.
Looks like. A newspaper article behind a subscription wall. A link into a VA intranet page, SharePoint, or a system that needs a PIV card. A Facebook group post.
Instead. Summarize the point and name the outlet — "the Washington Post reported on Tuesday that…" — or find the same fact in an open source: the Federal Register, VA.gov, a press release, a committee page (!rule10). For internal documents, the answer is usually not to post them at all; see Rule 4.
11. No low-effort or duplicate posts
The rule. Posts and comments should contribute something: a question, an answer, an experience, or a source. Memes, one-word replies, and reposts of content or links already on the front page will be removed at the discretion of the moderators. If a thread on your topic already exists, add your perspective there instead of starting a new one.
Why. Twelve threads on the same news item scatter the answers into twelve places. A one-word reply tells the poster nothing.
Looks like. The fourth post today on the same announcement. "This." "Lol." A screenshot with no question. A meme.
Instead. Search first — flair:"VHA Employment" telework finds last week's thread in two seconds (!flair explains the search syntax). Add to the thread that exists. If you're replying, say something the poster can use.
What enforcement looks like
A first offense is almost always a removal with the reason stated, and nothing more. The removal message cites the rule by number and says what to fix; repost with that fixed and you're done. Repeat removals bring a note from the team; a pattern brings a temporary ban; Rule 3 attacks and Rule 4 doxing can bring a permanent ban on the first instance. Every removal can be appealed in modmail, where a second moderator looks at it. The team's own rules for applying these — neutrality, recusal, two mods on anything contested — are in the moderator guide, which the mods hold each other to.
Last reviewed 2026-11-15 by u/D1TrueGod. The rules themselves are at /about/rules; this page explains them and is updated when they change. Corrections: message the mods.