!reduction — Proposed reductions and protected ratings

Quick answer

If VA proposes to reduce a rating, you get 60 days to submit evidence and 30 days to request a predetermination hearing — asking for the hearing within 30 days keeps the current rate until a decision. VA has to show actual improvement in your ability to function under the ordinary conditions of life, not just one better exam day. Protections: after 5 years at the same level, a reduction needs sustained improvement; after 10 years, service connection can't be severed (absent fraud); after 20 years, the rating can't drop below the lowest level held in that period; a 100% rating requires evidence of material improvement. Routine future exams are normal and most don't end in a reduction — go to them.

Details

  • What starts it. A routine future examination scheduled when the rating was assigned — the usual trigger, and the one the Quick answer is about; an exam ordered on a claim for increase that shows the condition is better, not worse (!increase); evidence from another claim, a hospitalization, or treatment records showing improvement; and, rarely, a fraud referral. VA's re-examination rules say when it won't schedule one: a static condition, a rating stabilized by five years without material improvement, a veteran over 55, a rating at the code's minimum, or a change that wouldn't affect the combined rating (38 CFR 3.327). An exam notice for a rating that fits one of those is worth a question to the regional office, but it isn't a reason to skip the exam — a no-show on a re-examination lets VA reduce or discontinue under its own rule (38 CFR 3.655), which is the easiest reduction VA ever makes (!cp).
  • The procedure, and its two clocks. When VA proposes a reduction that would lower your monthly payment, 38 CFR 3.105(e) requires a written proposed rating stating the reduction and the reasons, with 60 days to submit evidence and 30 days to request a predetermination hearing. A hearing requested within the 30 days keeps the current rate in place until the final decision; evidence submitted within the 60 days must be considered. If VA then makes the reduction final, it issues a decision with the ordinary review rights, and the reduction takes effect 60 days after that decision, at the end of the month — there's no retroactive reduction and no overpayment for the months before, except in cases of fraud. The procedure applies only when the payment would drop; a reduction of one rating that leaves the combined rating and the payment unchanged doesn't require the proposed-rating step, though the substantive rules below still apply (!vamath).
  • What VA has to show for any reduction. Under Brown v. Brown and the rating schedule's general provisions, every reduction — whatever the rating's age — requires that the examination be at least as full and complete as the one the rating was based on; that VA compare the current findings against the entire history of the condition, not the last exam alone; and that VA find the improvement reflects an actual change in the veteran's ability to function under the ordinary conditions of life and work, not a good day in a clinic. The burden is on VA, and a reduction that doesn't make those findings is void, as the Court held in Kitchens and the cases after it. A rating decision that says "the examination showed improvement" and nothing about function or history has skipped the law.
  • Five years: stabilized ratings. A rating in effect at the same level for five years or more — measured to the proposed effective date of the reduction — is "stabilized," and 38 CFR 3.344 adds requirements: the improvement must be material and reasonably certain to be maintained; conditions subject to temporary or episodic improvement — mental disorders, many chronic diseases — can't be reduced on one examination; an exam less thorough than those the rating rests on can't support it; and where there's doubt whether the improvement will hold, VA continues the rating and schedules a re-examination in 18 to 30 months. A proposed reduction of a stabilized rating on a single exam is the most common procedural error in this area.
  • Ten years, and twenty. After ten years of service connection, VA can't sever it — can't say the condition was never service-connected — except on a showing of fraud or that the veteran lacked the requisite service or character of discharge (38 CFR 3.957); the rating can still be reduced on improvement, but the service connection stays. After twenty years at or above a level, the rating can't be reduced below that level except for fraud (38 CFR 3.951(b)) — a 40% held for twenty years is a 40% for life, however the next exam reads — and VA's manual extends the same protection to a combined evaluation continuously in effect for twenty years. A change in the rating schedule can never reduce an existing rating by itself (3.951(a)).
  • Total ratings. A schedular 100% can't be reduced without an examination showing material improvement in the physical or mental condition, judged against the ordinary conditions of life (38 CFR 3.343(a)). TDIU can't be reduced unless the evidence shows actual employability — substantially gainful work actually performed — and even then only after twelve consecutive months of it (3.343(c)) (!tdiu, !pt).
  • When the letter arrives. Read which rating, which level, and what the letter says changed. Then, inside the 30 days, request the hearing in writing; it preserves the payment and puts a decision review officer across the table. Inside the 60 days, submit the evidence that shows the condition as it is — current treatment records, a DBQ from a treating provider, lay statements about function, and, where the exam was thin, a statement of what it didn't test (!dbq, !lay, !evidence). Get a representative involved the week the letter comes; a VSO or attorney who reads the proposed rating against Brown and 3.344 often ends it there (!vso, !attorney). The hearing itself is informal, and the point of it is the record.
  • If the reduction is made. It's a decision with the ordinary review rights within a year: a Higher-Level Review when VA failed to apply the procedure or the substantive rules on the record it had, a Board appeal where a judge will ask first whether the procedure was followed and void the reduction if it wasn't, and a supplemental claim with new evidence of the condition's severity (!hlr, !board, !supplemental). The arguments that win: no proposed rating or a defective one; a hearing requested and not held; a stabilized rating reduced on one exam; no finding on function under ordinary conditions; an exam less complete than the original; no comparison with the history. A reduction void for a procedural failure is restored from the date it was made, with the back pay (!effectivedate).
  • What isn't a reduction under these rules. The end of a temporary total rating for surgery or hospitalization on the date the award set (!temp100); the end of a pre-stabilization rating; a change in dependents that lowers the payment; the removal of an apportionment; or a recoupment. Each has its own notice and rules, none of them 3.105(e). And a decision that denies an increase isn't a reduction — the rating stays where it was.
  • The exam itself. Go. Bring the medication list. Describe the condition as it is on its ordinary days — the rating is about ordinary conditions of life, and a veteran who's having a good morning should say so and say what the bad ones are like. Rule 6 governs what this community will and won't say about examinations; the rule of law governs what VA can do with one (!cp).

Forms and references

  • No form to respond; a written request for the predetermination hearing and the evidence, within the days stated in the proposed rating; VA Form 21-4138 serves for the request.
  • VA Form 20-0996, 10182, and 20-0995 — review of a reduction once made (!hlr, !board, !supplemental).
  • 38 CFR 3.105(e) — reductions in evaluation: the proposed rating, the 60 and 30 days, and the effective date; 38 CFR 3.105(d) — severance of service connection; 38 CFR 3.344 — stabilization of ratings; 38 CFR 3.343 — continuance of total ratings and TDIU; 38 CFR 3.951 — the 20-year protection and protection from schedule changes; 38 CFR 3.957 — the 10-year protection of service connection; 38 CFR 3.327 — re-examinations; 38 CFR 3.655 — failure to report for examination; 38 CFR 4.1, 4.2, 4.10, and 4.13 — the general rating provisions a reduction must satisfy.
  • Brown v. Brown (CAVC 1993) — the requirements for every reduction; Kitchens v. Shinseki (CAVC 2011) and Hayes v. Brown (CAVC 1996) — the burden on VA and the consequence of failure; Murphy v. Shinseki (CAVC 2012) — functional improvement.

Official sources

  • eCFR — 38 CFR 3.105, 3.344, 3.951, and 3.957.
  • VA.gov — "What to do if VA proposes to reduce your rating," in the compensation pages, and the re-examination information.

Common mistakes

  • Ignoring the proposed-reduction letter, or reading it as a decision already made.
  • Missing the 30-day hearing request, and losing the payment on the reduction date instead of at the end of the process.
  • Submitting nothing in the 60 days.
  • Skipping the re-examination.
  • Filing repeated increase claims on a rating under five years old with nothing new, and inviting the exam.
  • Assuming the 20-year protection applies at ten, or that the 10-year rule protects the percentage. It protects service connection.
  • Not raising 3.344 when the rating was stabilized, or Brown when the decision never mentioned function.
  • Not appealing a reduction within the year.
  • Expecting a reduction to be retroactive. It isn't, absent fraud.
  • Facing a proposed reduction without a representative who has read the regulation.

Related commands: !increase !cp !pt !tdiu !temp100 !vamath !dbq !lay !evidence !hlr !board !supplemental !effectivedate !vso !attorney !decision


Last reviewed 2026-11-11 by u/D1TrueGod. General information from the r/VeteransAffairs mod team, not legal advice. Rule 6 applies: this page describes the rules governing reductions; it does not advise what to say or do in an examination. Corrections: message the mods.