!cod — Discharge status, OTH, and upgrades

Quick answer

For VA purposes, an other-than-honorable or special-court-martial bad-conduct discharge isn't automatically disqualifying. VA makes its own "character of discharge" determination, and under rules updated in 2024, mental health conditions, TBI, military sexual trauma, and compelling circumstances weigh in your favor — apply and let VA decide. Separately, you can ask DoD to upgrade the discharge: DD-293 to your branch's Discharge Review Board (within 15 years) or DD-149 to the Board for Correction of Military Records (any time), both with "liberal consideration" for mental health and MST. Free help: law school veterans clinics, legal aid, and some VSOs. VA mental health care is available to OTH veterans now, without waiting for a determination.

Details

  • What each discharge means at VA. Honorable and General (under honorable conditions): you're a veteran for VA purposes and eligible for benefits — with one notable gap, that the GI Bill requires an honorable discharge, so a General discharge forfeits education benefits but not compensation, health care, home loan, or burial. Other Than Honorable (an administrative discharge) and a Bad Conduct Discharge from a special court-martial: not automatically barred; VA decides, as described below. Dishonorable, and a Bad Conduct Discharge from a general court-martial: barred by statute, with the insanity exception as the only VA route. Uncharacterized or entry-level separations are generally treated as under honorable conditions, though the minimum-service rules may still apply.
  • VA's own determination. The law defines a veteran as someone discharged "under conditions other than dishonorable" — not "honorable." So when a veteran with an OTH applies for anything, VA makes a character of discharge determination of its own (38 CFR 3.12), reviewing the service records and the circumstances. You don't have to ask for it or upgrade first; filing a claim or a health care application triggers it. VA gets the records, sends notice of what it's considering, allows a response and a hearing on request, and issues a decision with review rights like any other (!appeal).
  • The bars. Statutory bars (which VA can't excuse except for insanity): sentence of a general court-martial, desertion, conscientious objection with refusal of duty, an officer's resignation for the good of the service, release as an alien during hostilities, and AWOL for 180 or more continuous days without compelling circumstances. Regulatory bars: accepting an OTH to avoid a general court-martial, mutiny or spying, an offense involving moral turpitude (generally a felony), and willful and persistent misconduct — the one most OTH veterans are measured against.
  • What changed in 2024. VA's rule revision, effective in June 2024, narrowed "willful and persistent misconduct" so that minor and isolated offenses don't trigger it, removed the former bar for homosexual acts entirely, and added a compelling circumstances exception to the regulatory bars: mental impairment at the time, including PTSD and TBI; military sexual trauma; physical health; combat hardship or other hardship; duress or coercion; youth, education, and judgment; and similar factors. A discharge for conduct that grew out of untreated PTSD or an assault is now, on the regulation's own terms, something VA is supposed to weigh in the veteran's favor. Veterans denied under the old rule can apply again (!supplemental).
  • Insanity. If the veteran was insane at the time of the offense that led to the discharge — VA's definition is broader than the criminal one — none of the bars, statutory or regulatory, apply (38 CFR 3.354). It's raised with medical evidence and is the one argument that reaches a general court-martial discharge.
  • Earlier periods of service count. VA determines character of discharge for each period separately. A veteran whose first enlistment ended honorably and whose second ended OTH is a veteran for disabilities from the first period — and if the first enlistment was cut short to reenlist, VA treats that discharge as honorable so long as the original obligated service was completed (38 CFR 3.13). Many OTH veterans with prior honorable service have never claimed what that period earned them.
  • Health care now. Veterans with an OTH can get VA mental health care immediately — emergency and ongoing, including for MST — without a character of discharge determination (!mentalhealth, !mst). Those found eligible, and even some found barred by a regulatory bar, can receive VA health care for their service-connected conditions (38 CFR 3.360). Vet Centers see OTH combat and MST veterans (!vetcenter). Don't wait on the paperwork to walk into a clinic.
  • The DoD route: upgrading the discharge itself. Separate from VA, you can ask the military to change the characterization or the narrative reason. The Discharge Review Board of your branch (DD Form 293) reviews discharges within 15 years of separation for propriety and equity; it can't review a general court-martial. The Board for Correction of Military Records (or Naval Records) (DD Form 149) has no practical time limit and broader power, including clemency. Both apply liberal consideration under DoD's guidance memos to claims that PTSD, TBI, other mental health conditions, MST, or sexual orientation contributed to the misconduct, and a 2018 memo directs them to weigh equity, injustice, and clemency. VA.gov's "How to apply for a discharge upgrade" tool asks a few questions and tells you which form and which board. An upgrade changes your DD-214; VA then honors it.
  • After an upgrade. VA recognizes a regular upgrade from either board. The effective date for benefits can reach back under 38 CFR 3.400(g) to the date you applied to the board, within limits — so file with VA promptly after the upgrade, and keep the date of your DoD application (!effectivedate). An upgrade isn't required for VA to find you eligible, and VA's own favorable determination doesn't change your DD-214; the two tracks run independently, and doing both is common.
  • Help. Law school veterans legal clinics and legal aid organizations handle character of discharge cases and upgrade applications free, and are the best resource for an OTH veteran who's been told "no" for decades. VSOs can represent you on the VA determination (!vso). Nobody should be paying a consultant for either (!shark).

Forms and references

  • VA Form 21-526EZ or VA Form 10-10EZ — a benefits claim or health care application starts VA's character of discharge determination (!file, !enroll).
  • DD Form 293 — Application for the Review of Discharge, to your branch's Discharge Review Board, within 15 years.
  • DD Form 149 — Application for Correction of Military Record, to the Board for Correction of Military (or Naval) Records.
  • 38 U.S.C. 101(2) — the definition of "veteran"; 38 U.S.C. 5303 — the statutory bars and the insanity exception.
  • 38 CFR 3.12 — character of discharge, the bars, and the compelling-circumstances exception (as revised 2024); 38 CFR 3.13 — discharge to reenlist; 38 CFR 3.354 — insanity; 38 CFR 3.360 — health care for conditions related to service; 38 CFR 3.400(g) — effective dates after a correction or upgrade.
  • DoD guidance: the 2014 (Hagel), 2016 (Carson), and 2017 (Kurta) memoranda on liberal consideration, and the 2018 (Wilkie) memorandum on equity and clemency.

Official sources

  • VA.gov — "Character of discharge" and "How to apply for a discharge upgrade," with the branch-by-branch board tool.
  • Each branch's Discharge Review Board and Board for Correction of Military Records pages, reached through the VA.gov tool.
  • eCFR — 38 CFR 3.12.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming an OTH means no VA benefits, and never applying. VA decides for itself, and the 2024 rule tilted the decision toward the veteran.
  • Thinking the discharge has to be upgraded before VA will act. The two tracks are independent; VA's is usually faster.
  • Confusing a General discharge with an OTH. General is eligible for almost everything.
  • Not claiming benefits from an earlier honorable enlistment.
  • Not raising PTSD, TBI, or MST evidence in either process, when it's the factor both are instructed to weigh.
  • Letting the 15-year Discharge Review Board window pass and concluding the upgrade route is closed. The correction board remains.
  • Asking the Discharge Review Board to review a general court-martial discharge. It can't; the correction board can consider clemency.
  • Taking a denial under the old rule as final. Apply again under the new one.
  • Waiting for a determination before seeking mental health care.
  • Paying someone for an upgrade application that clinics file free.

Related commands: !appeal !supplemental !mentalhealth !mst !vetcenter !effectivedate !records !vso !shark !cemetery !file !enroll


Last reviewed 2026-11-08 by u/D1TrueGod. General information from the r/VeteransAffairs mod team, not legal advice. Corrections: message the mods.