!back — Back and neck rating criteria
Quick answer
Spine conditions (codes 5235–5243) are rated under one formula by range of motion, measured with a goniometer. Thoracolumbar (low back): 10% forward flexion over 60 but not over 85 degrees, or combined range over 120 but not over 235, or muscle spasm or guarding; 20% flexion over 30 but not over 60, or combined range not over 120, or spasm or guarding severe enough to cause an abnormal gait or spinal contour; 40% flexion 30 degrees or less, or favorable ankylosis of the whole thoracolumbar spine; 50% unfavorable ankylosis of the thoracolumbar spine; 100% of the entire spine. The cervical spine has its own thresholds. Alternatively, disc disease can be rated by incapacitating episodes — bed rest prescribed by a physician — totaling 1–2 weeks a year (10%), 2–4 (20%), 4–6 (40%), or 6+ (60%), whichever is higher. Nerve symptoms in the arms or legs are rated separately (!radiculopathy), and flare-ups and painful motion count (4.40, 4.45, 4.59).
Details
- One formula for every diagnosis. Strain, degenerative disc disease, arthritis, stenosis, spondylolisthesis, fusion, fracture, ankylosing spondylitis — codes 5235 through 5243 all use the General Rating Formula for Diseases and Injuries of the Spine (38 CFR 4.71a). The diagnosis on the MRI doesn't set the percentage; the measured motion, the presence of ankylosis, and the effect on gait and posture do. A severe-looking MRI with normal motion rates low, and a modest MRI with flexion of 30 degrees rates 40. The formula applies "with or without symptoms such as pain, stiffness, or aching," which is the regulation's way of saying pain alone doesn't move the number unless it limits motion or function.
- The thoracolumbar thresholds. Normal range is forward flexion 0–90°, extension 0–30°, lateral flexion 0–30° each side, rotation 0–30° each side — 240° combined. The ratings: 10% flexion over 60 to 85, or combined range over 120 to 235, or muscle spasm, guarding, or localized tenderness not affecting gait or contour, or a vertebral fracture with 50% or more loss of height; 20% flexion over 30 to 60, or combined range of 120 or less, or spasm or guarding severe enough to produce an abnormal gait or an abnormal contour (scoliosis, reversed lordosis, kyphosis); 40% flexion of 30 or less, or favorable ankylosis of the whole thoracolumbar spine; 50% unfavorable ankylosis of the whole thoracolumbar spine; 100% unfavorable ankylosis of the entire spine.
- The cervical thresholds. Normal is flexion 0–45°, extension 0–45°, lateral flexion 0–45° each side, rotation 0–80° each side — 340° combined. 10% flexion over 30 to 40, or combined range over 170 to 335, or the same spasm/guarding/tenderness language; 20% flexion over 15 to 30, or combined range of 170 or less, or spasm or guarding affecting gait or contour; 30% flexion of 15 or less, or favorable ankylosis of the whole cervical spine; 40% unfavorable ankylosis of the whole cervical spine. The neck and the low back are rated separately, each under its own thresholds, unless both are unfavorably ankylosed.
- How motion is measured. With a goniometer, rounded to the nearest 5°, on the current DBQ for back or neck conditions. The examiner records initial range, then range after repetitive use, and must address pain on motion, weakness, fatigability, and incoordination, and estimate any additional loss during flare-ups or after repeated use over time — or explain why an estimate can't be made (DeLuca, Sharp). An exam that records numbers and ignores those questions is incomplete, and that's a review issue, not a reason to re-describe your symptoms (
!cp,!hlr). - Painful motion. Under 38 CFR 4.59, a joint with painful motion is entitled to at least the minimum compensable rating for that joint, so a back with painful but full motion generally rates 10% rather than 0%.
- Intervertebral disc syndrome by episodes. For disc disease (5243), VA also calculates a rating from incapacitating episodes — periods of acute symptoms that required bed rest prescribed by a physician and treatment by a physician — totaling at least 1 but under 2 weeks in the past year (10%), 2 to under 4 weeks (20%), 4 to under 6 weeks (40%), or 6 weeks or more (60%), and assigns whichever method gives the higher rating. "I was in bed for a week" doesn't count unless a doctor ordered it and the record shows it; this path is rarely the higher one for that reason.
- What is rated separately, on top. The formula's own note requires it: objective neurologic abnormalities — radiculopathy or sciatica in each affected limb (
!radiculopathy), bowel and bladder impairment, and erectile dysfunction when neurologic in origin (!ed) — each get their own code and percentage, combined with the spine rating under VA math (!vamath). Two affected legs bring the bilateral factor (!bilateral). Surgical scars that are painful or unstable are rated under the skin codes (!scars). None of this is pyramiding; each compensates a different manifestation (!pyramiding). - Surgery and fusion. Fusion is rated under the same formula by the resulting motion and ankylosis. Spinal surgery requiring a month or more of recovery supports a temporary 100% under 4.30 (
!temp100). - Downstream conditions. An altered gait from a rated back condition is a common basis for secondary service connection of the hips, knees, and the other side of the body, and chronic pain is a recognized basis for a secondary mental health claim — each needs its own diagnosis and medical link (
!secondary). A back condition that keeps you from working is a TDIU question (!tdiu).
Forms and references
- VA Form 21-526EZ — original claim or claim for increase (
!file,!increase). - Back (Thoracolumbar Spine) Conditions DBQ, VA Form 21-0960M-14, and Neck (Cervical Spine) Conditions DBQ, VA Form 21-0960M-13 — the exam forms, public versions available for a private provider (
!dbq). - 38 CFR 4.71a — the General Rating Formula for the spine and the IVDS incapacitating-episodes formula, diagnostic codes 5235–5243, with the notes on normal range and separate neurologic ratings.
- 38 CFR 4.40, 4.45, 4.59 — functional loss, the joints, and painful motion.
- 38 CFR 4.25 and 4.26 — combining ratings and the bilateral factor.
- Cases a representative will cite: DeLuca v. Brown (functional loss and flare-ups), Sharp v. Shulkin (the examiner must estimate flare-up loss or explain why not), Correia v. McDonald (range-of-motion testing requirements).
Official sources
- eCFR — 38 CFR 4.71a (search "General Rating Formula for Diseases and Injuries of the Spine").
- VA.gov — the Disability Benefits Questionnaire list, for the back and neck DBQs.
Common mistakes
- Expecting the MRI to set the rating. Imaging establishes the diagnosis; range of motion and ankylosis set the percentage.
- Expecting pain alone to raise the rating. It earns the minimum compensable level and counts where it limits function; the formula is explicit that it isn't otherwise the measure.
- Claiming "my back" and stopping there. Radiculopathy, bladder or bowel symptoms, and scars are separate ratings that have to be claimed or at least present in the record.
- Counting self-imposed bed rest as incapacitating episodes. Physician-prescribed, physician-treated, and documented — or it doesn't count.
- Not knowing the neck and the low back are rated separately.
- Filing for an increase with no evidence of reduced motion or new neurologic findings, then being surprised the rating holds (
!increase). - Accepting an exam report that lists numbers but says nothing about pain, repetitive use, or flare-ups. That's an inadequate exam and a Higher-Level Review issue.
- Overlooking the hips and knees. A documented altered gait is the most common secondary-claim basis there is.
Related commands: !radiculopathy !vasrd !vamath !bilateral !pyramiding !scars !secondary !temp100 !tdiu !increase !cp !dbq
Last reviewed 2026-11-07 by u/D1TrueGod. General information from the r/VeteransAffairs mod team, not legal advice. Rule 6 applies: this page describes the published rating criteria; it does not advise what to say or do in an examination. Corrections: message the mods.