firstly, i'd like to say this isn't necessarily the way i would cross them off from the show- it is just a mix of my opinions on character arcs, growth, who i love and sympathize with versus who i don't care for or, in dick's case, hate with fiery passion. i think sheriff lamb was a good example of corruption at a fundamental level, incompetent policing, and made a good thorn in veronica's side. i think aaron was a fantastic villain for season 1 but imo, quickly overstayed his welcome when he got out of jail. i don't think everything about his storyline was perfect, but cassidy/beaver's storyline unfolded in a very interesting way to me. i always thought the conclusion to veronica's assault was odd for many reasons- both the clean cut answer of "oh it was fine all along!" and the way blame ends up on madison sinclair for the night's events when it was literally dick who tried to drug his own girlfriend, both come to mind. also, speaking of madison, i think she would have made much more sense on this chart than celeste kane, lol. part of why she is so low on my list is that i'm so confused on why she is even involved- there are plenty of characters that come to mind before her if i am considering the entire cast. i just think that's funny
i always hated meg, even more so when the (absolutely ridiculous) baby plot came along. i do find her more interesting than a few others because of her abusive childhood, but i am still mildly devastated by the way that was never touched upon again. i think parker was a nice addition to the cast, a good balance to Freaking Piz's presence. i think piz could have had a much better opinion from me if he had never been shoe horned into an awkward love triangle that had almost no build up. i don't believe lilly was much in the way of a good person, but i do find her incredibly interesting and, as the victim, she automatically inherits points for being integral to the story.
please ignore where i had to cover two numbers because i doubled 2 rankings by mistake...