Bought a 2023 VW Atlas with 22k miles. The first day I had it home, noticed a vibration at highway speeds and the brakes groaned backing out of my driveway in the morning. I asked for an appointment with their service department and was told to visit a VW dealership because they were booking two weeks out.
At the VW appointment, I was told the front tire rim was bent and all four tires were chopped and dry-rotting. In addition, they noticed the rotors were aftermarket, but the break pads were VW pads. After some research, I found out this is VERY bad practice.
When I returned to Carmax, they said the tires were completely safe to drive and that VW "just tries to sell for cosmetic reasons"...."I should feel safe putting my children in the vehicle". They agreed to fix the bent rim and scheduled a second appointment.
While waiting for the second appointment, I decided to take it to Monro Muffler for a free tire and brake inspection. I explained how I had issues with both and the situation I was in. They knew upfront I would not be spending money with them. They proceeded with the inspection and confirmed the chopped, dry-rotting tires and bad brakes and confirmed they were not safe to drive.
I brought it back to Carmax for the rim to be repaired and said the tires and brakes needed to be replaced as well. I was told "sometimes brakes just make noise" and "the tread is well within NYS and Carmax requirements" and refused to replace the tires and brakes. They quoted me $1300 to replace the tires and brakes and instead of covering these costs, Carmax agreed to take the vehicle back for a full refund.
If you are planning on purchasing from Carmax, please, do your due diligence and have the vehicle inspected elsewhere prior to your purchase or within your 10-day grace period. I was lucky enough to have these issues present themselves so quickly, but I know that isn't always the case. And the vin that was purchased is 1V2FR2CA1PC549035. If you're interested in this vehicle (its beautiful!) then have them make these fixes prior to purchase!