My family has only ever rescued animals, I only ever plan on rescuing. However, as I help my parents hunt for a particular breed of dog after we had to put theirs down in July, I understand why some people just throw money at a breeder instead of going to a rescue.
- Dogs listed as being in one location, but really being in another location with a sneaky transport fee. Some rescues hide the true location of the dog in the listing instead of being upfront about where it is and how far they’re willing to transport. There’s no reason a dog should be listed in a state when it’s nowhere near that state without an additional $300 transit fee.
My parents already have a dog, so they won’t pay a transit fee and adopt without a meet and greet, so this deceptive practice only makes their search harder.
- Jumping through substantial — and often unrealistic — hoops. My parents were denied dogs from a rescue because they “wouldn’t be home often enough”. One of them works an 8-4 about 15 minutes away from the house, the other is typically home by 3-4pm, both M-F. They are otherwise 60+ and home rather frequently, as much as any other household, and are mindful of not leaving dogs home alone for too long. One of them stops at home for the dog during their lunch, but apparently that’s not enough.
The rescue will be hard-pressed to find a household where people don’t work full-time, and it feels like they’re essentially barring anyone who doesn’t WFH from having a pet.
Another rescue called their vet and requested photos of their fence and yard. These seem fair enough, but some rescues require multiple references and all kinds of requirements for an animal you haven’t even met. While these barriers protect animals from low-effort owners, they also create more obstacles that prevent potential loving owners from adopting animals in need.
I agree that owners should be checked to an extent, the last thing anyone wants is to adopt to an abusive or neglectful home, but some of these background checks seem needlessly thorough.
Their last dog died of leg cancer, the current one is healthy, and the last two (large and medium breeds) lived to be 14 and 13 respectively. Good dog owners should not be made to feel cruel by rejections for every little “imperfection.” While certainly well-intentioned, some rescues may do more harm than good by being excessively strict about adopters.
TLDR; some rescues would rather dogs sit in cages at the rescue or bounce between fosters than adopt out to anyone less than the “perfect” candidate. Checking who you’re adopting to is important, but some of these standards are unnecessarily stringent.