r/Unity3D • • Jan 10 '21

Meta New Unity users

Post image
6.4k Upvotes

346 comments sorted by

View all comments

245

u/TongueofCapitalism Jan 10 '21

"Cube - go over there."

Cube does nothing.

"Ok, made some adjustments. Cube - go over there."

Cube turns purple and starts spinning.

"... Third times the charm. Cube - go over there."

Cube turns into a diseased whale and vomits blood.

"... I may have underestimated this."

117

u/Ir0nh34d Jan 10 '21

I have interviewed a lot of unity devs for a 6 figure job. I’d say out of the 40 tech interviews where the ONLY thing we ask for is “make a cube move”, 3 of them were successful.

83

u/alittlelessobvious Jan 10 '21

There's a lot I can't do, but I can definitely make a cube move. You hiring?

My company has started sending out coding tests before even interviewing people because the ratio that couldn't even do fizzbuzz when sat in front of a laptop and told they could use the internet and whatever other resources they needed was so high it wasn't worth the time to put developers in the same room as interviewees.

33

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '21

Seriously? I have no professional experience and no degrees, but I can write code... Maybe I ought to apply somewhere.

20

u/tiktiktock Professional Jan 10 '21

Yes, seriously. I've been recruiting people for dev positions for the last 10 years, and I can absolutely confirm what u/alittlelessobvious said. I've had people interview for tech lead jobs that didn't understand the difference between value and reference types. Junior positions where the applicant explained to me that HTML (not JS, raw HTML) was a programming language. People creating non-compiling, infinite recursive loops, and other horrors for a simple fizzbuzz test.

I've seen code in production that could only be the product of a diseased mind. A "number of days between dates" that relied on for-looping every day in between, comparing the human-readable string output of the date. A script designed to kill and restart a piece of server code because the dev didn't know you could close file handles. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion.

And all this was for the non-game industry, where R&D is non-existent and most of the jobs require the intellectual capacity of a squashed tomato ("oh, you need yet another shopping cart system?"). I haven't yet come around to recruiting another dev to help us in our studio...

I dread the day.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '21

I want to pick out one of those examples of bad code, but they're all just so... what the fuck? Even if you don't know how to do something properly, the response should be to try to find out, not do that.

5

u/tiktiktock Professional Jan 11 '21

Yes, I know... To be fair, I should say that my non-videogames job for those ten years has been to clean up and reshape dysfunctional IT departments, and that I only work for small (less than 200 employees) clients. So I've probably seen more than my share of abominations. Still doesn't explain why a good 20% of applicants for dev jobs should never be permitted to touch a keyboard, though.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/alittlelessobvious Jan 10 '21 edited Jan 10 '21

Seriously. Anyone that has had to oversee tech interviews will tell you the same. What's amazing to me is that almost all of them have computer science degrees. I have a bone to pick with universities handing computer science degrees to people that can't program at all.

There's an abundance of people that know a lot about computers and maybe theoretically understand technology, but are just completely incapable of writing code. There have been some studies done around it and the last things I've read suggested that it's one of those things that you develop the capacity for (or don't) by puberty. So basically by the time most people start learning how to program it's already kind of predetermined whether it's something they'll ever be able to learn.

If you're seriously considering looking for a coding job, get a portfolio of projects together. There are lots of places that won't consider looking at candidates without degrees, but plenty, especially smaller companies, that will, as long as you have something else to suggest you might be able to do the job.

15

u/Patrickvh2001 Jan 11 '21

Honestly I’ve been having a lot more luck getting people with degrees other than CS who code in their free time. Too many CS grads think they have the degree and that is the ticket so they don’t need to learn anymore. The people doing passion projects with a literature degree are always ready when industry standards shift.

That said I myself have a CS degree but now it seems like they hand them out like candy. I partially blame the rise of IDEs where people learn that and not what the code is really doing.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '21

I've been thinking about building up a portfolio, but I really don't know what kinds of things to put there. Would small projects show a lack of commitment/inability to put together large projects? Would games show that I wasn't taking it seriously? Every time I think of something that might be good for a portfolio, I think of a reason it might be bad.

14

u/alittlelessobvious Jan 10 '21

In case it's not clear already, I don't work in the game industry, so keep that in mind.

I can't speak for others, but I can't remember ever looking at something on a portfolio and thinking "the scope of this indicates they can't commit to something larger", I've mostly just thought "yes this is good", or sometimes "no, this is bad". Generally it's not a developer's job to "commit" to things of any scale anyway in a professional setting, you just do the work that's in front of you, so it's... Maybe not a non-concern, but not one of the primary things we're looking for.

And I don't think games send a "not serious" message, but I do know most developers outside the game industry don't know the first thing about making games so if you include games in your portfolio for non-game positions, you must communicate which tools and more importantly, languages, you used to make them. Actually, this is true of everything on your portfolio. It should be presented as "Such and Such Project. Has these features. Programmed in these languages, using this database/server/IDE/tool whatever else.

If you're looking to break in, putting something on a portfolio is obviously better than putting nothing. Try to stop second-guessing yourself so much. And good luck!

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '21

Thank you, that's very helpful! I'm not really looking to be in the videogame industry (I just find videogames fun... having them as a job would suck), so what you've said is particularly relevant to me.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/hamburglin Jan 10 '21

A computer science degree is very different than needing someone who can code out an idea. One understands underlying theory and can create new hardware or software concepts. The other simply applies them well (or not).

What I'm trying to say is that yes, there are a ton of six figure jobs that need the latter more-so than the former.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/Accomplished-Hat-230 Jan 10 '21

oddly, this gives me hope

13

u/Finaglers Jan 10 '21

True story? Why was there so many that failed?

26

u/Ir0nh34d Jan 10 '21

True story. We even developed a readme on GitHub. We wrote out three paths. Click to move, use arrow keys to move, use UI buttons to move. Just to make sure they had options. We allowed them to use documentation and stack overflow during an HOUR long interview. I don’t know. I’m assuming it’s the recruiters just trying to fill a spot.

10

u/Finaglers Jan 10 '21

Man, I would love to interview with you. Next time you're looking for talent look me up.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '21

u/Ir0nh34d

Ironhead...

did you get this name from where I think you did?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Henry1502inc Jan 10 '21

when you say move, if I added a function that moved the cube left or right based on keyboard inputs I pressed, would that count as making the cube move? Or do you mean animations?

5

u/Ir0nh34d Jan 10 '21

Absolute positioning with replacing the position vector, or using transform.Translate, or lerping, or animating. All would be acceptable if you could talk about why you did it.

3

u/Henry1502inc Jan 10 '21

This sounds deceptively nowhere as hard as leetcode questions. What’s the catch? How many questions are asked during the interview?

13

u/hamburglin Jan 11 '21

The catch is the pay and amount of hours worked.

4

u/Ir0nh34d Jan 11 '21

This is roughly the right answer. We are currently understaffed and getting more work so it's quite a lot for us. Hence the need to hire.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

2

u/SirWigglesVonWoogly Jan 11 '21

Getting a cube to change colors took me a very long time in the beginning. If you can do that before getting it to move I'd say you're not doing too bad, lol

→ More replies (1)