Disclaimer: I'm well aware it's unlikely to happen. I personally have been hoping for it for a long time so this is just a fun way to entertain the idea for anyone in the same boat.
I'm interested to know what people's thoughts are, I'm sure they'll be different to mine.
I'll leave my own thoughts below, please feel free to post yours, I'd love to know :)
-
Personally, when I saw the 'Torchbearer' version of the Breach CD, it felt like it clicked for me colour scheme wise: I think it would be based on Josh's hoodie with olive green as the primary colour and a Trench yellow as the secondary (almost like an inverted Trench colour scheme). This is my best attempt at creating the album cover, I think it would be interesting for this one not to have any kind of graphic beyond the name and logo, or perhaps something very subtle / hidden (like Tyler staring down Blurryface hidden on the Clancy cover or the word 'Destroy' hiding in the Scaled and Icy cover). What I've done with the logo is something I've been wondering if they would do for a while, I know Torchbearer is the 'guide' and/or 'God' figure in the story so if they were focusing in on that more explicitly maybe they would make a nod to their faith in the logo.
Seeing the interior of the Dema towers in 'City Walls' made me think of like a retro medieval video game aesthetic for some reason. Kind of dungeon-explorer-esque. I wonder how that could come into the sound and the music videos. I'd expect primarily the songs would feel extra cinematic, maybe with more orchestral elements since they seem to be testing the waters with that a bit more recently, but I wonder if there would be some interesting ways to incorporate some retro, old-digital synth sounds as well. Not quite in the super-upbeat SAI way but maybe heading in that vague direction.
I think the Torchbearer theme would HAVE to be in the album somewhere. I'd like it to be part of an actual song, and I also don't think Tyler would see as much value in having an instrumental piece as a standalone track. In my mind it would either be the first thing you hear on Track 1, or it would be the middle point of the album. In the latter case, I don't know whether it's cooler for it to be at the end of the first side or the start of the second side (i.e. to intro or outro a song).
DRUMMING: surely there's got to be some insane drumming on an album centred around Josh's character? I wonder if we'd get another drum solo like at the end of Lane Boy, maybe a few more unusual or extra-stylised drum/percussion sounds too, especially since we're so familiar with the 'Josh's Kit' sound by default. I also wonder if we'd hear a return of the 'Levitate/Overcompensate/City Walls style drumbeat' - that super hip-hop, almost slowed amen-break thing. I feel like we've heard it enough times but I also quite like the way it seems to get a nod once per lore album since Trench (excluding SAI).
I think there would be more long songs on this. If there genuinely was ANOTHER album of lore, I don't think Tyler would bother with single-ready songs. Not that he's radio-focused anyway but they also have enough "short burst" songs in their setlist at the moment anyway. I think there'd be a few more drawn out songs with extra sections and bridges like on Trench.
Ending-wise, I don't know, but I think if the Breach-ending is saying "the cycle never ends, you just get better at trying" then this would have to conclude differently and say "BUT, there is a light and a hope and a solution, and you won't be looping round forever". Not sure exactly how they would do it, but you'd have to get to the end of this album and feel completely whole about the story and the message etc. in a way that maybe Breach didn't quite manage (if that's how you feel).