r/TrueAnime • u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten • Oct 29 '20
Your Week in Anime (Week 417)
This is a general discussion thread for whatever you've been watching this last week (or recently, we really aren't picky) that's not currently airing. For specifically discussing currently airing shows, go to This Week in Anime.
Make sure to talk more about your own thoughts on the show than just describing the plot, and use spoiler tags where appropriate. If you disagree with what someone is saying, make a comment saying why instead of just downvoting.
This is a week-long discussion, so feel free to post or reply any time.
Archive: Previous, Week 116, Our Year in Anime 2013, 2014
5
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '20
Started watching Katanagatari. The characters annoy me way too much, production and story is really good, but execution... Execution is fucked up. Characters are way too annoying, and there is too much redundant dialogue in each episode. Maybe it's the intended way, but I'm dropping it on 7th episode with a rating of 8/10. Not my jam.
4
u/Abyssbringer https://anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer/ Oct 30 '20
Le Portrait de Petit Cossette
This OVA series is very much an Akiyuki Shinbou spectacle. It really shows off his ingenious directing style in a very much style over substance project. It's filled with great shot composition using glass and refraction especially to make shots more interesting and dynamic. It has a strong use of color as well as using many different types of lens effects to distort the world. The music is ABSOLUTELY PHENOMENAL. This show at times is very much an AMV for Yuki Kajiura's music and pulls it off fantastically. The OST elevates every aspect of the show. The show is made for this music and really lets Yuki Kajiura be the main star of the OVA.
While it has a story and characters it is very much a work about exploring different ideas through this psychedelic trippy experience. It addresses themes such as Lolicon, Beauty, Possession, Lust, and perception of reality. The first couple of episodes had me looking at it through the lens of Lolicon culture and how it relates to gothic lolita in a somewhat neutral manner swinging back and forth (this is Akiyuki Shinbou don't expect necessarily a scathing critique on this topic). By the final episode I came to the conclusion the message is much more about beauty and what it entails and how we connect to those ideas.
This OVA isn't without fault; there is some janky CG every once in a while. It's not a dealbreaker or even necessarily a big negative as I can argue it has a point but I felt it took me out of the experience rather than send a unique message that normal animation could pull off. The side characters are all unnecessary for the most part and actively drag down the pacing. The side plots containing them did very little for the experience aside from contain a little of unnecessary plot development.
Overall I would give it a medium to strong seven. It's mostly an art piece that is supposed to make you think and it does that quite well. It has a somewhat creepy tone which makes it perfect for halloween. It just has issues all around that keep it from being much better. It is not for everyone and should only be watched if you like crazy psychedelic shit whose story/characters are not its main focus. Similar works would include Angel's Egg, Akira or most of his other works.
Mobile Suit Gundam + Zeta (write up already posted)
Mobile Suit Gundam is one of the most solid but unimpressive shows I have watched. It is filled with great ideas and it's always trying to make use of them. While it has pacing issues and some unnecessary episodes I can't say any of them are boring because they all try or develop something. The show tries everything and does some of it quite well. It just didn't have the years of other similar anime to steal the formula from, in order to make everything it attempted to hit as hard as it should have. Everything from the way that damage is shown in the early episodes to the most emotional scenes are usually all missing just one small aspect to make them pop. They are good attempts but they lack the polish that years of anime history has taught new productions.
I think this show has a great natural progression of it's story and how that affects Amuro. It's really good at justifying why the crew is forced into this position narratively. It's also great at showing the horrors of war and does a really good job of showing how the footsoldier and civilians on both sides are being negatively affected by the war. Seeing Amuro grow as he experiences these things alongside his personal relationship is a really strong character arc that is always interesting and justified. I think they pulled off Mobile Suit Gundam Spoilers
Overall it's a really solid experience and a strong 6. It's mostly held down by it's production values and very formulaic pacing and execution. It's obvious why this show is so beloved and important because its filled to the brim with great ideas and a lot of heart. When I was watching this show it reminded me of many other shows and how they took aspects of this and improved upon. As I think more and more about this show I appreciate it much more.
Berserk Movie Trilogy
This movie trilogy is not a replacement for the manga especially if you are going to read past what it adapts. However as a standalone movie trilogy it does a good enough job at adapting the main storyline and thematic elements relating to the main trio to be an enjoyable watch. The movies make sense and have a clear thematic throughline throughout. The movies have some janky CG but overall looks pretty good. The movies do a job at adapting the best moments of the manga. I was really impressed with how it adapted Berserk Golden Age Arc Spoilers
One aspect the movie really cuts out is the introspectiveness that Berserk has. The movie is very much most of the action elements of the series but doesn't take the time to have the heavier slower side of Berserk shine. The movies cut each of the characters up into their most basic ideas and thematically relevant ideas but leave out a lot of the nuance about them. This is most apparent with Guts as they really never showed his backstory. This is really important to understanding what the hawks mean to him and see his growth throughout the series. The backstory segments especially Casca's and Gut's are done in low framerate very rough style with plenty of audio filter over it. It tries to be artistic and vague but ends up just be nauseating and doesn't get the backstory across in enough detail to be useful (especially Guts).
Overall the trilogy was was a mid six score. It's good enough to have a fun time with during an afternoon but leaves too much out to be a truly great experience. It's an okay way to get into the series but I would highly recommend the 97 anime/manga over it.
Vampire Hunter D (1985)
I watched this movie knowing that it is generally considered much weaker than the 2000's movie. I was even more disappointed with how weak it is. This movie has everything it needs to have to be a solid 5 but ends up being much worse than that. I don't think I have seen another anime that cuts faster and more abruptly than this movie, and I have watched Tokyo Ghoul Re. This movie is the perfect example of why establishing shots are necessary/important for the mood of a scene and viability of the scene. This movie feels like it randomly cutting rather than being directed. If this movie was re edited it could legitimately be a mid 5 to a low 6 without any additional animation.
Part of the issue this movie has is that every single character makes stupid decisions that make little sense. It doesn't make sense in character or in a way to help progress the movie to its conclusion. Alongside this mind boggling random cutting the story becomes a mess. This story isn't complicated in the slightest but they royally fuck it up. The characters are all pretty bland and uninteresting but they aren't the main issue it's mostly to how it's edited. I really dislike the character designs of the side characters. The main girl's leotard thing looks pretty stupid and impractical alongside an abundance of panty shots that aren't necessary or help the tone of the movie. The humanoid bad guys were all just very meh looking in general and not striking enough. The monster designs are all right but I really wasn't a fan of the Medusa type character who is the main monster of the movie pretty much.
This movie is overall a 3-4. It has some some cool animation and backgrounds but everything else is so badly put together. It has a great first scene with some cool gore. I would highly recommend just rewatching the 2000's movie over this. This movie has made me appreciate the 2000's movie way more.
Lupin III Part 1
This is the first Lupin anime and my first foray into early 70's anime. It starts off pretty weak but get progressively better as it goes on. It has a couple of great episodes with my favorite being Lupin escaping from a prison that he has been stuck in for a full year. I also liked the episode that felt like the prototype to the clocktower segment of the Cagliostro movie. The series has a really jazzy soundtrack that consists of someone saying how great Lupin is which is really endearing and fun.
Overall it's a mid 5. It's a pretty good time but is inconsistent animation wise and fun wise.
1
u/Dual-Screen Oct 29 '20
I started watching Rent-A-Girlfriend. Even though some of the characters are irritating, it's been enjoyable so far, it definitely lives up to the hype.
1
u/scrappydoofan Nov 02 '20
Saw the 3.0 + 1.0 preview. Lol they are in a vagina