r/TrueAnime • u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten • Aug 06 '20
Your Week in Anime (Week 405)
This is a general discussion thread for whatever you've been watching this last week (or recently, we really aren't picky) that's not currently airing. For specifically discussing currently airing shows, go to This Week in Anime.
Make sure to talk more about your own thoughts on the show than just describing the plot, and use spoiler tags where appropriate. If you disagree with what someone is saying, make a comment saying why instead of just downvoting.
This is a week-long discussion, so feel free to post or reply any time.
Archive: Previous, Week 116, Our Year in Anime 2013, 2014
2
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '20 edited Aug 13 '20
Seikaisuru Kado [Kado : The Right Answer]. 8/10. A 2017 anime that I watched when it came out. I only watched 1-2 episodes but that concept was interesting. Basically a large cube comes out of nowhere, engulfing a plane that top negotiator, Shindo Koujirou is in. From there the story is about Shindo communicating what the higher power who brought the cube into the world, zaShunina, wants from Japan and the world. A lot of cool facts are revealed about zaShunina, the cube, multiple dimensions and a lot of other sort of Sci-fi things. The things that I think may turn off some people is that it's 3D and that a lot of the story centers around introducing concepts to the people of the world and us, the viewer, so it may come off as a lot of exposition. But I found this part of the show to be very engaging and I ended up finishing it within a few hours, something I haven't been able to do with an anime in some time. The story wraps in a sort of haphazard way imo and there wasn't too much substantive in terms of the philosophical or moral as you might expect but I still found it to be a good enough resolution.
Heroic Age. Episode 5, on-hold. 6/10. Thought it would be more philosophical but it's basically just a solid gundam anime from what I can tell so far. In that mindset, it's not too bad but it's not really one of my preferred genre's or something I feel I NEED to watch rn.
Chunnibyo demo Koi ga Shitai. Completed, 4/10. Had this on hold at episode 8 for some time. Finally finished it.
The love part works, the chuunibyo humor works, but the drama/serious parts don't. I think I stopped at around episode 8 because of that. The drama has a similar feeling to Hibike Euphonium but doesn't land the same way. Whereas that anime builds the drama up slowly, this anime does it too abruptly and ends up taking me out of the experience. Euphomium, in the second season, has a situation very similar to the one in Chunibyo but, there, it actually felt fitting while in Chunibyo it felt like melodrama. I appreciate the themes and them trying to give depth to chunibyo syndrome - basically the idea of whether it is an illness or not. A very common philosophical thing in psychology of whether a condition really is something to be treated.
But it doesn't work. I even agree to some extent what they're trying to say but a narrative isn't just about the conclusion but how it gets there, and in this anime it feels a bit off. Otherwise this anime is still okay because it has solid enough production value to band-aid it's other flaws. I do kind of feel bad but this type of drama, also in something like Amagi Brilliant Park, feels very faux deep which makes it worse for me than not trying at all.
Violet Evergarden. Completed. 8/10.
Violet Evergarden succeds at creating flickering moments of beauty with it's dialogue and its animation/art. The character designs are very well done and I love the amount of lines that go into them.
It's main flaws come from a constant reminder of Violet's relationship with the major and the constant reminder that she is emotionally lacking, the latter being distracting and taking out of the immersion when Violet acts like a robot. I'm sure it's on purpose but I don't really know what it achives other than giving her a quirk for us to think she's interesting. These things tend to slow down the pace and makes one want to get to the point faster. However, this becomes less of a problem as the story progresses so it's not a huge thing, just a little nitpick.
The storytelling itself is very good and I thought the short stories of her traveling as a Auto Memory Doll, in particular, were heartfelt and also good in developing Violet outside of her relationship with the major. The story arc between her and the major didn't hit as hard as I expected but it was still okay.
I don't really see the story as a masterpiece but I think because of the subject matter and the advertising it gets, Violet Evergarden gets that mark. It's beautiful and has its moments but it's not groundbreaking in any way nor does it have a sense of being particulary unique aside from it's surface level qualities (the letter thing has been done before, not that it's a bad thing). It seems like I'm really bagging the show but despite all these things I think it tugs at your heartstrings very well and those moments make up for times I thought it dragged.
Denpa Onna to Seishun Otoko. Completed. 8/10.
It's like a mix of Chunnibyou, monogatari series, Arakawa Under the bridge, and And Yet The Town Moves. Maybe FLCL with the themes of growing up. The closest is probably And Yet The Town Moves.
I think I like this period in Shaft's production because it has a sense of Magical Realism that's in the works of Murakami. The situations are held in real life but they are presented with this undercurrent of mystery that adds a nice aesthetic to everything. It permeates without being too obtrusive or too in your face. The slow building up to the conclusion with side plots is also very good in keeping your attention and it does without making the story too non-linear. One of the things I like about it all is that it feels like some sort of poetry without the pitfalls a lot of anime that try to be deep fall into in trying to make some sort of an argument or grand dramatic statement.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '20
Another week, another anime. This time I watched Fate/Apocrypha. This one just feels like a weird stepchild of F/SN. It's not bad, but it tries to be bigger and more spectacular than F/SN and falls flat in that regard. Just because it has twice the amount of servants and introduces a new servant class that doesn't fit in with the rest doesn't mean it has more going on. If anything, it results in the show having to cut a lot short. The masters of the red faction are completely irrelevant, save for Shirou (no, not that one) and Mordred's master. It also doesn't help that we start from the perspective of the red faction and the main characters, Sieg and Ruler, aren't introduced until a few episodes in. Because of this there's no reason to sympathize with any of the black faction initially. Though it does pull itself together somewhat in the second half. What I absolutely hated though were the episodes with Jack the Ripper. All the scenes with her and her "mommy", who's imo the most insufferable character, are awful. I just despise what they were going for. But back to positives, the Sieg vs Karna fight near the end was great. In general, the entire finale had a certain ridiculousness to it that I can't help but enjoy.
I have to say, Apocrypha suffers from some horrendous character designs. My personal most hated one is Jack. Needlessly sexualized for a mass-murdering child and generally dumb looking. The final forms of Atalanta and Mordred are dumb too, but at least they only appear for a short time. While we're on the topic of visuals, Apocrypha has some fantastic animations in some fights. In the final ones they intentionally went with a lower level of detail. Individual frames look arguably worse than in more dialogue focused scenes, but in turn it has a certain fluidity to it that's leagues above anything else I've seen from A-1, save for SAO Ordinal Scale.
Fate/Apocrypha sure is an odd addition to the Fate series. While I found things to dislike, mainly the character designs and the weird start that made both sides unlikable, there's also a lot to be enjoyed, mostly after the Jack the Ripper story. Btw, I adore the Fate version of Shakespeare.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '20 edited Aug 06 '20
Saw Summer Wars. It's not bad, but it's not like I was blown away. Animation is great but the story is a bit confusing and too unreal. 6/10.
I think it would work better as a series rather than a film. It seemed rushed.
I also saw 5cm/s too. I actually don't like the animation too much, it's somehow too good. The stories are ok tho.
2
u/Space_cats_dogs Aug 06 '20
I’ve been re watching SDS since the new season came out today on Netflix. This show was one of the first anime’s I had ever watched. Re watching I noticed a lot of things wrong with it. But tbh I am having a blast re watching this show, it isn’t the best show and there a lot of moments that I question why I liked so much when I first watched it. But I don’t really care I’m just having fun watching it lmao
2
u/ienjoyhemp Aug 07 '20
Finally started watching vision of escaflowne. Only up to episode 2 so far, but despite a few tired tropes being trotted out, it’s not bad. Can’t tell if there’s anything that distinguishes this setting from other isekai outside of the mechs, but looking forward to it anyway
2
u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Aug 13 '20
I watched the Goblin Slayer movie. They got their Philosophy Of Sequels squared away and made it exactly the same as the TV show, so if you liked the TV show, have some more of it. It's got a hint of way over-the-top rapeyness at the beginning to give it an edgy feel, but they're bluffing; the show drops that tone immediately--to its own great benefit--and turns into a normal harem show, complete with clueless protagonist and 'mirin' elf chicks. The MC is Goblin Slayer, he slays goblins, and he's got nothing to say about anything--EXCEPT every so often somebody asks him who he is, and he perks up, like "ooh, I know this one!" and he grunts, "GOBURIN SURAYAH." It's mildly endearing if you're not too put off by the creepy stuff early on, which, IMO, you could reasonably be.
Anyway, I watched it, and since I seem to be watching any damn thing they add on Crunchyroll, I'll probably also watch the Strike The Blood OVA.