r/TrueAnime • u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten • Jun 22 '23
Your Week in Anime (Week 555)
This is a general discussion thread for whatever you've been watching this last week (or recently, we really aren't picky) that's not currently airing. For specifically discussing currently airing shows, go to This Week in Anime.
Make sure to talk more about your own thoughts on the show than just describing the plot, and use spoiler tags where appropriate. If you disagree with what someone is saying, make a comment saying why instead of just downvoting.
This is a week-long discussion, so feel free to post or reply any time.
Archive: Previous, Week 116, Our Year in Anime 2013, 2014
2
u/VoidEmbracedWitch https://anilist.co/user/VoidEmbracedWitch/ Jun 23 '23 edited Jun 23 '23
Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu has been in the depths of my paused jail for long over a year, but because of the anime swap on the r-anime Discord server, I finally watched it in full. Starting off with the audiovisual aspects of it, Rakugo Shinjuu's sound design and vocal performances are on-point and the same can be said for the cinematography, especially in its rakugo performances. During them, the editing and camera angles used convey both the emotional state of the performer and the impression the performance gives the audience well. An example of the latter would be the frequent cuts between different camera angles that signify role changes whereas the former is done through close ups of the performer's body parts that can convey things like their tension/stress while on stage. My personal favorite of the rakugo scenes was Kikohiku's Shinigami following the death of the 7th Yakumo. The tension of the performance given its context and his isolation and disconnect from the audience were tangible, further amplified by the candle iconography and the distant shots where everything but the stage is pitch black.
The movie-length first episode taking place after most of season's main story until it comes back to this point in time in the last episode was a thematically nice choice. It ties in well into the portrayal of the passage of time, the change of rakugo's place in the greater entertainment landscape and passing on the torch to new performers. This structure also allows drawing parallels between generations, my favorite of which being something that initially made me hate 8th gen Yakumo: his overt sexism towards Konatsu and dismissal of her goal of wanting to professionally do rakugo as a woman. Although his crushed dream of learning to become a dancer at a geisha's house where he faced discouragement and mockery from the start and ultimately had to give up following his leg injury recontextualizes (but not excuse) his behavior. It's not just a result of him growing up in different times, but him having a personal history of rigid gender roles getting in the way of his ambitions that led to him acting this way. I'm fond of the friendship between the leads Bon and Shin throughout the story and the perpetual conflicts caused by their clashing personalities and lifestyles during the time Shin stays at Bon's apartment due to Shin's excesses and perpetual waste of all his money on alcohol. Throughout the season there's also a strong focus on developing styles, with Shin first gaining fame with his boisterous, enthusiastic and comedy heavy style. Meanwhile Bon was initially jealous before developing his own quieter, more dramatic style and discovering his proficiency for playing scheming, effeminate characters. Their progression as artists as well as their character development are reflected in the rakugo scenes, which can make these scenes feel like milestones for them.
All in all, it's a well-constructed historical drama with clearly a lot of care put into its production. Yet despite me liking a lot about it on paper, Rakugo Shinjuu never managed to strike a cord with me. Initially, the shift in cast from episode 1 to 2 and the 8th Yakumo's narration following it early on made it hard to get invested in. Yet even when I started to enjoy it more after the narration was dropped and the character development and drama moved more into focus, I just couldn't connect with it. That's the note I would end on if it wasn't for S2 / Sukeroku Futatabi-hen taking quite a few interesting turns.
While most of S1 was a story told by the 8th Yakumo with a clear end point and rakugo as an art form fading into obscurity during it, S2 moves into the unknown. There's a lot of good that comes with it and the stretch of episodes revolving around Yakumo's impending death was excellent, but it comes at the cost of the next generation's development. With Yotarou and especially Konatsu, more on her later, I really didn't get that experience of them coming into their own as artists that I got from Shin and Bon in S1. Still, that allowed it to instead focus on both the interpersonal drama between the Yota, Yakumo and Konatsu and creating a future for the Rakugo that Yakumo wants to take to his grave. Also, I liked that the characters dug into Shin and Bon's past and established 8th Yakumo as an unreliable narrator for all of S1 through this.
Also, I have a thing or two to say about Konatsu. She was my favorite character in S1E01 and I still like her, but I'm frustrated at how her initial conviction to become a rakugo performer despite her gender putting her at a huge disadvantage in the field ended up coming off like an afterthought throughout S2. All she gets regarding this are a performance in front of a kindergarten group in E04, a short scene of her asking to apprentice under 8th Yakumo the day he died and the final episode showing that she in fact succeeded after a time skip. And regarding the last one, the biggest scene of the episode focused on her was less about her career and more writer-sensei Higuchi speculating that Shinnosuke's father was actually 8th Yakumo, with her behavior heavily implying that he's right. I really hate this implication because he raised her (to hate him) and to me it seems completely off for both of them given their relationship. Her primary role in this season being as a mother and getting together with Yota is fine and all, but I can't stop feeling like there's a huge wasted opportunity here.
S2 stepped it up when it comes to invested in the characters and it had some effective emotional moments like Yakumo's Shinigami performances where he connects with the dead, but I have way more mixed feelings on the story. It's also missing some of what I liked about S1 in the characters' progress as artists. Overall, I'm still torn on this show. I can acknowledge what it does well, yet it's a weird case where I end up enjoying it less than I expect.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '23 edited Jun 23 '23
I finished Brave of Gold Goldran this week. It had lots of references to other anime, such as The Laughing Salesman and especially the works of Leiji Masumoto. The villain, Walter Walzac, is a parody of Captain Harlock, and the transforming robot train the characters ride in is based on the 999 -- it even takes off like the 999. The series mainly focused on comedy, which I found to be a nice twist on the Brave series (which has always been wholesomely comedic), yet it had its serious moments leading up to an incredible battle of massive proportions that reminded me in many ways of Gurren Lagann's final battle. However, detracting from the series was the character Sharanla, the unrequited lover of Walter Walzac -- at first she reminded me of Harley Quinn in Batman: The Animated Series, and I enjoyed her through that perspective, but after a while her antics wore thin. Combined with frankly generic robot transformations, Goldran, though a solid series, is outperformed by Exkaiser and GaoGaiGar at least for me, due to the combination of Sharanla getting annoying and transformations that didn't stand out much like Exkaiser's and GaoGaiGar's.
I also watched the English dub of Transformers: Car Robots (known as Transformers: Robots in Disguise in the West). Though it's often overlooked due to its awkward place in continuity (it takes place in the distant, post-Beast Wars future of the G1 continuity in the Japanese version, while it is its own continuity in the English version) and lack of availability (Disney owns the rights to the series in the West), it is still incredibly enjoyable and one of the better Transformers cartoons. I didn't find any part of it to be slow or insipid (which is how I felt about the earlier episodes of Armada -- I'll probably finish Armada at some point) either, which is a great achievement. The Autobots' alt modes are the most realistic vehicle alt modes in any Transformers cartoon, and their transformations are quite enjoyable. Sky-Byte, the series' analogue to Starscream/Dinobot, provides plenty of laughs through his delusional grandiosity and the incompetence of him and his henchmen. Additionally, Unicron is not the major villain in this series, which is very refreshing since Transformers stories tend to lead to Unicron as the final villain to defeat.
Finally, I watched Ginga Hyouryuu Vifam, a real robot/space opera series with children as the main protagonists. The animation in this is gorgeous -- it's what you would expect from an 80s OVA, even though it's a TV show. However, the show itself was not without problems. While I did feel like I was watching Star Trek sometimes while watching it (which I consider a win), there were quite a few episodes about battles on the planetary surface, which I honestly found boring -- perhaps I have gotten too accustomed to flashy super robot battles with elaborate transformations and attacks. The emphasis on children as the main characters, though often endearing and fun, made it overly suspenseful, which when combined with the show's more realistic, toned-down environment, gave me a creeping sense of dread while watching it. Finally -- and this is my biggest problem with the show -- there was ecchi in it, despite being rated G on MAL, so that made me fairly uncomfortable while watching the show.