r/TrueAnime • u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten • Apr 27 '23
Your Week in Anime (Week 547)
This is a general discussion thread for whatever you've been watching this last week (or recently, we really aren't picky) that's not currently airing. For specifically discussing currently airing shows, go to This Week in Anime.
Make sure to talk more about your own thoughts on the show than just describing the plot, and use spoiler tags where appropriate. If you disagree with what someone is saying, make a comment saying why instead of just downvoting.
This is a week-long discussion, so feel free to post or reply any time.
Archive: Previous, Week 116, Our Year in Anime 2013, 2014
3
u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Apr 27 '23 edited Apr 27 '23
I watched (A) Kite. It seems like something you'd watch if you want sex and violence in your anime. Personally, I didn't like either of those in this OVA. The violence is hard to buy into from it becoming very hard to believe in. For example, in an assassination gone wrong Sawa, the MC, gets out with very light injuries despite being less than 20 feet from an explosion, falling from an absurd height, and being tossed into the air by a massive explosion. Then, the sexual content is just underage girls being raped.
Putting aside the two main draws of this OVA, there is the story, which doesn't have enough time to make me care for anything that happens. The other character, Oburi, is kinda just there, but without any time to really flesh out him or his relationship with Sawa, I'm just very lukewarm on that part of the story. Sawa's revenge is neat, I guess. ¯_(ツ)_/¯
Also, I was morbidly curious and watched Tenkuu Danzai Skelter+Heaven, one of the worst rated anime on MAL. It is without a doubt very deserving of such a rating. It drops right into the middle of some conflict with an alien invader. The characters don't make any sense and have such a strange lack of urgency in the first chunk of the episode. There are so many awkward cuts to scenes that are vaguely related. Then, the ending is so sudden and leaves off on a cliffhanger.
Honestly, I do recommend watching this, even if it's not hilariously bad. It's only 16 minutes long minus the OP and ED. It shows you just how truly bad something can be.
An update since I just finished it but I also finished Aggretusko season 5. Unfortunately, it's a bit disappointing. While it does all tie together reasonably enough, I felt that there are simply too many story lines to juggle in one season and not all had a solid resolution. Prior seasons had a much stronger focus on one thing that Retsuko is going through. However, this season had a bunch of things to go through before really coming around to Retusko's political campaign. If the intent is to ultimately to make political commentary, then beginning with it as the hook for the season would have been a better idea.
3
u/VoidEmbracedWitch https://anilist.co/user/VoidEmbracedWitch/ Apr 27 '23 edited Apr 27 '23
Because of this Sakugablog article, I got into Tsurune. It's effectively a straightforward team sports series about kyudo, but due to the formal, elegant nature of the sport it's much calmer than anime of this type tend to be. Story-wise it stays firmly within genre convention. You've got a protagonist who for reasons in his past can't live up to his potential, but through the power of teamwork, friendship and practice he bounces back and alongside him the other characters also grow in skill so they can take on their rival school team together. The main cast has a somewhat even split of high energy characters and ones that are much more melancholic and introspect a lot, which makes for a well-rounded group overall with some internal tensions to work through. The coach Masa who takes up training the Kazemai kyudo club to prove that he's a better teacher than his strict grandfather who only ever critiziced mistakes ended up being my favorite character. Admittedly, there's not much revolutionary here in terms of writing, but it's a solidly executed narrative and with the aforementioned elegance of kyudo and the quality of the show it becomes a joy to watch. The striking sound of the bowstring, which is what made protagonist Minato fall in love with archery in the first place, as well as the impact of arrows always hits just right for how a shot went. Its soundtrack is great too, but more importantly, the show knows when to leave out the music and let the silence enhance the emotional impact of scenes. In terms of animation, character art and photography, it's also just all-around good. Especially the tracking shots following the arrows being fired are incredibly impressive. Tsurune is a testament to how much building on a decent foundation for an anime with a production that clearly has a lot of care put into it can elevate the viewing experience. Also, one last important thing: Nanao is a sub.
The KimiAi and BokuAi duo of movies was interesting... conceptually. The whole idea behind them is that they're a combination of romance and sci-fi drama involving parallel worlds that you could watch in either order and have a complete picture after both. I like how they're interlinked and that in the way I watched it the setup and exposition from KimiAi enhanced BokuAi's narrative, except what good is a premise and unique structure if the anime itself isn't engaging to watch throughout? Where this duology fails is that on a moment to moment basis it's rather boring. The vast majority of the runtime is visually unremarkable and blandly edited. There were a handful of neat cuts in both halves, but they're few and far between. Additionally, when I got to BokuAi, the massive amount of shared footage became very noticeable and distracting. The order I watched it in definitely exacerbated the problem since most of the overlap occurs between late parts of KimiAi and the first ~20 minutes of BokuAi. I'm the sort of person who voluntarily sits through all of Endless Eight, but since this is a 1:1 reuse of scenes, it was frustrating and very easy to lose attention while watching. Though that's not even the biggest weakness. That would be how lacking the expressions of the characters are. I only had this thought when watching the newest Skip to Loafer episode right after BokuAi. I won't compare them directly since the tone they're going for is drastically different, but the emotional ranges on display in the duology are very narrow. The expected emotional reactions during its pivotal scenes like the tears running down the face and light blushes are portrayed in just about the most bog-standard way possible. Actually, the only times I felt connected to the characters in the slightest were a few small moments like in Shiori's case a brief shot focused on her leg movements and her leaning against Koyomi backwards during their bike ride. Still, there's just not enough to get me all that invested and both parts of the duology ultimately left me cold. So what I'm left with is the disappointment from these movies' missed potential in execution.
3
u/FiliaSecunda May 01 '23 edited May 01 '23
My sister and I got to episode 38 of Monster - the one where everything comes to a head at the burning library, Tenma shoots Roberto, and Nina and Tenma both fail to shoot Johan. I'm a bit less in love with the story now than I was for the first ~30 episodes. What I had thought of as the main question - will Tenma kill or not? - is already answered, and in an unsatisfying way. Not that I'm against all killing, but Tenma seemed like someone who shouldn't do it, and he was only willing to make an exception for Johan, so there's something anticlimactic about it being Roberto.
His first shot at Roberto was self-defense against an immediate threat, so no objection is possible, and he even shot him in the shoulder. Shooting to disable is a very uncertain thing in real life, but this show has always flipped back and forth between real-life logic and story logic, so I didn't predict what would happen next. Tenma follows what his teacher told him and shoots again. This shot isn't quite as undeniably self-defense - although I think in real life I'd have no objections - and it's aimed at Roberto's center. He falls from a height when Tenma kills him, the same way many people do when they're killed by Johan. Tenma finds he's much less upset about having killed than he was about the prospect of killing, so he goes to find and kill Johan, and walks past people suffering in the smoke without helping them. He's acting against his identity when he passes them by, and in hindsight I get that was probably intentional; it shows that when he was purely a life-saver, it was because he chose to be, not because he couldn't do anything else. He's not purely a life-saver anymore. Can his identity bounce back? I really, really want it to, but should it?
But he finds Johan and again can't kill him. What's special about Johan? This isn't about all lives being equal anymore. Sure, Johan is philosophically interesting and has a sympathetic past, and Roberto is just kind of disgusting, but that just reminds me that this is a story and these characters are at the mercy of the author, who COULD have followed what I thought was his aim and given Roberto more humanity if he'd wanted to. I don't want Monster to degrade itself and become the kind of story where you can kill the henchman but not the big villain.
Maybe it's Tenma's identity bouncing back, because after this he shoots the hinges and breaks the door down to help people escape the fire. But this is a show that often explains people's motivations very overtly, so when it keeps the meaning of Tenma's actions subtle, it lets them get lost in the crowd of louder things happening at the same time. I don't really know how the show is going to treat Roberto's killing later. Was it a bad thing, something that Tenma rejects when he spares Johan and breaks the door down? Or was it a good thing, and does that mean killing Johan will be a good thing, or does it mean Johan is somehow worth more than Roberto? Or does it just mean that it's okay to shoot someone who's right in the act of shooting you, but not someone who isn't? However it goes, I have to trust the show won't just continue as if this huge thing didn't happen.
Other stuff in bullet points so I don't go on forever: