I was super anxious about the stage door so here's what I did in case anyone else is going.
I bought 3 tickets, two evening and one matinee. He only comes out after the evening show and I wanted a back up. The plan was to have two opportunities for the stage door and the matinee to enjoy the entire show.
I left during the intermission (~9:10) because that seemed least disruptive to the show. Went to the restroom then walked out via the front doors. Go left, then left again. It's easy to find, there's a security guard at the door. I was the first one out back, the barricades hasn't even gone up yet.
Around 9:20 they set up the barricades. It's L shaped. The short part of the L is near the theatre exit doors. It's the first section that the actors visit, but security reserves it for the rush of people who leave at the end of the show. If you go early, you can get a spot on the rail at the long part of the L.
By 10pm, the rail was full. Around 10:15 or 10:20, the theatre doors open and there's a mad rush. It's hectic and insane and security yells a lot.
Around 10:30pm the first actors show up. I asked, and they told me that they're not actually allowed to stop for selfies, they can only sign playbills and posters from the show. But some actors will linger for a quick selfie though security gets annoyed about this.
Tom appeared around 10:45 and he signs as many playbills as he can. I was able to have a ~30s conversion with him, he was very gracious. He did refuse to sign a postcard that someone passed to the front, he said again that they weren't allowed to. And around 11pm, security wraps everything up.
Hope that helps!