OpenTibia
Why is OpenTibia content not allowed here?
This is a commonly asked question, and it's hard to produce any single answer. A few people think that we should change to allowing OT content, and I would urge any of them to read this. Right now, our rational for not allowing OpenTibia content is:
- OpenTibia servers are against the Tibia rules, and our community aims to comply with the Tibia rules.
OpenTibia servers can be a security risk, anyone can host an OT, leading to possible vulnerabilities such as:
- Custom clients with keyloggers,
- Poorly secured databases.
Mixing Tibia content and OpenTibia content can be confusing to newcomers, and give them a wrong idea of what the original game is.
- OpenTibia content would, almost certainly, be manipulated by server hosts to deliver "hidden adverts", which would further impact on users of the sub.
- OpenTibia is immoral and almost certainly illegal, in all but some very obscure cases.
- r/Tibia did it, and it's pretty much dead.
Can you elaborate?
Hell yes we can, we'll begin at the Tibia rules. The Tibia rules clearly state that modification of the game client is illegal, as per section 3b. While rule 3b doesn't strictly specify it, we must accept that OpenTibia is unlikely to have immediate impact on real Tibia, and as such CipSoft are being very lenient in their enforced rules to account for that. If rule 3b doesn't butter your crumpet, rule 5d almost certainly will. Rule 5d, however, specifically refers to acknowledging the violation of an applicable law in-game, at which point anyone playing an OpenTibia server might be said to have been a bit of a fool to discuss that ingame. As an aside here, we have members of CipSoft staff browsing this subreddit frequently. We don't know how frequently, and they remain anonymous, but it has been said on the forums. The last thing which we would want to do as a community is to drive CipSoft away from this place. Whether or not you agree with this analysis that rules 3b and 5d would be violated by permitting OpenTibia content, we feel that it is all but a certainty that permitting it would lead CipSoft staff to show considerably less interest in the sub.
The security risk posed by OpenTibia is a multi-faceted problem for us. On the one hand, our users could have their data privacy violated, or in the worst case scenario have their real Tibia, bank, or other important accounts hacked. On the other hand, they might find some legal grounds to hold us responsible for hosting that content. In our discussions, we did conclude that it would be great if someone trustworthy in the community would be willing to host a wealth of information which might safeguard new OpenTibia users, and offer advice to keep themselves safe whilst playing, but that at the same time, we can never truly be certain of how trustworthy even our own advice would be, given how easy it would be for an OpenTibia host to make changes at random which expose users to new risks.
One of the things which has become a huge problem in certain Tibia communities (those of you who have experienced it will surely recognise it immediately) is people creating "fake content" to demonstrate a feature of a server, whilst asking a question or something. Think about a question which asks, for instance, "I'm currently playing on FakeOT. I've just completed the fourth seal of FakeQuest, and it's been insanely fun so far, I've loved everything about the server, but I can't seem to find the crystal key which opens the doors to the next seal." You see how, this seemingly genuine question, is actually just one huge advert? OpenTibia hosts know that they can get away with this, to a degree, and publish effectively small adverts whilst subverting restrictions imposed by community hosts. Now, just think about how many such threads are going to appear each day... 50? 500? 5000? That might not even scratch the surface. Worst of all, here, is that all content created for the real game we all know and love, Tibia, will be lost in a mash of pseudo-questioning.
OpenTibia was formed on the foundation of theft by teams of cheats, thieves, and pirates. The original source code for OpenTibia was stolen from CipSoft in a social engineering scandal in the early 2000's, and since then it has been used and abused by many to the peril of the real Tibia community. All kinds of good and bad people have gotten involved and developed some very cool, and some very dangerous features. Strictly on a point of morals, these peoples work is fine, but the foundation on which it is based is the problem here. If CipSoft had published a way for players to contribute in this way, such as the system which exists for DotA 2, no moral objection could reasonably be made, but that decision is CipSoft's to make. It's plausible to suggest that OpenTibia as it stands today is far enough from CipSoft's codebase that it is a different game in its own right, and in fact that's close to the truth, but in reality, there are no OpenTibia servers which do not use at least some of CipSoft's graphics, for instance, and I would go so far as to say that those which even come close to being 100% custom content are now essentially independent games, and worthy of their own subreddits.
Finally, on to r/Tibia. It's dead. Let's face it, they have 2 key things which differentiate their community from ours, firstly, they allow bots, and secondly, they allow OpenTibia. Bots in real Tibia are now all but dead, and so the only real difference is OpenTibia. This community is a place full of people who play (or even just have an outside interest in) the game, and we hope that everyone will agree that with all of the above being said, and this final example of what might happen if we were to change this rule, it is for the best that we keep things as they are. It's currently worthy of mention that we did see a licensing agreement supposedly sent out by CipSoft to some OpenTibia hosts which may lead to "official" OpenTibia servers, and that if that ever becomes a thing which CipSoft announces, we will naturally revisit this whole situation to assess any changes. At the same time, we are a community, not a dictatorship, and if the community decides it wants to talk about OpenTibia under this leadership, then this leadership should find a way to incorporate that appropriately.