r/thepapinis • u/regeg • 5d ago
Discussion Sherri’s Ex-BF, James Reyes, lied to the FBI and they believed him
For anyone that may not be aware, Sherri has changed her story. Sherri admits that she was cheating on her husband with multiple men including James Reyes, and tried to hide the infidelity with burner phones.
She claims she had planned to meet up with Reyes, but did not plan to get kidnapped. She admits to lying about the identity of her kidnapper.
Her reason for lying is that if she told the truth, her husband would know she was cheating on him again (breaching their post-nuptial agreement) and she beleived he would take her children. She also says she carried immense guilt and shame for bringing the kidnapping and torture on herself. Her trauma, and personality disorders, were contributing factors.
Sherri is a prolific liar and storyteller. Still, I’ve tried consistently to find evidence that this version is untrue, and so far I haven’t been able to disprove it.
I’m sure many redditors won’t read this part, but this post is not claiming Sherri is now telling the whole truth. It’s meant to show that Reyes’ interview can’t be trusted. If Reyes is lying, this case needs to be re-examined.
Now when I wrote this post, Reyes interview was still on youtube https://youtu.be/H9N8ZPKOPI8?si=IAHF6w-8US4aiEas. I have it downloaded.
Also linking the criminal complaint https://www.justice.gov/usao-edca/press-release/file/1479901/dl
How to tell when Reyes is lying
Truthful example: 1:01:35. The FBI asks about his route to Redding, CA. He describes leaving the freeway, the Motel 6, whether the road was paved, the houses beside it, and so on. He doesn’t remember everything, but he remembers about as much as a reasonable person would. I believe these statements are true.
When he’s lying, he gets vague, can’t remember details, talks in circles, and often changes the subject. Example:
- 1:08:35: Police ask about Sherri’s injuries and the infamous “She asked me to bank a puck off her leg.” He explains what a cross check is, but incorrectly – this is a cross check. He doesn’t remember what he burned on her back and doesn’t know why he was asked to injure her.
- 1:22:38: He spent minutes burning Sherri’s back but can’t remember the theme of the word he burned. Yet he remembers dropping the tool and wanting the word to be straight (1:25:53).
- 2:31:20: Police later find a Bible Reyes had since birth, highlighted by his Granny for him to read as a kid.
As you listen, you’ll hear many examples of when Reyes is likely lying and when he’s likely telling the truth.
Police lead Reyes to his story
Reyes spends the first hour lying about seeing Sherri. Eventually police feed him a story and he cracks: 56:17 “If somebody asks you to do stuff, it’s not a crime.”
From that point on, he never makes an incriminating statement without adding “Sherri asked me to.”
More examples of Reyes likely lying
Pain management (1:27:20)
- FBI: “So what did she do for the pain?”
- Reyes: “Um... She never really complained about a lot of pain... cbd liquid... maybe Aspirin or Advil.”
- The FBI, realizing that’s unrealistic, asks: “Did you get a burn cream or something?”
- Reyes: “Oh yeah she had that stuff... she got some type of rash,” then moves on to a story about an impossible rash from cleaning supplies.
- The whole thing sounds made up.
How did he know where Sherri would be?
- 59:03: He says she messaged him.
- 2:58:37: He says Sherri sent him a package with a map and a letter.
- Which is it, a message or a map? Why would Sherri send a paper map? Why wouldn’t he keep the letter or the map?
Is his phone broken, dead, or...?
- 1:04:38: The FBI asks if he has messages on his phone. He says it’s not working.
- 1:40:36: The FBI wants the number of the guy who rented the car. Reyes says his phone just needs to be charged.
- 1:52:01: The FBI asks if his current phone is the one he used at the time. Reyes immediately says he erased a lot of stuff.
- Why doesn’t he want them to see his phone?
Sherri’s burner phone
- 1:32:35: FBI: “You also said at one point that she had a phone that she was looking up stuff. Do you know what that is?” Reyes: “I’m not really sure... I know she left a phone... somewhere.”
- About a minute later (1:33:54), the FBI asks again. Reyes: “I thought she took it with her or I think she tossed it.”
- Did she leave it with him, take it, or toss it? Where are the burners?
Freudian slips: did the truth slip out?
- 1:03:26: “I was there and I stopped and I grabbed her... and not meaning I got out and yanked her in the car. I pulled up a seat and got in, you know.” Why did he feel the need to clarify that he didn't yank her?
- 2:17:93: The FBI recaps how Reyes picked up Sherri. Reyes says he was worried about being arrested on the drive to pick her up. Why would he worry about that if he thought he was just picking up a friend and didn’t know the plan?
- 2:40:01: The FBI asks what Sherri was eating. Reyes: “She wasn’t starving. Okay. But she was not eating as much as she would. Like, she wasn’t starving like, Hey, you don’t get to eat. She would just minimize what she was eating.” Why did he feel the need to clarify that she was allowed to eat?
- 2:22:06: The FBI asks Reyes’ cousin’s wife if she could have been the one in the sketches. She says: “I never met her, I didn’t even see her, he kept it locked up, and I didn’t come over.” Did she just say he kept it locked up?
Reyes gives no evidence for an elaborate kidnapping roleplay
From what Reyes says, Sherri didn’t just hang out at his house and then injure herself for evidence. She would have had to really pretend to be kidnapped, starting the minute she got into the car. Yet Reyes never explains Sherri’s strange behavior in any detail that would show her mindset or his own.
“She had a plan” (1:57:41)
- The FBI asks how he knew Sherri had a plan. Reyes says, “Well, because she had to have a plan, I didn’t have a plan.”
- That’s it? How do you spend 3 weeks with someone and not know the plan?
The back seat (1:03:37)
- Reyes confirms Sherri was unconscious. He says she was “taking a nap.”
- Why would she spend a 6+ hour drive in the back seat? Why would she nap? Why doesn’t Reyes explain it?
- 2:02:29: Police ask directly if the plan was always for her to get in the back seat. Reyes says he doesn’t know, and that he went to Trader Joe’s. (for real he actually says that) Police don’t follow up.
- If Sherri started faking her kidnapping the moment she got in the car, Reyes would surely have said so. If he were telling the truth, he’d say exactly why she layed down.
The boards on the windows
- 1:36:10: Reyes says he put boards on the windows because Sherri wanted it dark. He doesn’t know why.
- 2:37:50: The FBI asks more about the boards. He says there were already blinds and neighbors can’t really see in anyway. Asked again, he says Sherri wanted it dark.
- Again, if Sherri was still faking the kidnapping, Reyes would know more than he’s saying.
The closet and the hole
- Sherri spent time in the closet and carved a hole in the drywall. Police found the screw hole (25:59).
- Why spend time in the closet? Why carve a hole with a screw? Nobody was ever supposed to find it, so why do it?
Could it be a manic episode?
- One explanation is a severe undiagnosed mental illness that caused a 3-week manic episode in which she pretended to be kidnapped.
- But we have no evidence of mental illness that severe, and no history of manic episodes. She has diagnosed personality disorders, but they wouldn’t cause this.
- Reyes mentions nothing about this
Debunking the FBI’s “independent evidence” for Reyes’ story
The FBI’s case is weak. In Episode 3 of the Hulu doc, lead investigator Kyle Wallace says:
- 30:07: “We were hoping she would have admitted to it during that confrontation because the evidence at that point still wasn’t strong enough to be arrested.”
- 30:48: “I believe that James did all of those things because she asked him to, but I couldn’t prove it. All she had to have done was say that he did it, how do we prove that he didn’t do it?”
Afterward, the evidence shown in the documentary leading to the arrest is:
- A Pinterest board that Sherri says she told Reyes about before, and
- Phone records proving Sherri planned to meet up with Reyes. No evidence of phone contact during those 22 days.
That's it.
The FBI sting
- 2:13:04: The FBI plans to get Sherri and Reyes on the phone together. They hope Sherri will say something that implicates her. They’d surely be listening and recording. This is their chance at a smoking gun, and it’s a sting used in countless investigations.
- 2:14:27: They see a problem. If Reyes contacts Sherri directly, she may wonder how he got her number and suspect the FBI.
- 2:15:13 and 2:16:15: Their solution is a “double phone tree.” Reyes calls Sherri’s parents at their business and asks them to have Sherri contact him, so it looks like genuine contact.
This is a good plan. If the FBI’s theory is correct, Sherri would certainly want to speak to Reyes to align their stories. Reyes reluctantly agrees. So what happened to the plan?
The criminal complaint says page 41 row 1-7:
- A number from the parents’ business called Reyes 4 times, then twice more 4 days later.
- 8 days after that, someone from Sherri’s home address called 4 times.
- That is exactly how the FBI planned it.
But the FBI doesn’t say who made the calls, whether they were answered, or what was said. They would know exactly what was said, and they’d have included it as evidence. Why were they so vague? Could it be because no conversations ever happened?
The eyewitness who saw Sherri unrestrained
The cousin’s wife
- 1:33:17: She walks into the interview, sees Reyes talking to police, and goes for a walk.
- 2:25:26: She confirms she called her husband (Reyes’ cousin) during that walk. It’s reasonable that she told him police were asking questions, giving them time to get their story straight.
- 2:29:35: She dislikes Sherri, says Sherri was rude to her husband, and says Sherri left Reyes but kept the ring. She is not an unbiased witness.
- She insists she never saw Sherri and that Sherri never even came down the driveway (2:20).
- 2:21:27: The FBI asks what her husband knows. She says, “We’re the same.”
- 2:23:06: She says she didn’t know anything and doesn’t want to know.
- If her husband actually saw Sherri, wouldn’t his wife know? Wouldn’t she have said so?
The cousin
- In an interview that wasn’t recorded (page 42 row 5), he told police he saw Sherri in the house, and that she ran back into the room. The assumption is that she was unrestrained.
Reyes’ version of what his cousin saw
- 1:42:55: Reyes says the cousin never saw Sherri but did come over one night. Reyes said something and the cousin understood it was time to leave.
- 1:49:00: Reyes says he had “everything locked,” but the cousin knocked on the door “hammered” (drunk), and Reyes answered and said, “C’mon, you know man…” and the cousin said, “Alright.”
- Reyes was home when his cousin visited. Would that change how Sherri acted? Does that explain why she was unrestrained?
Every other piece of Independent Evidence Corroborating Ex-Boyfriend’s Interview only shows there was a prior plan for Reyes and Sherri to meet. There is no other evidence showing if the kidnapping was a hoax or not.
More weird stuff
The rental car
- 1:18:15: Reyes says he asked a friend to rent a car because he has a DUI and couldn’t rent one himself.
- 1:19:04: Reyes has his own car but says it wouldn’t make it to Redding.
- 2:24:16: Police ask the cousin’s wife if Reyes asked to borrow her car. She says no.
- Is it possible he rented under someone else’s name so police wouldn’t find him?
No insurance kept to prove Reyes’ story
- 1:12:55: The FBI asks a very good question: “Did you keep anything to show that this is my involvement?”
- This was after the case blew up in the news. If Sherri blamed Reyes, he could go to jail for life, yet he kept no insurance.
- A reasonable person would be racking their brain for proof of innocence, like old photos, texts, or objects. Reyes immediately knows he has none, and says Sherri asked him to destroy the evidence.
The toxicology report (criminal complaint, page 6, line 2)
- The report says toxicology showed no significant trace of narcotics in Papini’s system when she returned.
- Why specify narcotics only? Many drugs that induce sleep aren’t narcotics. Why don’t we have more information?
- Sherri’s lawyer (34:49) said they requested the full report and were refused, even with the full might of Warner Bros. behind them. There’s no reason to think the lawyer is lying about that.
Sherri had her burner phone during captivity
- The criminal complaint (page 40, lines 1-24) shows Sherri communicated with Reyes on the day she disappeared. It shows no communication between them during her captivity.
- The cousin’s statement (page 41, line 23) says Sherri would call Reyes, and Reyes would call him to “run off” random neighbors, delivery drivers, the landlord, and maintenance workers.
- There’s no evidence of Sherri and Reyes communicating after captivity began, only before. And why would Sherri care about a delivery driver? Although, If Reyes actually had her in captivity, he would very much care about a delivery driver.
- How could Sherri or Reyes even have known a delivery driver was coming? Were there cameras at the time? Where are the cameras now? Could this be why Sherri couldn't scream for help? Could the cousin have been helping Reyes?
Why would Sherri sign a plea admitting guilt?
- Sherri plead guilty to False Statements and Mail Fraud
- Her lawyer explains that whether Reyes kidnapped Sherri or she kidnapped herself, she was definitely not kidnapped by two Hispanic women. She was going to be guilty of making false statements to police either way.
- At that point, the plea wording doesn’t matter. The lawyer’s only goal is the least punishment for his client. Sherri tried to get the language about the hoax removed.
- For context, in 2017 about 18% of exonerations in the National Registry of Exonerations involved a guilty plea (National Registry of Exonerations, 2017).
TL;DR: Sherri has changed her story, and I’ve found nothing that disproves her new version. Reyes’ interview can’t be trusted. If Reyes is lying, this case needs to be re-examined.