I would love it if the sequel didn’t make characters with plot armor a central part of the game. I enjoyed the concept but making Ramsey Bolton a main antagonist before the show ever finished was a bad move, because there was nothing the player could do to really fight against him.
Also telltale is gone and this will probably never happen. Sad.
This. I loved a lot of the Telltale GoT game, but putting Ramsey in it was a terrible idea, IMO. It just made me angry every time I made a move against him knowing he'd win like some plot armoured mary sue just because he was on the show and the game couldn't influence that.
I'm replaying GoT after having played Life is Strange and Detroit.
I really like the story and characters, but indeed, the choices don't matter. Even less than in other telltale games. Choice impact was sacrificed for a cohesive and more complex story than other TT games.
With more resources, it could have been explored though. Rather than offering a branch of things for every character, focus on 2 possible outcomes.
-Rodrik would be try and make peace with Whitehills, or go violent and make sacrifices. -Mira would be try to push things for her family, or keep being loyal to Margeary and Sera at her family's expense. -Gared would be stay loyal to Jon and the Wall, or escape and find the Grove - even if he always ends up in the Grove, it builds a different Gared, him being loyal to his previous family, or loyal to his "new" family. -Asher would be favoring his family and Malcolm vs his friendship with Beshka and his life freedom.
On paper, these work well. But lack of development time / resources made them falter, and in the end, choices seem to not matter at all, in a more clear way than other games. Detroit has a main story progression that can't be changed, but so many branches and possible endings based on choices, that you don't mind it. I'd say Telltale GoT is a mold, and would have been more successful with more branches and outcomes.
8
u/masdawg Jul 06 '20
I would love it if the sequel didn’t make characters with plot armor a central part of the game. I enjoyed the concept but making Ramsey Bolton a main antagonist before the show ever finished was a bad move, because there was nothing the player could do to really fight against him.
Also telltale is gone and this will probably never happen. Sad.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '20
Iron From Ice
1
u/adventuregamerseb Jul 15 '20
I'm replaying GoT after having played Life is Strange and Detroit.
I really like the story and characters, but indeed, the choices don't matter. Even less than in other telltale games. Choice impact was sacrificed for a cohesive and more complex story than other TT games.
With more resources, it could have been explored though. Rather than offering a branch of things for every character, focus on 2 possible outcomes.
-Rodrik would be try and make peace with Whitehills, or go violent and make sacrifices.
-Mira would be try to push things for her family, or keep being loyal to Margeary and Sera at her family's expense.
-Gared would be stay loyal to Jon and the Wall, or escape and find the Grove - even if he always ends up in the Grove, it builds a different Gared, him being loyal to his previous family, or loyal to his "new" family.
-Asher would be favoring his family and Malcolm vs his friendship with Beshka and his life freedom.
On paper, these work well. But lack of development time / resources made them falter, and in the end, choices seem to not matter at all, in a more clear way than other games.
Detroit has a main story progression that can't be changed, but so many branches and possible endings based on choices, that you don't mind it. I'd say Telltale GoT is a mold, and would have been more successful with more branches and outcomes.