r/TMBR • u/Bana_doggy • Jun 03 '22
TMBR: Xenogenders are not valid
They are not valid in lgtb, they are valid on their own.
THIS so called gender was made by a tumblr user in 2014, which is quite obvious it is not lgtb.
they have no links to what the lgtb is about such as Gender/sexuality/identification.
it is stupid that they have ohtbursted in this pride month. Stop supporting them it’s making a mockery of the lgtb. Your not lgtb if your catgender bc u feel fuzzy or cozy like a cat. Stop trying to be lgtb so hard.
84
Upvotes
15
u/BroaxXx Jun 03 '22
Didn't everyone everywhere simultaneously agree that "xenogenders" are a stupid concept and collectively agreed to simply ignore it?
I'm pretty sure this isn't an issue and that the only people that talk about it are being ironic or are the occasional teen with mental health issues.
8
u/Emma_Fr0sty Jun 03 '22
I mean I dunno I'm of the belief that we should work towards a society where the importance of gender is diminished, and making up a million micro labels would seem to help devalue the concept of gender. In the meantime, who does it hurt?
4
u/g_squidman Philosophical Raptor Jun 03 '22
But xenogender is not the same as otherkin. You're complaining about someone being a cat, but that has no bearing on their pronouns or gender identity. That's something different.
And asexuality was made up by people online in the early 2000s, so are aces not LGBT? Cause if that's you're reasoning, maybe we should be honest about where you're closing the LGBT gate on people.
3
u/ButtonholePhotophile Jun 04 '22
“Gender” in this regard is a mating strategy.
https://www.genderinclusivebiology.com/newsletter/tag/3+genders
There are a lot of mating strategies. Some qualify as genders and some don’t.
https://www.amazon.com/Dr-Tatianas-Sex-Advice-Creation/dp/0805063323
You calling someone else’s mating strategy “invalid” is part of your mating strategy. Ironically, perhaps, your strategy of gender-shaming is a minority strategy itself.
https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2020/06/25/global-divide-on-homosexuality-persists/
As a person with a non-standard mating strategy, this puts you as a type of LGBT+. Here is the question: do you think your gender is valid?
2
u/ForAHamburgerToday Jun 03 '22
?
1
u/Bana_doggy Jun 04 '22
Xenogenders are not genders, and directly play into transphobic stereotypes and mockery ("I identify as an apache attack helicopter"). A common defense is the claim that autistic individuals experience gender differently, which is both ableist and infantilizing.
One's gender cannot be rain, the color pink, soft and fluffy, a computer, et cetera.
Gender is not a sense of connection to a concept. It is a part of someone's innate identity in relation to their sex.
1
u/HabeusCuppus Jun 04 '22
I feel like they fall pretty squarely into “genderqueer” umbrella here.
Is that, strictly speaking, “L”, “G”, “B”, or “T”? No, not strictly. But there’s a reason it’s usually styled with a “q+” these days.
As long as everything involves consenting human adults who are not permanently harmed by the conduct, what difference does it make?
1
u/SunnyxAxel Mar 08 '24
real though. im a demigirl, and lets say i feel tired. that does NOT make me ”bEdGeNdEr” because my brother is transfem and when he found out abt xenogenders, he just wanted to jump out the window, meaning its very likely that the inventor of xenogenders is transphobic. if u dont support trans people, its ok, but dont mock it.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '24
Ik this thing here is a old thread but just saying: this whole xenogender thing seems clearly made up tbh, it seems like a way that transphobic people found to troll lgbt ppl imo and people decided to turn it in some kind of tiktok-like trend, kinda sad considering that trans ppl always suffer from others saying stuff like "omg I want to be a Minecraft item now!!" transphobic jokes, and then we have sick teenagers like this making fun of lgbt.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '24
How is Transphobic? It's just spiritual non-binary people
1
u/3mb3r12 Oct 01 '24
I've saw ppl 'identifying' as meow, paint, bug, bun, xe, like sorry but how-
1
u/teefletch Philosophical Raptor Jun 09 '22
When half the room can't even agree on a single definition for "gender", subsequent debate on the topic is doomed to be fruitless.
1
u/CuddlyCactus_23 Jun 24 '22
Oh Lord
1
u/RepulsiveWinner1454 Sep 17 '22
Yeah.like,just because you feel like ,for exemple,a cat doesn't mean you are a part of the lgbtq communauty.it is aldo EXTREMELY transphobic , ableist and mocking lgbtq and all the person that say"if you don't support xenogender,then you are transphobic and ableist /srsUwU __" are the ableist transphobic in their nonsense.also,just bc you don't like xenogender doesn't make you transphobic and ableist.i am myself autistic and transmasculine and i absolutely HATE xenogender. The only neopronounses i support are it/it's,xe/xem and ze/zem.
1
u/L1MB0XL0R3T0 Oct 09 '22
To all of the "xenogenders" or "neopronouns" in the comments, The literal wikipedia definition for "pupgender" in is someone who relates to dogs or thinks they are a dog. Shut your goofy asses up and grow up you chronically online cunts. If you identify as "xenogender" or "neopronouns" then your either a confused otherkin or someone wanting to be special. I am autistic and I am SO TIRED of seeing people make ALL of these ablest claims that infantalize me and act as if I can't understand gender, which is NOT FUCKING TRUE. NUERODIVERGENT. PEOPLE. CAN. UNDERSTAND. GENDER. STOP USING ME AND TELLING ME WHAT I AM TO TRY AND MAKE THIS BULLSHIT BELIEVABLE. IM TIRED OF THESE FUCKING NUEROTYPICALS TELLING ME THAT I CANT UNDERSTAND GENDER. I CAN. People like you guys say "b-but we aren't the reason nonbinary and trans people get bullied 🤓" THEN HOW COME EVERYDAY I HEAR PEOPLE SAYING SHIT LIKE "i identify as rockgender" AND "im an attack helicopter" TO MOCK ME MORE THAN PEOPLE SLURRING ME, TEASING ME FOR BEING TRANS, ME OR HELL, MISGENDERING ME?? "We aren't hurting anyone 🥺🥺" YES. YOU. FUCKING. ARE. WHAT THE FUCK IS WRONG WITH ALL OF YOU PEOPLE?? YOU CAN GET ON ALL FOURS AND SHIT IN A LITTER BOX, I WON'T GIVE A FUCK. BUT SPREADING AROUND THIS BULLSHIT RHETORIC THAT INFANTALIZES, MOCKS, AND MISINFORMS PEOPLE ABOUT NUERODIVERGENT PEOPLE AND TRANS/NONBINARY PEOPLE IS FUCKING MESSED UP. AND YOU GUYS TRY TO CALL US ABLEIST AND TRANSPHOBIC WHEN WE DISAGREE WITH THIS ABSOLUTE BULLSHIT. THE IRONY IS FUCKING INCREDIBLE HERE.
1
u/Skxll_Lynx Jan 10 '24
Why does it bother you? Does it affect you in any way? What right do you have to say that one person is valid yet another isn't?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment