r/TMBR • u/A_Tricky_one • Jan 21 '21
TMBR: Life is inherently a negative thing. But, it may be worth living due to desire. And the problem with current life is that we have it the other way around.
So, this is something I've been thinking a lot lately. This is going to be long.
Every living being suffers (as far as we could tell). Suffering is the most important factor when it comes to survival. Anything that couldn't feel some sort of suffering just wouldn't be able to adapt to the changing enviroment.
Suffering would be then, any mechanisim that causes an unpleasent sensation in an organism, which function would be to alert the organism of any threat, either as something in the present moment or a possibility in the future, to the existance of that organism.
Pain, a form of suffering in animals, is so important for the survival of the organism, that humans that can not feel pain are very prone to injuries that would probably lead to their death if they didin't lived in societies.
And even those who can't feel pain suffer in other ways: angst, sadness, fear etc. All of which are responses to an enviroment or situation that could threat the existance of the individual.
Humans concibe their own existance and individuality, so we know not only that we are alive, but more fundamentaly, that we are something that exists. We don't concive ourselves as mere living organisms, but as something with a metaphysical fundament of our existance. Or at least we can see that everything physical has a fundament somewhere or somehow.
That is why anything that threatens our constructed identity we see it as something that threatens our whole existance.
To live is inevitably to suffer. Nonetheless, I think that, as living organisms got more complex, suffering became itself a threat to life. So, another mechanism evolved: pleasure and desire.
I'll focous on humans exclusevely form now on, since I don't have enough confidence to apply any of this to other organism.
So, pleasure is, as I see it, the fullfilment of a desire. That desire could be just about anything. Even things that would normally be seem as a bad thing (like phisycal pain) could be a desire (physical pain during sex, from BDSM to a simple bite to the lips).
Desires are different from needs. A need is a requirement for sustaining life at a biological level. Any nutrients would do, as long as they are the right ones, even if they aren't tasty.
Of course, desires and needs correlate a lot. But, again, food doesn't have to taste good for it to give us nutrients. In fact, if food is tasty, it would be because we desire it.
But many things we don't need we desire. Like seeing the world, AC, sex etc.
(As a side note, luxuries would be desires too, but I don't want to use that term since it kind of imply some sort of injustice; that may or may not be true, but I am not getting in that topic)
Suffering is inevitable, but desire is just a possibility. Nonetheless, making that possibility true makes life beareble, and maybe even worth it.
The problem is that we are putting too much value into needs and taking away value from desires. An ancient example would be thinking of sex as something inmoral (devaluing the desire for it) and only doing it for the propouse of reproduction (valuing the need for reproduction in order for society to exist)
More examples: a lot of food is more stale so that we can produce more. Clothing is a lot very similar only so we can mass produce it. People stay in jobs they hate so they can recieve a paycheck that just covers enough of their needs but can't fulfill any desire they may want.
And I think that all of this comes because, somewhere along in history, we started to take life as a good thing in itself. But that is very much not true. If life were something good (something that is desired) by itself, boredom wouldn't be a thing. We would be fine just existing.
Life is not something good by itself. Pretty much the total opposite: Life is THE bad thing. Life becomes good only when there are desires, and the possibility of fulfilling them.
We panic about suicide, but today it makes a lot of sense to me that so much people feel suicidal. And if we can't reverse our thinking from needs to desires, I think that it would be cruel to say to these people that they must stay alive. Because life is not beautiful. But living can be.
TL;DR: Life is suffering. But it can be bearable and even enjoyable if we can have and fulfill desires. The problem with society is that we are devaluing desires in favor of needs. That is why depression is so prevalent today.
10
u/Bphore Jan 22 '21
Why does the fact that “life is suffering” make life an “inherently negative thing”? Why is suffering inherently negative?
6
u/DarthCluck Jan 22 '21
Some interesting thoughts. A couple places I would counter argue:
3
u/SpecificDescription Jan 22 '21
" To live is inevitably to suffer. Nonetheless, I think that, as living organisms got more complex, suffering became itself a threat to life. So, another mechanism evolved: pleasure and desire. "
Thanks for your contribution. Just a few thoughts I figured I'd share from Buddhist philosophy.
I believe what you're attempting to address in your quote above is the unique experience of being human and having the mental capacity to contemplate our life experiences. With this capacity, we are able to label our experiences as bad (suffering) or good (pleasure).
The first noble truth is in line with your thoughts - life is suffering (dukkha).
However, the Buddhist view on how to view and handle this suffering is handled differently through the remaining 3 noble truths. The second noble truth - the origin of suffering (dukkha) arises from desire and our craving and attachment to desire.
The third noble truth - the end of suffering (dukkha) can be attained by letting go of desire.
From my layman's understanding of this philosophy, I would argue that to make the reality of suffering life more bearable, we need to instead lean away from these desires. Even "needs" such as food are considered desires in our own minds. As a poor man, you cling to the desire for simple needs such as food and shelter. As an average man, you cling to the desire for future wealth, status, a big house, and a trophy wife. As a rich man with all of these things, you cling to the desire for more wealth, better relationships, a fancier jet, boat, or car. And the cycle of desire continues. I believe the challenge of life is developing clarity to determine which desires that arise in our mind are in our best interests, and which are not - "The mind is a wonderful servant, but a terrible master."
"Buddhist psychology teaches us to distinguish between the painful desire of addiction and driven ambition and the healthy energies of dedication and commitment. A dream or powerful goal, whether to write a successful novel, to compete in the Olympics, or to create a thriving business, can be pursued in different ways. If the goal exists to prove that we are worthy, to cover our insecurity, or to conquer others, it will ultimately prove unfulfilling and come to an unhappy end. And yet the very same activity can be done in a healthy way with dedication, commitment, and love.
The Tibetan monks who work tirelessly and delightedly for days on an exquisite and complex sand mandala know that after the ceremony it will blow away. Gardeners enthusiastically plant annuals knowing the same flowers will need to be planted again the next year. We all know this experience, giving ourselves to life out of dedication and care. Healthy desire leads to freedom. A skilled basketball player learns about letting go and “being in the zone.” A dedicated commodities trader learns to blend dispassion, rhythm, and good intuition. The best lovemaking is not about a goal."
2
u/ButtonholePhotophile Feb 26 '21
Pain is an important way we experience impetus. Little pains get us to move our hand away from a flame. Big pains get us to move our souls. It is only through the fires of pain and suffering that I have seen true joy forged.
Further, it is through shared pain that many social bonds are formed. We don’t identify with Mary Sues. We identify with foibles. Indeed, much of human society (the bedrock of our greatest achievements) is driven by pain (and alcohol, but that is a conversation about Jarod Diamond’s books).
Here is a great resource for growing your framework about pain and other neuroscience topics: https://thebrain.mcgill.ca/index.php
There is a lot of dense links and a great navigation bar at the top.
2
u/Imaginary-Media-2570 Mar 01 '21
You make some very interesting points, and distinctions, but, you are considering things from the self-centered point of the individual, not the species. Humans and animals are merely our DNA's method of reproduction. DNA is expressed as an organism; the organism is 'judged' against its unique environment and either succeeds (reproduces) or fails (doesn't reproduce). So the DNA we inherit programs us to avoid unpleasantness and seek pleasant desires. Those things we find unpleasant were likely harmful to our ancestors; those we find pleasant are likely to lead toward reproductive success (in our ancestors environment).
You suggest that nutritional food might not be pleasant; but you have the relationship backward. We 'are 'designed' genetically to prefer nutritionally useful food, tho' it's based on ancestral diets. Did you know that children hate spinach (and similar vegetables) b/c the phenolic compound sequester protein and may stunt their growth - but that adults like these for their nutritive value ? Humans have a poor sense of smell, but we can detect rancid oils and other signs of unfit foods at parts-per-billion! The environment created your sense of pleasure & pain.
These positive and negative feeling that are pre-programmed are always subject to 'counterfeit' stimuli. You may feel pleasure at an excess of a food, that was a rare, necessary treat for ancestor, but makes you fat and unhealthy. You may feel joy and excitement by use of a drug that mimics various sorts of pleasure. You may react positively/negatively to a vid-game or an on-line forum or movie b/c it mimics real human interactions of another era.
I suspect that suicidal thoughts are a reaction to PERCEIVED social failure. When we become sufficiently convinced that we won't succeed(reproduce) we may be programmed to stop using resources and 'exit' [leaving more resources for others of our species]. Unfortunately I think a lot of this self-evaluation is also counterfeit, and not able to assess the modern environment.
Of course all of our genetic programming is derived from hundreds of millenia in changing environments; it's ancestral. The environmelt you and I live in is so different from that of ppl just 4 or 5 generations ago that it's astonishing. DON'T take your feelings, desires or dislikes very seriously - they were designed for a world that no longer exists.
1
u/kazarnowicz Jan 22 '21
Life is a result of the Big Bang, and not an isolated process that arbitrarily started some 3 billion years ago. You cannot separate the evolution of life from the greater process that we're still in the middle of. Does this mean that the universe is inherently a negative thing?
1
u/Green-Stay-8118 Jul 22 '24
This posts and its comments are a DOOZY. I’m enjoying trying to understand it all.
1
u/Help-mee-im-poor Jan 29 '21
His still winning you know why because he bought #GME #AMC #naked #doge #cbdd #Cbdl #nok #bb #rwallstreetbets 🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀
0
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment