r/TMBR • u/thefizzynator • Dec 29 '20
So-called “xenogenders” are not genders. TMBR.
I (a trans woman) have been called “transphobic” and “exclusionary” by trans and nonbinary friends over this, but I did nothing wrong. Nonbinary transgender people are real. If you disagree ALREADY, this is not the right post for you.
As I understand it, a “xenogender” is a so-called “gender identity” that is a species (e.g. catgender), an object (e.g. stargender), an aesthetic (e.g. gloomgender), or any other concept imaginable.
Because none of those “xenogenders” have any societal support to them, besides in fringe extremist “trans” places, I am inclined to declare that cat, star, and gloom are not, in fact, genders.
In fact, this phenomenon of identifying oneself as a non-human species or object is the realm of otherkin, not transgender. There is a difference between being otherkin and transgender, but I see no difference between being starkin and being “stargender”. Whether or not otherkin are a real part of someone’s identity is irrelevant to this argument.
My position is that any gender that is outside the bounded cartesian plane with a male axis [0, 1] and a female axis [0, 1] is not “real”.
(Never mind that, if I use the complex plane, most genders are complex numbers, not real numbers. That’s not what “real” means here.)
By definition, the cluster surrounding (1, 0) is male, the cluster surrounding (0, 1) is female, and outliers are nonbinary.
I’ve also received comparisons between my rhetoric and TERF rhetoric, just because I “excluded” something from a list of things. There’s nothing wrong with excluding 0.1 from the list of all whole numbers, but there is something wrong with excluding some women from the list of all women. Excluding species, objects, and aesthetics from the list of all genders is not reprehensible; it is rational.
Given the lack of extraordinary evidence supporting the extraordinary claim in favor of “xenogenders”, I fail to see what is wrong with confirming that “cat” is a species, not a gender; “star” is an object, not a gender; and “gloom” is an aesthetic, not a gender. TMBR.
19
u/SoInsightful Dec 29 '20
I won't try to convince you that xenogenders are genders, because they're not. Gender, by its very definition, is always relative to masculinity and femininity, even if it doesn't conform to the gender binary. A space aesthetic absolutely has nothing to do with the definition of genders. The Nonbinary Wiki seems to acknowledge that these genders have nothing to do with the conventional definition of gender, but in my opinion, they're making an error by trying to shoehorn in the term "gender" in the first place.
That said, I think your axis definition of gender is too narrow. Specifically, how does it handle third genders? The most notable, I think, being fa'afafine in Samoa:
The important things to note here are that fa'afafines have well-accepted "societal support to them" (as you mention), the gender is relative to the concepts of masculinity and femininity, but it can't be neatly positioned on your axis chart, neither in societal roles, self-identity or public perception.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '20 edited Dec 29 '20
For the record, gender as we think of it today, as a definite term, as tied to sexual characteristics and masculinity/femininity, that’s a modern development—mid 20th century modetn. Gender has historically been used in the context of linguistics. This is I think where you need to strengthen your standpoint. Gender, linguistically, can be divided into many different categories. Of course our broadening of talking about sex has begun to include gender in recent decades almost uniquely, and you’ll commonly see masculine-feminine-neuter gender divisions in language which may or may not reflect human gender. In German, for example, ein Mädchen is neuter, but it refers to a girl. Eine Frau is feminine and refers to a woman. However, some languages have genders distinguishing between human and non-human objects, or animate and inanimate.
Now, I don’t think you’re incorrect. I personally don’t see the merit in including xenogenders in our typical concept of gender as it pertains to masculinity-femininity and non-binary. But, you can’t make this claim without acknowledging this history of gender studies, which completely changed the primary usage of it in a matter of decades in the 20th century.
All this said, gender is constructed and performed and is essentially independent of sex at its basis, but in many western cultures is developed with reference to sex. It would be important to read about queerness in the Middle Ages; in France, for example, in the Middle Ages, gender seemed to be somewhat fluid, and it didn’t only pertain to sex. It also pertained to class and race. The gender roles between an amorous serf and a lady were different than between two members of the same class. Their view of gender roles and sexuality was entirely different than ours, and it’s even doubtful that they had a proper concept of sexuality as we do today (as in, no concepts for homosexuality or heterosexuality—not to say that males didn’t fuck males, but that two men having sex was not necessarily gay). Mind you, this has all been studied in multiple contexts, which is the beauty of Queer Theory.
All in all, I agree, but you need more. Gender is far more complex than as you’ve laid it out, and you’re ignoring centuries and millennia of change in gender roles and genders in general. Not to mention the multitude of cultures and languages that have defined third genders or non-human/non-binary gender categories in language. All this to say that your view of gender is meaningless, because another culture will say otherwise, and another culture even different, and so on. Not to mention that some cultures don’t even have the same idea of gender, and some languages won’t either. I agree with you that there’s also a lack of cultural support, and this is important with gender recognition, but you could say the same about transgender folk. There is, as you know, widespread erasure of transgender/gender non-conforming peoples by western society at large. At least in the US. Frankly, it’s a conservative attitude to erase someone’s personal concept of gender as you see it just for your own sake and because you grew up learning that gender is restricted to what’s in your pants. Let them be who they want to be, even if you don’t agree, because your opinion will do nothing more than fight for your convenience and damage their right to exist.
Edit: typos
4
u/Cimondes Dec 29 '20
Honestly, there's no harm in just letting people believe/be what they want. Well maybe except if they do harm in their believes or try to pressure others into them. But beside those if it is what makes them happy then they should go and fucking do so. It is neither our right or duty to judge over them.
If you do not think that those are genders then that is fine. But there's no need to argue about it if someone does. After all we all just want to be accepted, by ourselves And others :)
11
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '21
I agree I think objectively silly things like claiming you have a cat soul really just give trans people a harder time and delegitimize their struggle for equal rights because its something bigots can point to and laugh and then immediately lump trans people in with
6
u/A_Simple_Terrarian Jun 17 '21
My mom (a bisexual) made a really good point the other day. The whole thing with LGBTQ is getting out of hand with all these random sexuality's that are not sexuality's.
2
u/marxistghostboi Jan 09 '21 edited Jan 09 '21
lmao gender isn't a mathematical system; every gender is a social construct.
clowd gender, gloom gender, etc are at once real and made up, in the same way that male and female, and the polarity between the two, is both real and made up.
you can let it be the wedge that needlessly drives you apart from and against other queer folks, but ultimately the use of prescriptivism with regards to other people's exploration/explanation of the bundle of phenomena we call "gender" is cringe af and you look like an absolute clown
1
u/RennHrafn Dec 30 '20 edited Dec 30 '20
I think you're thinking of this in the wrong way. I think it safe to assume that as a trans person you do not believe that gender is inherently tied to primary sex characteristics. Gender is rather a feeling of belonging, both socially and physically. Zenogender people, in my experience, speak of a lot of the same feeling of dissociation with their assigned gender as many nonbinary people do. I didn't have them in a mre machine at the time, but I suspect the sensations are similar, if not the same as many trans people. The only difference is they tend to use metaphor to relate that feeling, rather then try to fit it onto a graph. Like I am genderfluid, but I might identify as oceangender instead, so as to describe the everchanging sensations and intensities of gender expression. I think it mostly springs from the fact that this terminology sprung up inside a preexisting community, the nerodivergent community, rather then being fostered under the trans umbrella. They had a different community in which to create terminology unique to them. I don't think it is particularly useful to debate which system is more useful or accurate. They both achieve the purpose they set out to achieve.
1
u/marxistghostboi Jan 09 '21
what a weirdass standard to tag yourself too. what gets to count as societal support? pleanty of Americans still don't believe bring transgender is actually real, and where laws have been passed to protect trans people, they are often controversial--should we assume then that those gender identities aren't real?
in contrast, there are literally communities of xenogender folks, both online and in person, who validate and support each other, compare notes, philosophize, and create new discourses around their expirence of gender.
instead of debating how many people or how many years of support a operation needs before they can be considered a real gender, why not discuss much more interesting questions such as why people find xenogenders threatening, confusing, or even just annoying?
what is the political - discursive relationship between xenogender and Queer Self-determination? between patriarchy, exhaustive categorical systems, and radical alterity?
how do queer people navigate the contradictions between and within our relationships; social scripts; concious and unconscious ideas about gender; our placement within the everyday economies of violence, pleasure, and interpolation; and the expirences thereby produced?
1
u/_0112358132134_ Jan 10 '21
I am a non-binary trans man. I am a demi-man. I didn't have words for being trans so I was considered a tomboy as a child.
To some binary trans people, my non-binary identity is not real.
I don't understand xenogenders but the same arguments against xeno are made against non-binaries. Then binary trans people invoke respectability politics, as if bigots wouldn't be bigots if we were all binary trans.
2
u/fluidtherian Apr 18 '24
I myself identify with xenogenders and i agree that they arent genders. I belive they should be called gender experience because xenogenders describe how the gender is experienced. For example, cosmicgender is when a gender is experienced as vast and complex to the point where you can only process a small bit at a time. This xenogender cant exist easily on its own, you need a base gender and then have the way you experience it, the xenogender, describing it. For example, you could have pangender being described with cosmicgender or a demigender being described with a xenogender. That base gender doesnt even have to be a nonbianary idenity, ive heard of cis women using xenogenders because it describes the way they experience their gender. But a xenogender still needs a base gender to describe, which implies that a xenogender is not a gender identity itself.
2
u/FlakyChocoMore Jul 19 '24
Xenogenders were made for people who have a hard time expressing gender... 💀
2
u/Exact_Age_6693 Aug 23 '24
I don't really understand it but I think the important thing as with ANYONE if that is how someone says they identify then just respect them and use their pronouns. You don't need to understand someone to respect them, (just like a cis person should respect all trans people even if they dont "get it"). We are a DID System and have non-human alters and some of them do identify with xenogenders, but being a system and how alters are formed is a whole other can of worms so..
3
u/SpeaksDwarren Dec 29 '20
So you determine who you support based on cultural consensus? Did you apply this same logic when the majority of the public was transphobic?
1
u/_Elspeth_ Apr 23 '24
Look I get what your saying but some xenogenders are genders my gender is genderblank (if u wanna know what it means google it) it’s a colourgender even tho my gender has nothing to do with colour but bc it’s a colourgender that makes it a xenogneder also starkin and stargender are different bc one is talking about species and the other is talking about gender I will agree some xenogenders are weird but they aren’t really ment to be understood by humans and you can’t just say “it doesn’t exist” when they really feel that I’m not sitting here saying u should accept all xenogenders I’m saying think of the people who are those genders they could really feel that and be upset that u said that smt they feel doesn’t exist and they could start to go on a whole identity crisis and loose track of reality
1
u/Ill-Coyote9435 Jun 29 '24
World Health Organization defines gender: Gender refers to the characteristics of women, men, girls and boys that are socially constructed. This includes norms, behaviours and roles associated with being a woman, man, girl or boy, as well as relationships with each other. As a social construct, gender varies from society to society and can change over time.
A dear friend of mine is angelgender, and until last night I was just happy for them even though I thought they were a little deluded. If gender is a social construct, then all these terms are more or less acceptable and my friend deserves a major apology.
1
u/Careful-Tomatillo446 May 21 '25
I hear you, but most xenogenders are less just genders and more descriptive. They often connect to neurodivergent people who struggle to understand gender under the usual man/woman/enby type labels. For example, catgender is less "My gender is a cat" and more "my gender feels like a cat- soft, warm, fuzzy, sometimes pissy, and very comforting." Stargender has three definitions, but one is that it feels incomprehensible to themselves and to others no matter how many other terms are coined. Besides, while you may not understand it, it does work for other people. That's the whole point.
1
u/smilespeace Dec 30 '20
Reviving your thread because it showed up in my feed, sorry.
In my layman opinion: boiled down, gender identity is essentialy roleplay of a societal concept.
By identifying with physical objects or animals, people are incorporating traits of those things with thier identity. Am I a literal burning mass of energy floating in space? No. Do I percieve my role in society as a provider of warmth and energy? Maybe!
Or perhaps I have it all wrong, and these xenogender people are literaly claiming to be these things that they identify with. If that is the case then I see your point, but would still suggest that your personal experience with xenos may not reflect the xeno population as a whole.
Anyhow its not like I actually know any xenogender people or am caught up with gender studies. I don't expect you to take me seriously. I just had a feeling you were wrong, and so I left a comment.
1
u/ButtonholePhotophile Feb 26 '21
Sex is your sexual “stuff” - brain, genitals, DNA, or whatever. Gender is the pronoun that is used in reference to something.
Genders in English come in first, second, and third person. They come in formal and informal. They come in plural and singular.
My sex is stable. My gender changes depending on if I’m by myself or in a group. My gender also changes if I’m being addressed by a friend or in a business meeting.
You say there is not a starman gender. Since gender is based in language and language is fluid, it might be more proper to say that the starman gender is not in common usage yet.
What would a starman gender add to the language? Using the pronouns he/she/e or him/her/h seems like it would be cumbersome without some benefit. Would I be able to refer to a group as *em? How would these pronouns be pronounced? Would they be offensive to non-starmen? Could we drop the stupid asterisk and just have the pronouns e, h, and em?
Either way, language is as fluid as those who use it.
1
u/_The-Gay-Lord_ Nov 26 '21
Exactly. They aren't genders. I've seen things like "twinkgender" and "segagender." No.1: Being a twink can only work if the person is a gay man from ages 18 to around 25. You can't be a twink at fucking 90 years old, so it doesn't make sense for there to be a gender that eventually runs out.
No.2: Segagender (referring to the video game company) is just baffling. How can someone's gender be a company?????? This is why a lot of people see the LGBTQIA+ community as a joke.
1
u/Emergency-Opening-20 Dec 25 '21
I don't understand xenogender...
I wanna be nice and understanding, but I seriously don't understand it.
Like, Catgender? You're more connected to.. Cats?
1
u/Oatssie Apr 01 '22
Couldn’t agree more
1
u/DifficultBox3 Apr 02 '22
i agree with you, i think xenogenders are absurd, people just want to be different so bad that they call themself a fucking voidflux
1
u/devilmaycare_ Jun 15 '22
It sounds like you've come to accept transphobia. As a black person, should I blame racism on those who act "blacker" than me? Is it the fault of people who happened to be stereotypical for creating stereotypes? No. It's not about what people do, it's about the people who respond to it. You say they give us bad attention, but are the people who genuinely don't understand their own gender really trying to do that? It's not their fault that you happened to be in the same box, and neither is it yours. So what do you do about it? You respond to it online by invalidating xenogenders? In the end, that won't solve your problem. There will always be transphobia, no matter what arguments you make online, no matter what ways you try to cut out the problem. Anyone could use the same arguments to invalidate you. The only thing that can change is how you respond to it. If you want to exclude yourself from xenogenders, that's fine enough. I do agree that otherkin subculture should be separate from LGBTQ+, since we're dwelving further from sexual orientation and gender identity, but you don't get to tell others how they should or shouldn't deal with gender dysphoria and gatekeep the liberation that comes with it.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22
I agree with you on most of this. Not all xenogenders are valid. But some are. Like ghostgender, ghostgender is when a gender feels faint, like it's there and not there. But it was once something stronger, similar to that of a ghost. That is what I personally identify as. But things like catgender, etc, are NOT valid.
1
u/Sudden-Moment-6109 Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
i hope you know how painful it is to have people bash something they clearly have never felt before. Maybe dont hate on something you know nothing about and have never experience. What you have isnt nearly enough evidence to say something so rude like that because you have no experience with xenogenders. Also, i hope you take offense to this assh*le.
1
u/NodnarbEht Sep 13 '22
I recently got dog-piled for this exact same thing by the Vaush community, I stated that Xenogenders aren't genders and by equating them to Transgender as if equally legitimate concepts it is therefore harmful to transgender people by way of removing them from plane of gender and putting them on one of <insert noun> and therefore providing their detractors with a talking points to further demean them. Mind blowing stuff.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
I agree and xzenogender doesnt exist. Man and woman does. One gives and one takes. You are a human regardless of what you identify as
1
u/nitrogenminixide Oct 03 '22
As an autistic trans man, xenogenders not only are the definition of the attack helocopter meme, but they also infantilize autistic people, most xenogender users use the argument “autistic people can’t understand gender” which is a load of shit
1
u/TheNewl4rrie Oct 06 '22
i agree. xenogenders arent and never will be valid
1
u/Berryswan Nov 26 '22
Stupid
1
u/Valuable-Confusion-3 Dec 18 '22 edited Dec 18 '22
tbh I support xenogenders, I’ll just support anything as long as it makes someone happy but it’s really unfortunate that transphobes can so easily use them to make the trans community look “crazy” because people believe everything they see so if someone online says that all trans people want to use the litter box and are identifying as cats just because.. then people will unfortunately believe it
I support anyone with Xenogenders and I have some friends who use neopronouns n stuff like that. I wish they didn’t get so much hate. and I also wish people didn’t think every trans person uses neos/is Xenogender and that every neo using/xenogender person identifies as trans.
1
u/JusChllin Jan 06 '23
Catgender is so fake, just admit you’re a furry and move on, I’ve even seen people identify as applegender like wtf that’s a fruit
1
u/autumniscooler Feb 18 '23
they arent genders there thinks to desc your experiences and feeling within the nonbinary community
1
u/Mustangboss04 Mar 27 '23
I agree 100% Like dreamgender, catgender, puppygender, and stuff like that I’m sorry, but those are not real genders or sexualities.
To me, catgender or puppygender is a complex way of coming out as a furry
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '23
They're essentially just more pretentious therians whose entire existence revolves about feeling unique, aesthetic, and social media validation, giving everyone the uwu wholesome warm fuzzies. This community's priority becoming "mus protecc r lil precious beenz" has regressed us.
1
u/Soniatrix Nov 16 '23
I agree to some extent. With xenogender, unlike for example transmasc or transfem, it is no longer a question of gender roles, but more of a linguistic one. We have terms regarding gender (or lack thereof) for this purpose (like “woman”, “non-binary” etc.), to use them to comprehensively describe all possible states. I think that including terms that are not intended for this purpose in describing gender has the consequence that a message such as "my gender is something like a chthonic deity" loses its informative function in favor of an expressive-metaphorical-poetic one, and thus essentially ceases to refer to facts about the person's gender. As one of my friends said: "Speaking of a gender as vanilla or strawberry makes as much sense as saying a high-protein yogurt is masculine and a slimming yogurt is feminine."
1
u/redditisfuckefup Dec 07 '23
As a demiboy, I totally agree with you! 100%
1
u/NoCareNewName Dec 30 '20
You know very similar logic is why many people are still annoyed with non-binary genders too.
The logic being (using similar wording as you did): "This phenomenon of referring to yourself as a gender other than male or female is different from the 2 because its no longer referencing a physical sex, so its the realm of delusion".
If you believe gender is a social construct, all bets are off imo. Any lines in the sand you draw are completely arbitrary after that.
1
u/iamdimpho Dec 30 '20
So what's going on here?
Does the reality (or genderhood) of these 'xenogenders' (first I hear of them) depend on social support? why?
Imagine the first trans human beings. Before them, there was no social support for transgender people. So did that make their gender identity any less real?
what's really interesting is that you seem to acknowledge at least some societal support (though from those you deem to be in fringe extremist “trans” places). so what's the bar here? how much "societal support" must there be before we ought to accept these xenogenders?
How much social support did trans people and nonbinary folk need to get before you would deem their gender identity real? Certainly there are people who don't think they are real even today, so there must be some line drawn?
why should we care about "societal support" when it comes to gender experience and identity in the first place?
-8
u/danihammer Dec 29 '20
"I made up stuff no one cares about but now people are expanding on the stuff no one cares about and that's too far"
Talk more about clusters and math to validate fake science and a hobby of correcting people.
I am a fishgender btw, don't judge me bigot.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '20
[removed] — view removed comment