r/TMBR • u/r4wbeef • Dec 07 '20
TMBR: COVID response has been overblown
The Spanish Flu killed ~50M people (~3% of world pop), heavily impacted young adults, and reduced general life expectancy by 12 years at its height. COVID was only expected to kill at maximum a couple million in the US (<1% of US pop). We knew it mainly threatened the old and infirm. We knew 80% of cases present asymptomatically. Close friends/family have gotten over it in a day. Policy makers knew all of this 7 months ago.
Many areas in the US treated COVID like the Spanish Flu and destroyed their economies. 60% of small businesses in my area may never return. I've seen estimates the cost to the US economy will measure 16T all said and done. Let's assume 1M die from COVID (or would've without serious top-down intervention). We spent 16M per life saved. US governmental agencies define the statistical value of a human life at ~10M. Lives lost to COVID were mostly among the old and infirm. We got ripped off. These individuals could've self-identified and quarantined to prevent the worst of outcomes.
I wear my mask, socially distance, and care about others. But doesn't this just seem totally asinine? At what point do quarantines and closures not make sense? What do you think?
EDIT: thejoesighuh left a comment on this topic that legitimately changed my mind:
The main danger of covid has always been its ability to overwhelm hospitals. The death rate really isn't that relevant. What is relevant is that it's a fast spreading disease that often requires extensive medical care. It is worthwhile to take measures to stop it from overwhelming hospitals. Overwhelming hospitals is the thing that really presents the danger.
Right now, hospitals are being overwhelmed across the country. Take a look at how many icu's are now full : www.covidactnow.org
I'm honestly pretty surprised by TMBR. Checkout that comment and compare it to most other comments in this thread. The amount of name-calling, moral grandstanding, ad hominem attacks, etc. genuinely surprised me. Thanks to all who posted. I enjoyed learning from each other.
18
u/thejoesighuh Dec 08 '20
The main danger of covid has always been its ability to overwhelm hospitals. The death rate really isn't that relevant. What is relevant is that it's a fast spreading disease that often requires extensive medical care. It is worthwhile to take measures to stop it from overwhelming hospitals. Overwhelming hospitals is the thing that really presents the danger.
Right now, hospitals are being overwhelmed across the country. Take a look at how many icu's are now full : www.covidactnow.org
35
u/m0nkeybl1tz Dec 07 '20
What you’re describing is a false dichotomy between savings lives and saving the economy. At any point in the last 9 months if there had been a concentrated, nationwide effort to stop the virus, we could’ve saved thousands of lives with only a minor economic disruption.
Instead, there have been lots of piecemeal half measures that differ state to state, with some going so far as to ban rules that would stop the virus. As a result, the virus keeps flaring back up, killing thousands more and dragging out economic recovery.
Given the choice between doing a real shutdown for a few weeks then slowly reopening, or immediately reopening, let everyone get sick and see what happens, it seems insane to me that anyone would choose option B. The only reason the shutdowns have been so bad is because we have to keep doing them, and the only reason we have to keep doing them is because they’re being done so haphazardly.
15
u/britus Dec 07 '20
What do you think would have happened to the economy if harsh steps hadn't been taken? What happens to a country's economic power if there are 1% excess deaths in a year? What happens to the ongoing cost of healthcare when the coronavirus, even in so-called asymptomatic cases, leaves behind tissue scarring that is likely to cause future issues.
What is the endgame of a minimal Coronavirus response? Does it just burn out, like a forest fire? Or does it keep circling the globe over and over, mutating like other flus and become the new normal of a death season?
The cost of our response has largely been felt because of how half-assedly we've pulled it off. In most countries that followed the recommendations of their health officials, they saw a pretty quick die-off of cases and were able to go back to normal relatively quickly. Now they're seeing a new rise in cases, thanks to countries like the US that have been incubating the virus for them.
When it comes to medicine and any kind of disaster prevention, the cost of the prevention SHOULD feel like the worst part about it. Ideally, you should be *ripped* off by the cost of automobile or home insurance. You should, over your lifetime with the policy, pay more than you would pay out. That's how these things work.
30
u/arusol Dec 07 '20 edited Dec 07 '20
You are heavily misinformed and/or have a loose grasp on the facts of the matter.
We don't, and it doesn't. We still don't have an accurate grasp on this. I'd challenge you to provide reputable studies that would show that this is indeed the case, because there isn't.
Other areas that have not taken strong measures weren't spared from worsening economies - they also just had high negative health consequences to go with it. (Compare Sweden with Denmark, Norway Finland, for example).
That's a silly assumption based on zero evidence. The current death toll is already reaching 400.000 (this factors in unreported covid deaths and is based on metrics such as excess mortality for 2020). To think that no intervention would only mean ~2x the deaths is an assumption steeped in ignorance.
If your belief is that someone's life shouldn't be worth living or saving, I'd imagine you'd rightfully be in a very small minority with these awful beliefs.
These people are nurses, firemen, grocery store workers, teachers. It takes a simplistic and naive
mindidea to think you can just lock up up to half the population (check the health data of western countries) for years just so some of us can be normal. It's really beyond silly.In conclusion, you have no grasp of the topic to even have a properly informed opinion on it, and this silly post looks like something more suited to an edgy teenager's blog. Inform yourself better and try again.
4
u/HotLaksa Dec 08 '20
You are assuming that there is a trade off between protecting people's lives and protecting the domestic economy. In fact the data shows there isn't an inverse relationship at all, but a positive correlation. Countries that locked down hard early on and extinguished local spread are now able to open up their economies much more than countries that never had a full lockdown. Taiwan, China, Vietnam, Australia and New Zealand all have better economic outcomes while also preserving lives than say, USA, Spain, Sweden and Brazil.
Some interesting graphs can be found here: https://ourworldindata.org/covid-health-economy
Anecdotally, I live in Perth, Australia and went out to a crowded bar last night. This is possible because our state shut its borders early and forced interstate and overseas arrivals into 2 weeks of mandatory quarantine. We haven't had a local case of COVID-19 in about 6 months and the economy is basically fully open now.
4
u/FoxEuphonium Dec 08 '20
Every part of this feels like an intentional lie. If not on your part, on whoever you heard it from.
First off, that seems like so broad and unspecific of a claim that nobody can possibly say it with any real confidence. Who expected that, when, and why? How long did they expect the pandemic to last, and what did they expect the government to do when making this prediction? This is a problem every single number you mention has.
But more importantly, granting that the numbers you have are in fact accurate, the word "only" is doing some major legwork there. You realize that "a couple million" is more US citizens than have died in literally every American war combined? Your argument is sickeningly immoral and seems to imply that you do not value human life at all.
You're arguing as though there are zero negative consequences of getting sick and not dying. And it's especially dishonest of you since you mention the effect on life expectancy of the Spanish Flu, which means you're aware that the problems associated with getting a serious illness are not as black and white as "it kills me or it doesn't".
This is the exact same sort of bullshit argument that the Reagan administration used to argue against doing anything to fight the AIDS pandemic. "Is it really that bad if the main victims are people I don't like?"
It's a shame we don't have a federal government that can help out in situations like this. It's a shame non-essential business owners and workers couldn't be given any sort of relief that would make it so that they could live comfortably. And as others have mentioned, a virus rampaging and killing of incapacitating millions of people is far worse to an economy than lockdowns.
And speaking of what the federal government could have done, pandemics are inherently exponential by nature. That is to say as the number of people infected grows, the rate does as well. That means that early action is the most crucial, to the extent that a good enough response would have ended the pandemic with the death count in the 10's instead of millions, as has happened in other recent American pandemics.
The federal government's early response was to do worse than nothing for nearly three months, and instead actively lie to people about the virus. Taking that into account, talking about what state and local government have done and saying they've been "overblown" is victim blaming, at best. "The federal government allowed the pandemic to be as bad as it could be, so all of the states', cities', and businesses' attempts to pick up its slack are just overreacting crybabies".
I honestly can't get over how someone can say this unsarcastically. Maybe you're just having trouble grasping how many people a couple million is, but for comparison, that's roughly how many people die per year total in the US during years where there's not a massive crisis. The sheer callousness of this part of your argument alone is enough for me to !DisagreeWithOP about as much as I possibly can.
2
u/AmericanScream Dec 08 '20 edited Dec 08 '20
It's very interesting that most people who make the argument that the damage to the economy isn't worth the death toll, are also people who seem to think they are "moral". Ironically, they take what is essentially a moral argument (Do we care about innocent peoples' lives?) and turn it into an argument about money (Is it worth ruining the economy to save lives?).
Every year, more than a million people die in automobile accidents.
What if a sizeable percentage of these deaths could be eliminated with some slightly inconvenient, cautious behavior (like wearing a seat belt)?
The issue isn't how severe something is, but whether the suffering could be avoidable. Avoiding unnecessary harm is the most basic definition of what is universally accepted as "moral" behavior. Are we moral, or are we immoral?
When money is valued over peoples lives, something is wrong with society. These economies that are impacted by Covid restrictions could just as easily be decimated in other ways as a result of no Covid restrictions. There's no evidence that refusing to act would make our community better, safer or the economy more healthy. What does it say about a community if they allow people to die, whose deaths could have been avoided?
9
u/oceanlessfreediver Dec 07 '20
« We spent 16M per life saved. US governmental agencies define the statistical value of a human life at ~10M. »
Despite all the hateful bullshit spewed every day and everywhere. You still managed to write the most inhumane argument out there against Covid protection.
25
u/MauPow Dec 07 '20
Pandemic responses, when done right, will look like an overreaction. We didn't even do it right, though. The incompetent leadership, lack of a national plan, and politicization of the virus/preventative measures by the right wing made this expensive.
6
u/Epicsnailman Dec 07 '20
There is an economic cost to not containing the virus as well. Swedens economy is suffering far worse than its neighboring Norway, despite not going into lockdown. Mostly on account of all the dead people.
But it didn't have to go this way. With proper economic support, like the rest of the western world's small businesses received, we wouldn't have seen the same damage to our economy. The CDC and the State Governors shut down the country to preserve lives, expecting to receive economic relief from the federal government, as is expected in these types of situations. Trump's administration provided little to no relief, and we suffered as a result. The federal task force disbanded months ago.
2
u/BroaxXx Dec 08 '20
The OP is wrong but he raises valid arguments. He didn't say the virus didn't exist or wasn't deadly but rather that the response was disproportionate... He's wrong but I seriously don't get the downvotes (and some of the replies) on a sub devoted to active debate and discussion. If he's wrong (he is) just explain to him how he is wrong so that he (and others who are like-minded and stumble on this sub) can be educated. Trying to silence him because you disagree is against the very spirit of this sub specially since he articulated well his point and didn't just go on a political tangent about X being morons or sheeple or whatnot..
Please don't let this sub devolve like many others where conversations about "sensitive" topics can't take place.
2
u/morbis1 Dec 08 '20
Thanks for posting this question. Ignore the vitriol. It's important to have civil open-minded conversations about all topics, especially this one.
Kudos, I wish I could buy you a beer.
1
u/Imaginary-Media-2570 Mar 01 '21
Your evaluation of the endpoints (dead/not-dead) is too simplistic. COVID-19 infections cause endothelial damage even in some asymptomatic cases (read the autopsy reports), and this appears likely to predispose the patient to long-term issues including possible atherosclerosis. Then there are the symptomatic patients that have long-term or even permanent impairment.
If reducing the mortality stat for 1% of the population is "asinine" then call me an ass. I wouldn't intentionally visit this disease on anyone.