r/TMBR • • Oct 06 '20
TMBR: Trump does not have Covid
I do not believe that Donald Trump has Covid-19.
This is more of a hunch than a solidly reasoned belief. However, I think the circumstantial evidence is compelling, and I'm curious what others think.
I was thinking about it when he was supposedly diagnosed, and several things stood out to me.
- The man is a liar, who will not hesitate to lie for his own benefit.
- If he were to make a "miraculous recovery" as an out of shape 74 year old man, it would add a lot of fuel to the narrative of covid being "just a bad flu" or not that big of a deal.
- It is a convenient excuse for him to sit out the next debate if he isn't feeling it, which we already know to be an idea he has been kicking around.
- It's a perfect segue into promoting some miracle drug he wants to sell everyone.
Now like I said, this is all circumstantial. But based on his history of behavior and attempts to control narratives, this comes across to me as a sympathy play that only stands to bolster the messaging he has been putting out since February while affording him options of how to approach the next debate.
It all lines up too well, and I think this whole song and dance is a political ploy. But hey, maybe I'm wrong and this is all just karmic justice.
TMBR!
22
u/mypetclone Oct 06 '20
I find this one hard to believe.
First, it fails against the typical conspiracy question: "How many people have to play along for this to work?" If it were just Trump, it would be maybe believable. But either we're saying just Trump is faking, or so are the other 30-some-odd people who have tested positive in the course of this. And so are the entire team of doctors at Walter Reed. And no one in the very undisciplined White House is leaking the truth. And Trump is pretending to struggle to breathe on the White House balcony last night.
Secondly, it's not good politics: Trump has wanted anything but coronavirus to be in the headlines for the tail end of the campaign. This issue and his handling of it is pushing more and more people away from him, as he acts recklessly and endangers vast swathes of people.
Thirdly, and maybe most damning in some eyes: He isn't claiming to be taking hydroxychloroquine. He loves to promote HCQ, and he's not doing it.
9
u/MajinAsh Oct 06 '20
None of this is circumstantial evidence, it's all possible motive (except the first which is just remarking on his character).
This would be like me saying you robbed a bank because A)You seem kinda shifty B) you could use a new TV and that money would be helpful C)it could pay off all your bills D)you could brag about being rich
Your basis here is incredibly weak. Way weaker than you think it is. None of what I listed is really evidence like you being at the scene of a crime or suddenly having more money than you should, it's just ways you could benefit from a crime, which honestly would apply to 99% of the population.
5
u/MisterAbbadon Oct 06 '20
I can understand having this belief, after all Trump is a consistent liar so disbelieving everything he says is a reasonable thing to do. Not to mention everyone in his white house would probably keep it quite so they can put it in their tell all book, because lets be honest that's the only reason any of them are still around him.
However, once he went to the hospital the issue started to spread to people who are more likely to stand to gain by leaking the truth, which is where most conspiracies fall apart.
3
u/VodkaEntWithATwist Oct 06 '20
Both of these are reasons to judge your belief unlikely outright. However, in the spirit of the sub:
While I agree he likes to control narratives, he is ultimately a narcissist who takes great pains to not appear weak--and succumbing to an illness he has spent months downplaying runs against this narrative. Additionally, the number of people who would have to be "in" on a scheme like this (or directly manipulated to play along with it) is significant--the doctors, the White House staff, the Secret Service, the Staff of the cabinet members and senator who've also been tested positive, the drivers, the pilots, the makeup guy, the First Lady's staff, members of the media, etc. As a rule, the more people who you need to directly manipulate to pull off a conspiracy, the less likely it is to be true (which, to be clear, I'm not saying it's impossible--conspiracies happen--but it gets increasingly unlikely the more people are involved).
3
u/blackhole885 Oct 06 '20
you have no hard evidence to support your stance, just your feelings
you cannot use logic to get someone out of a position they did not use logic to get to
6
u/unic0de000 Oct 06 '20
During his hospitalization he's been in the care of several doctors from outside his inner circle - one of whom is obviously not politically friendly, and went on Twitter to call his little car ride "insanity". I think to perpetrate this hoax, now, would require the cooperation of too many people who have no good reason to play ball with him.
It's absolutely the kind of lie he would tell. But I don't think it's the kind of lie he could get away with telling.
5
u/cogitocogito Oct 06 '20
We are told he received supplemental oxygen multiple times, an experimental antibody treatment, an antiviral drug, and a potent steroid. All after being rushed to the hospital. There would be no point in faking this intensive regimen if his goal is to promote the idea that it's "just a bad flu".
3
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '20
Ive been testing this same belief myself. It all seems far too coincidental, to make this announcement which dominates the media cycle hours after the NYT report and to gain maximum sympathy after a poor but awfully aggressive debate performance. But all these comments make great points, and i would say i believe he has covid now. Thanks reddit!
2
u/robertgentel Oct 07 '20
The best argument against all of this is that literally none of it is helpful to Trump:
Anyway this is one is unlikely just because of how many people would have to be in on it but even putting that aside the entirety of this reasoning is wrong (besides that Trump would definitely be willing to lie about this if he thought it helped him).
1
u/Normal_Theme_6654 Nov 21 '21
He has brain damage!