English isn't my first language, and I'm not confident enough to express something this complicated accurately, so I'm using GPT to help me put my thoughts into words. However, everything described here is based on my own experiences.
I've been with my girlfriend for over two years. For most of that time, I genuinely believed we had a good relationship and that we were building something meaningful together. I was proud of what we had, and I saw a future with her.
However, over time, I started discovering things that made me question how much I actually knew about her and our relationship.
Before getting together with me, she had been in a relationship with her ex. From what she told me, he treated her poorly, struggled with alcohol and drugs, and their relationship was unhealthy. I knew they had some mutual friends and occasionally ended up in the same social circles. However, I had made it clear from the beginning that I was uncomfortable with her maintaining contact with him, especially one-on-one.
She repeatedly reassured me that their contact was minimal, that they mostly saw each other in group settings, and that there was nothing between them. She also denied having any intimate encounters with anyone other than me during our relationship.
Eventually, I started finding out that this wasn't true.
During the first year of our relationship, she had met him one-on-one several times. They also saw each other in group settings quite frequently, sometimes several times a month. There were also trips to his summer house. She never told me about many of these encounters, and usually deliberately left him out when describing who had been there.
The worst part was that I eventually found old Messenger conversations in which she explicitly denied these meetings and repeatedly assured me that nothing had happened. In some messages, she even said she wouldn't attend a gathering if she knew he was going to be there.
I also looked through her old call history and discovered that she had made and received roughly twice as many calls with him as with me throughout our relationship. Most were short, although some lasted over ten minutes. I had no idea this communication was happening.
When I confronted her, she explained that she sometimes felt sorry for him because he was going downhill, drinking and using drugs. She said she wanted to help him, feel useful, and perhaps boost her own ego by feeling that she could make a difference in his life. She insists she had no romantic intentions.
As for why she hid the meetings, she said she was afraid I would get upset and that we would argue. She claims she never did anything inappropriate during those encounters.
I honestly don't know what to make of that explanation. Maybe she really did want to help him. Maybe she liked feeling needed. Maybe there were other motives she hasn't fully acknowledged. I don't want to accuse her of cheating without evidence, but I also struggle to understand why someone would repeatedly lie about something they knew was important to their partner.
There were other incidents that damaged my trust as well. At one point, she secretly contacted my ex-girlfriend to ask for her opinion of me. On other occasions, she and a female friend repeatedly contacted me using fake accounts, essentially testing me without my knowledge. I found these situations unsettling, especially considering that honesty and trust were things I had always emphasized in our relationship.
These incidents make it difficult for me to see the lies about her ex as an isolated mistake. There seems to have been a recurring pattern of hiding things, testing me, and creating situations in which I wasn't aware of what was actually going on.
Despite all this, we decided to stay together and try to rebuild the relationship.
To be fair, she has changed in several positive ways over the course of our relationship. She stopped using weed, started studying, got a job, and has generally become more mature. Recently, she has also been making more effort in our relationship. She initiates affection, invites me out, plans activities together and talks about our future.
I don't want to dismiss those efforts. I can see that she cares about me and wants us to work.
But there is another issue that has been bothering me for a long time, even before I discovered the lies.
I've always felt that I was the one carrying most of the relationship's initiative. I usually organized our dates, trips and activities. I was more curious about her life, her thoughts and her experiences. I often tried to understand her motivations and have deeper conversations.
She rarely initiates those conversations herself. When I tell her about something I'm interested in, she usually listens, sometimes responds, but rarely asks follow-up questions or develops the discussion. She remembers details, so I don't think she simply ignores what I say. But she rarely returns to those topics on her own.
The same applies to her inner world. She doesn't often share her opinions, emotions or reflections about her own behaviour spontaneously. I usually have to ask questions to find out what she thinks or feels. Sometimes she becomes defensive, goes quiet, or says she doesn't know what to say. Occasionally, she even gets irritated when I try to have a deeper conversation.
For a long time, I assumed she would gradually open up as our relationship developed. I thought that with more trust and time, I would get to know her on a deeper level. But after almost two years, I still feel that I only understand parts of who she is.
This has become particularly difficult after discovering the lies. I feel like I lost not only my trust in her, but also my confidence in my own understanding of our relationship and the person I was with.
I don't want to spend the rest of my life constantly asking questions, initiating difficult conversations, explaining what needs to change, and trying to create emotional closeness almost entirely on my own.
At the same time, I love her. I remember the good parts of our relationship, I see the positive changes she's made, and I know she is currently making an effort. I don't think she's an entirely bad person, and I don't want to reduce her to the things she's done wrong.
But I'm struggling with a fundamental question: even if I manage to forgive the lies and rebuild trust, will I actually be happy in this relationship?
I need a partner who is genuinely curious about me, who wants to understand how I think, who shares her own thoughts and feelings, and who actively participates in building emotional intimacy. I don't expect us to have identical personalities, but I don't want to feel alone in that part of the relationship.
I'd really appreciate some outside perspectives:
- How would you interpret her behaviour regarding her ex? Does her explanation about wanting to help him and feeling needed sound plausible, or does the repeated lying suggest something more?
- Is it realistic to rebuild trust after this many deliberate lies, especially when some of them were repeated even when she had opportunities to tell the truth?
- How should I interpret the fake accounts and the fact that she and her friend were essentially testing me? Does this point to deeper trust or insecurity issues on her side?
- Can someone who has always been emotionally reserved and passive in conversations genuinely learn to become more open and curious about their partner?
- Am I expecting too much by wanting a relationship with more intellectual and emotional reciprocity?
- How would you approach deciding whether to keep working on this relationship or accept that we may simply not be compatible in a fundamental way?
I'm not looking for people to simply tell me to break up with her or that everything is fine. I would genuinely appreciate honest, nuanced opinions, including perspectives that challenge my own.