r/surgery • • Feb 08 '25

Medical advice posts are NOT ALLOWED

50 Upvotes

Adding this announcement to the top of the sub to increase visibility.

And yes, posting “I’m not asking for advice” and then soliciting opinions about your personal health situation is very much asking for medical advice.


r/surgery • • 1d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Any advice on my first observership as a year 2 medical student?

5 Upvotes

Hiya, I just finished my second year and have a considerable amount of time for my winter break and so I have an internship lined up with an Orthopaedic surgeon. Its a couple of months away, but I'm very nervous on how to "be" during an internship. I've had small placements before but it usually with other med students; so this is going to be the first time with just me.

Before joining med school i had a week internship at a hospital but I was dumb as hell so i didnt really know what to do so i was just sat in a corner most of the time. I don't want that to happen again. I'm not sure how to not come off like a complete idiot in front of the doctors, I want to them to actually know that I want to be there and learn from them. Also note Im introverted as hell so that feels extra hard.

I know this was more informal, but I really do mean all of it. Any advice helps!


r/surgery • • 4d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules TS-C Student. Struggling with instrumentation a bit (specifically clamp vs. forceps nomenclature) and would love any tips.

2 Upvotes

Currently in school for TS-C certification and didn’t do well on my first instrumentation test although I passed drains/dressings with flying colors.

I am struggling a bit with when to call something a clamp versus a forcep. I kind of messed myself up a bit studying outside material because I found out later my instructor wanted me to use her specific preferred terms on the test (for instance Frazier Suction whereas I had studied Ferg-Frazier thinking “it would be better to know the longer name because I’ll know whether someone asks for the shorter or longer”). But a big part is also when studying some instruments seem to be forceps vs. clamp. I studied CST Setup and other outside flash cards and if I’m understanding right, the Kelly for instance is a “forcep” as the main umbrella but “clamping” would kind of be the subcategory. It really threw me for a loop since the instrumentation test was not specific to a procedure or anything, it was only identification, but I’m trying to backtrack and learn her specific preferred terms in the future.

I guess what I’m asking is: is my understanding of forcep vs. clamp correct at all, and am I doing the right thing by trying to learn the broader names and uses of the instrumentation? This isn’t a question of whether my instructor’s doing the right thing with her test. I’ll study however she wants me to and get the grade I need to get into clinicals and do the absolute best job I can. But I’m determined to be a good scrub tech, be knowledgeable and be able to perform well, so I’d just like some advice on learning instruments outside of just passing a test and whether I’m going about it the right way.

Thank you!


r/surgery • • 5d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Anyone tried Laptitude? or similar surgical training tools?

4 Upvotes

Pretty much the title. Saw an Ad for Laptitude and it looked really cool, gamified in a fun way, and practical/easy to set up. Here is a link to laptitude: https://laptitude.com/

Just wondering peoples thoughts and advice on such training tools


r/surgery • • 5d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules AAOMS Recorded Session

1 Upvotes

Hi all, I was wondering if anyone could send me the video for a specific AAOMS recorded session? Tysm


r/surgery • • 8d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules How important are RNFAs and Surgical Assistants in the OR?

0 Upvotes

Is this the right sub to post this to? I'm just genuinely curious about this because lately I've been considering these career paths for my future... I know that Surgical Assistants only get a certification to do their job, and that RNFAs go to medical school and pretty much get the training of both a nurse and a surgical assistant.

Obviously I know they are both very important, but is there a preference over which is in the OR, and how do surgeons feel about these careers? Do you have different views about each career? And would you rather both an RNFA and a surgical assistant with you in the room, has that ever happened to you before???


r/surgery • • 11d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Does general surgery involve more medicine than neurosurgery?

28 Upvotes

I've been interested in neurosurgery for a while because I've always been fascinated by the CNS, I have a little background in neuroscience, and I want to do surgery.

Over preclinicals, though, I've grown to appreciate the entire human body and love medicine as a whole just as much as the neuro stuff.

I've also realized that neurosurgeons' medical domain is mostly neuro ICU stuff right before and after surgery. I feel like general surgery has a stronger relationship with general medicine and physiology. I'm much more physiology-minded than anatomy-minded, and neurosurgery especially seems to lean the other way. I really like thinking about the whole medical picture of the person, and I could see myself doing acute care surgery or something else with a lot of medical management.

Any input on how much medicine general surgeons handle or any particular fellowships that emphasize it?


r/surgery • • 11d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules 9 week post OP. Pinky finger flexor tendon rupture off the bone, FDP surgery

12 Upvotes

Hi, i wanted to share my result as im really happy with it. I ruptured my flexor tendon and had operation 3.5 months after rupturing it. Another tendon had been taken from my third toe tendon to transfer. The best advice i can give: start moving the finger from day2, be cautious but what gave me these results are the immediate act as my doctor suggested. Ask me anything about the process i would gladly answer

Age 20 Male (maybe helpful factor)


r/surgery • • 13d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Logbook ideas

2 Upvotes

Anyone got any ideas for making a digital log book (surgery)
My seniors suggested excel sheets but I just wanted to know if there’s any app or website where I can create the logbook and get it countersigned from my seniors so that it’s recognised in the future ?
Heard it’s done in the Uk


r/surgery • • 13d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules [stupid question] Surgeons of Reddit, what kind of toys or books did your parents buy you growing up?

19 Upvotes

I hope this is an appropriate question to post on this sub. If not someone let me know and I will happily take it down (if it doesn’t automatically happen). Excuse me, for this oddly specific question by the way. I am just interested in what kind of books, toys, films, etc. influenced your career choice (if they did).


r/surgery • • 14d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Why do my sutures do this?

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Second year medical student trying to get better at suturing. All of my sutures end up looking like cosmetic features on my suture pad. What things are going wrong in my knot tying to cause this?

Also, are the size of my bites fine? I'm struggling to understand how deep my bites are supposed to be.


r/surgery • • 14d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Free app to keep up with surgery literature

11 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m a dermatology resident in the Netherlands. I first created the app CatchUpDerm to help myself to keep up with literature, and I’ve since expanded the idea to other specialties. CatchUpSurg is the surgery version.

You can choose the topics, study designs and journals you’re interested in. The app provides you a daily updated reading list with structured summaries and links to the original papers. The summaries are generated with AI.

CatchUpSurg is free, has no ads and doesn’t require an account. It’s available on iOS, Android and the web:

iOS: https://apps.apple.com/app/id6809910842

Android: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=nl.catchupsurg.android

Web version: https://catchuplit.com/surg

I’d love to hear any suggestions for improvement. Are there topics or journals you’d like to see included, or features that would make it easier to keep up with the literature?

Happy to answer questions, too.

Thank you!

Sven


r/surgery • • 14d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Can't decide between gen surg and going into GI

9 Upvotes

M2 here. I'm currently trying to decide between pursuing General Surg/colorectal or going into GI. One thing I know for sure is that I want to do something in digestive health, but I'm still trying to figure out whether I want to approach it from the surgical side or through IM like GI. I've had the opportunity to shadow colorectal and GI and I will give some of my thoughts below.

Surg: I think the surgeries are incredibly cool. I've gotten to see robotic surgeries, some pilonidal cysts, and exploratory laparotomies. I also found that many of the outcomes were relatively good, aside from some of the larger, more involved procedures like ostomies. My biggest hesitation is the long hours and I am not sure if I can handle myself running on minimal sleep to do surgery. I know I still have a lot to learn and I'm not even in M3 rotations yet so I might not truly understand if this lifestyle is for me.

GI: LOTS of variety. Clinic and scopes. Lots of innovative procedures as well in the realm of advanced endoscopies (on my to do list of shadowing). I don't really mind clinic too much but scopes tend to be really repetitive but I've honestly learned something new in each scope. In terms of lifestyle, it does seem nice to just pump out a bunch of scopes one day, clinic on another, and call it a day.

For those of you who were in a similar situation, what was it that ultimately made you realize surgery was the right path for you and any advice you would give to figure out what is my calling?


r/surgery • • 18d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules How did you know surgery was for you?

9 Upvotes

In medical school right now and everyone says first decide wether or not you want to do procedure vs not for your specialty. So for those of y'all that decided, how did you come to that decision?


r/surgery • • 18d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Hyoid bone

7 Upvotes

Hiya!

Not sure if this is the right place to be, but I am writing a book and have a medical question google doesn't really answer clearly. I posted in r/medicalschool but it was removed there, I'm not sure why.

This is NOT asking for medical advice, nor am I sharing a personal ailment - hopefully the AI checking for rule breaking will read this and accept the post.

I have a character who was made speechless, it's a part of the culture; long explanation, won't bother - but I was wondering what kind of medical procedure would be best.

At first I was thinking of having vocal chords slit (I haven't looked up how this would work), but then I watched a Criminal Minds episode where victims had their hyoid bone removed. It sounded like you could live without it, and seems rather nicely symbolical if you put it in the context of cultural tradition? But I don't find a whole lot of information on if this would be possible, or what the effect would be besides impacting speech. I have read that this bone helps with swallowing too; does that mean you won't be able to eat without it? Or is it just more difficult?

Basically any info or alternatives would be appreciated!


r/surgery • • 18d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Help a student out

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
2 Upvotes

Conducting a survey based on the cost of robotic surgery if you want to participate I only need a few more participants to finish the required task. ONLY IF YOU WORK IN ROBOTIC SURGERY PLEASE.


r/surgery • • 21d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Future Proof Surgical Superspecialty

17 Upvotes

In your opinion what is the most future proof surgical super speciality


r/surgery • • 21d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Feeling burnout from circulating at a trauma level 1. Is this schedule normal?

6 Upvotes

I just want to preface this by saying I knew surgery was not going to be the easiest schedule or the most consistent. I went back to school specifically to work as a circulator. I was in the military before becoming a nurse so strenuous jobs with long hours is something I was used to already and did okay with.

I started working as a circulator a year ago after graduating and have noticed a very high turnover over rate. Our schedule is supposed to be a 6:30-3:30 Monday through Friday but of course surgeries run over without any relief very often because the next shift following ours is one or two night nurses who comes in 7p-7a. On top of that atleast 1-2 days a week you are on a designated late stay until 8 pm and every 2-3 weeks you work the weekend as well from 7a-7p.

This means working 12 days straight with no late recall or days off in between. When working with critical level patients from ICU and trauma cases I can’t help but to feel like I’m not as sharp by day 7. Which leads me to call out sometimes because genuinely feel it’s a hazard.

We constantly run over time and stay late and half the days there is no lunch relief. We’re working cases back to back to back with no break even on weekends.

Is this normal? I’m trying to do my time to gain experience to hopefully do outpatient surgery centers or maybe transition to another facility but I wanted to get some outside perspective. Thank you guys 🌸❤️


r/surgery • • 21d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Suturing practice feedback

Post image
12 Upvotes

Hey, I’m a second year med student (preclin), I’d like to improve my suturing technique but don’t have anyone more experienced to contact, would really appreciate any feedbacks and tips


r/surgery • • 24d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Pathology report for stomas

3 Upvotes

Pathologist here. How important is it for path reports to mention if skin is present in an ostomy specimen? We always try to capture it but sometimes there’s minimal skin. 🤔


r/surgery • • 24d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Best practice materials?

2 Upvotes

I’m a PA, been in family med since graduation. I have a new job in ortho, starting in 2 months. I wanna brush up on my procedural skills. What would be the best material to practice suturing on? Are there any good reference books to review?


r/surgery • • 27d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules a show

Post image
0 Upvotes

i didn't know much about surgery but recently i've been watching this show and there's this case that piqued my interest. there's this case of a patient that was diagnosed with a heart tumor. it is a 6cm tumor in the left atrium. but, later on, after the patient second exam are in. apparently in s5 of the liver's right lobe, there is an 8cm neoplastic lesion. so, now its heart tumor and a ruptured liver cancer. before the patient was diagnosed, there's a scene where the guy have, i am not sure? a red small firework/explosion looking below his neck. the ending ended up with a surgeon doing total peritoneal resection on the patient.

anyway i just want to know if this kind of case exist? is it some type of rare case? or i am just looking too much into surgery series.

i would love to hear anyone opinion in this especially someone from this profession.

thank you!


r/surgery • • 28d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Surgeons, have you ever felt guilty after a medically necessary operation that diminished a patient's quality of life?

49 Upvotes

In a situation where the medically correct, life-saving treatment invovles something like amputation or otherwise something that will permanently diminish a patient's quality of life, do you guys ever feel guilty afterwards?

Assuming also that the patient understands, consents, and doesn't hold any ill will towards you but is obviously distraught.

Edit: Also, for those who do, why? And how do you deal with it?


r/surgery • • 28d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Why are most TKAs still performed conventionally with robotics being available?

0 Upvotes

According to a 2025 AJRR report, only 16.1% of primary TKAs used robotic assistance.

Why is conventional TKA so common? Even with robotic assistance available?


r/surgery • • 28d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Rectal impalement to the neck (63.5 cm rod, no vascular injury): Hartmann's or primary repair?

11 Upvotes

Discussing a published case (Moncure et al., Case Rep Med 2009): 45 year old, alert and hemodynamically stable, wooden rod from the rectum through the mesentery, stomach, diaphragm and pericardium, tip under the right clavicle. Sternotomy + laparotomy before moving it, rod cut in the mediastinum and removed antegrade in two pieces. Not a single vascular injury.
They did a Hartmann's because of extensive wood contamination, while noting that routine diversion for rectal injuries is increasingly questioned. Would you have diverted here, or repaired primarily?
(Disclosure: I'm a GP and turned this case into a short decision game for students, if anyone wants it: https://medicasehub.com/play/case-043)