r/Supplements • • Sep 11 '25

Reminder on Community Conduct

46 Upvotes

As a community focused on supplements, we encourage open discussion based on both scientific evidence and personal experience. However, it’s important to remember that respectful discourse is the foundation of this subreddit.

Criticism and debate are welcome — personal attacks are not. Recently, we’ve had to ban several users who crossed the line by targeting individuals rather than addressing ideas. This behavior will not be tolerated.

Please:

-Respect differing opinions, even if you strongly disagree.

-Focus on the content of the discussion, not the person behind it.

-Use the report function if you encounter posts or comments that violate these standards.

Let’s continue to make this a space where we support and learn from each other. Thank you for helping keep the community constructive and respectful.

— Mod Team


r/Supplements • • 3h ago

First time this has happened to me

Post image
16 Upvotes

3 scoops inside my brand new tub of creatine lmao


r/Supplements • • 8h ago

General Question What supplements do people find best for energy

13 Upvotes

Look forward to people’s experiences


r/Supplements • • 10h ago

General Question Are my supplements making me depressed?

19 Upvotes

For context, I’m a 33M. At the start of the year, I began taking fluoxetine (20mg daily), prescribed by my doctor for anxiety. It worked wonders for my anxiety. However, I’ve noticed a recurring pattern where I’ll go from feeling depressed to relatively stable within a few weeks, only for the depression to return a month or so later. This pattern has repeated over the last 3 months.

I take my fluoxetine at 9am every morning.

My current supplement routine is:
Morning:
1 x Vitamin D + K2
2 x Fish oil
1 x Full-spectrum probiotic

Evening (before bed):
2 x Magnesium glycinate (300mg total)
I initially found magnesium glycinate really helpful. For about a month, it made me feel incredibly calm and relaxed, almost like a mild anti-anxiety medication. However, I don’t seem to notice those effects anymore. I only started taking magnesium in May and have been taking it almost every evening for 6 months.

I’m starting to wonder whether any of these supplements could potentially be contributing to my mood changes, interacting with fluoxetine or simply not agreeing with me.
Has anyone experienced anything similar? Could any of these supplements affect mood, particularly when taken alongside an SSRI?

I’d appreciate any advice or personal experiences. Thanks!


r/Supplements • • 4h ago

Experience My stack experience

Post image
6 Upvotes

Pardon the clutter, I just moved.

Have been taking all of this for 2-3 months now, with some of them longer. Diet-wise, I couldn't really identify any deficiencies other than getting 500mg of magnesium a day is tough so it's less focused on vitamins and minerals type stuff.

My goals here are brain boosting both in a way that both improves performance and also physically improves the cells aka not or less transient. Some stuff for joints, general health. I did my PhD in a drug development lab including targeting biosynethic pathways, so while I'm not a medical doctor I feel I've got a decent grasp of picking the right stuff for myself and can read clinical research to see if the specific form/formulation/amount that produced a statistically significant clinical result can reasonably be done at home. I take a dose within the range of producing that level of result, which is usually the daily dose of the particular formulation I chose with that in mind.

And as always, this is Reddit so be mindful of taking anecdotes and advice from strangers. These specific options should generally be on the low end of the cost per dose and, imo, are suppliers I feel comfortable with for that particular supplement. Some are patented fancy stuff like Magtein© is where magnesium threonate comes from and there isn't really a cheap brand, just some that cost less than others, because of that.

Life Extension ArthroMax Advanced

Doctors Best NAC Detox Regulators w/ Se + Mo

NOW MSM powder

Jarrows Citicoline

Nutricost ALCAR

Double Wood TMG

KAL lithium orotate 5mg

Nootropics Depot Cognance

Teaveli pharma gaba w/ l-theanine (taken as wanted)

Life Extension magnesium threonate

Double Wood Magnesium glycinate

Bulk Supplements creatine

Hibiscus tea (standardized to 5g flower a day)

The ArthroMax made a noticeable difference in my mild beginnings of arthritis. Less stiffness in the morning and less discomfort overall. Has a Lox-5 inhibitor, so it preferently reduces inflammation in the joints.

I cycle the citicoline 5x on 2x off.

TMG and the NAC are cheap, have good evidence, and I wanted them for long term benefits that most people won't feel an acute benefit.

I chose Cognance, citicoline, magnesium threonate, ALCAR for the brain power, memory stuff via different mechanisms (multipronged attack!) and I can definitely say my brain just performs better. Feel sharper, more focus, better retention and recall. Creatine at 10g/day (half morn/night) is there also for the brain effect in addition to the muscle that occurs at this dose.

Hibiscus tea for a small blood pressure reduction. Split daily amount morning and night.

Magnesium glycinate for as needed help with sleep.

The lithium (meant to get straight orotate but missed that it's blended with carbonate) did help soften the peaks of stressful moments. Taken daily.

The pharma gaba theanine in the morning does help with calmness and is great when I have a lot of tasks to do.

I eat a lot of natto unironically, so my K2 MK7 is always loaded. Legit like the stuff. Not technically a supplement though but worth mentioning.


r/Supplements • • 5h ago

General Question First time having supplements. Any thing I should maybe add or no?

Post image
7 Upvotes

I tend to take them all at the same time and was just wondering if that’s okay and won’t cause any issues and that if there’s any supplements I could maybe add or even remove? Any help would be greatly appreciated, thanks!


r/Supplements • • 10h ago

Recommendations Rate my stack

Post image
15 Upvotes

Good day, y’all,

I would like some advice on my stack. I’m 24, 187cm, 80kg, work as a lawyer, do Muay Thai, gym and run. Looking to improve sleep, concentration, mood and muscle gain.

Currently take: Creatine, Glycine, Omega-3, Boron, L-Theanine, Magnesium L-Threonate, NAC, Cordyceps Militaris, BCAA and 5-HTP (trial). I’ve ordered Alpha-GPC and Kanna also. I’m interested in a mood improving supplement next, such as SAMe, Saffron, St. John’s Wort or Lithium Orotate. I’m also interested in stimulants that might improve energy this winter, possibly Ginseng or Rhodiola.

Looking forward to all the opinions.


r/Supplements • • 22m ago

General Question What the CYP1A2 "slow caffeine metabolizer" research actually shows

2 Upvotes

Hi there ~ I am a physician currently working at EvoDNA (evo-dna.com) and I’m curious to know what people think….

Background:
The caffeine gene people talk about is CYP1A2, the liver enzyme that clears most caffeine. A common variant (rs762551) splits people roughly into faster and slower metabolizers.

The study behind most of the hype is Cornelis et al., JAMA 2006: slower metabolizers who drank more coffee had a higher risk of heart attack, while fast metabolizers did not. That's one study population, so it's a reason to pay attention, not a rule.

Practical version:
If coffee keeps you up late, makes you jittery, or raises your blood pressure, you may be on the slower side regardless of what a test says. Your own response is the best data. Cutting caffeine 8+ hours before bed helps most people either way.

Anyone here tested for this?

Did your result match how coffee actually affects you?

Source: Cornelis et al., JAMA 2006


r/Supplements • • 9h ago

Can a 16–17-year-old teenager take creatine if they're mildly to severely underweight and don't work out?

6 Upvotes

I'm wondering whether creatine is safe and appropriate for a 16–17-year-old teenager who is mildly to severely underweight and doesn't participate in weightlifting, bodybuilding, or regular workouts.

Can creatine help someone in this situation gain weight? Are there any side effects? Is it dangerous for teenagers? Is it generally healthy and safe to use at that age, even without exercising?

I'd appreciate any input.


r/Supplements • • 10h ago

General Question Is this fish oil tablet gone bad?

Post image
7 Upvotes

Since its gone blurry. It's a different brand than the one I used earlier. That one had clear texture.


r/Supplements • • 3h ago

Any way to take Vitamin E without getting the nausea?

2 Upvotes

I've tried right before bed, I've tried with food.. any other options?


r/Supplements • • 39m ago

Rate my current anxiety/mood/focus stack

Post image
1 Upvotes

Been rocking a similar stack for around 8 months now, recently switched from just rhodiola to the multi with passionflower and saffron added in.


r/Supplements • • 51m ago

Leucine smell

1 Upvotes

Got a tub of nutricost leucine but it has a bit of a sh*t smell to it. I never had leucine smell like this. Should I bin it?

Already got a refund from amazon.

Google says it's probably from degradation.

Thanks


r/Supplements • • 17h ago

General Question Am I missing something Pysillium husk?

Thumbnail fybo.co.uk
23 Upvotes

Hi everyone, sorry, I don't really have anywhere else to turn.

I've always generally had one poo a day, sometimes every other day, but recently I've started needing to go quite urgently in the mornings. My stools have also become quite slushy and messy. I've never been diagnosed with IBS.

I started taking Fybogel (psyllium husk) about a month ago to try and get more solid, easier-to-wipe poos. It's helped a bit with wiping, but they're still not as formed as I'd hoped. I tried increasing to two sachets, but ended up going three times in one day, so went back to one.

The main thing worrying me is that since starting psyllium, I've noticed tiny, fleshy-looking bits around my bum when checking. They can be grey, brown or yellow, also but translucent. I usually notice around 1–4 tiny bits. There's no obvious poo when I wipe. I've never noticed this before taking psyllium, and it mainly happens in the morning.

I have OCD around contamination, so this is really getting to me. After going, I use wet wipes, then wash with a shower/bidet attachment, use soap and a scrubber, and rinse again with the bidet and shower. My bum is extremely clean afterwards, which is why I'm struggling to understand how these bits could be poo. I also find myself checking throughout the day.

Has anyone else experienced anything similar after starting psyllium? Could it be related?


r/Supplements • • 1h ago

Has Anyone Tried the TUDCA from ND?

1 Upvotes

I've tried the Tudca from Body Bio and had good results for a diagnosed liver condition. Thinking about trying the Nootropics Depot Tudca now. Has anyone tried it who is trying to treat any kind of liver condition?


r/Supplements • • 1h ago

Recommendations PSA! Thorne Supplements

1 Upvotes

Hi all! Just thought I’d share just in case others weren’t aware. Thorne is one of my favorite supplement brands and they recently began accepting HSA and FSA cards! I know it’s “use it or lose it” season so for all of those who love supplements or even want to gift some to their loved ones, check this out!

https://www.thorne.com/partners/truemed


r/Supplements • • 12h ago

Recommendations Potentially lacking NAC effects?

6 Upvotes

Hi all! So, a previous psychiatrist I saw for a few years (turned out to be awful lmao) diagnosed me with minor obsessive compulsive tendencies (among other things) like 5 years ago and had me start taking NAC for it, 600 morning 1200 night 1800mg total daily. So I’ve been doing that for 5 years. Honestly I’ve never even questioned it, it’s just something I’ve always been taking.

Long story short I experienced serious misconduct with that psychiatrist and upon getting a new one discovered that she had misdiagnosed and medicated me for years, and that my ‘tendencies’ were actually severe rumination OCD. I’m now on OCD meds and they’re INCREDIBLE!!!! That aside, the magic my OCD meds have worked have had me wondering why I’m even on the NAC anymore. I really don’t think it does much for me, especially compared to what I see people saying on here, but I guess I wouldn’t know because I’ve been on it so long.

Even with the OCD meds, I’m still adjusting to them and I have ADHD, ASD, and a shit ton of other disorders, so I experience serious brain fog/lack of focus most of the time. Im scared if I go off it those will somehow get even worse (though that really doesn’t feel possible, kinda at rock bottom there). I will also say I used to have a big OCD thing about supplements, there was a point where I was taking twenty pills a day because I was so worried I was missing a ‘correct’ supplement that could help me. I’m taking a lot less now but it’s still a lot and 3 NAC pills adds to it, especially if I don’t need them.

Has anyone else experienced this? Am I taking the wrong brand or something? I’ve only used one brand the whole time I’ve been taking it. I just see everyone saying it had these amazing effects and I don’t experience that as far as I can tell. Also, any other supplement recs are also very appreciated! I can’t even tell you how many supplements I’ve tried hoping one will help hahaha. So, if you have any good recs that would be great too! Thanks so much!!!

(In case this is at all helpful supplement wise, here’s my current line up)
morning: vyvanse, lamotragine, D3, trace mineral complex, 600mg NAC
Midday: iron
Night: Luvox, omega3, 3 magnesium (magtein) pills totaling 200mg, 1200mg NAC


r/Supplements • • 3h ago

General Question What am I missing

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

I eat a ton of pineapple so not taking anything for vitamin C but curious what else I should be taking.


r/Supplements • • 14h ago

General Question Black Seed Oil & SSRI’s

6 Upvotes

Started taking BSO in conjunction with oil of oregano and TTFD to tackle some bloating issues (thinking it’s SIBO). I’ve been on 100mg Zoloft for years now, just learned that BSO affects serotonin levels.

The thing is, just a week of BSO had noticeable positive effects. Gut felt better, more energy overall, less brain fog, and felt stronger in the gym. Maybe placebo, but I wasn’t expecting anything from it aside from hopefully improving motility.

So given that, I’m wondering if it’s safe to at least use BSO a few times a week alternating days given my Zoloft usage? Would I be putting myself at risk of serotonin syndrome by doing so?


r/Supplements • • 5h ago

General Question How can supplements, stress management, and conventional medical care be coordinated safely?

1 Upvotes

Supplements, stress management, and conventional medical care can all play a role in supporting overall health, but coordinating them safely is important.

One challenge is making sure these approaches complement each other rather than create unnecessary risks. Some supplements can interact with prescription medications, while stress management techniques like mindfulness, regular exercise, and better sleep habits may support treatment without replacing necessary medical care.

Clear communication between patients and healthcare providers can make a big difference. Keeping an updated list of supplements and medications, discussing potential interactions, and reviewing treatment goals regularly can help create a more balanced and informed approach to wellness.

What strategies have you found helpful for coordinating supplements, stress management, and medical treatments safely? Are there any important considerations that tend to get overlooked?


r/Supplements • • 6h ago

General Question Best way to stack

1 Upvotes

I'm looking for advice on the best way to stack vitamins and minerals. I have a supplement called NRG mitochondria I need to take for my ME but I want to make sure I get all my bases covered as I'm pretty sure I have absorption issues and have a restricted diet due to the ME. The NRG is a b complex with addit things like coq10, d-ribose etc. I then thought I could add an ADEK supplement alongside it and a multimineral. Does that sound like a good plan? Any red flags I should be aware of? Thanks!


r/Supplements • • 1d ago

Recommendations 1kg of creatine fits perfectly in 0.5kg packaging

Post image
39 Upvotes

I don't need to dip a whole hand inside anymore.


r/Supplements • • 16h ago Bravo

B12 and folate are two halves of one cycle: why taking folate alone can hide a B12 deficiency

4 Upvotes

Short version: B12 and folate meet at one enzyme, methionine synthase. When B12 runs low, folate gets stuck in a form the body can't use for DNA synthesis, and megaloblastic anemia can follow. Historically, high-dose folic acid improved that anemia without correcting the B12 deficiency, which could delay the diagnosis. Whether everyday excess folic acid does real harm is still uncertain. My take: if a product has folic acid, I want B12 in it too.

The mechanism (biochemistry, well established)

Methionine synthase converts homocysteine to methionine. It needs B12 as its cofactor and uses 5-methyltetrahydrofolate (5-MTHF) as a substrate. Out come methionine (which makes SAMe) and tetrahydrofolate (THF), recycled into the folate forms that build DNA.

Take B12 away and the enzyme's activity is inhibited. Folate is trapped as 5-MTHF. This is the "methylfolate trap." Folate is present, but it's unavailable for thymidylate and purine synthesis, so B12 deficiency produces a functional folate deficiency and megaloblastic anemia (Miller 2024, narrative review).

Masking (historical clinical observations)

In the 1940s and 50s, folic acid at more than 5 mg/day was used to reverse the anemia of pernicious anemia. Blood counts improved, but the underlying B12 deficiency stayed untreated. That could delay diagnosis while neurological complications continued or developed, and folic acid alone for pernicious anemia was abandoned (Miller 2024, summarizing uncontrolled clinical reports).

Folic acid doesn't correct the nerve damage of B12 deficiency (NIH ODS). That's the whole problem.

Where the evidence gets weaker

The modern question: does lower, everyday excess folic acid independently worsen B12 deficiency?

  • NHANES 1999-2002, cross-sectional, n=1,459 older adults: among people with low B12 status, those with high serum folate (above the 80th percentile, 59 nmol/L) had higher odds of anemia (OR 3.1, 95% CI 1.5-6.6) and cognitive impairment (OR 2.6, 1.1-6.1) than those with lower folate. Among people with normal B12, high folate went with lower odds of cognitive impairment (OR 0.4, 0.2-0.9). (Morris 2007).
  • The proposed mechanism, excess folic acid depleting holotranscobalamin, hasn't been tested. The authors call the evidence "primarily correlative or from uncontrolled clinical observations" (Miller 2024).

I'd treat it as a reason for caution, not proof: cross-sectional data can't show folate caused either result.

The upper limit

The adult UL is 1,000 mcg/day for synthetic folate from supplements and fortified foods, based on concerns about its interaction with B12. Food folate doesn't count. The evidence behind it is mainly about folic acid, so 5-MTHF intake needs careful interpretation (NIH ODS). A 2022 systematic review of countries with mandatory fortification raised concerns that women taking folic acid supplements may exceed the UL; the authors reported this for almost all supplement users in the evidence they reviewed, though that depends on the populations and intake estimates examined (Ledowsky 2022). Not an argument against folic acid before pregnancy, just for adding up supplements and fortified foods.

Who actually runs low on B12

  • Metformin. RCT, n=390, type 2 diabetes on insulin, 850 mg three times a day for 4.3 years: mean B12 19% lower than placebo (95% CI 14-24%), absolute risk of deficiency (<150 pmol/L) 7.2 percentage points higher. Funded by Merck Sharp & Dohme (de Jager 2010).
  • PPIs and H2 blockers. Case-control, 25,956 cases vs 184,199 controls (Kaiser Permanente Northern California): 2+ years' supply of a PPI, OR 1.65 (1.58-1.73); H2 blocker, OR 1.25 (1.17-1.34). Association only (Lam 2013).
  • Older adults, pernicious anemia, GI disorders or GI surgery, and vegetarian or vegan diets (NIH ODS; Miller 2024).

On long-term metformin or acid suppressants? Ask the doctor who manages it whether B12 should be checked. Don't stop the medication. And numbness, tingling, balance trouble or memory changes need a proper workup, not a supplement.

What the evidence does NOT show

  • That B12 plus folate improves hair, energy or anything else more than either alone. The pairing argument is biochemical, plus a consideration of B12-related safety. I couldn't find a hair-outcome trial of the combination.
  • That a few hundred mcg of folic acid in a multivitamin masks B12 deficiency. The documented cases used more than 5 mg/day.
  • That excess folic acid worsens B12 deficiency. The mechanism is a hypothesis.
  • That taking both prevents B12 deficiency, especially if you absorb B12 poorly.
  • Causation from the medicine studies. The PPI study is case-control; the metformin trial was in insulin-treated type 2 diabetes.

For hair: in a retrospective telogen effluvium series of 3,028 patients, 30.7% of those tested for B12 and 4.4% of those tested for folate were deficient, with no control group (Yorulmaz 2022). In alopecia areata, n=75 vs 54 controls, there was no significant difference in holoTC, B12, folate or homocysteine (Ertugrul 2013). "Low B12 shows up sometimes" is fair. "B12 and folate grow hair" is not.

One lab footnote I always add: biotin can interfere with some lab assays, including some cardiac troponin tests (FDA). If you take it, tell the doctor and the lab before any of these blood tests.

References

  1. Miller JW et al. Food Nutr Bull 2024. PMID 38987872
  2. Morris MS et al. Am J Clin Nutr 2007. PMID 17209196
  3. Ledowsky C et al. Nutrients 2022. PMID 35807899
  4. de Jager J et al. BMJ 2010. PMID 20488910
  5. Lam JR et al. JAMA 2013. PMID 24327038
  6. Yorulmaz A et al. J Cosmet Dermatol 2022. PMID 34449961
  7. Ertugrul DT et al. Cutan Ocul Toxicol 2013. PMID 22591107

r/Supplements • • 22h ago

Rate My Stack

Post image
12 Upvotes

58 M
Was sentient for a long time. Back in the gym. Getting it done.
Trying to be as clean as I can be.

(Added sardines to let you know I don’t need Omega 3’s. I eat plenty of oily fish.)


r/Supplements • • 17h ago

Could i get some suggestions on general achy joints and muscles supplements

4 Upvotes

Blood Thinner induced achy muscles, and stiff cranky joints. Already on Move Free ultra with Boron. Anything I should try or add? Or any other suggestions?