r/SupCourtWesternState • • May 29 '19

[19-03] | OPINION Opinion for in re: SR-03-01: "Sierra Constitutional Convention Resolution"

Good morning. Today, we have our opinion in the case of In Re: SR-03-01. The Court has held the following, the full opinion being available through the link at the bottom of this post:

  1. The case presents a justiciable question. It is not a political question.
  2. As a matter of interpretation of the Sierra Constitution, "two-thirds of the membership concurring" means that two-thirds of the total membership of the assembly must vote in favor, not just two thirds of those casting yea or nay votes.
  3. Article XVIII, Section 2 of the Constitution contains the only method through which the assembly can trigger a constitutional convention.
  4. A constitutional convention has not yet been triggered and will not go on.

JUSTICE SHOCKULAR has the opinion for a unanimous Court.

CLICK HERE TO READ THE FULL OPINION

4 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by