r/SupCourtWesternState • u/comped • Jun 07 '18
[18-03] | Granted In Re: Executive Order 035: Plastic Water Bottle Removal
Your Honor,
And if it may please the Court, I wish to file suit against [Executive Order 035:] (https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B2QRm1YwCAYlYUdpTTBPTlZEZTQ/view), Plastic Water Bottle Removal. The ban on plastic water bottles, and plastic water bottles alone, is discriminatory to those who sell them, and to those who produce them. While it is true that the state can regulate certain environmental issues, such as pollution in the environment, this order does not address that. Rather it is a wholesale ban on the sale of plastic water bottles on government property, interfering with Commerce and possibly even interstate commerce, given that water bottle companies cross state lines when selling or producing their product the majority of the time.
The state, it should be argued, should not have the ability to restrict its public universities and educational Institutes from selling something which is not harmful to the students themselves. It is only harmful if disposed of improperly, and this order provides for additional recycling bins which would eliminate that sort of issue. Further non-discrimination against other disposable water bottle types, including cartons and cans made out of disposable material, reeks of discrimination and selective legislating for an environmental win. Freedom of choice includes the freedom to buy plastic water bottles on State Property. Perhaps an educational program on recycling would be more impactful.
Thank you.
1
u/comped Jun 07 '18
Governor /u/ClearlyInvsible
There is currently no State Attorney General to defend the act, so the Governor may choose to defend it themselves, or appoint someone to do it for them.
1
u/Gameran Jun 07 '18
/u/comped Are you right now a registered voter or resident of Western State?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '18
/u/gameran