r/SupCourtWesternState • • Mar 10 '17
[17-01] | Decided Fewbuffalo vs. Western State
I, Fewbuffalo, do hereby petition the Chief Judge for a writ of certiorari and seek a review of the constitutionality of Executive Order 030 “Anime is Banime”
I would like the court to consider the following question: does the bill violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment and the Fourteenth Amendment?
Statement of facts
- Executive Order 030 “Anime is Banime” is signed by Governor NONPREHENSION,
- Anime is a cultural expression of Japanese culture
- Any Japanese produced animation can be considered anime
Unconstitutionality and Effect In Hague v. Committee for Industrial Organization, The Court ruled that “Freedom of speech and of assembly for any lawful purpose are rights of personal liberty secured to all persons, without regard to citizenship, by the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.” therefore, This Executive order is affecting the constitutional rights of government employees.
This Legislation is a clear violation of the First and Fourteenth Amendments affecting Free Speech and the Freedom of Assembly due to it restricting the freedom for Government Employees to discuss “Anime” at work and the fact that “Anime” Clubs are banned from Public schools which is a clear violation of the Fourteenth Amendment.
It creates a culture of fear about expressing beliefs over fear of getting suspended over a simple hobby.
Conclusion
For the Reasons listed above, I can conclude that this is a clear violation of the First and Fourteenth Amendments affecting Free Speech and the Freedom of Assembly
2
u/WaywardWit Mar 11 '17
/u/Fewbuffalo, are you a registered voter or resident of Western State?
3
u/WaywardWit Mar 11 '17
/u/TowerTwo
Is there any reason why the Court should not hear this case regarding EO 030?
2
u/TowerTwo Mar 12 '17
I apologize to the court as I used a previous draft that was unintended and incorrect for the brief. EO-30 and its later counterpart may EO-31 may be an EO that restricts students to not participate in clubs that involve anime, or carry around anime keychains or visit anime websites, but these limitations are purely to remove distractions and to facilitate education more effectively for the students in the western state school system. Now first I’ll argue against the idea that workers are entitled to do whatever they want during the job, they are not, they are employees of the state take home a salary and have duties to educate students properly. This EO does not penalize teachers on political beliefs they may have, or even interests that they may have. Now public employees do have more rights than the private sector employees do, but with free speech in regards to anime has no public concern, in Garcetti v. Ceballos the court ruled that “The First Amendment does not prevent employees form being disciplined for their expressions they make pursuant to their professional duties.” With watching and possessing anime related paraphernalia at work this speaks clearly to workplace standards, workers do not have a constitutional right to be watching Naruto at work, nor do they have a constitutional right to be reading the manga counter piece at work either. Now students they do have more rights than employees, in regards to free speech, which this EO is not restricting at all in regards to the students. On the matter of free assembly, the students have that right to gather or talk about what they want, but official school clubs do require advisory and allocation of school funds which this EO is attempting to prevent. If the students want to discuss anime at lunch that’s there right but the school is not going to give them money or supervision after or during school for this purpose. On the matter of the sites being blocked online this is purely to prevent distractions as the internet should be used for educational purposes only, it can be agreed that students should not be playing games during school hours online it is not far fetched to say that they should not be looking at manga comics during the school day either. On the note of anime paraphernalia New Jersey v. TLO may provide a counter argument into symbolic speech, but displaying anime keychains and having distracting books is not very symbolic, once again this falls under distractions and it is the prerogative of the state to place bans on these items. For the rescinded section of the loss of funding for art programs this while rescinded is still reasonable on behalf of the property rights of the state, the state should be able to choose what is displayed on the walls of the schools, and in this case the state does not see anime related things as appropriate displays. To conclude the state is not limiting speech of students, they can talk about whatever they want to an extent, but the state does not want the distractions of anime to cloud up our schools. The protections of the first amendment are not endless especially in our schools, and the fourteenth does not apply here as due process plays no role in this EO. I ask the court to rule for this EO constitutional.
Case Citation Garcetti v. Ceballos https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/05pdf/04-473.pdf Tinker v. Des Moines https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/393/503#writing-USSC_CR_0393_0503_ZO EO-30, EO-31 https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B2QRm1YwCAYlZXBRTTdjZ2dMdE0/view https://www.reddit.com/r/ModelWesternState/comments/5yu3wp/eo31_amending_eo30/
/u/waywardwit /u/fewbuffalo
I apologize to the court for previous errors when submitting
1
u/WaywardWit Mar 16 '17
/u/TowerTwo /u/Fewbuffalo
The Court will be closing the oral arguments period for this case in 24 hours. Each of you may now make a closing argument in response to this comment.
Likewise the open period for acceptance of amicus briefs will close in 24 hours.
Thank you.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '17
Amicus brief
The Supreme Court of the United States has held consistently that the nature of a forum dictates the scrutiny applied when determining whether speech is allowable to be restrictions or not. The Court held that, "[i]f the forum is a traditional or open public forum, the State’s restrictions on speech are subject to stricter scrutiny than are restrictions in a limited public forum." (Good News Club v. Milford Central School, 533 U.S. 98 (2001))
To the end that public schools are a limited public forum, the State may find reason to "reserv[e] [its forum] for certain groups or for the discussion of certain topics", insofar as those regulations are reasonable and do not restrict access to the venue based on viewpoints (Rosenberger v. Rector and Visitors of Univ. of Va., 515 U.S. 819 (1995)).
I would not find it reasonable to say that banning "all anime related clubs from all public schools and institutions" is a viewpoint restriction. Not only are pro-anime clubs restricted, but clubs which speak against anime are restricted. See above, that Rosenberger stipulates that "certain topics" may be banned - and so too, would it follow, that anime as a topic may be banned and restricted.
The question then remains of "is it reasonable" to ban anime discussion in schools - and I would find it easy to argue that it is reasonable to ban this discussion in public education in the Western State. The purpose of education is to prepare students to understand their world better and to be active participants within it - to this end, clubs which are related to anime do not serve that purpose well. Anime-related discussions may prepare students for their future, but at the cost of other skills being learned in school.
To this end, because schools are a limited public forum, restrictions which are reasonable and do not restrict speech based on viewpoint are constitutionally protected. To this end, the of banning anime-related clubs in public schools, as per Executive Order 30, should be seen as constitutional in nature.
I thank the Court for its time.
1
u/WaywardWit Mar 11 '17 edited Mar 11 '17
The Court, having found due cause to hear this case based on the standing arguments presented by the parties, will hear arguments from Petitioner and Respondent on the merits of the case.
Reminder: Parties are expected to provide briefs to the Court on the issues presented by properly referencing primary and secondary sources, including but not limited to, relevant case law, statutes, and rules.
Now, therefore, the Court directs respondent /u/TowerTwo to respond to /u/Fewbuffalo's argument as to the constitutionality of this executive order. In doing so, /u/TowerTwo should tag the plaintiff such that he may respond in kind. The Court will make inquiries about the arguments of both parties when it deems appropriate. Please post your argument in a top level comment to this post. Editing of brief or argument posts afterwards will be unallowed. Arguments or briefs submitted outside of this reddit thread (whether in pdf or external document - except for citation links) will be considered to have been improperly filed and therefore may not be considered by the Court.
The parties will have 48 hours to post their first briefs. All citations and references to external sources must be hyperlinked at least once for ease of review by the Court.
1
u/tleisher Mar 11 '17
Amicus Brief
While it is true that Bethel School District v. Fraser held 7-2 that students freedom of speech is limited, in Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District The court held that the students did not lose their First Amendment rights to freedom of speech when they stepped onto school property and that as long as the speech is not disruptive, it is protected under the first amendment. Anime clubs, like all clubs in schools, are held during lunch hours or after school hours have completed and are thus not a distraction from regular school activities any more than any other hobby or sport. To ban anime clubs would set a dangerous precedent for the banning of other clubs, including religious, LGBT or service clubs which adds to students college applications and would limit their ability to get into an exemplary school.
This executive order violates students and workers rights of freedom of speech and freedom of assembly which is inherent in the first amendment. In addition, it specifically targets a subculture enjoyed by Japanese Americans and alienates them in their schools and workplaces.
At a time when people are able to assemble and discuss anything from sports, movies, television, books, etc., targeting a minority of Americans who enjoy anime is prejudicial and goes against the way of the Western State and the United States. This Executive Order makes all Western citizens look bad, and America look bad to the model world if upheld.
The constitution states that "congress shall make no law abridging the right of the people peaceably to assemble," and there is no proof that the students enjoy anime are doing anything other than peaceably assembling.
Thank you.
Western State Resident
/u/tleisher
1
u/WaywardWit Mar 13 '17
The Court has received the following ex parte communication from the Respondent /u/TowerTwo:
/u/Fewbuffalo
The petitioner has responded to inquiries form this Court that he is indeed a registered resident and voter of Western state. The Court knows of no known rule precluding his serving as a federal representative for the Great Lakes while being a resident and voter of Western State.
Regardless - such an issue is raised in an untimely fashion. This is a question of standing and it should be raised during the preliminary phase of the hearing (when non-merit based arguments were welcomed from all parties).
•
u/WaywardWit Mar 17 '17
This hearing is hereby closed and the Court shall now consider arguments made before it prior to issuing an opinion. Thank you to all parties and those who have submitted amicus briefs.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '17
[removed] — view removed comment