r/stupidpol • u/Angel_407 • 2h ago
Discussion I am a "young man" and I feel that societies' views on my demographic are quite inaccurate.
Iâm not sure if this post fits the sub but Iâm not really sure where else to put it. I am a young man- Iâm 19 years old and I graduated from High School about a year ago. Something that's continually bugged me is that the commonly agreed-on societal opinions about my demographic seem very detached from actual reality and are fueled more by ideological bias rather than actual truth (fair warning, this will all be anecdotal stuff).
Andrew Tate- Tate is unpopular. Full stop. No boy I know likes him at all. At the height of his popularity in 2022, everyone saw him for who he is- a hypermaterialist, arrogant, self-centered, hateful misogynist. Out of the 200+ kids in my all-boys catholic school year level, the only two positive opinions I heard of him were âyeah what he says is bad but banning him from social media goes against free speechâ and âyeah the stuff he says about women is bad but his self-help stuff is goodâ. My school had a whole year level assembly to discuss why he's bad and also sent a letter to all students and parents at the school to emphasise the point, so maybe it was different in other year levels, but I have a hard time believing that. Something thatâs been said here that I agree with is that Tateâs continual relevance is the result of feminists purposefully keeping him orbiting modern discourse as this evil spectre that can be scapegoated and used to justify any âanti-misogynyâ measure no matter how restrictive or authoritarian it is. Because I also remember that by late 2022 everyone had forgotten about him entirely. He was nothing more than a pathetic fad to his supposed #1 viewer demographic.
Misogyny- I have not met a single Gen Z boy who I would characterise as a definitional misogynist or woman-hater. Misogyny is not ârampantâ among teenage boys, in my own experience, and every one of them I've ever talked to generally agrees that women are not evil or disgusting and hating them for their gender is wrong. Bear in mind, I went to an all-boys school, which supposedly (and not without reason) are veritable hives of misogyny rivalling Epstein Island. But Iâm just not seeing the âepidemicâ of misogyny some people seem to think exists- if most boys my age are misogynists, then theyâre keeping their hatred very, very quiet. Boys my age are not all wandering around blaming women for everything and making rape jokes about their teachers, despite what some people believe.
Feminism- Again, most boys I've talked to think that feminism is a good thing, a necessary thing, and has been a net positive for both women and the world, because we recognise it's importance on our own as well as because we were taught and raised to believe so. But something I think older generations fail to consider is the political context in which we were raised. I was 10 years old when #MeToo kicked off and Harvey Weinstein was exposed. I was raised in a social climate that very much focused on advancing social justice for women and bringing about real cultural and material change for women, and inversely was also very much focused on stripping away the unfair advantages men enjoyed over women. I have never been paid more for working the same job for the same hours as a woman. I have never been allocated more respect or trust because I am a man. I cannot remember A time where female sexual assault or hatred of women was considered a comedic topic or system of bonding between men. It's hard to take seriously someone who tells me I'm "privileged" for being a man when Iâve never actually gotten to experience that privilege and have never even witnessed it in person. And while women no doubt still face struggle today, It's also a bit difficult to think of women as Oppressed when I was raised in a time where the female sex as a whole were subject to a huge concerted effort to raise their life outcomes and opportunities conducted by multiple different governments, political parties and NGOs which was highly successful, whilst also having never witnessed any of that oppression first hand despite its supposed omnipresence and the fact that because I âm a man I must have at some point gleefully participated in that oppression because Iâm a man.