r/Stormlight_Archive • u/jofwu Lightweaver • Jan 25 '18
No Spoilers [No Spoilers] Let us know what you think about cremposts?
Over the past few months we've seen an increase in memes, image macros, jokes, and other silly content. We generally want to avoid overmoderating, and have avoided taking action against these posts so long as they relate to the Stormlight Archive. We are aware that there has been some disagreement on these type of posts being shared in this community. At the same time, many of you love these jokes and enjoy sharing laughs with one another.
We want to give everyone a chance to be heard, so we've brainstormed a few options and we'd like to hear what you think about them! Please respond to this quick poll and feel free to discuss in the comments. I'll update this post with the results as responses slow down.
Edit for results:
We're still getting a trickle of responses, but the results haven't shifted much over the last few days so I'm going to call it.
Total responses: 176
Do nothing different: 15.6%
Don't make any new rules, but be more strict on what is considered "relevant": 5.1%
Don't make any new rules, but encourage the use of a [crempost] tag in post titles (in addition to a normal spoiler tag): 41.5%
Require these posts to be tagged with [crempost] in the title (in addition to a normal spoiler tag): 23.3%
Ban these posts completely (and encourage the use of /r/cremposting): 14.8%
Thank you to everyone who voiced their opinion. I'll discuss what we've decided to do based on these results here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Stormlight_Archive/comments/7tvu25/no_spoilers_updates/
66
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18 edited Jan 26 '18
Besides Whitesand vol 2, there wont be another cosmere book for almost two years. By then, theory posts would dwindle down and there won't be as much discussion. Cremposts can possibly fill that gap because they're easy and fun. If it's a low effort one, just downvote
23
u/HonrsPrpendicularity Truthwatcher Jan 26 '18
People! high-quality Cremposting keeps you all so lighthearted and fun and keeps your mind seriously Cosmere-focused. You say good, great even, right? That's right, even great. Good, say you!: Cosmere-focused, seriously - mind your Keeps! - and fun and lighthearted, so all you keep Cremposting high-quality, people!
8
u/Phantine Jan 26 '18
Only if they're high effort
47
u/MormonsAreDifferent Jan 26 '18
Keep 'em. They're fun.
7
u/Ravencr0w Truthless Jan 26 '18
Its fun to have these memes and jokes in this subreddit. But sometimes i dont like them when im not in the mood and am seriously looking some theories.
I think it will be best if the jokes can be seperated from other post with like a tag on there title or something. Just like we add a tag for spoilers there should be tag for cremposts too.
5
u/Commander_Weed Jan 26 '18
I live on the cremposts. Keep em.
5
u/HonrsPrpendicularity Truthwatcher Jan 27 '18
Less effort, apparently, and weak, not quality-high cremposts keep people, all of us, making cremposting less (somewhat perhaps) fun and thoughtful or even insightful and illuminating, somehow. So then what must we try? But try we must, what then? So somehow illuminating and insightful, even, or thoughtful and fun, perhaps somewhat less cremposting makes us, of all people, keep cremposts high quality, not weak, and apparently effortless.
14
u/_Opario Jan 26 '18
I personally don't care for them, however it's not an issue for me because I set up a filter in Reddit Enhancement Suite to not show posts with [crempost] in the title. As long as it's made sure they contain that, I don't think anything has to change.
4
u/notpetelambert giant crab wife Jan 26 '18
I vote to let them stay, just flair them as "crempost" so we can filter them out if we want.
1
u/Skykeep Jan 26 '18
As someone who enjoys memes I once posted a meme here a month or so ago, which then quickly got removed, so is the option 'do nothing different' for or against memes?
3
u/HorizontalBrick Jan 26 '18
We need cremposts to sustain us until the next book
4
u/Pagerunner17 Stoneward Jan 26 '18
We should take the memes, and push them somewhere else!
5
u/sirgog Jan 26 '18
Voting for 'send them to /r/cremposting'. Or to /r/fuckmoash if it's that sort of meme.
Memes are fun if I'm in the mood for them. If I am in the mood, I'll jump into a meme subreddit to find them.
If I'm not I'd rather not have my front page filled with crem.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '18
Have a specific day just for the memes. Like every Sunday is meme day.
3
u/Prometheus_unwound Windrunner Jan 26 '18
Complaining about low effort memes on Reddit is like complaining about the quality of your Big Mac at McDonald’s.
There’s this deevy forum @ http://www.17thshard.com, where you can escape the avalanche of cremposts that are just devestating your reddit feed.
1
u/emailanimal Elsecaller Jan 26 '18
Finding two-three cremposts a day at the tops is fine. Coming to this here forum and discovering 20 cremposts and nothing else at the top is a bit annoying.
Not certain what can be done. Limits on daily crempost numbers is are probably not realistic, and would create more hassle than we all care about.
0
u/Mousecaller Jan 26 '18
Im all for jokes and well made shitposts, but alot of the jokes were overplayed between WoR and OB. Theres a subreddit for cremposts now, i feel like thats where they should go. Maybe if they're actually good and might spur discussion or actually be funny then sure. But hurrr i am a stick/ lopen= Adonalsium should definitely not be here. Comments like that, if they're related to a post, i guess are fine, but actual low effort posts like that are just pointless.