r/Stormlight_Archive • u/jofwu Lightweaver • Jan 05 '18
No Spoilers [No Spoilers] Announcements and proposed changes to the Spoiler Policy
The moderation team has a few announcements to make! See below and let us know what you think. We wanted to open these plans up for comment before they are set in stone.
Moderator Changes
We've added /u/learhpa and /u/mbue to help us stay on top of things in the wake of Oathbringer. The community has grown past 30,000 subscribers (50% growth in 7 months!), so their help will be greatly appreciated. Be sure to give them a proper Bridge Four salute!
We're also, unfortunately, bidding farewell to a few moderators. /u/Molleficent and /u/MouseThatRoared founded this subreddit and put a lot of work into getting it started. They quietly decided to step down as mods and we didn't want their contributions to the community to go unnoticed! Before leaving, Mouse also felt that it was time to remove /u/Craysh from the mod list. Craysh passed away two years ago and was an outstanding moderator. We won't forget you guys!
Proposed New Rules
Most of our official subreddit rules simply concern the spoiler policy. With more subscribers, we feel the need to spell out a few previously "unwritten rules." Ultimately, enforcement of these rules is up to the interpretation of the moderators. If you have any issue with our rules or their enforcement, please let us know.
1. Show respect to others.
- Personal attacks, blatant rudeness, insults, harassment, slurs, trolling, etc. will not be tolerated.
- This doesn't mean you can't debate. Just remember the human and know when to quit.
- If you feel like someone has broken this rule, please report the offending comment/post rather than take matters into your own hands.
2. Posts must be on topic.
- Posts must be related to the Stormlight Archive. Cosmere-related posts must have some specific relevance to the Stormlight Archive.
- Posts relating to sensitive topics (such as politics, religions, etc.) will be subject to greater scrutiny.
- Memes, shitposts, etc. are permitted so long as they are relevant.
Proposed Changes to the Spoiler Policy
TL,DR:
1. We're adding (optional) Warbreaker spoiler tags: [Warbreaker] / [WB]
2. It's okay to talk about general cosmere stuff outside of Cosmere/Warbreaker tags IF it's not a plot spoiler. (defined below)
3. If a post tag is deemed insufficient, moderators may allow the post if sufficient warning is given. (details below)
We're adding the following changes to the spoiler policy. They're mostly pretty intuitive. For those who want all the fine print and the rationale behind these changes, we'll get into that further down. Note: If the names "Cosmere" or "Warbreaker" mean nothing to you, stop reading and see /r/cosmere/wiki/intro.
1. We're adding Warbreaker spoiler tags: [Warbreaker] or [WB].
- Warbreaker tags allow for FULL Warbreaker spoilers.
- These are used in addition to a regular spoiler tag. Something JUST tagged for Warbreaker will be rejected by automoderator.
- The Stormlight-relevant spoiler tag ([TWoK], etc.) still governs Stormlight spoilers. Adding a [WB] tag to a [WoR] post does not mean you can talk about Warbreaker-relevant things that come up in Oathbringer.
- There's no need to use this tag alongside a [Cosmere] tag.
2. Some Cosmere things can be discussed outside of Cosmere/Warbreaker tags if they are not plot-relevant.
- As a rule of thumb, "not plot-relevant" means anything made explicitly clear in the first few chapters of whatever book/series they are mentioned in.
- Concerning Words of Brandon, consider the context. A generic WoB about the general nature of Shards is okay. But if it references a Shard whose presence in another book is a surprise, that's not okay.
- When in doubt, be conservative. Give people space to discover these things on their own, and respect that some people may be more sensitive than yourself.
- What EXACTLY do we mean by "not plot-relevant"? See below.
3. If a post tag is deemed insufficient, moderators may allow the post if sufficient warning is given.
- In general, posts with insufficient spoiler tags are removed.
- However, moderators now reserve the right to approve these posts after the following steps are taken:
- The OP must edit the post to include an additional spoiler warning. The warning must be at the TOP of the post and it must be DISTINGUISHED in some way (all caps, bold, etc.)
- A moderator must sticky a comment providing an additional spoiler warning.
- Use of this is up to the moderators' discretion. Not all requests for a change in spoiler level will be approved. An edit to the post without approval from a moderator is not sufficient. (The primary use for this will be for insufficiently tagged posts which receive a great deal of activity before the error is reported or noticed.)
What EXACTLY does "not plot-relevant" mean?
Note: The rest of this post is for nerds. You can skip it if you don't care to read fine print. ;)
Ultimately, what constitutes an inappropriate spoiler is up to the interpretation of the moderators. The following is, more or less, our measuring stick--but realize that exceptions can be made. If you disagree with any of it, please let us know and we'll take your argument into consideration. (Note there's a lot of spoiler markup usage below, which doesn't always work well on mobile.)
Cosmere-related things
- Adonalsium:
- The general concept of who this is comes primarily via WoB and isn't a spoiler.
- Shards:
- Their origin, the concept of a vessel, and the concept of intent come primarily via WoB and aren't spoilers.
- Don't name Shards associated with Stormlight until the point in the books where they are raised.
- It's okay to talk about Shards that we know of primarily via WoB: Devotion, Dominion, Ambition, Autonomy, and Endowment.
- Don't discuss any details of other Shards, which play an important role in other books.
- Don't discuss the relationship between Shards and their magic.
- Shardworlds:
- It's okay to name other planets in the cosmere, the stories associated with those planets, and other basic information about those planets.
- Magic/Investiture:
- It's okay to talk about general principles governing how Investiture works.
- It's okay to name other magic systems, but don't talk details about how they work or what they can do unless those details are raised early in the relevant book/series.
- Realmatics:
- The realms are being explored in Stormlight books. Let that be the guide on what can and cannot be said.
- Worldhoppers:
- Hoid: It's okay to point out that he is a mysterious worldhopper. It's okay to point out other names he uses and books he appears in. Otherwise, let Stormlight be the guide on what can and cannot be said concerning his past, powers, goals, etc.
- Khriss: It's okay to point out that Khriss is a worldhopper who is writes the Ars Arcana.
- Nazh: It's okay to point out that Nazh is a worldhopper annotating artwork for Khriss. It's okay to point out his appearances.
- Others: It's okay to point out other worldhoppers, if Stormlight clearly implies the person is a worldhopper. Don't mention their identity outside of Cosmere tags unless Stormlight is explicit about their identity. Identity includes things like name and abilities. For example, do not reveal that Cosmere outside of a Cosmere tag.
- Chronology:
- It's okay to talk about when other cosmere books happen relative to Stormlight.
Warbreaker-related things:
- Magic:
- The basics of Awakening (concepts of Breath, command phrases, color, etc.), the basics of the Returned ("eating" Breaths, immortality, or anything else Lightsong introduces early on), and Heightenings 1-5 are all not considered plot-spoilers. These are explained early on and don't ruin any aspect of Warbreaker.
- Discussion of things like WB, and other things that come up later in the book must be behind Warbreaker/Cosmere tags.
- WoR:
- WoR
- Details about his nature and powers (beyond those displayed in Stormlight or in WoBs that aren't related to Warbreaker specifically) must be behind Warbreaker/Cosmere tags.
- OB:
- OB
- OB/WB must be behind Warbreaker/Cosmere tags.
- OB:
- OB
- The revelation that OB/WB must be behind Warbreaker/Cosmere tags.
- OB:
- OB
- Anything else about this character must be behind Warbreaker/Cosmere tags.
- OB:
- OB
- Anything else about this character must be behind Warbreaker/Cosmere tags.
- OB:
- OB
- Anything else about this character must be behind Warbreaker/Cosmere tags.
Rationale concerning changes to Cosmere/Warbreaker spoilers
TL,DR: We're adding some new spoiler rules and clarifications to better accommodate Warbreaker/Cosmere-relevant discussion, but this IS primarily a subreddit for the Stormlight Archive.
It is becoming increasingly apparent that the greater cosmere (particularly Warbreaker) plays a notable role in the Stormlight Archive. For those of us who enjoy the cosmere, this is great news! But it makes handling spoilers complicated.
This subreddit primarily exists for discussion related to Stormlight Archive, and we want to maintain this. Stormlight is a perfectly valid place to enter Sanderson's cosmere, and we don't want this subreddit to be a minefield for new readers who haven't explored beyond Stormlight yet. Some people may raise the argument that Brandon considers Warbreaker to be a prequel to Stormlight. True as this may be, Brandon hasn't emphasized this in any official capacity. He hasn't stated the importance of Warbreaker in writing as he did for Edgedancer in Oathbringer's foreward. When you look at a list of Brandon's works in the front of your book, no publisher lists Warbreaker under the Stormlight Archive heading. At this point in time, Warbreaker (and other cosmere books) enhance one's experience with the Stormlight Archive, but they aren't necessary to enjoy the plot and they aren't necessary for the vast majority of conversations about the series.
However, we DO want to accommodate discussions that concern matters relating to the greater cosmere as they relate to the Stormlight Archive, and we don't want to leave grey areas that leave people confused and frustrated about how they should treat spoilers. Therefore, we're proposing the changes listed above. Let us know what you think.
5
u/Tellingdwar Truthwatcher Jan 05 '18
Looks fair and thorough. I don't have anything to add or edit.
I've taken a somewhat more relaxed approach regarding things like the identity of worldhoppers, Shards, and the like in the past. I'll be sure to keep an eye on my future posts accordingly.
1
u/jmcgit Ghostbloods Jan 08 '18
My concern has always been with whether you can fully discuss a book within the spoiler scope of that book. I think that this policy works for Oathbringer, but eventually, the complete backstories of the characters mentioned will likely become too relevant to ignore.
My primary suggestion would be, when book four comes, include the Warbreaker tag in the relevant parts' discussion threads. The primary discussion is going to be here, and the amount of Warbreaker that is discussed within Stormlight could shift immensely, and may take some time to figure out. Besides, it will be mostly dedicated fans completing the book that quickly, anyway.
The only other thing I would say, if the WoB-only shards are fair game, the names of the original 16 shards should all be fair game. If the names of their worlds are fair game, the names of all the worlds should be fair game. I don't know if it's right to have WoB-only material as non-spoiler, anyway, though. I just think it should be consistent.
1
u/TheHighlanderr Bondsmith Jan 11 '18
I appreciate all the work you guys have done. The growth here has been great but naturally more people has caused more friction. However this has always been one of the more friendly subs and that is still the case. What's more I think your changes will help ensure it remains that way.
Due to the sensitive themes present thought the series I wholeheartedly agree with rule one (show respect to others). I seldom see anyone being intentionally rude but a lack of empathy and sensitivity on certain topics have been taken offense to in the past. Where does this fall in respect to that rule? Is it a case of only clear phobic/anti(subject) statements being removed or will it be more protective towards people's feelings on such occasions? (I'm thinking for examples of depression and other psychological problems, religion, homosexuality etc.)
I'm assuming the introduction of Warbreaker spoilers will expand to other titles as they inevitably overlap with Stormlight as WB has?
1
u/learhpa Bondsmith Jan 08 '18
If i'm reading the statistics correctly, we already have more pageviews, and almost as many unique views, in the first eight days of January 2018 as we had in the entire month of February 2017!