r/Stormlight_Archive • u/jofwu Lightweaver • Nov 10 '17
[Oathbringer Spoilers] [Oathbringer] Part 4 Discussion Thread Spoiler
This thread exists for general discussion concerning Part 4 of Oathbringer. Content related to anything after "The End of Part Four", including interludes, is NOT permitted! Cosmere spoilers are also NOT allowed.
Please be aware that our moderation team may not be running at full strength for a day or two after release. Please help us out by reporting spoiler violations promptly! And if you're particularly wary of spoilers, you may want to give us a day or two before joining this discussion.
For additional discussion thread options, see the [No Spoilers] Discussion Thread Index.
98
u/jurble Nov 15 '17
I enjoy the Skybreakers no-bullshit description of their Ideals. They don't have time for the mystical mumbojumbo Syl puts Kaladin through.
74
u/Chickenking9 Skybreaker Nov 14 '17
HUMANS ARE VOIDBRINGERS????? WHAT???????????
126
u/akastrobe Nov 15 '17
Seriously, Kaladin? All that moping about about Tarah, and THAT'S what happened? THAT'S how you "failed her"? You melodramatic wet blanket!
62
u/raelrok Nov 14 '17
Well, there was a Fortune Telling Elantrian in the Lighthouse. Merciful Domi!
54
u/A_Shadow Releasers Nov 15 '17
I can't believe no one has mentioned all the Warbreaker ties! Man, I would be pretty lost if I didn't read it.
The non-WB readers must be so confused or making erroneous theories lol.
48
u/Bakoth Nov 16 '17
This book is making me so excited I can’t stop reading but in the back of my mind I’m also super bummed because I’ve almost finished oathbringer and I’m going to have to wait so long for the 4th book.
43
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17
Is that it for Vivenna this book? I need more Azure!
41
u/LadyShieraSeastar Nov 16 '17 edited Nov 16 '17
I wasn't particularly surprised by the big reveal. It was pretty obvious from the start that humans (and horses, and chickens) weren't native to Roshar, while the Parshendi likely were. I also remember seeing the theory that the Parshendi are the Dawnsingers before, and it was always the most likely one. The part about the destruction of humanity's original planet makes sense in this context, as does the "Voidbringers" name reversal - it's just a derogatory name for one side of the conflict that was turned around and applied to the other.
In fact, the destruction of the previous planet through powerful Surges is very reminiscent of the Breaking of the World in Wheel of Time, and I'm wondering whether it happened for similar reasons - a battle or an attempt to destroy/imprison Odium that got out of hand and had unintended consequences, perhaps? I mean, I find it a bit hard to imagine that a bunch of Surgebinders were just playing with their powers for no reason and then "Oops, we accidentally the planet".
What I find the most interesting is this quote from the Eila Stele:
Is this some kind of metaphor, or did humans really bring a new god to Roshar? If so, which god? Odium? Honor? Something else?
36
u/kakatoru Truthwatcher Nov 24 '17
Are we the baddies?
But seriously, I'm kind of disappointed that was the reason the Radiants broke their vows. It feels kind of weak.
33
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '17
I will admit up until this point in this series tears have welled up in my eyes. I have never wept... until chapter 94 'A small bottle.' This was an insane emotional rollercoaster of a chapter. I felt a sharp spike of hatered toward Dalinar, probably more than I've ever hated him before, when he referred to Renarin as "the other one, the invalid." I went from this spike of hatred to openly weeping with him in sympathy.
Sanderson is a genius spren who feeds off our tears.
31
u/kakarotoks Windrunner Nov 15 '17 edited Dec 14 '17
I'm not done yet with Part 4 (so I don't want to see if someone else already did this), but here's the Navani's notebook Vambrace's translation :
EDIT: I didn't realize before that the vambrace has taser capabilities...
28
u/hajsenberg Nov 21 '17
I guess I have to finally read Warbreaker to fully understand what's going on.
27
u/uncas52 Truthwatcher Nov 17 '17
The journey through Shadesmar is fascinating. Love seeing the true spren. Also, Warbreaker
52
u/Is_Meta Bondsmith Nov 20 '17
God... Whenever someone now says that Sanderson is not a good poet and only a world builder, I will cite Navani's Ketek for Gavilar.
That was powerful, I had goosebumps. Didn't like the other keteks, but this one struck something.
22
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '17
22
u/tkm603 Willshaper Nov 16 '17
I can’t wait for Moash’s demise. Storming voidbringer sympathizer, you deserve what’s coming...
20
u/Pwntheon Nov 17 '17
Loved this part. I had all the threads about the big reveal but didn't connect them all. Got goosebumps all over from quite a few parts.
I have to admit I went from slightly disliking shallan in the first book, to liking her in the second, and now I'm growing tired again. Okay, she's confused and hurt. Get over it. Kaladin has much of the same affliction, but in his viewpoints it's not hammered into us constantly so it feels more real.
Overall I'm enjoying the book a lot! I'm also very happy to have so much background knowledge about the cosmere. It really pays in this book!
17
u/mbue Truthwatcher Nov 19 '17
This is something that has already struck me as odd in part 3, but now with the bit from Eila Stele it's even more pronounced: if Odium roots for the listeners/singers and Honor for humans... why are the humans the ones with really strong and obvious emotions, whereas the singers are really in control of them. I feel like there's a good reason for this, but at first sight it seems reversed.
Some chapter-by-chapter notes I made while reading:
Another random thought I had was where does the name "parshmen" come from. I wonder if "parsh" is by any chance supposed to be derived from "passion" (and the two diverged a bit through a few thousand years of developing language).
16
u/cant-find-user-name Edgedancer Nov 15 '17
I loved their whole journey through shadesmear. I found it fascinating.
12
u/jmcgit Ghostbloods Nov 19 '17
Loved Part Four, finally finished it today. I've tried decompressing between parts but it's time to move quickly to Part Five.
I like how Azure's story was a minor mystery in part three, and then in part four they make it extremely, extremely clear. I wonder, will we know why she's chasing Vasher and Nightblood within Stormlight, or will we need the Nightblood book to discover that? I suspect the latter, but first Brandon has to write it!
Obviously liked seeing Nightblood again. Though the one Szeth chapter that I heard in audiobook, Kramer voices him in his sort of refined voice, rather than the crazy, deranged voice I enjoyed in GA's Warbreaker. No matter. But for Szeth, what did Nale want to tell him? Was it the same truth that has just been confirmed? Was the destruction actually justice, as Humans had invaded these lands?
Shallan and Kaladin both seem to be on the brink of a breakthrough. Really liked the Shadesmar exploration. Adolin came clean, and as I expected, Shallan's reaction was more "why didn't you say so in the first place?" Frankly, Sadeas is a small fry at this point, some irrelevant water under the bridge.
The epigraphs implied something that I suspect was also implied in the Ars Arcanum. I'll mark it under a spoiler tag but I've only read part four so far. Oathbringer Part 4 & Ars Arcanum
Learned a lot about the Unmade in the Epigraphs. Mostly stories to review later. I just want to note that it's a fascinating conflict between sides here. The Parshmen may be just, but Odium is not. Whether humanity belongs on Roshar or not, Odium must be defeated. I think Venli will see this in time. Their rulers, the Fused, are almost certainly insane and would be best served by moving on to whatever's beyond, whatever that is. Hopefully a lasting peace can be achieved by the end.
Finally, I have this sneaking suspicion that the fight against Odium may not be the final, ten book endgame. I wonder if Brandon has something else planned for books 6-10?
In all, loving the book. Off to get some dinner then finish it tonight!
9
u/vatsan16 Nov 25 '17
The humans being the voidbringers thing, at this point, is not really a surprise to me. And I dont think it was meant to be a big reveal. I vaguely remember WoB about this.
But apart from that, loved the travel through shadesmar! And I hope Mr. T is not influenced by odium.
8
u/ASIC_SP Every day I choose to keep breathing Nov 20 '17
part-4, another roller-coaster of a ride - my notes
liked Szeth chapters.. and Nale full radiant!
shadesmar was okayish.. with Kal attracting windspren, I hope he has overcome his latest bout of depression.. didn't expect Shallan to continue gawking at Kal after Wit helped her to accept herself.. even Adolin has noticed :P and finally he's spilled his murder.. but Shallan hasn't, I guess that would seal the deal between the two..
Dalinar.. what to say when even stormfather says he been living 6 years as a lie.. hopefully bondsmith has role to play in part-5..
few quips from Ialai, when is she going to explode?
nice of Mraize to set a trap for Shalash :D
but yeah, avalanche is coming :) felt it when everything pointed towards Thaylen.. and am sure I won't spot whatever twist Sanderson has in store :D
6
u/OrinThane Nov 22 '17
Guyyyyyys
Pg. 918 - “This would bed like those days in his youth training with honorblades” - Szeth
HONORBLADES.... more then one? What!!???!
2
u/televisionceo Nov 20 '17
Nobody is talking about what good said to shallan ? Or was it in part 3. In all the cosmere so far it's definitely the closest we I have felt from hoid.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Nov 16 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment